[{"id":"SW200-001","pmid":"41651897","doi":"10.1038/s41598-026-37160-3","title":"Efficacy of radial and focused shockwave therapy for tendinopathy: a systematic review and meta-analysis.","year":2026,"condition":["Lateral elbow tendinopathy","Calcific shoulder tendinopathy","Noncalcific rotator cuff tendinopathy","Patellar tendinopathy"],"category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas tendinopatias"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials","population":"Human adults with several tendinopathy subtypes","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human adults with several tendinopathy subtypes","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":["Radial pressure wave versus focused shockwave","Monotherapy and combinations with exercise/physical therapy kept as reported strata"],"comparator":"Radial versus focused treatment, alone or combined with rehabilitation","findings":"The review reports no clear pain/function superiority and a radial wrist-extensor-strength advantage. The pilot found a source-direction conflict and repeated-timepoint pooling concerns; headline estimates need reconciliation.","patient_relevance":"This review compared focused and radial treatment in several tendon problems. It does not provide a reliable basis for saying that one type is better for everyone. The studies used different settings and often included exercise. We also found inconsistencies in how some results were labelled and combined. For you, the useful question is which evidence applies to your particular tendon problem and treatment plan.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Şah VISA-P direction and follow-up origin disagree with original trial; sample basis is not uniformly randomized.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: Confirmed material inconsistencies. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"Extraction accuracy","source_locator":"ReviewTable2p7/Fig4Cp9; Şahpp39–41"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Seven pain rows from 2 trials and 10 strength rows from 2 trials repeat cohorts. Ordinary random effects does not itself address within-cohort correlation. Main methods do not describe a dependency adjustment; raw data/code unavailable.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: Serious unresolved concern. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"Statistical dependence","source_locator":"PDFp4Synthesis; Fig4A/5A–B"}],"depth":"pilot_appraisal_reused","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41651897/","next":["Retrieve and compare PROSPERO protocol and supplement.","Obtain analytic data/code; independently reconstruct at prespecified clinically coherent timepoints with one contribution per cohort or justified dependence model.","Resolve every directional label against arm-level data, not just Şah."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Focused or radial: which helps more?","pt-BR":"Focal ou radial: qual ajuda mais?"},"summary":{"en":"A review of several tendon conditions compares the two approaches, with and without rehabilitation. Its findings need to be read alongside inconsistencies in the underlying analysis.","pt-BR":"Uma revisão compara as duas modalidades em diferentes tendinopatias, com e sem reabilitação. Para interpretar os resultados, é preciso considerar inconsistências na análise."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"One answer for every tendon?","pt-BR":"Uma resposta para todos os tendões?"},"population":{"en":"Adults with several tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Adultos com diferentes tendinopatias"},"comparison":{"en":"Focused and radial treatment, alone or alongside rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Tratamento focal e radial, isolados ou associados à reabilitação"},"comparisonLabel":{"en":"Treatments examined by the review","pt-BR":"Modalidades examinadas pela revisão"},"comparators":[{"label":{"en":"Focused shockwaves","pt-BR":"Ondas de choque focais"},"name":{"en":"Focused","pt-BR":"Focal"}},{"label":{"en":"Radial pressure waves","pt-BR":"Ondas de pressão radiais"},"name":{"en":"Radial","pt-BR":"Radial"}}],"note":{"en":"Different tendon conditions and rehabilitation regimens were combined. Read each outcome and the analysis concerns before choosing a winner.","pt-BR":"Foram reunidas diferentes tendinopatias e formas de reabilitação. Considere cada desfecho e os problemas da análise antes de apontar uma modalidade superior."}},"findings":{"items":[{"name":{"en":"Pain","pt-BR":"Dor"},"status":{"en":"No clear superiority","pt-BR":"Sem superioridade clara"},"detail":{"en":"The review reports no clear pain advantage for one modality over the other.","pt-BR":"A revisão não relata vantagem clara de uma modalidade sobre a outra para a dor."}},{"name":{"en":"Function","pt-BR":"Função"},"status":{"en":"No clear superiority","pt-BR":"Sem superioridade clara"},"detail":{"en":"The reported functional results do not establish a clear winner across tendon conditions.","pt-BR":"Os resultados funcionais relatados não estabelecem uma modalidade superior para o conjunto das tendinopatias."}},{"name":{"en":"Wrist-extensor strength","pt-BR":"Força dos extensores do punho"},"status":{"en":"Reported advantage, unresolved","pt-BR":"Vantagem relatada, ainda incerta"},"detail":{"en":"A radial-treatment advantage was reported. Repeated strength observations and unresolved inconsistencies elsewhere in the review mean its headline estimates need checking.","pt-BR":"Foi relatada uma vantagem do tratamento radial. Medidas repetidas de força e inconsistências em outras partes da revisão exigem conferir as estimativas em destaque."}}],"note":{"en":"No clear superiority does not establish equivalence. Our earlier appraisal identified inconsistencies that require checking against the original trials.","pt-BR":"Ausência de superioridade clara não comprova equivalência. Nossa análise anterior identificou inconsistências que exigem checagem dos ensaios originais."}},"treatment":{"label":{"en":"Modalities in the review","pt-BR":"Modalidades da revisão"},"title":{"en":"Focused + radial","pt-BR":"Focal + radial"},"description":{"en":"Treatment alone and treatment combined with exercise or physical therapy were described as separate strata.","pt-BR":"O tratamento isolado e o tratamento associado a exercícios ou fisioterapia foram descritos em estratos separados."},"contextLabel":{"en":"Reading the regimen","pt-BR":"Como ler o esquema de aplicação"},"context":{"en":"Device, pulses, energy and schedules belong to each original trial. A review-wide setting would conceal those differences.","pt-BR":"Aparelho, impulsos, energia e intervalos pertencem a cada ensaio original. Um único esquema para a revisão ocultaria essas diferenças."},"note":{"en":"A trial-by-trial dose comparison has not been verified for this profile.","pt-BR":"A comparação das doses, ensaio por ensaio, ainda não foi verificada neste perfil."}},"limitations":{"note":{"en":"Concerns recorded in our earlier critical appraisal.","pt-BR":"Pontos identificados em nossa análise crítica anterior."},"items":[{"label":{"en":"Check the direction","pt-BR":"Conferir a direção"},"title":{"en":"One trial does not align","pt-BR":"Um ensaio não corresponde"},"body":{"en":"VISA-P direction and the origin of follow-up timing in the Şah trial disagree with the review. Each label needs comparison with the original arm-level data.","pt-BR":"A direção do VISA-P e a origem do prazo de acompanhamento do ensaio de Şah divergem da revisão. Cada rótulo precisa ser confrontado com os dados dos grupos no artigo original."},"locator":"Review Table 2, p 7; Fig 4C, p 9; Şah, pp 39–41"},{"label":{"en":"Check repeated observations","pt-BR":"Conferir observações repetidas"},"title":{"en":"More rows can reuse the same people","pt-BR":"Mais linhas podem repetir as mesmas pessoas"},"body":{"en":"Several follow-up results from the same cohorts were pooled. Ordinary random-effects analysis does not by itself account for their correlation; a dependency adjustment was not described in the checked main methods.","pt-BR":"Resultados de diferentes avaliações dos mesmos grupos foram combinados. Uma análise convencional de efeitos aleatórios, por si só, não considera essa correlação; os métodos principais consultados não descrevem um ajuste para essa dependência."},"locator":"Review synthesis methods, p 4; Figs 4A and 5A–B"}]}}},{"id":"SW200-004","pmid":"39704142","doi":"10.1177/02692155241295683","title":"Does shockwave therapy lead to better pain and function than sham over 12 weeks in people with insertional Achilles tendinopathy? A randomised controlled trial.","year":2025,"condition":"Insertional Achilles tendinopathy","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Insertional Achilles tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia insercional do tendão de Aquiles"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Randomized controlled trial","population":"76 adults with persistent insertional Achilles tendinopathy","sample":{"n":76,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"76 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"76 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"76 adults with persistent insertional Achilles tendinopathy","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":["SW200-042"],"source_note":"ACTRN12620000035921","link_status":"linked_in_catalog","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Radial extracorporeal pressure-wave therapy (rESWT)","comparator":"Three radial sessions versus sham, both added to exercise and education","findings":"No clear added benefit was demonstrated at 6 or 12 weeks. The abstract/discussion and adjusted table contain different VISA-A estimates; both include the null, but their model relationship needs clarification.","patient_relevance":"For pain where the Achilles tendon meets the heel, this trial did not find a clear extra benefit from three radial shockwave sessions added to exercise and education over 12 weeks. Both groups improved. The treatment could be uncomfortable, and the results remain imprecise enough that a useful benefit cannot be ruled out.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Unmasked treatment provider, unequal treatment pain and unresolved delivered-dose reporting; common exercise/education and ITT reduce some concerns.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: some concerns. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"Deviations from intended interventions","source_locator":"Methods; Table 3"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"73/76 contributed 12-week questionnaires; mixed model uses available longitudinal data. Missingness mechanism still not independently tested.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: low risk, preliminary. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"Missing outcome data","source_locator":"Flow diagram; Results—Participants; Statistical analysis"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Primary outcome/timepoint align with registry; late public SAP versions, internally different model descriptions and unreconciled Table 2/narrative estimates prevent a clear low-risk judgment.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: some concerns. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"Selection of the reported result","source_locator":"Registry; SAP V2 sections 3.4/6.2; Table 2 versus Abstract"}],"depth":"pilot_appraisal_reused","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39704142/","next":["Obtain Supplement File 3 and full protocol; reconcile Table 2 versus narrative estimands and covariate versions.","Confirm delivered pressure units/values, VAS scaling and adverse-event percentages with publisher/authors.","Independent second extraction and clinical/language review remain pending."],"editorial":{"presentation":"rose"}},{"id":"SW200-005","pmid":"38904119","doi":"10.1136/bjsports-2024-108139","title":"Is radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy (rESWT), sham-rESWT or a standardised exercise programme in combination with advice plus customised foot orthoses more effective than advice plus customised foot orthoses alone in the treatment of plantar fasciopathy? A double-blind, randomised, sham-controlled trial.","year":2024,"condition":"Persistent plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial with sham / placebo control","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com tratamento simulado / placebo"},"report_type":"Four-arm randomized trial with sham control, observer blinding, and partial participant blinding","population":"200 adults with persistent plantar fasciopathy","sample":{"n":200,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"200 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"200 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"200 adults with persistent plantar fasciopathy","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":["SW200-045"],"source_note":"NCT03472989","link_status":"linked_in_catalog","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Radial pressure-wave therapy (reported as rESWT)","comparator":"Radial, sham, or exercise added to advice/custom orthoses versus advice/custom orthoses alone","findings":"At six months, radial add-on activity-pain change versus advice/orthoses was −0.02 (95% CI −1.01 to 0.96). This is not a direct extracted radial-versus-sham contrast.","patient_relevance":"In this Norwegian study, 200 people with persistent plantar heel pain all received advice and custom foot orthoses. Adding three radial shockwave sessions did not improve average activity-related pain more than that care alone at six months. Improvement over time does not show which part of care helped. The result applies to this combination and schedule; it does not compare radial with focused shockwave or predict your individual response.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Care provider unblinded; primary comparator participants knew no adjunct was provided. Additional care occurred in 23/174 reported respondents; two radial courses delayed during COVID. ITT model mitigates adherence exclusion but trial-context behavior effects cannot be ruled out.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: some concerns, preliminary. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"D2 Deviations from intended interventions","source_locator":"main pp 913–914"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Observed primary data 47/50 radial vs 45/50 control; other arms lower. Model assumes missing at random, but no missing-not-at-random sensitivity analysis verified. The attendance count of 184 is not the primary-response count of 176.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: some concerns, preliminary. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"D3 Missing outcome data","source_locator":"main pp 914–915; SAP p 7"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Primary endpoint agrees with protocol/current registry/SAP. SAP publicly posted after follow-up and model random-effect structure differs from publication; historical preanalysis status remains unverified.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: some concerns, preliminary. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"D5 Selection of reported result","source_locator":"SAP pp 1, 7; main pp 912–914; registry documentSection"}],"depth":"pilot_appraisal_reused","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38904119/","next":["Obtain supplement 1 for detailed harms, adherence and missing-data sensitivity.","Check historical registry and analysis timestamps, model specification and contrast signs.","Second extractor to verify all primary numbers and resolve reporting ambiguities before patient publication."],"editorial":{"presentation":"sage"}},{"id":"SW200-006","pmid":"38592705","doi":"10.3390/jcm13051323","title":"Effectiveness of Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy in Treatment of Spasticity of Different Aetiologies: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.","year":2024,"condition":"Upper and lower limb spasticity after chronic stroke and in cerebral palsy","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Spasticity: mixed neurological conditions","pt-BR":"Espasticidade: condições neurológicas mistas"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis","population":"Human; adults with chronic stroke and children with cerebral palsy","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; adults with chronic stroke and children with cerebral palsy","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Control interventions not described in abstract","findings":"Authors report reduced upper and lower limb spasticity, greatest immediately after treatment and persisting up to 12 weeks; no pooled magnitude or confidence interval is supplied.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining an emerging adjunct for tone reduction; it does not establish lasting independence or replace condition-specific rehabilitation.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Abstract combines children with cerebral palsy and adults with chronic stroke.","implication":"Condition, age and limb-specific estimates are needed before a common patient claim.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Main endpoint is Modified Ashworth Scale, not walking, caregiving burden or participation.","implication":"A tone-scale improvement cannot automatically establish useful functional recovery.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Comparators and pooled uncertainty are absent from the abstract.","implication":"Magnitude and incremental benefit cannot be assessed from this summary.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38592705/","next":["Extract stroke and cerebral-palsy strata with sham/usual-care comparisons.","Check functional outcomes, harms, risk-of-bias domains and repeated follow-up handling."]},{"id":"SW200-007","pmid":"36684664","doi":"10.3892/br.2022.1597","title":"Biological effects of extracorporeal shockwave therapy in tendons: A systematic review.","year":2023,"condition":"Tendon biology across experimental tendinopathy models","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Tendon mechanisms and translational research","pt-BR":"Mecanismos do tendão e pesquisa translacional"},"level":"mixed_translational","levelLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical / preclinical","pt-BR":"Evidência clínica / pré-clínica"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic mechanistic review with human, animal and laboratory components","pt-BR":"Revisão mecanística sistemática com componentes humanos, animais e de laboratório"},"report_type":"Systematic mechanistic review, predominantly preclinical, with a small human in-vivo mechanistic component","population":"Mixed animal and human tendon research; the review includes two human in-vivo tissue/microdialysis studies alongside animal and cell-culture studies. Quantitative pain/function studies were excluded.","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Mixed animal and human tendon research; the review includes two human in-vivo tissue/microdialysis studies alongside animal and cell-culture studies. Quantitative pain/function studies were excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Diverse experimental controls, not detailed in abstract","findings":"Authors describe dose-dependent biological responses and potential structural injury above suitable experimental doses, alongside improved biomechanical properties in studied models.","patient_relevance":"This review explores how tendon tissue may respond to shockwaves. Most evidence is from animals or laboratory cells, with a small amount of human tissue research. It does not establish how much pain relief patients gain or which treatment dose works best.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"Mechanistic evidence includes animal and human tendon models.","implication":"Biological plausibility is not an estimate of pain relief or recovery probability in patients.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Abstract proposes an optimal dose per species and tendon without a transferable clinical range.","implication":"Do not turn this into a patient dose recommendation or a universal therapeutic window.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The original abstract did not provide a complete study-by-study appraisal; selected full-text scope checking identified two human in-vivo studies but did not complete that appraisal.","implication":"Map the controls and methodological limitations for each mechanism before clinical interpretation.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Full-text eligibility explicitly excludes quantitative pain/function studies; the human contribution is tissue/microdialysis evidence rather than clinical benefit estimates.","implication":"Retain as a mechanism review with the two human studies separated from animal/in-vitro findings. No efficacy, recovery-probability or clinically validated optimal-dose claim follows.","verification":"source_confirmed","source_locator":"Methods inclusion/exclusion and study-characteristics paragraphs"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36684664/","next":["Map mechanisms to species, tendon, exposure and control.","Check structural-injury ascertainment and beneficial mechanical outcomes."]},{"id":"SW200-008","pmid":"36461894","doi":"10.1111/iwj.14035","title":"Extracorporeal shockwave therapy compared with standard care for diabetic foot ulcer healing: An updated systematic review.","year":2023,"condition":"Diabetic foot ulcers","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Diabetic foot ulcers","pt-BR":"Úlceras do pé diabético"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical review","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática de estudos clínicos"},"report_type":"Systematic review of comparative trials","population":"Human; participants with diabetic foot ulcers","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; participants with diabetic foot ulcers","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"ESWT plus standard ulcer care versus standard ulcer care alone","findings":"Review reports shorter healing time and more healing at 20 weeks, both assigned low certainty by its authors, with substantial heterogeneity.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining why an adjunct may be discussed in selected ulcer care; cannot promise healing or determine suitability for an individual wound.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The comparison is adjunctive ESWT plus standard care.","implication":"Any benefit concerns adding treatment, not replacing wound management.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Authors report low certainty and unclear/high bias assessments.","implication":"The promising conclusion must retain these qualifications rather than imply routine superiority.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Use of “unclear” bias alongside RoB 2 requires checking the implemented judgments.","implication":"Verify the tool version and outcome-specific assessments before adopting its ratings.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36461894/","next":["Extract absolute healing counts and time-to-event definitions.","Check ischemia/infection eligibility, standard care and device-specific doses."]},{"id":"SW200-009","pmid":"35187851","doi":"10.1002/pmrj.12790","title":"Best practices for extracorporeal shockwave therapy in musculoskeletal medicine: Clinical application and training consideration.","year":2022,"condition":["Musculoskeletal tendinopathy and fasciopathy","Bone pathology","Spasticity discussed as an additional indication"],"category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple musculoskeletal conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições musculoesqueléticas"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Evidence synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese de evidências"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Narrative practice review","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa da prática clínica"},"report_type":"Practice-management narrative review","population":"Clinical musculoskeletal practice; no enrolled efficacy cohort","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Clinical musculoskeletal practice; no enrolled efficacy cohort","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":["Focused shockwave","Radial pressure wave","Combined modalities discussed"],"comparator":"Not applicable; narrative practice overview","findings":"The article explains practical application and training. It does not estimate an individual chance of improvement or establish an optimal universal device/dose.","patient_relevance":"Shockwave treatment can involve different devices and settings, so a session is planned around the problem being treated and what you can tolerate. This article explains the practical steps, possible discomfort and the importance of matching activity to your condition. It is an expert overview rather than a treatment trial, so it cannot tell you your chance of improvement or prove that one device is best.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"No reproducible search or inclusion/exclusion process; omitted or contradictory evidence cannot be mapped reliably.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: Limited transparency. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"Source selection and completeness","source_locator":"PDFpp1–8"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Mechanisms are described as incompletely understood; cellular hypotheses and condition-wide efficacy statements require direct trial support before patient claims.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: Mixed, with useful explicit caveat. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"Separation of mechanism and clinical efficacy","source_locator":"PDFp2/printed612, Tables1–2; p3/printed613"}],"depth":"pilot_appraisal_reused","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35187851/","next":["Verify intended energy-range correction against publisher or authors.","Link each condition-specific efficacy claim to directly appraised trials.","Refresh safety recommendations against current device/clinical guidance before writing patient advice."]},{"id":"SW200-010","pmid":"35407583","doi":"10.3390/jcm11071977","title":"Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy in the Treatment of Nonunion in Long Bones: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.","year":2022,"condition":"Long-bone nonunion, including hypertrophic and atrophic/oligotrophic forms","category":"bone","categoryLabel":{"en":"Bone healing and bone disorders","pt-BR":"Consolidação e doenças ósseas"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Fracture healing, delayed union and nonunion","pt-BR":"Consolidação de fraturas, atraso de consolidação e pseudoartrose"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis","population":"Human; 1200 nonunions, not necessarily unique patients","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 1200 nonunions, not necessarily unique patients","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Varied or absent controls; pooled healing proportions","findings":"876 of 1200 nonunions reportedly healed (73%); healing differed by morphology and site, and increased beyond six months in some studies.","patient_relevance":"Frames nonunion as a specialist indication with selected cases; the pooled proportion should not become a personal healing forecast.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Headline 73% is a treated-lesion healing proportion.","implication":"It is not causal benefit over revision surgery or observation and may reflect cointerventions and selection.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Subgroup healing rates vary with morphology, site and treatment delay.","implication":"Cross-study differences cannot establish optimal timing or prove one subgroup responds biologically better.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Unit is nonunions, not explicitly unique patients.","implication":"Check clustering, duplicate cohorts and weighting before making success-rate graphics.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35407583/","next":["Separate randomized comparisons from uncontrolled series.","Verify union definitions, surgical cointerventions and cohort overlap."]},{"id":"SW200-014","pmid":"26585999","doi":"10.1093/bmb/ldv047","title":"Efficacy and safety of extracorporeal shock wave therapy for orthopedic conditions: a systematic review on studies listed in the PEDro database.","year":2015,"condition":"Multiple orthopedic tendon and musculoskeletal conditions","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple musculoskeletal conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições musculoesqueléticas"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical review","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática de estudos clínicos"},"report_type":"Systematic review with narrative synthesis of PEDro trials","population":"Human trials across heterogeneous orthopedic conditions","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human trials across heterogeneous orthopedic conditions","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed","comparator":"Placebo, no treatment and alternative nonoperative treatments","findings":"Authors broadly call treatment effective and safe, reject radial/low-energy equivalence and propose the highest tolerable energy within their schedule.","patient_relevance":"Useful for terminology and the history of common protocols; patients need condition-specific current estimates instead of a global efficacy claim.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Methodological considerations cite over 80% of studies as positive while acknowledging heterogeneity.","implication":"Counting positive trials does not weight effects, precision or selective outcomes and cannot yield condition-wide certainty.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"One proposed optimum schedule spans conditions and devices.","implication":"Present as historical practice inference, not a validated universal prescription.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"Evidence source is restricted to PEDro.","implication":"Coverage of unpublished, non-indexed and safety evidence needs assessment.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26585999/","next":["Read selection methods and funding declarations.","Trace optimal-dose inference to direct comparisons."]},{"id":"SW200-016","pmid":"23185732","doi":"10.5535/arm.2012.36.5.675","title":"Extracorporeal shock wave therapy in myofascial pain syndrome of upper trapezius.","year":2012,"condition":"Upper trapezius myofascial pain syndrome","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Neck and trapezius myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial cervical e do trapézio"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Small randomized single-blind trial, confirmed in selected full text","population":"Human; 22 enrolled, 20 analyzed, predominantly women","sample":{"n":22,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"22 enrolled; 20 analyzed.","pt-BR":"22 participantes incluídos; 20 analisados."},"source_population":"Human; 22 enrolled, 20 analyzed, predominantly women","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"focused","comparator":"0.056 versus 0.001 mJ/mm² exposure","findings":"Abstract emphasizes VAS decline 4.91 to 2.27 and pressure-threshold improvement. Selected Results also report post-treatment between-group differences favoring treatment.","patient_relevance":"Early controlled signal for short-term trapezius symptoms; does not establish sustained benefit or coverage of all myofascial pain.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Discussion acknowledges that examiner knew allocation.","implication":"Pain-threshold testing may be influenced by unmasked assessment.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Both withdrawals were from active treatment; analyzed groups were nine and eleven.","implication":"Completer results are vulnerable to imbalance in this tiny sample.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Only immediate outcomes were measured and disease duration was not collected.","implication":"Durability and applicability to chronic refractory disease remain uncertain.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23185732/","next":["Check sequence generation and concealment beyond selected methods.","Extract between-group confidence intervals and compare later sham trials."]},{"id":"SW200-017","pmid":"22547246","doi":"10.1007/s00167-012-2009-3","title":"ESWT for tendinopathy: technology and clinical implications.","year":2013,"condition":"Tendinopathy technology; systematic clinical component is patellar tendinopathy","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Tendon mechanisms and translational research","pt-BR":"Mecanismos do tendão e pesquisa translacional"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Evidence synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese de evidências"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Narrative technology review with a systematic clinical component","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa de tecnologia com componente clínico sistemático"},"report_type":"Narrative technology review with systematic clinical component","population":"Mixed; laboratory tendon studies and human patellar studies","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Mixed; laboratory tendon studies and human patellar studies","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed","comparator":"Laboratory controls and clinical comparators unspecified","findings":"Focused and radial waves differ physically; biological work mainly used focused waves. Patellar clinical evidence was conflicting.","patient_relevance":"Helps explain why different machines are not interchangeable and why tissue effects do not guarantee symptom improvement.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Only the patellar clinical component is systematically reviewed.","implication":"Do not label every technology assertion as a systematic clinical finding.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Laboratory evidence mainly concerns focused waves.","implication":"Applying those mechanisms unchanged to radial devices is extrapolation.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Practice suggestions accompany inconsistent clinical results.","implication":"Dose/timing advice requires tracing to comparative trials rather than rationale alone.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22547246/","next":["Identify included trials and follow-ups to prevent double counting.","Trace timing recommendations to direct trials or author inference."]},{"id":"SW200-018","pmid":"19755551","doi":"10.1136/bmj.b3360","title":"Radial extracorporeal shockwave treatment compared with supervised exercises in patients with subacromial pain syndrome: single blind randomised study.","year":2009,"condition":"Persistent subacromial shoulder pain","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Rotator-cuff / subacromial pain: mixed or unspecified subtype","pt-BR":"Dor do manguito rotador / subacromial: subtipo misto ou não especificado"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Single-blind randomized comparative trial","population":"Human; 104 patients, symptoms at least three months","sample":{"n":104,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"104 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"104 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 104 patients, symptoms at least three months","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"NCT00653081","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Four to six weekly radial sessions versus up to twelve weeks supervised exercise","findings":"Adjusted effect favored exercise by −8.4 SPADI points (95% CI −16.5 to −0.6); additional treatment at twelve to eighteen weeks was more common after shockwave allocation.","patient_relevance":"Supports explaining exercise as an active option and comparing complete treatment programs rather than assuming device treatment is superior.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Exercise entails different duration and substantially more contact.","implication":"This compares care packages rather than isolating shockwave physiology.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Additional treatment was uneven by group.","implication":"Later results need interpretation with cointerventions and estimand.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Confidence interval includes small and larger advantages for exercise.","implication":"Clinical importance requires thresholds, not statistical significance alone.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19755551/","next":["Check concealment, masking role, adherence and rescue treatment.","Read comments PMID 20445371 and 20500139 for context, not presumed misconduct."]},{"id":"SW200-024","pmid":"12855524","doi":"10.1136/bmj.327.7406.75","title":"Extracorporeal shock wave therapy for plantar fasciitis: randomised controlled multicentre trial.","year":2003,"condition":"Persistent plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial with sham / placebo control","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com tratamento simulado / placebo"},"report_type":"Randomized, blinded, placebo-controlled multicenter trial","population":"272 adults with persistent plantar fasciitis","sample":{"n":272,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"272 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"272 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"272 adults with persistent plantar fasciitis","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"Ultrasound-targeted focused ESWT with Dornier Epos Ultra lithotripter","comparator":"Focused treatment under local anaesthesia versus sham with the same anaesthesia","findings":"Twelve-week composite success was 43/127 versus 39/129, with a difference CI from −8.0 to 15.1 percentage points. This is a protocol-specific result, not proof that every shockwave regimen fails.","patient_relevance":"In this 2003 study, 272 people with persistent plantar heel pain were assigned to shockwave or a sham procedure, both with local anesthesia. At 12 weeks, about one-third in each group met the study's combined success rule, with no clear extra benefit from shockwave. That rule required both a good symptom score and no additional treatment. Later improvement is harder to interpret because many people received further care. This study tests one protocol, not every form of shockwave.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"16/272 primary outcomes missing (8 per arm), including 9 unknown reasons; complete-outcome analysis called ITT with no sensitivity checks. Balanced attrition alone does not exclude bias.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: some concerns, preliminary. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"D3 Missing outcome data","source_locator":"Figure 1; Statistics; Table 2"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Primary outcome and planned sample-size rationale clearly reported, but no accessible dated original protocol/SAP to verify all analysis choices.","implication":"Prior appraisal judgment: some concerns / incomplete information. Retain the result/access qualifications and resolve the linked verification questions before synthesis.","verification":"interpretation","prior_domain":"D5 Selection of reported result","source_locator":"Statistics; protocol availability search"}],"depth":"pilot_appraisal_reused","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12855524/","next":["Recover original eligibility/prior-care supplement and original protocol if publicly available.","Second extraction of primary and harms denominators.","Review full original PDF when legitimately accessible; current review used complete PMC HTML and visual flowchart."]},{"id":"SW200-027","pmid":"42744356","doi":"10.1136/bmjopen-2026-122686","title":"Patient expectations assessed before randomisation and after the first treatment session, and their associations with pain outcome at 3 months in patients with tennis elbow: a secondary analysis of a randomised controlled feasibility trial in Norwegian secondary care.","year":2026,"condition":"Lateral epicondylalgia; treatment expectations","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"secondary_analysis","levelLabel":{"en":"Secondary reports","pt-BR":"Relatos secundários"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Exploratory secondary analysis of a feasibility trial","pt-BR":"Análise secundária exploratória de um ensaio de viabilidade"},"report_type":"Exploratory secondary analysis of randomized feasibility trial","population":"Human; 54 participants in secondary analysis","sample":{"n":54,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"54 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"54 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 54 participants in secondary analysis","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":["SW200-059"],"source_note":"NCT04803825","link_status":"linked_in_catalog","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Heavy slow resistance training, shockwave and advice; expectation-outcome associations","findings":"Post-session expected pain was associated with later pain (b 0.61, 95% CI 0.33–0.89; R² 0.27); baseline expectations were not. Adding education and baseline pain raised explained variance to 0.32.","patient_relevance":"Can support an explanation of expectations and unmasked treatment research without implying pain is imaginary or solely psychological.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Expectations after allocation are postrandomization variables.","implication":"The association does not show expectations caused outcomes; early symptom response and treatment experience may influence both.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"This is a 54-person exploratory secondary analysis, not the trial efficacy comparison.","implication":"Do not count it as independent evidence that shockwave reduces pain.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The same registry is stated for the underlying feasibility trial.","implication":"Link companion reports to avoid double counting participants.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42744356/","next":["Verify prespecified analyses and missing data relative to the parent trial.","Link registry NCT04803825 and companion PMID 39806585."]},{"id":"SW200-030","pmid":"42603267","doi":"10.1002/brb3.71652","title":"Shockwave Therapy or Acupoint Stimulation Combined With Physiotherapy for Spasticity and Motor Function in Post-Stroke Recovery: A Randomized Controlled Trial.","year":2026,"condition":"Post-stroke upper and lower limb spasticity and motor impairment","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Post-stroke spasticity and motor function","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e função motora após AVC"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Three-arm randomized controlled trial","population":"Human; 120 post-stroke patients, 40 per arm","sample":{"n":120,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"120 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"120 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 120 post-stroke patients, 40 per arm","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"CTRI/2025/05/087383","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"ESWT plus usual physiotherapy versus Acu-TENS plus usual physiotherapy versus usual physiotherapy","findings":"Many ESWT-versus-Acu-TENS differences were nonsignificant; upper-limb MTS and later upper-limb FMA and walking outcomes favored ESWT in selected contrasts.","patient_relevance":"Can inform discussion of several rehabilitation adjuncts, but should not rank them from selected significant endpoints.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Numerous limbs, scales and timepoints generate multiple contrasts.","implication":"Isolated p-values need multiplicity and prespecification context before declaring one adjunct superior.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Abstract details active-versus-active contrasts more than comparisons with physiotherapy alone.","implication":"The claim that both are useful adjuncts requires direct add-on estimates versus usual care.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"MAS similarity is described alongside differences on selected other measures.","implication":"Nonsignificance does not establish interchangeability or equivalent patient benefit.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42603267/","next":["Check CTRI/2025/05/087383 timing and primary-outcome plan.","Extract all usual-care contrasts, confidence intervals and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-031","pmid":"42087422","doi":"10.12659/msm.951779","title":"Comparison of Outcomes From Radial Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy Combined With Physical Therapy Versus Infrared Therapy Combined With Physical Therapy Among Patients With Myofascial Low Back Pain.","year":2026,"condition":"Myofascial chronic low back pain","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Myofascial low back pain","pt-BR":"Dor lombar miofascial"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized adjunct-treatment trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado de tratamento associado"},"report_type":"Randomized comparative add-on trial","population":"Human; 112 patients, 56 per group","sample":{"n":112,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"112 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"112 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 112 patients, 56 per group","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Radial ESWT plus physical therapy versus infrared plus physical therapy","findings":"Reported NRS changes were 0.68 versus 0.13 and ODI changes 5.29 versus 0.84, with statistical significance and moderate-to-large standardized effects.","patient_relevance":"May help patients compare options after a myofascial diagnosis, with realistic expectations about the size of symptom change.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Large standardized effects accompany small absolute changes on NRS and ODI.","implication":"Clinical importance must be judged on the original scales and baseline severity, not Cohen’s d alone.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"Comparator is another physical modality rather than sham ESWT.","implication":"This estimates relative care-package effects, not efficacy against an inert matched exposure.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Population is myofascial low back pain.","implication":"Do not extend the result to radiculopathy, spinal stenosis or all chronic back pain.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42087422/","next":["Check NRS/ODI scales, change direction and confidence intervals.","Verify diagnostic criteria, participant masking and outcomes beyond six weeks."]},{"id":"SW200-035","pmid":"41913227","doi":"10.1186/s12984-026-01901-2","title":"Efficacy of different frequencies of extracorporeal shockwave on plantar flexor spasticity of the ankle in patients with stroke: a single-center, prospective, single-blind, randomized controlled trial.","year":2026,"condition":"Post-stroke ankle plantar-flexor spasticity","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Post-stroke spasticity and motor function","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e função motora após AVC"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized treatment-schedule comparison","pt-BR":"Comparação randomizada de esquemas de tratamento"},"report_type":"Single-center single-blind randomized frequency-comparison trial","population":"Human; 45 patients, fifteen per group","sample":{"n":45,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"45 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"45 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 45 patients, fifteen per group","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"ChiCTR2400079721","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Conventional rehabilitation alone versus adjunct 4 Hz versus 10 Hz ESWT","findings":"Both active groups improved selected tone and mechanical outcomes versus control. Frequency differences were mainly lateral gastrocnemius stiffness; five patients reported transient mild pain.","patient_relevance":"Helps explain that pulse frequency is a dosing research question rather than a settled patient prescription.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Many outcomes were tested, but frequency superiority relies on selected stiffness contrasts.","implication":"Do not declare 4 Hz clinically superior without prespecified primary comparisons and multiplicity handling.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Follow-up covers an immediate session and three-week course.","implication":"Durable walking improvement and long-term dosing choices are not demonstrated.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Frequency is varied with pulse count and pressure held constant.","implication":"Confirm actual delivery duration and device modality; bar units alone should not determine classification.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41913227/","next":["Inspect ChiCTR2400079721 and primary outcomes.","Extract functional between-group estimates, confidence intervals and blinded-assessment procedures."]},{"id":"SW200-039","pmid":"41593558","doi":"10.1186/s12891-026-09542-1","title":"Comparative efficacy of corticosteroid injection, extracorporeal shock wave therapy, and radiofrequency ablation for chronic plantar fasciitis: a prospective randomized controlled trial.","year":2026,"condition":"Chronic plantar fasciitis after at least six months of conservative treatment","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Prospective randomized comparative trial","population":"Human; 49 patients contributing 62 feet across three arms","sample":{"n":49,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"49 people contributed 62 feet; feet are not independent people.","pt-BR":"49 pessoas contribuíram com 62 pés; pés não correspondem a pessoas independentes."},"source_population":"Human; 49 patients contributing 62 feet across three arms","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"NCT06737445","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Ultrasound-guided steroid injection versus three weekly ESWT sessions versus radiofrequency thermal lesioning","findings":"Steroid pain results were better than ESWT at one month; radiofrequency favored later pain and selected function outcomes, particularly at twelve months.","patient_relevance":"Relevant to specialist choices for stubborn heel pain; does not justify escalating directly to an invasive procedure from an abstract.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Some patients contributed both feet.","implication":"Precision may be overstated unless within-person correlation and the actual randomization unit were handled.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"design","observation":"Procedures vary in invasiveness and number of sessions.","implication":"Benefits need comparison with adverse events, burden and additional care, not outcome rank alone.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Numerous significant contrasts are described without effect sizes or confidence intervals.","implication":"A strongest-treatment claim is premature without magnitude, adjustment and attrition data.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41593558/","next":["Check NCT06737445 timing, allocation unit and analysis clustering.","Extract primary pain contrast, losses and procedure-specific harms."]},{"id":"SW200-042","pmid":"41308020","doi":"10.1177/02692155251394951","title":"Does radial shockwave therapy lead to immediate improvements in pain in people with insertional Achilles tendinopathy? A randomised controlled trial.","year":2026,"condition":"Insertional Achilles tendinopathy; immediate movement-evoked pain","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Insertional Achilles tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia insercional do tendão de Aquiles"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Companion randomized-trial report: immediate pain","pt-BR":"Relato complementar de ensaio randomizado: dor imediata"},"report_type":"Randomized sham-controlled trial report","population":"Human; 76 adults, symptoms over three months","sample":{"n":76,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"76 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"76 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 76 adults, symptoms over three months","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":["SW200-004"],"source_note":"ACTRN12620000035921","link_status":"linked_in_catalog","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Three radial sessions versus no-pressure sham; identical education and exercise","findings":"No immediate advantage was reported at any session: differences −0.4, 0.4 and −0.4 with intervals spanning zero. Average improvements were 0.6 and 0.7 points in active and sham arms.","patient_relevance":"Useful for setting expectations about immediate pain relief during a session; it does not answer every longer-term rehabilitation question.","critique":[{"category":"reporting","observation":"Methods specify a 100-mm VAS, while results use “points” near zero to ten scale magnitudes.","implication":"Verify unit conversion before reproducing or pooling the estimates.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Outcome is immediate movement-evoked pain.","implication":"Do not infer the absence of later effects from this immediate endpoint alone.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"Exact registry ACTRN12620000035921 is supplied.","implication":"Link companion publications under one trial family rather than count reports as independent patients.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41308020/","next":["Verify VAS units and prespecified immediate outcome.","Match registry and authors to other reports, including the pilot Achilles appraisal."]},{"id":"SW200-043","pmid":"41063112","doi":"10.1186/s12891-025-09103-y","title":"The effectiveness of radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy (rESWT) in plantar fasciitis: a 12 months randomised controlled trial in a Tunisian rehabilitation department.","year":2025,"condition":"Plantar fasciitis in tertiary rehabilitation care","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Randomized comparative trial","population":"Human; 129 patients, predominantly women, mean BMI 29.2","sample":{"n":129,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"129 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"129 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 129 patients, predominantly women, mean BMI 29.2","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PACTR202308802969500","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Radial ESWT versus physiotherapy plus therapeutic ultrasound","findings":"Both groups had declining VAS scores without significant between-group differences at any post-treatment time. Pes cavus and pes planus were common baseline findings.","patient_relevance":"Useful for realistic comparison of two rehabilitation programs; foot assessment can be discussed without turning observed prevalence into causation.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Within-group pain improvement occurs without a comparative advantage.","implication":"Neither isolated ESWT efficacy nor equivalence to the alternative package follows from these findings.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"Recruitment began before the stated August 2023 registry date.","implication":"Check prospective registration of endpoints and whether protocol changes occurred; retrospective timing alone is not proof of selective reporting.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Foot-posture prevalence is descriptive.","implication":"It does not prove that correcting posture modifies response or that posture caused pain.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41063112/","next":["Inspect PACTR202308802969500 dates and endpoint history.","Extract twelve-month retention, confidence intervals and treatment protocols."]},{"id":"SW200-045","pmid":"40671207","doi":"10.1002/jfa2.70067","title":"One-Year Trajectory of Pain, Function, and Health-Related Quality of Life in Patients With Plantar Fasciopathy.","year":2025,"condition":"Plantar fasciopathy recovery trajectories","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"secondary_analysis","levelLabel":{"en":"Secondary reports","pt-BR":"Relatos secundários"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Secondary trajectory analysis of a randomized trial","pt-BR":"Análise secundária de trajetórias em ensaio randomizado"},"report_type":"Longitudinal secondary analysis of a four-arm randomized trial","population":"Human; 200 patients referred to specialized care","sample":{"n":200,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"200 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"200 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 200 patients referred to specialized care","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":["SW200-005"],"source_note":"NCT03472989","link_status":"linked_in_catalog","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Advice and orthoses alone or with radial ESWT, sham or high-load exercise; focus is trajectories","findings":"Improvement was greatest in the first three months. Bilateral pain was associated with different resting-pain/function trajectories and little improvement from six to twelve months.","patient_relevance":"Helpful for discussing recovery timing and follow-up, while avoiding a guaranteed individual recovery schedule.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"This report analyzes a previously randomized cohort under NCT03472989.","implication":"It is not another independent 200-patient treatment trial for pooling.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Bilateral-pain association is prognostic rather than a randomized exposure.","implication":"Do not claim bilateral symptoms cause slower recovery or prescribe different treatment solely from association.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"All participants received advice and custom orthoses with optional trial adjuncts.","implication":"Trajectories describe treated specialist-care patients, not untreated natural history.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40671207/","next":["Link NCT03472989 to pilot PMID 38904119.","Inspect treatment adjustments, missing-data assumptions and trajectory uncertainty."]},{"id":"SW200-046","pmid":"40841952","doi":"10.1186/s12984-025-01724-7","title":"Dose-response effectiveness of focused shockwave therapy on ultrasonographic muscular properties in patients with stroke exhibiting ankle spasticity.","year":2025,"condition":"Post-stroke ankle plantar-flexor spasticity; imaging dose response","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Post-stroke spasticity and motor function","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e função motora após AVC"},"level":"secondary_analysis","levelLabel":{"en":"Secondary reports","pt-BR":"Relatos secundários"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Post hoc analysis of a randomized trial","pt-BR":"Análise posterior de um ensaio randomizado"},"report_type":"Post hoc analysis of a double-blind randomized dose-comparison trial","population":"Human; 39 stroke patients","sample":{"n":39,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"39 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"39 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 39 stroke patients","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"focused","comparator":"4000 versus 2000 pulses per session; both active ESWT","findings":"No significant between-group effects on pennation angle, fascicle length or elastography. Some pooled time changes and within-high-dose correlations with clinical scales were reported.","patient_relevance":"Useful for showing that more pulses are not automatically better and that imaging correlations do not establish functional recovery.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"No architectural between-group effect was found, but conclusion suggests higher dose may enhance architecture.","implication":"Within-group correlations and pooled time trends do not demonstrate a dose-dependent treatment effect.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"Analysis is explicitly post hoc.","implication":"Multiple imaging/timepoint correlations require exploratory labeling and replication.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Both groups received active shockwave.","implication":"The report cannot distinguish overall shockwave benefit from rehabilitation, time or common exposure.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40841952/","next":["Find parent trial and exact registry before family assignment.","Extract confidence intervals, multiplicity plan and complete clinical contrasts."]},{"id":"SW200-049","pmid":"40629484","doi":"10.1186/s13287-025-04499-9","title":"High-activity placenta-derived mesenchymal stem cells combined with low-intensity extracorporeal shock wave therapy for diabetic erectile dysfunction: a prospective randomized controlled trial.","year":2025,"condition":"Refractory diabetic erectile dysfunction","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Erectile dysfunction","pt-BR":"Disfunção erétil"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Prospective randomized experimental combination trial","population":"Human; 33 patients assigned to three groups","sample":{"n":33,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"33 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"33 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 33 patients assigned to three groups","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Placenta-derived mesenchymal cells versus low-intensity ESWT versus combined treatment","findings":"Combination arm showed superior selected erection-duration outcomes and 70% with EHS greater than two at six months; no severe events reported.","patient_relevance":"Research-background only for a highly selected experimental combination; should not appear as a routine treatment option for patients.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Three active groups lack a no-treatment/sham fourth factorial cell.","implication":"A combination outperforming either component does not by itself prove biological synergy.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Only about eleven participants per arm and multiple functional measures.","implication":"Estimates are fragile; check the 70% denominator, losses and multiplicity.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Experimental cell therapy changes risk, regulation and clinical context.","implication":"Do not generalize to ordinary shockwave treatment or describe long-term cell safety from six months of observation.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40629484/","next":["Verify registry, cell-product characterization, permissions and long-term safety plan.","Extract all randomized denominators, prespecified endpoint and between-group confidence intervals."]},{"id":"SW200-053","pmid":"40275291","doi":"10.1186/s12891-025-08659-z","title":"The effectiveness of radial shockwave therapy on myofascial pain syndrome: a two-armed, randomized double-blind placebo-controlled trial.","year":2025,"condition":"Neck and upper-back myofascial pain syndrome","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Neck and trapezius myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial cervical e do trapézio"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial with sham / placebo control","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com tratamento simulado / placebo"},"report_type":"Double-blind placebo-controlled randomized trial","population":"Human; 70 adults in tertiary rehabilitation care","sample":{"n":70,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"70 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"70 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 70 adults in tertiary rehabilitation care","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"NCT05381987","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Six radial sessions plus exercises versus low-energy sham plus same exercises","findings":"No statistically or clinically significant between-group differences at four, eight or twelve weeks. Both groups improved pain and pressure threshold; conclusion nevertheless recommends adjunct radial treatment.","patient_relevance":"A strong teaching example that getting better during treatment does not prove the machine supplied the benefit.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Recommendation is based on improvements shared with the placebo arm.","implication":"The randomized contrast does not support an incremental adjunct benefit; this is a specific conclusion-to-results mismatch.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"Control is described as no-energy despite specified nonzero pressure.","implication":"Verify sham construction, delivered energy and credibility before calling it physiologically inert.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"All patients received stretching, exercise and home rehabilitation.","implication":"Observed recovery may reflect common care, context or time; this trial does not isolate those components.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40275291/","next":["Verify NCT05381987 history, masking and sham delivery.","Extract effect estimates, confidence intervals and clinically important thresholds."]},{"id":"SW200-059","pmid":"39806585","doi":"10.1136/bmjopen-2024-085916","title":"Heavy slow resistance training, radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy or advice for patients with tennis elbow in the Norwegian secondary care: a randomised controlled feasibility trial.","year":2024,"condition":"Lateral epicondylalgia in specialist care","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized feasibility trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado de viabilidade"},"report_type":"Three-arm randomized feasibility trial","population":"Human; sixty randomized participants in feasibility trial","sample":{"n":60,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"60 randomized in a feasibility trial; not a definitive efficacy sample.","pt-BR":"60 participantes randomizados em um estudo de viabilidade; amostra sem finalidade de confirmação definitiva de eficácia."},"source_population":"Human; sixty randomized participants in feasibility trial","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":["SW200-027"],"source_note":"NCT04803825","link_status":"linked_in_catalog","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Heavy slow resistance training versus radial ESWT versus information/advice","findings":"Recruitment fell slightly below target; only 6/19 complied with heavy resistance training. Six-month retention missed criteria; all arms improved symptom/performance measures.","patient_relevance":"Useful for discussing treatment burden and feasibility of exercise protocols, not for telling patients shockwave is superior to exercise.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Trial is explicitly designed around feasibility criteria.","implication":"It is not powered or presented as a definitive treatment-effect comparison.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Abstract reports sixty randomized as 92% after sixty-nine eligible; stated denominators need reconciliation.","implication":"Check the CONSORT flow before calculating recruitment proportions; this may reflect a different consenting denominator.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Low compliance is interpreted as training being unsuitable.","implication":"This conclusion may depend on the exact load progression, support and selected patients rather than all resistance training.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39806585/","next":["Link expectation companion PMID 42744356 using NCT04803825.","Check adherence definition, adverse symptoms, recruitment denominator and protocol revisions."]},{"id":"SW200-060","pmid":"39652840","doi":"10.1080/10790268.2024.2379067","title":"Shockwave therapy in persons with a spinal cord injury and spasticity: A multiple single-case experimental design study.","year":2025,"condition":"Spasticity after chronic spinal cord injury","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Spasticity after spinal cord injury","pt-BR":"Espasticidade após lesão medular"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Multiple single-case experiments with randomized baseline length","pt-BR":"Experimentos de caso único com duração da linha de base randomizada"},"report_type":"Multiple single-case experimental study with randomized baseline length","population":"Human; eleven adults, mean injury duration nine years","sample":{"n":11,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"11 adults in multiple single-case experiments; baseline length was randomized, not parallel treatment groups.","pt-BR":"11 adultos em experimentos de caso único; houve randomização da duração da linha de base, não de grupos paralelos de tratamento."},"source_population":"Human; eleven adults, mean injury duration nine years","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Within-person baseline phases versus treatment/follow-up; no parallel sham group","findings":"Twenty-eight of thirty-three individual goals improved descriptively; secondary measures varied and no serious events occurred.","patient_relevance":"Patient-chosen activities make the report valuable for discussing meaningful goals, but its design cannot securely separate treatment from context or time.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Randomized baseline length differs from a parallel randomized controlled trial.","implication":"Do not let the indexed RCT label imply sham-controlled efficacy evidence.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Thirty-three goals belong to eleven people.","implication":"Goals are not independent patients; a 28/33 figure must not become an 85% patient response rate.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Targets vary between hand and calf with individualized daily activities.","implication":"Useful functional signals are exploratory and cannot define a common dose or expected effect.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39652840/","next":["Inspect baseline stability, randomization tests and individual trajectories.","Check goal-setting blinding, concomitant rehabilitation and all adverse events."]},{"id":"SW200-061","pmid":"39172722","doi":"10.1097/js9.0000000000002063","title":"Effects of supplementing extracorporeal shockwave therapy to hyaluronic acid injection among patients with rotator cuff lesions without complete tear: a prospective double-blinded randomized study.","year":2024,"condition":"Rotator-cuff lesions without complete tear","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Rotator-cuff / subacromial pain: mixed or unspecified subtype","pt-BR":"Dor do manguito rotador / subacromial: subtipo misto ou não especificado"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized treatment-schedule comparison","pt-BR":"Comparação randomizada de esquemas de tratamento"},"report_type":"Prospective double-blind randomized adjunct-dose trial","population":"Human; patients with non-complete rotator-cuff lesions; sample size absent in abstract","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Sample size is not stated in the abstract used for screening.","pt-BR":"O resumo usado na avaliação não informa o número de participantes."},"source_population":"Human; patients with non-complete rotator-cuff lesions; sample size absent in abstract","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Three hyaluronic-acid injections plus two sham sessions versus one active/one sham versus two active ESWT sessions","findings":"Selected functional/motion contrasts favored one or two ESWT sessions at one or six months. No MRI deterioration was reported in the one-session group.","patient_relevance":"Potentially useful for combination care after a specific rotator-cuff diagnosis; avoid equating better motion with proven structural healing.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Many endpoints/timepoints show a patchwork of significant contrasts without a consistent dose pattern.","implication":"Check prespecified primary endpoint, interaction and multiplicity before declaring a general dose benefit.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"design","observation":"All participants receive hyaluronic-acid injections.","implication":"Result concerns ESWT added to this injection regimen, not stand-alone shockwave or injection efficacy.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"No MRI deterioration is stated for one group without a quantified between-group structural contrast.","implication":"This cannot establish tendon repair or protection from future tearing.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39172722/","next":["Extract numbers, allocation, dose settings and outcome hierarchy.","Check all MRI groups, missing scans, confidence intervals and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-063","pmid":"39472446","doi":"10.1038/s41598-024-77410-w","title":"Focused shock wave and ultrasound therapies in the treatment of lateral epicondylitis - a randomized control trial.","year":2024,"condition":"Persistent lateral epicondylitis","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Three-arm randomized controlled trial","population":"Human; sixty patients, twenty per group","sample":{"n":60,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"60 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"60 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; sixty patients, twenty per group","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"ISRCTN11907358","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"focused","comparator":"Three focused sessions versus ten ultrasound sessions versus placebo ultrasound; massage in all groups","findings":"Pain/function percentage changes favored focused shockwave over ultrasound. Strength improved within active groups without between-group percentage-change differences.","patient_relevance":"Relevant to comparing short procedural courses, but it does not isolate massage benefit or establish a universal shockwave protocol.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The sham is ultrasound sham rather than a matched shockwave sham.","implication":"It does not by itself control sensation, expectation or contact for the shockwave procedure.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Abstract highlights focused-versus-ultrasound comparisons but gives little on focused-versus-placebo ultrasound.","implication":"Extract all randomized contrasts before accepting the recommended combination.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Effects are assessed with percentage changes from baseline.","implication":"Check baseline dependence, prespecification and confidence intervals rather than interpreting percentage change as inherently comparable.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39472446/","next":["Inspect ISRCTN11907358, primary endpoint and planned analysis.","Extract placebo comparison, attendance, assessor masking and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-065","pmid":"39019948","doi":"10.1038/s41598-024-67313-1","title":"Effects of extracorporeal shockwave therapy versus ultrasonic therapy and deep friction massage in the management of lateral epicondylitis: a randomized clinical trial.","year":2024,"condition":"Lateral epicondylitis","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Randomized comparative trial described as double-blind","population":"Human; eighty participants","sample":{"n":80,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"80 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"80 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; eighty participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"ESWT versus ultrasound plus deep friction massage","findings":"Reported PRTEE medians fell from 24 to 1.5 with ESWT and from 25 to 11.5 with ultrasound/massage by week seven; authors report superior ESWT results.","patient_relevance":"Could inform short-term elbow care comparison after verification, but should not become a near-complete recovery claim from abstract medians.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Visible and tactile procedures differ substantially despite double-blind labeling.","implication":"Identify who was actually masked and whether sham procedures made participant blinding credible.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"PRTEE values are described as percentile scores without a clear scale transformation.","implication":"Verify scoring range and original units before applying clinical thresholds or pooling.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Very large short-term changes are reported without confidence intervals or longer outcomes.","implication":"Magnitude, missing data and reproducibility need checking; striking results alone are not evidence of error.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39019948/","next":["Extract randomization/concealment, masking roles and intervention dose.","Check PRTEE scoring, attrition, baseline-adjusted estimates and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-066","pmid":"38727119","doi":"10.52312/jdrs.2024.1648","title":"Comparison of local massage, steroid injection, and extracorporeal shock wave therapy efficacy in the treatment of lateral epicondylitis.","year":2024,"condition":"Lateral epicondylitis","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparative study","pt-BR":"Estudo comparativo não randomizado"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Prospective randomized comparative trial","population":"Human; 52 patients across three groups","sample":{"n":52,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"52 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"52 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 52 patients across three groups","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Local massage versus corticosteroid injection versus ESWT","findings":"All groups initially improved. At six months only ESWT retained significant within-group improvements; authors conclude ESWT was superior throughout.","patient_relevance":"Useful in a comparison table only with the distinction between continued within-group improvement and an established comparative benefit.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"The abstract largely contrasts which groups improved significantly from their own baselines.","implication":"Different within-group significance does not prove between-group superiority.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Conclusion of superiority throughout is not accompanied by direct effect estimates in the abstract.","implication":"Retrieve actual group-by-time comparisons before presenting a treatment rank.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Small groups and work-module outcomes may represent different baseline activity demands.","implication":"Precision, occupational context and missing data are important to interpretation.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38727119/","next":["Extract direct between-group contrasts and confidence intervals.","Verify primary outcome, injection/massage protocols, masking and follow-up losses."]},{"id":"SW200-070","pmid":"38813497","doi":"10.55730/1300-0144.5753","title":"Comparison of the effectiveness of instrument-assisted soft tissue mobilization and extracorporeal shock wave therapy in myofascial pain syndrome.","year":2023,"condition":"Myofascial pain syndrome involving the neck region","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Neck and trapezius myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial cervical e do trapézio"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized adjunct-treatment trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado de tratamento associado"},"report_type":"Three-arm randomized adjunct-treatment trial","population":"Human; 42 women aged 18–60","sample":{"n":42,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"42 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"42 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 42 women aged 18–60","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Conservative treatment alone versus plus IASTM versus plus ESWT; home stretching in all arms","findings":"IASTM favored pain, pressure threshold and motion. Between-group changes in broader neck outcomes and anxiety/depression were not significant.","patient_relevance":"Can inform short-term multimodal neck-pain research but should not imply durable psychological or disability improvement.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"All participants were women and assessment was three days after treatment.","implication":"Generalization across sexes and claims of lasting benefit are unsupported.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The abstract does not report clear ESWT-versus-conservative-care superiority.","implication":"A conclusion that all treatments alleviate MPS cannot be taken as specific evidence for adding ESWT.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"Several concurrent conservative treatments are delivered frequently.","implication":"Identify their content and adherence to understand which contrast the trial estimates.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38813497/","next":["Extract conservative-care components, exact muscles and device type.","Check prespecified primary outcome, direct ESWT contrasts, masking and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-072","pmid":"33512943","doi":"10.1097/jsm.0000000000000880","title":"Three Sessions of Radial Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy Gives No Additional Benefit Over \"Minimal-Dose\" Radial Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy for Patients With Chronic Greater Trochanteric Pain Syndrome: A Double-Blinded, Randomized, Controlled Trial.","year":2022,"condition":"Chronic refractory greater trochanteric pain syndrome","category":"hip_pelvis","categoryLabel":{"en":"Hip and pelvis","pt-BR":"Quadril e pelve"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Greater trochanteric pain / gluteal tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Dor trocantérica / tendinopatia glútea"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized treatment-schedule comparison","pt-BR":"Comparação randomizada de esquemas de tratamento"},"report_type":"Double-blind randomized dose-comparison trial","population":"Human; 120 patients, predominantly women, mean symptoms about forty-five months","sample":{"n":120,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"120 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"120 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 120 patients, predominantly women, mean symptoms about forty-five months","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Recommended/maximally tolerated dose versus minimal dose; same home exercises","findings":"Both arms improved selected symptoms and sleep, without time-by-group interaction at any follow-up. Authors retain several explanations, including an active minimal dose or no specific efficacy.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining uncertainty about dose and the importance of shared rehabilitation, without promising improvement from a stronger setting.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Minimal-dose comparator may have physiological activity.","implication":"A neutral contrast cannot distinguish both-dose benefit from common exercise/context or neither-dose benefit.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"High retention strengthens interpretability but does not establish equivalence.","implication":"Effect confidence intervals and clinical margins remain necessary.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Population had long-standing symptoms despite rehabilitation.","implication":"Do not apply results automatically to early GTPS or focused-device regimens.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/33512943/","next":["Extract exact doses, sham credibility and primary effect precision.","Review comment PMID 34759179 and verify exercise adherence."]},{"id":"SW200-079","pmid":"32390724","doi":null,"title":"One Session of Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy-Induced Modulation on Tendon Shear Modulus is Associated with Reduction in Pain.","year":2020,"condition":"Patellar tendinopathy","category":"knee","categoryLabel":{"en":"Knee","pt-BR":"Joelho"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Patellar tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia patelar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial with acute mechanistic outcomes","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com desfechos mecanísticos agudos"},"report_type":"Randomized acute mechanistic trial","population":"Human; 34 young male volleyball/basketball athletes","sample":{"n":34,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"34 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"34 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 34 young male volleyball/basketball athletes","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"One session at 0.13–0.33 mJ/mm² versus nominal sham below 0.08 mJ/mm²","findings":"Shear modulus decreased significantly within the active group but not sham. Active-group stiffness change correlated with squat-pain change, not pressure pain.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining the limits of ultrasound stiffness measurements and short-term mechanistic findings.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Active-arm p=.001 and sham p=.06 are reported without a between-group change contrast.","implication":"Different within-group significance levels do not prove a treatment-by-time effect.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"The nominal sham delivers a low stated energy.","implication":"Its biological inactivity and credibility require checking.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"The window is immediate and the pain correlation is within one small arm.","implication":"This does not demonstrate durable healing or that stiffness change causes pain relief.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32390724/","next":["Extract actual between-group estimates and intervals.","Verify device, sham credibility and correlation prespecification."]},{"id":"SW200-081","pmid":"31033610","doi":"10.1097/jsm.0000000000000520","title":"Comparison of the Effect of 5 Different Treatment Options for Managing Patellar Tendinopathy: A Secondary Analysis.","year":2019,"condition":"Patellar tendinopathy","category":"knee","categoryLabel":{"en":"Knee","pt-BR":"Joelho"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Patellar tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia patelar"},"level":"secondary_analysis","levelLabel":{"en":"Secondary reports","pt-BR":"Relatos secundários"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Pooled secondary analysis of randomized-trial datasets","pt-BR":"Análise secundária agrupada de bases de ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"Secondary pooled analysis of randomized-trial datasets","population":"Human; 138 participants pooled from three trials","sample":{"n":138,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"138 participants pooled from three trial datasets; not newly recruited.","pt-BR":"138 participantes de três bases de ensaios; não houve novo recrutamento."},"source_population":"Human; 138 participants pooled from three trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Five received-treatment groups including ESWT, ESWT/exercise, exercise, GTN/exercise and placebo","findings":"Fifty-two improved; exercise and ESWT/exercise had higher odds of improvement. The independent ESWT role remained uncertain.","patient_relevance":"Relevant to exercise and recovery expectations, but not a validated personalized treatment-selection tool.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Five treatments were pooled across three trials rather than randomized together.","implication":"Trial populations and protocols can confound apparent rankings.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Exercise alone includes 17 participants, and prognostic findings are described as trends.","implication":"Sparse groups and exploratory predictors cannot establish patient-specific treatment rules.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"This reuses previous randomized datasets.","implication":"Link parent trials to avoid counting a secondary analysis as new independent evidence.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31033610/","next":["Identify all parent trials and adjustment for trial/site.","Extract odds-ratio intervals and reference categories.","Check missing-data handling and prespecification."]},{"id":"SW200-088","pmid":"12234230","doi":"10.1001/jama.288.11.1364","title":"Ultrasound-guided extracorporeal shock wave therapy for plantar fasciitis: a randomized controlled trial.","year":2002,"condition":"Ultrasound-confirmed plantar fasciitis","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial with sham / placebo control","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com tratamento simulado / placebo"},"report_type":"Double-blind placebo-controlled randomized trial","population":"Human; 166 adults enrolled, 160 completed the 15-week protocol; symptoms at least six weeks","sample":{"n":166,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"166 enrolled; 160 completed the 15-week protocol.","pt-BR":"166 participantes incluídos; 160 concluíram o protocolo de 15 semanas."},"source_population":"Human; 166 adults enrolled, 160 completed the 15-week protocol; symptoms at least six weeks","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Three weekly ultrasound-guided ESWT sessions versus low cumulative-dose placebo","findings":"Both groups improved similarly. No measured between-group outcome difference was statistically significant; overall pain improvement at 12 weeks was 26.3 versus 25.7 in the abstract's scale.","patient_relevance":"Explains why placebo-controlled trials can show improvement in both groups without an added device effect.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"Eligibility begins at six weeks rather than requiring long-term refractory symptoms.","implication":"This population differs from chronic refractory trials and should be separated in synthesis.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract reports cumulative energy totals of at least 1,000 versus 6 mJ/mm².","implication":"These are not safely interchangeable with per-impulse energy settings; reconstruct the protocol before making dose comparisons.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Multiple outcomes are nonsignificant, but confidence intervals for the randomized effects are omitted.","implication":"Preserve lack of demonstrated benefit for this protocol without claiming every ESWT regimen ineffective.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12234230/","next":["Extract primary-outcome effect interval, device and dosing units.","Read the linked JAMA correspondence.","Verify sham credibility and analysis of the six missing participants."]},{"id":"SW200-091","pmid":"8666632","doi":"10.1302/0301-620x.78b2.0780233","title":"Analgesic effect of extracorporeal shock-wave therapy on chronic tennis elbow.","year":1996,"condition":"Chronic lateral epicondylitis (tennis elbow)","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Prospective randomized controlled trial","population":"Human; 100 patients with symptoms longer than 12 months","sample":{"n":100,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"100 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"100 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 100 patients with symptoms longer than 12 months","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified low-energy system","comparator":"3,000 impulses at 0.08 mJ/mm² versus 30 impulses","findings":"At final review good/excellent outcomes were reported for 48% versus 6%, and acceptable outcomes for 42% versus 24%, favoring the full-dose group.","patient_relevance":"Can inform historical evidence in persistent tennis elbow, but the large categorical result requires scrutiny before visualizing a success rate.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The control receives 30 impulses versus 3,000.","implication":"A large duration/sensation difference may compromise masking; control activity and credibility need verification.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Good, excellent and acceptable categories are not defined in the abstract.","implication":"These cannot be translated into recovery probabilities without outcome definitions and complete denominators.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"The report selects symptoms persisting beyond a year.","implication":"Applicability to recent-onset elbow pain is limited.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8666632/","next":["Extract category definitions, patient flow and absolute pain differences.","Verify allocation concealment, sham credibility and adverse events."]},{"id":"SW200-098","pmid":"41522497","doi":"10.7717/peerj.20506","title":"Extracorporeal shockwave therapy versus sham extracorporeal shockwave therapy for chronic Achilles tendinopathy: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.","year":2026,"condition":"Chronic Achilles tendinopathy; insertional/noninsertional classification explored","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendinopathy: mixed or unspecified location","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia do tendão de Aquiles: localização mista ou não especificada"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of sham-controlled randomized trials","population":"Human; eight randomized trials totaling 458 participants","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; eight randomized trials totaling 458 participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed/varied ESWT protocols","comparator":"ESWT versus sham","findings":"Overall comparisons showed no clear benefit at reported follow-ups. Symptom duration below 12 months showed exploratory pain differences of −0.76 at one month and −1.23 at three months; adverse events were 4.5% versus 1.2%, p=.12.","patient_relevance":"A useful counterweight to broad Achilles efficacy claims, while retaining uncertainty and differences in anatomy and protocols.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"The one-month subgroup estimate is smaller than the review's stated pain MCID of 1.1/10.","implication":"Statistical significance must not be described as a clinically important benefit at that timepoint.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Subgroup analyses are explicitly hypothesis-generating and involve several dimensions.","implication":"Verify interaction tests and study counts; within-subgroup significance is not proof of a treatment-response subgroup.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Adverse-event difference is nonsignificant but numerically higher with ESWT.","implication":"Nonsignificance does not establish equal safety, especially with uncommon events.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41522497/","next":["Extract pooled intervals and study-level site/modality classification.","Check subgroup interaction tests and multiplicity.","Verify harms definitions, denominators and included-trial overlap."]},{"id":"SW200-100","pmid":"40401767","doi":"10.1111/andr.70069","title":"Low-intensity shockwave therapy for erectile dysfunction due to diabetes mellitus or coronary artery disease: An individual participant data meta-analysis from a single center.","year":2026,"condition":"Vasculogenic erectile dysfunction associated with diabetes or coronary artery disease","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Erectile dysfunction","pt-BR":"Disfunção erétil"},"level":"secondary_analysis","levelLabel":{"en":"Secondary reports","pt-BR":"Relatos secundários"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Secondary individual-participant analysis of active-treatment arms","pt-BR":"Análise secundária de dados individuais dos braços de tratamento ativo"},"report_type":"Individual-participant-data secondary meta-analysis restricted to active-treatment recipients","population":"Human; 208 men receiving LiST from five single-center trials, including 50 with diabetes and 28 with CAD","sample":{"n":208,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"208 active-treatment recipients from five trials; control arms were excluded.","pt-BR":"208 participantes que receberam tratamento ativo em cinco ensaios; os braços de controle foram excluídos."},"source_population":"Human; 208 men receiving LiST from five single-center trials, including 50 with diabetes and 28 with CAD","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"focused; ARIES 2 Smart Focus specified in checked body","comparator":"DM versus no DM and CAD versus no CAD among LiST recipients, not LiST versus sham","findings":"Authors describe equal efficacy across etiologies. Table 2 nevertheless reports CAD versus no CAD MCID at three months OR 0.33 (95% CI 0.12–0.86); other estimates vary in precision.","patient_relevance":"Potentially useful for discussing uncertainty in diabetes/CAD, but cannot establish that LiST works equally well or is universally first-line.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The checked body includes only LiST recipients; comorbidity is not randomized.","implication":"This estimates association among treated patients, not a sham-controlled treatment effect or causal effect modification.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The equal-efficacy narrative conflicts with the significant CAD MCID contrast explicitly bolded in Table 2.","implication":"The summary must acknowledge this discordance and verify extraction before asserting equal response.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Only one center is represented, six-month CAD includes 13 patients, and some source arms include tadalafil.","implication":"Generalizability, sparse subgroups and co-treatment confounding limit broad claims and the authors' high-certainty language.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40401767/","next":["Independently verify Table 2 counts, effect calculation and multiplicity.","Identify all parent arms and adjust for tadalafil/trial design.","Check current guideline wording separately from this paper's first-line assertion."]},{"id":"SW200-101","pmid":"42733276","doi":"10.1111/os.70408","title":"The Effect of Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy in Tendinopathy: A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials.","year":2026,"condition":"Five tendinopathies: lateral elbow, rotator cuff, Achilles, greater trochanteric and patellar","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas tendinopatias"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review with pairwise and network meta-analysis of randomized trials","population":"Human; 65 publications and 3,921 cases across condition-specific networks","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 65 publications and 3,921 cases across condition-specific networks","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed/varied","comparator":"Placebo and multiple conservative interventions","findings":"Selected pain estimates favor ESWT in several conditions; patellar VISA-P versus placebo is nonsignificant. Shoulder pain heterogeneity is high (I² 89.1%). Network ranks place ESWT favorably for selected outcomes.","patient_relevance":"Useful as a map of why response differs by condition; rankings alone cannot choose an individual's best treatment.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The report spans five disorders and several outcome/comparator networks.","implication":"A favorable average or rank must not become an all-tendinopathy efficacy claim; preserve condition, comparator and follow-up.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Rotator cuff versus placebo has I² 89.1%, while active-treatment ranking differences often have intervals crossing no effect.","implication":"High rank does not establish superiority, and heterogeneity warrants calcific-status/dose/timepoint examination.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The abstract counts publications, not explicitly unique independent trials.","implication":"Check companion reports and correlated timepoints before using 3,921 as an independent-participant denominator.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42733276/","next":["Map unique trials and follow-ups by condition.","Assess network transitivity/inconsistency and GRADE judgments.","Reconcile Achilles sham estimates with more focused syntheses."]},{"id":"SW200-102","pmid":"42177532","doi":"10.1186/s13018-026-06984-0","title":"Comparison of the efficacy of different types and intensities of extracorporeal shock wave therapy for lateral epicondylitis: a systematic review and network meta-analysis.","year":2026,"condition":"Lateral epicondylitis","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review and network meta-analysis mixing randomized and cohort designs","population":"Human; 938 patients from 11 RCTs and two cohorts","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 938 patients from 11 RCTs and two cohorts","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed focused/radial with intensity categories","comparator":"Different ESWT modalities/intensities, sham and waiting","findings":"Authors report distinct highest-ranked regimens. Sham itself outperforms waiting, including a very large reported PRTEE SMD of −5.97.","patient_relevance":"Relevant to modality/dose questions but too fragile for a simple best-device recommendation without network verification.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Randomized and cohort studies enter the evidence network.","implication":"Confounding and study-design imbalance may affect indirect comparisons; examine RCT-only sensitivity analyses.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"A SUCRA of 100% is a ranking statistic, not a 100% response rate or certainty of benefit.","implication":"Patient visuals must use effect estimates with uncertainty rather than translating ranks into success probabilities.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The sham-versus-wait PRTEE SMD is unusually large at −5.97.","implication":"Verify scale, SD extraction, change/final scores and study contribution; unusual size is a query, not a proven error.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42177532/","next":["Check network geometry, transitivity and cohort sensitivity.","Verify extreme SMD extraction against primary reports.","Confirm intensity definitions are comparable across radial and focused devices."]},{"id":"SW200-105","pmid":"41670830","doi":"10.1007/s10103-026-04824-5","title":"Comparison of laser therapy and extracorporeal shock wave therapy in the treatment of patients with plantar fasciitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective studies.","year":2026,"condition":"Chronic plantar fasciitis","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of prospective studies; randomization mix not specified","population":"Human; 803 patients in ten prospective studies","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 803 patients in ten prospective studies","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified ESWT","comparator":"ESWT versus high-intensity laser; ESWT versus low-intensity laser; high versus low laser","findings":"Selected comparisons are nonsignificant: ESWT versus high-intensity laser VAS MD −0.50 (−1.42 to .42), FFI −8.08 (−22.09 to 5.94); the authors conclude similar efficacy.","patient_relevance":"Supports a careful discussion of uncertainty between laser and ESWT, not a claim that all options work equally well.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"The reported intervals include nonzero differences potentially relevant to patients.","implication":"Nonsignificance does not demonstrate equivalent efficacy among three therapies.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Included reports are called prospective studies, not exclusively randomized trials.","implication":"Confirm design-specific bias and perform randomized-only comparisons before causal ranking.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Different pairwise comparisons use different scales and unspecified post-treatment windows.","implication":"The same-looking pooled conclusion may hide differences in outcome definition and duration.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41670830/","next":["Extract trial designs, exact timepoints and modalities.","Compare confidence intervals with scale-specific important differences.","Check change-score SD handling and co-interventions."]},{"id":"SW200-106","pmid":"40591667","doi":"10.1530/eor-2024-0078","title":"Treatments for rotator cuff calcific tendinitis: a systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomized-controlled trials.","year":2025,"condition":"Rotator cuff calcific tendinitis","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Calcific rotator-cuff tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia calcária do manguito rotador"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review and network meta-analysis","population":"Human; 33 randomized trials covering 26 treatments","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 33 randomized trials covering 26 treatments","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42023476423","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed focused/high-energy and radial regimens","comparator":"Multiple nonsurgical packages and separate surgical comparisons","findings":"Comprehensive physical therapy ranks highest for function; radial ESWT plus PT ranks highest for pain. Authors explicitly report no direct operative-versus-nonoperative comparison.","patient_relevance":"Useful for showing several management options and the role of rehabilitation, with uncertainty about which combination is best.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Top SUCRA positions are presented as best or superior therapy.","implication":"Ranks must be accompanied by comparative effects, certainty and network connectivity; a top rank alone does not prove superiority.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"ESWT-plus-PT is a treatment package.","implication":"Its rank cannot isolate the contribution of shockwave from rehabilitation.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Surgery and nonoperative evidence lack direct comparison, and deposit resolution is not pooled.","implication":"Do not create a single definitive surgery-to-ESWT ladder or imply imaging and symptoms rank identically.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40591667/","next":["Inspect treatment-network connectivity and indirectness.","Extract absolute effects and certainty for ESWT-plus-PT.","Compare registered protocol and timepoint definitions."]},{"id":"SW200-107","pmid":"41002287","doi":"10.1111/os.70175","title":"Efficacy of Conservative Approaches on Pain Relief and Function in Patients With Rotator Cuff Calcific Tendinopathy: Which Is the Best Option? A Systematic Review and Network Meta-Analysis.","year":2025,"condition":"Rotator cuff calcific tendinopathy","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Calcific rotator-cuff tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia calcária do manguito rotador"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review and network meta-analysis of conservative treatments","population":"Human; 19 articles and 1,160 subjects","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 19 articles and 1,160 subjects","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD420250650833","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified ESWT node","comparator":"PRP, EDTA, aspiration, ESWT and other conservative options","findings":"Reported ranking probabilities favor PRP for function (85%), EDTA next (75%), aspiration (65%) and ESWT (57%); different rankings appear for pain.","patient_relevance":"Useful for identifying options worth discussing, but the ranking percentages must not become a treatment-benefit infographic.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Percentages are described as probabilities of improving function without providing clinical response denominators.","implication":"Treat these as network ranking metrics until verified, never as patient success rates.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Nineteen articles support multiple intervention nodes with potentially different co-treatments and follow-ups.","implication":"Sparse comparisons and transitivity assumptions can make rank order unstable.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract declares several strategies more effective without supplying effect sizes, reference treatments or intervals.","implication":"The superiority claim needs the league table and certainty assessment.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41002287/","next":["Determine exactly what the percentages represent.","Extract pairwise effects, intervals and network certainty.","Reconcile differing ranks with other calcific-shoulder reviews."]},{"id":"SW200-108","pmid":"42088914","doi":"10.3389/fneur.2026.1705104","title":"Extracorporeal shock wave therapy for post-stroke spasticity: an umbrella review of systematic reviews and meta-analyses.","year":2026,"condition":"Post-stroke spasticity","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Post-stroke spasticity and motor function","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e função motora após AVC"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Umbrella review","pt-BR":"Revisão de revisões"},"report_type":"Umbrella review","population":"Human evidence synthesized through 17 systematic reviews/meta-analyses","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human evidence synthesized through 17 systematic reviews/meta-analyses","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD420251124065","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed/unspecified","comparator":"Varied comparisons inherited from underlying reviews","findings":"All reviews suggest benefits, but 12 of 17 are low/very-low methodological quality and overlap is moderate. Authors call the evidence limited and inconclusive.","patient_relevance":"Can explain an emerging rehabilitation adjunct while preserving uncertainty about meaningful functional improvement.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Seventeen reviews share primary trials, with explicit moderate overlap.","implication":"Agreement among reviews is not 17 independent replications.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Spasticity, range of motion, pain and sensorimotor function are grouped in the summary.","implication":"Reduced tone scores should not automatically imply improved daily activities or durable neurological recovery.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract gives review-quality counts but not outcome-specific GRADE results or effects.","implication":"Patient claims require outcome/timepoint certainty and effect sizes, not only the overall positive direction.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42088914/","next":["Extract outcome-specific GRADE and functional effects.","Map unique trials and follow-up duration.","Check language/country restrictions and registered timing."]},{"id":"SW200-109","pmid":"40419363","doi":"10.3760/cma.j.cn501225-20241213-00486","title":"[A systematic review and Bayesian network meta-analysis of the effectiveness of non-pharmacological interventions in treating chronic wound pain in patients].","year":2025,"condition":"Chronic wound pain across wound types","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Chronic wounds and graft wounds","pt-BR":"Feridas crônicas e áreas de enxerto"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review and Bayesian network meta-analysis","population":"Human; 1,929 patients in 30 randomized trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 1,929 patients in 30 randomized trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified ESWT among many nonpharmacologic interventions","comparator":"Standard wound care, placebo and multiple device/behavioral treatments","findings":"Significant comparisons highlighted in the abstract favor several non-ESWT modalities. An ESWT-specific effect or interval is not reported.","patient_relevance":"Potentially useful for wound-pain options, but this is distinct from wound closure and supplies no extracted shockwave-specific benefit.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"ESWT is listed among included interventions, but the stated benefits concern other modalities.","implication":"This abstract cannot support an ESWT pain-relief claim.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The ranking presentation calls the 14th position best, without defining direction or all nodes.","implication":"Verify rank orientation and node definitions before translating this into a best-treatment graphic.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Different wounds and standards of care may contribute to the network.","implication":"Transitivity depends on wound etiology, severity and co-care, not just use of a pain scale.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40419363/","next":["Extract ESWT trials, effects and credible intervals.","Check wound etiologies, follow-up and ranking direction.","Separate pain outcomes from healing outcomes."]},{"id":"SW200-112","pmid":"40797370","doi":"10.1111/andr.70108","title":"Comparative efficacy of combination therapy including regenerative therapies versus monotherapy for erectile dysfunction: A systematic review and meta-analysis.","year":2026,"condition":"Erectile dysfunction, including vasculogenic and diabetic subgroups","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Erectile dysfunction","pt-BR":"Disfunção erétil"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review/meta-analysis of randomized and observational comparisons","population":"Human; 553 patients in eight studies","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 553 patients in eight studies","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42024522307","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified low-intensity ESWT","comparator":"PDE5 inhibitor plus Li-ESWT versus monotherapy; comparator type varies","findings":"The overall IIEF comparison was nonsignificant. Combination versus Li-ESWT alone favored combination (SMD .61, CI .13–1.09); authors report high risk of bias.","patient_relevance":"Useful for discussing combination therapy only after distinguishing what is being added to existing care.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Adding a PDE5 inhibitor to ESWT is a different question from adding ESWT to a PDE5 inhibitor.","implication":"The favorable ESWT-alone comparator subgroup cannot prove the incremental value of shockwave over medication.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The overall null finding is less prominent in the patient summary than favorable subgroups.","implication":"Patient text should state which monotherapy was compared and avoid a blanket combination-superiority claim.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Despite the broad regenerative title, no stem-cell or PRP studies were included.","implication":"Do not generalize the results to other regenerative treatments.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The synthesis includes observational comparisons as well as randomized evidence.","implication":"In nonrandomized comparisons, baseline erectile-dysfunction severity, prior medication response, treatment preference and concurrent medication can confound the result. Show randomized-only estimates separately and retain the direction of the added treatment component.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40797370/","next":["Extract separate medication-alone and ESWT-alone comparisons.","Check study designs, dose, medication adherence and interaction tests.","Assess the influence of high-risk studies."]},{"id":"SW200-116","pmid":"35114853","doi":"10.1177/19417381211073316","title":"The Role of Hyaluronic Acid for Soft Tissue Indications: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.","year":2023,"condition":"Varied soft-tissue conditions including rotator cuff, elbow, ankle sprain, Achilles, patellar and trigger finger","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple musculoskeletal conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições musculoesqueléticas"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review/meta-analysis of hyaluronic acid","population":"Human; 1,629 participants in 19 randomized trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 1,629 participants in 19 randomized trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified ESWT as one active comparator","comparator":"HA versus placebo and active interventions including ESWT","findings":"HA is reported favorable across many comparisons, but rotator-cuff and elbow heterogeneity is very high (I² 94% and 99%).","patient_relevance":"Can inform a narrow injection-alternative discussion after the actual HA-versus-ESWT trial is identified.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Fixed-effects pooling is used despite extreme heterogeneity in two major indications.","implication":"Check whether pooled estimates are meaningful and how indication/comparator differences are handled.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"The pooled HA result includes placebo and several active comparators.","implication":"It cannot be read as an HA-versus-ESWT effect without isolating those trials.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Eleven placebo-controlled and nine active-comparator trials are reported within 19 total.","implication":"This may reflect a multi-arm study, not an error; verify overlap and avoid double-counting shared controls.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35114853/","next":["Identify and extract direct HA-versus-ESWT studies.","Check multi-arm overlap and random-effects sensitivity.","Separate disease-specific outcomes and follow-up windows."]},{"id":"SW200-117","pmid":"41691098","doi":"10.1038/s41598-026-40038-z","title":"Comparative effectiveness of minimally invasive therapies for plantar fasciitis: a systematic review and network meta-analysis.","year":2026,"condition":"Plantar fasciitis","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review and network meta-analysis","population":"Human; 63 randomized trials, 4,170 participants","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 63 randomized trials, 4,170 participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD420250641285","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified/varied ESWT","comparator":"ESWT, prolotherapy and multiple injectable therapies","findings":"Different interventions rank best by outcome/time: botulinum toxin for short-term pain, prolotherapy for sustained pain, steroid for short-term function, PRP for longer-term function; ESWT is described as broadly effective.","patient_relevance":"Useful for a balanced alternatives guide showing that goals and timing matter, once rank claims are translated into absolute benefit and uncertainty.","critique":[{"category":"reporting","observation":"Broad ESWT efficacy is asserted without its effect size, comparator or confidence interval in the abstract.","implication":"Do not turn that phrase into a numeric success rate or universal superiority claim.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Networks combine injection and device packages whose patient chronicity and co-care may differ.","implication":"Verify transitivity and direct evidence before choosing treatment by rank.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Plantar-fascia thickness is included alongside pain/function.","implication":"Imaging change must not substitute for patient-perceived recovery.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41691098/","next":["Extract ESWT comparisons and network certainty by follow-up.","Check trial overlap, modality grouping and transitivity.","Separate imaging from pain/function and inspect harms."]},{"id":"SW200-119","pmid":"38704572","doi":"10.1186/s12891-024-07445-7","title":"Effect of extracorporeal shockwave therapy for rotator cuff tendinopathy: a systematic review and meta-analysis.","year":2024,"condition":"Rotator cuff tendinopathy, calcific and noncalcific","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Rotator-cuff / subacromial pain: mixed or unspecified subtype","pt-BR":"Dor do manguito rotador / subacromial: subtipo misto ou não especificado"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review/meta-analysis with indexed correction","population":"Human; 16 randomized trials, 1,093 patients","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 16 randomized trials, 1,093 patients","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"Corrected by PMID 38951805; DOI 10.1186/s12891-024-07611-x","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified/varied","comparator":"ESWT versus sham/placebo and other treatments","findings":"Reported pooled effects favor ESWT for several scales, including VAS SMD −1.95; abduction is nonsignificant. A correction is linked as PMID 38951805. The full correction notice was checked and describes authorship changes only.","patient_relevance":"Potentially useful shoulder evidence, but a generic rotator-cuff claim would conceal important diagnostic and comparator differences.","critique":[{"category":"reporting","observation":"The linked correction adds an omitted sixth author and corresponding-author details; it describes no numerical outcome correction.","implication":"Retain the correction/version link without treating the notice itself as evidence of an efficacy error. Main-review methodology still requires appraisal.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Calcific and noncalcific disease and varied controls are eligible.","implication":"The overall large effects cannot be assumed to apply equally to each pathology or sham-controlled comparison.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The total effective rate is pooled alongside validated scales without an abstract definition.","implication":"Verify consistent responder criteria and outcome selection across studies.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38704572/","next":["Separate calcific status, control type and follow-up.","Audit very large SMDs, heterogeneity and total-effective-rate definitions."]},{"id":"SW200-121","pmid":"40821981","doi":"10.7717/peerj.19809","title":"Comparison of the efficacy of 12 interventions in the treatment of diabetic foot ulcers: a network meta-analysis.","year":2025,"condition":"Diabetic foot ulcers","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Diabetic foot ulcers","pt-BR":"Úlceras do pé diabético"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review and network meta-analysis","population":"Human; 99 randomized trials and 7,356 patients across 12 interventions","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 99 randomized trials and 7,356 patients across 12 interventions","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42023461811","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Device/biological therapies versus standard care/placebo and indirect alternatives","findings":"ESWT showed a reported area-reduction MD of 27.50 (95% CI 11.00–44.00) versus standard care; highest-ranked treatments differed across healing, timing and amputation outcomes.","patient_relevance":"Relevant to an adjunctive wound-care research page, with standard ulcer care and patient-important healing endpoints kept explicit.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"Area reduction, complete healing and limb preservation are distinct outcomes.","implication":"ESWT's favorable area result cannot be restated as preventing amputation or achieving complete closure.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Standard wound care and ulcer severity can vary across many trials.","implication":"Check offloading, infection/ischemia care and severity balance before treating indirect ranks as treatment choices.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract does not give the ESWT-specific healing-rate estimate, harms or certainty.","implication":"A complete patient summary requires those data rather than only its favorable area rank.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40821981/","next":["Extract ESWT-specific trials, dose and complete-healing outcomes.","Check wound-care balance and risk of bias.","Assess adverse events and amputation evidence separately."]},{"id":"SW200-123","pmid":"42178420","doi":"10.1007/s00402-026-06349-6","title":"Extracorporeal shockwave therapy in bone fractures: a systematic review.","year":2026,"condition":"Fractures, delayed union and nonunion","category":"bone","categoryLabel":{"en":"Bone healing and bone disorders","pt-BR":"Consolidação e doenças ósseas"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Fracture healing, delayed union and nonunion","pt-BR":"Consolidação de fraturas, atraso de consolidação e pseudoartrose"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical review","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática de estudos clínicos"},"report_type":"Systematic review of controlled clinical studies","population":"Human clinical studies; seven included controlled reports, sample totals not stated","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human clinical studies; seven included controlled reports, sample totals not stated","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified/varied","comparator":"Presence of a control required, but control interventions not detailed","findings":"Most studies were described as positive, with small samples and substantial protocol heterogeneity; authors call ESWT promising rather than established.","patient_relevance":"A useful research map for difficult fracture healing, but not evidence to replace established surgical or stabilization care.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The abstract relies on most-studies-positive wording without comparative effects or weighting.","implication":"Vote counting can conceal study size, precision and bias; extract each controlled effect.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Acute fractures, delayed union and established nonunion differ greatly in spontaneous healing probability.","implication":"These must remain separate rather than supporting one general bone-regeneration claim.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Eligibility says controlled clinical studies, not all randomized trials.","implication":"Determine allocation and co-interventions before assigning causal weight.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42178420/","next":["Extract fracture type, chronicity, fixation and control care.","Check randomized versus nonrandomized designs and healing adjudication.","Report absolute union rates and reoperation/harms with follow-up."]},{"id":"SW200-125","pmid":"38295551","doi":"10.1016/j.physio.2024.01.001","title":"Exercise compared to a control condition or other conservative treatment options in patients with Greater Trochanteric Pain Syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.","year":2024,"condition":"Greater trochanteric pain syndrome","category":"hip_pelvis","categoryLabel":{"en":"Hip and pelvis","pt-BR":"Quadril e pelve"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Greater trochanteric pain / gluteal tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Dor trocantérica / tendinopatia glútea"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of exercise interventions","population":"Human; 733 patients across six randomized trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 733 patients across six randomized trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42021261380","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified ESWT in two comparator trials","comparator":"Exercise versus control, steroid injection, ESWT or different exercise","findings":"Exercise shows small longer-term benefits versus control and better global improvement than steroid. Two trials compare exercise with shockwave, but their effects are not reported in the abstract.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining why exercise is central to care; ESWT's relative role requires reading the two direct comparisons.","critique":[{"category":"reporting","observation":"The shockwave comparisons are enumerated but not quantified in the abstract.","implication":"An exercise first-line recommendation here must not be recast as demonstrated exercise superiority over ESWT.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The counts by comparator exceed six because trials can contribute multiple comparisons.","implication":"Identify multi-arm overlap and shared controls before using trial counts.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"GTPS is clinically diagnosed and may include differing gluteal/trochanteric presentations.","implication":"Compare diagnostic criteria and exercise content before generalizing to every lateral hip pain condition.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38295551/","next":["Extract the two exercise-versus-ESWT comparisons.","Check exercise intensity/adherence and diagnostic subtypes.","Map multi-arm trials to prevent duplicate counts."]},{"id":"SW200-128","pmid":"37553459","doi":"10.1186/s40798-023-00616-1","title":"Effectiveness of Exercise Treatments with or without Adjuncts for Common Lower Limb Tendinopathies: A Living Systematic Review and Network Meta-analysis.","year":2023,"condition":"Achilles tendinopathy, patellar tendinopathy and greater trochanteric pain syndrome","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas tendinopatias"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Living systematic review and network meta-analysis","population":"Human; 68 randomized trials across three condition-specific analyses","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 68 randomized trials across three condition-specific analyses","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42021289534","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified/varied ESWT adjuncts","comparator":"Exercise alone versus exercise with adjuncts or alternative exercise-containing arms","findings":"Moderate-strength evidence indicates no short-term benefit from adding ESWT to eccentric exercise in patellar disease. Statistically/clinically favorable adjunct comparisons otherwise have low/very-low strength.","patient_relevance":"Helps patients understand why rehabilitation remains central and why adding a device may not improve outcomes.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"Eligibility requires an exercise intervention in at least one trial arm.","implication":"This is particularly useful for add-on decisions but is not an unrestricted review of all ESWT trials.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The most secure ESWT statement is short-term and patellar-specific.","implication":"Do not extend it automatically to every Achilles/hip outcome or longer follow-up.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The title calls the review living.","implication":"Verify update status and search cutoff before treating this publication as the latest evidence snapshot.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37553459/","next":["Locate any living updates and extract current ESWT comparisons.","Check exercise protocol/adherence and exact intervals.","Map parent studies against other tendon reviews."]},{"id":"SW200-131","pmid":"39139789","doi":"10.3389/fmed.2024.1394268","title":"Efficacy and safety of extracorporeal shock wave therapy for upper limb tendonitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.","year":2024,"condition":"Rotator cuff, lateral elbow, finger and long-head biceps tendon disorders","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas tendinopatias"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis","population":"Human; 18 randomized trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 18 randomized trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42023403594","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed, with radial and low-energy subgroups","comparator":"Placebo and other controls, not fully specified","findings":"General pain findings are favorable, but low-energy shoulder subgroups improve function without demonstrated pain relief; authors describe low adverse-effect incidence.","patient_relevance":"A starting map of potential upper-limb uses, not one treatment recommendation for every tendon disorder.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Four anatomically and clinically different disorders contribute to the review.","implication":"The broad upper-limb conclusion should be decomposed by condition, comparator and protocol.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Claims of stronger radial effects may derive from subgroup comparisons rather than head-to-head randomization.","implication":"Verify interaction testing and confounding by condition/dose before recommending radial over focused.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Low adverse-effect incidence is asserted without denominators or definitions.","implication":"The harms conclusion needs collection methods and duration, not just sparse reporting.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39139789/","next":["Extract condition-specific effects and trial identities.","Check radial/focused subgroup basis and energy definitions.","Audit harms reporting and follow-up."]},{"id":"SW200-133","pmid":"41133500","doi":"10.3390/medsci13040219","title":"Efficacy of Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy in the Management of Chronic Diabetic Foot Ulcer: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.","year":2025,"condition":"Chronic diabetic foot ulcers","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Diabetic foot ulcers","pt-BR":"Úlceras do pé diabético"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis","population":"Human; 672 patients across eight randomized trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human; 672 patients across eight randomized trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified/varied ESWT","comparator":"ESWT adjunct to standard care versus standard care/control","findings":"Pooled complete-healing OR 2.747 (95% CI 1.965–3.841) favors adjunct ESWT, with a reported I² of .02.","patient_relevance":"Potentially useful evidence for wound-care adjuncts, with absolute healing chances, care context and follow-up still needed.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"The effect is an odds ratio, not an absolute healing probability or risk ratio.","implication":"Patient graphics need control event rates and a common follow-up; do not claim 2.7 times as many patients heal.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Robvis is named as the bias assessment tool, and I² is written .02 without percent clarification.","implication":"Verify the underlying RoB instrument and heterogeneity units rather than assuming they are adequately specified.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Benefit is reported as adjunctive to standard care.","implication":"Offloading, infection management, vascular status and wound severity must be characterized before generalizing.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41133500/","next":["Extract event counts, healing definition and follow-up for each trial.","Check standard-care consistency and wound severity.","Verify RoB assessment, heterogeneity and rare harms."]},{"id":"SW200-134","pmid":"37662911","doi":"10.3389/fimmu.2023.1193835","title":"The effectiveness of shockwave therapy on patellar tendinopathy, Achilles tendinopathy, and plantar fasciitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis.","year":2023,"condition":"Patellar and Achilles tendinopathy, plus plantar fasciitis","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Múltiplas tendinopatias"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review/meta-analysis with GRADE","population":"Human trials across three separate conditions; total sample not reported in abstract","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human trials across three separate conditions; total sample not reported in abstract","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42023396835","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified/varied","comparator":"Placebo, shared eccentric exercise and varied conservative/active care","findings":"Patellar sham comparisons show negligible short-term effect; Achilles effects are small/inconclusive. Plantar outcomes appear favorable, but active-comparator effects are small/inconclusive.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining why the treatment's evidence differs by diagnosis and by what it is compared against.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"The final strong plantar conclusion coexists with inconclusive active-treatment comparisons.","implication":"Specify the comparator and timepoint rather than saying ESWT is broadly superior for plantar disease.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Achilles results are summarized without insertional versus midportion detail in the abstract.","implication":"That distinction can materially alter applicability and must be extracted.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract assigns high-quality evidence to a large plantar effect without displaying the supporting numerical estimates or GRADE table.","implication":"Verify certainty by outcome/comparison and updates before adopting the label.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37662911/","next":["Extract sham versus active-control effects and GRADE judgments.","Separate Achilles insertional status and dose.","Check newer trials and overlapping review populations."]},{"id":"SW200-135","pmid":"42529114","doi":"10.3389/fcell.2026.1876711","title":"Comparative efficacy and safety of core decompression, cell-based therapy, hyperbaric oxygen therapy, extracorporeal shock wave therapy, and combined regimens for osteonecrosis of the femoral head: a network meta-analysis.","year":2026,"condition":"Early-to-mid-stage osteonecrosis of the femoral head","category":"bone","categoryLabel":{"en":"Bone healing and bone disorders","pt-BR":"Consolidação e doenças ósseas"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Osteonecrosis of the femoral head","pt-BR":"Osteonecrose da cabeça do fêmur"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Network meta-analysis of randomized and retrospective comparative studies","population":"Human adults; 29 studies, 2,177 hips","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human adults; 29 studies, 2,177 hips","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD420261379078","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified ESWT alone or combined","comparator":"Core decompression, cell therapy, hyperbaric oxygen, ESWT and combinations","findings":"Core decompression plus ESWT ranks highest for HHS but network inconsistency limits confidence. No treatment significantly reduced arthroplasty conversion; safety ranks combine events of different severity.","patient_relevance":"Explains promising joint-preservation research while clarifying that avoiding hip replacement has not been demonstrated here.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The authors explicitly identify substantial inconsistency for the favorable HHS rank.","implication":"That rank is not reliable evidence that the ESWT combination is best.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"Randomized and retrospective studies are combined and hips, not unique patients, are counted.","implication":"Confounding and bilateral-hip clustering need evaluation before trusting precision.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Structural and symptom advantages do not correspond to demonstrated arthroplasty reduction, and harms differ in severity.","implication":"Patient summaries must separate these outcomes and avoid presenting a composite safety rank as proof of safest care.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42529114/","next":["Inspect RCT-only sensitivity and clustering.","Extract stage-specific absolute progression/arthroplasty rates.","Disaggregate minor and serious adverse events."]},{"id":"SW200-138","pmid":"40824407","doi":"10.1186/s10195-025-00871-w","title":"Comparison of extracorporeal shockwave therapy, ultrasound therapy, and corticosteroid injections for treatment of lateral epicondylitis: an umbrella review of meta-analyses.","year":2025,"condition":"Lateral epicondylitis","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Umbrella review","pt-BR":"Revisão de revisões"},"report_type":"Umbrella review","population":"Human evidence summarized in nine overlapping meta-analyses","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human evidence summarized in nine overlapping meta-analyses","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42024586419","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified/varied ESWT","comparator":"Placebo, ultrasound and corticosteroid injection","findings":"Pain favors ESWT versus placebo by MD −.68 and versus ultrasound at one/three months, with high heterogeneity. Grip-strength change is statistically significant but not clinically important.","patient_relevance":"Useful for comparing elbow treatments while distinguishing statistical effects, clinical importance and repeated use of the same trials.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Substantial primary-study overlap is explicitly documented.","implication":"Nine meta-analyses are not nine independent confirmations; check selection rules for pooled estimates.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Ultrasound comparisons have I² 92–98%, yet are summarized as large superiority.","implication":"Context-specific effects and clinical thresholds matter more than a broad rank.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Pain SMD versus steroid is positive while described as favoring ESWT, unlike negative MDs elsewhere.","implication":"Verify comparator ordering and direction before assuming either a sign error or benefit.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40824407/","next":["Extract unique trials and review-selection rules.","Verify steroid contrast direction and follow-up.","Translate pain/responder effects into absolute benefits with uncertainty."]},{"id":"SW200-142","pmid":"39382530","doi":"10.23736/s1973-9087.24.08544-7","title":"Ultrasound-guided percutaneous lavage for the treatment of rotator cuff calcific tendinopathy: a systematic review with meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.","year":2024,"condition":"Calcific rotator-cuff tendinopathy","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Calcific rotator-cuff tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia calcária do manguito rotador"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials","population":"Human patients with calcific shoulder disease; seven trials, 709 participants","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human patients with calcific shoulder disease; seven trials, 709 participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT as comparator to ultrasound-guided lavage","comparator":"Lavage versus ESWT; separate lavage plus corticosteroid versus corticosteroid alone","findings":"Lavage versus ESWT had uncertain pain differences at 12 and 26 weeks, but favored lavage at 52 weeks, SMD −0.52 (−0.85 to −0.19). Function at 52 weeks remained uncertain, SMD 0.10 (−0.40 to 0.60). Added lavage improved calcification resorption versus injection alone, RR 1.63 (1.34–1.98); review certainty low to very low.","patient_relevance":"Useful for discussing lavage versus shockwave when a shoulder deposit is present; a radiographic change and a meaningful functional improvement are different outcomes.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"The disease is explicitly calcific; original discovery also assigned a noncalcific shoulder topic.","implication":"Remove noncalcific applicability: lavage targets deposits.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Pain heterogeneity reaches 93% and 82% at earlier visits and comparisons change by endpoint.","implication":"A pooled overall advantage should not replace outcome- and time-specific interpretation.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Calcification resorption comes from a different comparator than the ESWT pain comparison.","implication":"Do not present deposit clearance as evidence that lavage beats ESWT or that symptoms necessarily improve.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39382530/","next":["Inspect ESWT modalities, dosing, shared injection use and per-outcome trial counts.","Extract harms and clinically important pain thresholds before comparing treatments."]},{"id":"SW200-143","pmid":"28630217","doi":"10.1136/bjsports-2016-096515","title":"Effectiveness of conservative interventions including exercise, manual therapy and medical management in adults with shoulder impingement: a systematic review and meta-analysis of RCTs.","year":2017,"condition":"Shoulder impingement symptoms; calcific subtype not resolved in abstract","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Rotator-cuff / subacromial pain: mixed or unspecified subtype","pt-BR":"Dor do manguito rotador / subacromial: subtipo misto ou não especificado"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized trials","population":"Human adults in conservative-care trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human adults in conservative-care trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"ESWT versus sham; other separate conservative comparisons","findings":"ESWT versus sham pain SMD −0.39 (95% CI −0.78 to −0.01). Exercise versus nonexercise SMD −0.94 (−1.69 to −0.19). Several other therapies had favorable comparisons; authors described overall evidence as very low quality.","patient_relevance":"Provides context for shockwave within conservative shoulder care, especially the role of exercise. It does not establish which current treatment a particular shoulder diagnosis needs.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Reported effects use different control treatments across intervention classes.","implication":"Do not rank exercise and ESWT by comparing their separate SMD magnitudes.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The ESWT interval narrowly excludes zero and the abstract gives no trial count or follow-up for that estimate.","implication":"Clinical importance, precision and persistence need the actual subgroup.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Shoulder impingement is a broad symptom grouping; calcification eligibility is not provided.","implication":"The discovery noncalcific label is provisional, and findings cannot be transferred to every shoulder diagnosis.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28630217/","next":["Check ESWT trial eligibility, calcification status, doses and follow-ups.","Trace the contributing trials and update beyond 2017."]},{"id":"SW200-147","pmid":"38896858","doi":"10.1097/js9.0000000000001836","title":"Extracorporeal shock wave therapy with imaging examination for early osteonecrosis of the femoral head: a systematic review.","year":2025,"condition":"Early osteonecrosis of the femoral head","category":"bone","categoryLabel":{"en":"Bone healing and bone disorders","pt-BR":"Consolidação e doenças ósseas"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Osteonecrosis of the femoral head","pt-BR":"Osteonecrose da cabeça do fêmur"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with before-after meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise de antes e depois"},"report_type":"Systematic review with before-after meta-analysis of mixed RCT and case-series reports","population":"Human adults, mainly ARCO I–IIIA; nine reports, 716 patients","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human adults, mainly ARCO I–IIIA; nine reports, 716 patients","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT; reported energy 0.2–0.63 mJ/mm²","comparator":"Pooled pretreatment versus post-treatment within ESWT groups","findings":"HHS change pooled from 146 hips was reported as MD −33.38 (−46.31 to −20.45); pain improved, but lesion area and ARCO-stage changes were not statistically clear. Full text reports HHS I² 96%. Imaging effect labels for ARCO/BME remain unresolved.","patient_relevance":"Can explain why improved pain need not mean dead bone has regenerated. Structural-progression claims require controlled, stage-specific follow-up.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Selected full-text analysis confirms the headline synthesis is before-after, despite including randomized reports.","implication":"Natural history, concurrent care and regression to the mean are not removed by this pooling.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"ARCO is labelled MD 1.11 with CI 0.76–1.62 and P .60, which is inconsistent with a usual difference-scale null but resembles a ratio result.","implication":"Verify forest plots and metric before reproducing a numeric imaging claim; do not silently relabel.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Participants are early-stage hips and imaging progression differs from symptomatic relief.","implication":"This does not establish prevention of collapse or avoidance of replacement.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38896858/","next":["Inspect original forest plots for ARCO/BME metrics and paired-data handling.","Retrieve controlled effects and patient-versus-hip clustering."]},{"id":"SW200-151","pmid":"37173661","doi":"10.1186/s12891-023-06418-6","title":"The effect of therapeutic physical modalities on pain, function, and quality of life in patients with myofascial pain syndrome: a systematic review.","year":2023,"condition":"Myofascial pain syndrome with trigger points","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain syndrome: multiple sites","pt-BR":"Síndrome Dolorosa Miofascial (SDM): múltiplas regiões"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical review","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática de estudos clínicos"},"report_type":"Systematic review with qualitative synthesis","population":"Human trial participants; 25 articles across physical modalities","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human trial participants; 25 articles across physical modalities","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT alongside TENS, laser and other modalities","comparator":"Modality-specific comparators not supplied","findings":"Authors describe improvements across several domains and state no side effects were reported. They propose perfusion, neural sensitivity and muscle-contraction mechanisms, while acknowledging no agreed protocol.","patient_relevance":"Useful as a map of conservative options for trigger-point pain, but the wiki should separate hypothesized biology from clinical improvements and avoid a blanket safety guarantee.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Effects of multiple modalities are narrated together without ESWT-specific estimates.","implication":"The broad conclusion cannot quantify shockwave's additional benefit or compare it with TENS/laser.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"No side effects reported is presented alongside a safe-treatment conclusion.","implication":"Unreported harms and actively monitored absence of harm must be distinguished.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"Mechanistic explanations are described as possible associations.","implication":"Patient benefit does not establish any of these causal mechanisms.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37173661/","next":["Extract ESWT-only trial populations, comparators, follow-ups and effect estimates.","Check risk-of-bias methods and whether adverse effects were actively collected."]},{"id":"SW200-152","pmid":"34900334","doi":"10.1136/bmjsem-2021-001110","title":"Management of patellar tendinopathy: a systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised studies.","year":2021,"condition":"Patellar tendinopathy","category":"knee","categoryLabel":{"en":"Knee","pt-BR":"Joelho"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Patellar tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia patelar"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review, pairwise and network meta-analysis","population":"Human participants in 37 RCTs covering 33 interventions/combinations","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human participants in 37 RCTs covering 33 interventions/combinations","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"ESWT versus sham, with eccentric exercise in both groups","findings":"Short-term pain MD +0.1 (−0.8 to 1.0) and function MD −1.8 (−8.0 to 4.4) did not demonstrate superiority over sham plus exercise. Network rankings favored several adjuncts with low/very-low evidence; most interventions had one study.","patient_relevance":"Especially useful for explaining why exercise remains part of the treatment conversation and why an extra procedure may not add a detectable short-term gain.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The ESWT pairwise question is an add-on to eccentric exercise.","implication":"It does not compare ESWT monotherapy with no care or determine whether exercise itself caused improvement.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Thirty-three options are mostly represented by single trials.","implication":"Network ranking probabilities may look decisive despite sparse, uncertain comparisons.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The conclusion calls some nonsignificant exercise comparisons equally effective.","implication":"Equality is not established without an appropriate equivalence design and margin.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34900334/","next":["Retrieve the two ESWT trials, instruments, dose and follow-up definitions.","Examine network transitivity, inconsistency and trial-family duplication."]},{"id":"SW200-156","pmid":"39878070","doi":"10.1097/js9.0000000000002251","title":"The effects of extracorporeal shock wave therapy in children with cerebral palsy: a systematic review.","year":2025,"condition":"Spastic cerebral palsy in children","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Cerebral palsy","pt-BR":"Paralisia cerebral"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical review","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática de estudos clínicos"},"report_type":"Systematic review of randomized trials","population":"Human pediatric participants; 12 RCTs, 421 children","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human pediatric participants; 12 RCTs, 421 children","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Not specified in abstract","findings":"Authors report favorable passive resistance, range of motion and gross-motor findings, with effect sizes 0.65–14.62.","patient_relevance":"Relevant to parents considering an adjunct to pediatric rehabilitation; requires age, functional-level and daily-life outcomes, not only tone reduction.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"An effect size 14.62 is unusually large and the abstract does not define its metric or calculation.","implication":"Verify scale/variance and whether effects are controlled or within-group before repeating dramatic magnitudes.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Resistance to passive movement and gross motor skill are distinct outcomes.","implication":"Reduced muscle tone cannot be assumed to improve participation or independence.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract gives no harms, intervention dose or persistence of benefit.","implication":"A less invasive premise is not comparative evidence of a reduced side-effect profile.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39878070/","next":["Recalculate largest effect from original trial data and identify its metric.","Extract GMFCS/age, background rehabilitation, follow-up and active harms monitoring."]},{"id":"SW200-157","pmid":"38837237","doi":"10.1002/14651858.cd013468.pub2","title":"Interventions for postburn pruritus.","year":2024,"condition":"Postburn pruritus in healing/healed burn or donor-site wounds","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Burn wounds and postburn itch","pt-BR":"Queimaduras e coceira após queimaduras"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Cochrane systematic review/meta-analysis; updated review","population":"Human burn survivors; ESWT evidence from two trials with 91 participants","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human burn survivors; ESWT evidence from two trials with 91 participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"Cochrane CD013468; PubMed UpdateOf DOI10.1002/14651858.CD013468","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Sham stimulation for ESWT","findings":"ESWT itch SMD −1.20 (−1.65 to −0.75; 2 trials, 91 people), translated by authors to 5.93 points on a 22-point pruritus scale. Pain evidence is pressure-pain threshold MD 2.96 (1.76–4.16; 1 trial, 45 people). Both low-certainty; no ESWT adverse-event data reported.","patient_relevance":"Useful for burn-itch treatment choices, with clear distinction between itch relief and experimental pressure sensitivity. Does not establish wound closure or scar removal.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The review's total 1166 participants do not belong to the shockwave comparison.","implication":"Use 91 for itch and 45 for the pain-threshold result; avoid denominator inflation.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The pain result uses pressure threshold rather than a patient pain-intensity score.","implication":"Higher tolerance to pressure should not be presented as a 2.96-point reduction in everyday pain.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"No adverse-event data were reported for ESWT.","implication":"This is a reporting gap, not observed absence of harm; the low-certainty label belongs to the review authors.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38837237/","next":["Check how SMD was translated to the 22-point scale and the contributing trial protocols.","Trace updated-review lineage and extract itch durability, patient experience and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-161","pmid":"37237355","doi":"10.1186/s12891-023-06443-5","title":"The conservative management for improving Visual Analog Scale (VAS) pain scoring in greater trochanteric pain syndrome: a Bayesian analysis.","year":2023,"condition":"Greater trochanteric pain syndrome","category":"hip_pelvis","categoryLabel":{"en":"Hip and pelvis","pt-BR":"Quadril e pelve"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Greater trochanteric pain / gluteal tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Dor trocantérica / tendinopatia glútea"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Comparative evidence synthesis with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Síntese comparativa de evidências com metanálise"},"report_type":"Bayesian comparative evidence synthesis with pairwise meta-analysis","population":"Human patients; eight reports, 596 participants","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human patients; eight reports, 596 participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Exercise, usual care, guided/landmark corticosteroid and guided PRP","findings":"ESWT versus exercise MD −3.17 (95% CI −4.13 to −2.15) and PRP versus guided corticosteroid MD −5.21 (−6.24 to −3.64) are reported. Ranking percentages list PRP 99%, ESWT 81%, and exercise 84%, despite narrative ordering exercise last.","patient_relevance":"Potentially useful for comparing lateral-hip options, but the reported ranking is not yet reliable enough to guide a patient preference table.","critique":[{"category":"reporting","observation":"The ranking order and quoted percentages do not agree on their face.","implication":"Clarify whether percentages refer to different rank probabilities before making a best-treatment graphic.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The network includes different injections and rehabilitation comparators; direct versus indirect ESWT evidence is unspecified.","implication":"Verify transitivity, follow-up and comparable patient severity before interpreting large differences.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The conclusion calls procedures relatively safe but the abstract supplies only pain outcomes.","implication":"Safety requires event data and ascertainment, not favorable VAS rankings.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37237355/","next":["Read rank table/curves and identify the meaning of each percentage.","Extract direct trial effects, follow-up, bias and adverse-event data."]},{"id":"SW200-163","pmid":"37482613","doi":"10.1186/s12905-023-02532-8","title":"Effectiveness of physical therapy interventions in women with dyspareunia: a systematic review and meta-analysis.","year":2023,"condition":"Female dyspareunia","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Female pelvic pain and dyspareunia","pt-BR":"Dor pélvica feminina e dispareunia"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis","population":"Human women; 19 physiotherapy reports, only one ESWT report","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human women; 19 physiotherapy reports, only one ESWT report","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42021236155","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT; main pooled interventions are electrotherapy and pelvic-floor training","comparator":"Varies; ESWT comparison not reported in abstract","findings":"Pooled pain and quality-of-life benefits are reported for electrotherapy with/without pelvic-floor training; sexual-function improvement was nonsignificant. One included report involved ESWT, without an ESWT-specific estimate.","patient_relevance":"Can place shockwave within a broader pelvic-floor care discussion, but offers little direct shockwave decision evidence at abstract level.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Most results are for therapies other than shockwave.","implication":"The pooled findings cannot be attributed to the single ESWT study.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The conclusion says massage techniques guarantee pain reduction.","implication":"Guaranteed individual relief exceeds a heterogeneous evidence synthesis.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Pain, quality of life and sexual function show different reported patterns.","implication":"Pain improvement should not be presented as established restoration of sexual function.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37482613/","next":["Identify and appraise the sole shockwave trial, including dyspareunia subtype.","Read outcome-specific bias, effect sizes and follow-up for the broader options."]},{"id":"SW200-165","pmid":"40785236","doi":"10.1080/07853890.2025.2543056","title":"The efficacy of ultrasound for plantar fasciitis, a systematic review and meta-analysis.","year":2025,"condition":"Plantar fasciitis","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of therapeutic ultrasound","population":"Human patients in 13 trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human patients in 13 trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT as active comparator","comparator":"Ultrasound plus exercises versus ESWT plus exercises; other ultrasound comparisons separate","findings":"Ultrasound plus exercise versus ESWT plus exercise pain MD 0.75 (95% CI −0.28 to 1.78) was nonsignificant. A broader other-treatment comparison and FFI comparison were significant; abstract does not clearly identify all arms for those function results.","patient_relevance":"Supports a careful ultrasound-versus-shockwave discussion alongside exercise, without suggesting a precise advantage when the comparison is uncertain.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"This is an ultrasound review, with ESWT one comparator subgroup.","implication":"Its main conclusion about ultrasound cannot establish ESWT efficacy versus sham.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The ESWT comparison interval permits benefits in either direction.","implication":"It does not prove the treatments equal or distinguish a clinically important difference.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Function results differ by instrument and comparator linkage is ambiguous.","implication":"Check score direction and which trial pool supplies FFI versus AOFAS before patient translation.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40785236/","next":["Extract ESWT subgroup size, modality and follow-up.","Trace the FFI comparison and reconcile its clinical direction and threshold."]},{"id":"SW200-166","pmid":"32345281","doi":"10.1186/s12891-020-03270-w","title":"The effects of shockwave therapy on musculoskeletal conditions based on changes in imaging: a systematic review and meta-analysis with meta-regression.","year":2020,"condition":"Calcific rotator-cuff disease, plantar fasciitis and femoral-head osteonecrosis imaging","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple tissues and imaging outcomes","pt-BR":"Múltiplos tecidos e desfechos de imagem"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review/meta-analysis with meta-regression","population":"Human adults in prospective studies; 63 reports, 27 with pooled data","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human adults in prospective studies; 63 reports, 27 with pooled data","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42018091140","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Mixed focused and radial shockwave","comparator":"Before-after morphology and separate controlled comparisons","findings":"Abstract calcium MD 8.44 mm gives CI −4.30 to 12.57 with p < .001; selected main text instead gives +4.30 to 12.57. Likewise plantar thickness CI is negative −0.03 in abstract but +0.03 in main text. ONFH change 4.84% (−0.06 to 9.75) is borderline; no corrected synthesis performed.","patient_relevance":"Excellent for explaining why a scan and symptoms can change differently; exact quantitative imaging claims need source reconciliation.","critique":[{"category":"reporting","observation":"Two lower confidence limits disagree between the fresh abstract and selected main text.","implication":"Do not reuse abstract intervals or infer a definitive correction without checking source figures.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Imaging associations with baseline lesion size are prominent in meta-regression.","implication":"Baseline-change coupling and natural evolution may explain part of the pattern; this is not established biological regeneration.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Structural measures span several diseases and durations.","implication":"Smaller imaging lesions do not automatically mean better function, pain or avoidance of surgery.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/32345281/","next":["Visually inspect calcium and plantar forest plots and reproduce interval direction.","Separate controlled from within-group effects and inspect baseline-change meta-regression."]},{"id":"SW200-171","pmid":"41244766","doi":"10.3389/fmed.2025.1646903","title":"Evaluation of the efficacy of physical agent modalities in patients with fractures: a systematic review and network meta-analysis.","year":2025,"condition":"Fracture healing across heterogeneous sites/stages","category":"bone","categoryLabel":{"en":"Bone healing and bone disorders","pt-BR":"Consolidação e doenças ósseas"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Fracture healing, delayed union and nonunion","pt-BR":"Consolidação de fraturas, atraso de consolidação e pseudoartrose"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with network meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise em rede"},"report_type":"Systematic review with conventional and network meta-analysis","population":"Human patients; 39 studies, 2,379 participants","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human patients; 39 studies, 2,379 participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT among seven physical modalities","comparator":"Other modalities and trial-specific controls","findings":"Across all modalities, pain MD 1.30, healing-time MD −21.58 days and complete-healing RR 1.37 favored treatment. Most network comparisons between modalities were nonsignificant; ESWT was not among the abstract's leading ranked therapies.","patient_relevance":"Explains that electrical stimulation, ultrasound and shockwave are separate technologies and that a combined physical-therapy result does not validate each one.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The pooled fracture improvements combine seven different modalities.","implication":"They are not ESWT-specific estimates and should not be credited to shockwave.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Very high SUCRA values coexist with mostly uncertain between-treatment comparisons.","implication":"Rank probabilities do not establish superiority or a reliable absolute healing advantage.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Fracture site, acute versus delayed healing and stabilization are not specified in the abstract.","implication":"Network transitivity and patient applicability require those clinical details.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41244766/","next":["Extract ESWT node studies, comparators and union stage/site.","Review network connectivity, bias, treatment ranking uncertainty and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-174","pmid":"39198038","doi":"10.1111/os.14212","title":"Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy Versus Local Corticosteroid Injection for Chronic Lateral Epicondylitis: A Systematic Review with Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials.","year":2024,"condition":"Chronic lateral epicondylitis","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized comparisons","population":"Human patients in six randomized trials","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human patients in six randomized trials","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Local corticosteroid injection","findings":"Corticosteroid favored at one month (pain WMD 1.14 against ESWT); ESWT favored at three months (−1.15) and six months (−1.81). Adverse-event OR 0.69 had a very wide CI 0.05–8.60; reported events were mild.","patient_relevance":"Useful for discussing early relief versus later pain/function and the burden of a procedure course. It supports time-specific comparisons rather than blanket claims that one approach is always better.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Treatment ranking reverses with follow-up.","implication":"A single overall best-treatment statement would hide a meaningful timing tradeoff.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Safety is described as similar despite an interval spanning large relative differences.","implication":"The data do not establish equivalent safety; mild observed events do not exclude uncommon problems.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Three/six months are labelled long term.","implication":"These intervals do not establish durability beyond six months or recurrence risk.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39198038/","next":["Verify clinically important thresholds, ESWT protocol and steroid formulation.","Extract absolute event counts, allocation/masking and follow-up beyond six months."]},{"id":"SW200-179","pmid":"24847788","doi":"10.3109/17453674.2014.920991","title":"Guideline for diagnosis and treatment of subacromial pain syndrome: a multidisciplinary review by the Dutch Orthopaedic Association.","year":2014,"condition":"Subacromial pain syndrome, with a separate calcific tendinopathy recommendation","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Rotator-cuff / subacromial pain: mixed or unspecified subtype","pt-BR":"Dor do manguito rotador / subacromial: subtipo misto ou não especificado"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Evidence synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese de evidências"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Clinical guideline supported by an evidence review","pt-BR":"Diretriz clínica apoiada em revisão de evidências"},"report_type":"Practice guideline based on evidence review","population":"Human clinical-care populations addressed by a Dutch multidisciplinary guideline","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human clinical-care populations addressed by a Dutch multidisciplinary guideline","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Treatment recommendations rather than new randomized comparisons","findings":"Shockwave or ultrasound-guided needling is specifically suggested for calcific tendinosis. Nonoperative care is preferred for broader SAPS; no quantitative ESWT effect is provided.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining that a painful shoulder has several possible causes and that a calcium deposit changes which procedures are considered.","critique":[{"category":"applicability","observation":"The shockwave recommendation concerns calcific tendinopathy, not all subacromial pain.","implication":"Do not use broad shoulder query membership to extend the recommendation to noncalcific disease.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"This is a guideline recommendation, not an independent new trial.","implication":"Trace its evidence and recommendation strength instead of counting the guideline as another efficacy study.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"The document dates from 2014 and a specific national context.","implication":"Check current guidance before translating diagnostic or medication recommendations into present patient advice.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The guideline reports searches for existing guidelines/reviews, clinical-question database searches, language limits, reference checking and evidence grading.","implication":"It qualifies as a guideline evidence review rather than consensus-only. Its 2014 recommendation remains historical and is not an additional independent trial.","verification":"source_confirmed","source_locator":"Methods; Extracorporeal shockwave therapy subsection"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24847788/","next":["Inspect ESWT recommendation grading and cited trials.","Find an updated guideline and preserve national-context differences."]},{"id":"SW200-184","pmid":"40654049","doi":"10.1002/14651858.cd013166.pub3","title":"Low-intensity shockwave therapy for erectile dysfunction.","year":2025,"condition":"Erectile dysfunction excluding transplant and post-prostatectomy cohorts","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Erectile dysfunction","pt-BR":"Disfunção erétil"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Cochrane systematic review and meta-analysis","population":"Human men 39–65; 21 RCTs 1,357 randomized","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human men 39–65; 21 RCTs 1,357 randomized","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"Cochrane CD013166; protocol DOI 10.1002/14651858.CD013166.pub2; abridgment PMID 41906634","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Low-intensity electrohydraulic, electromagnetic or piezoelectric shockwave","comparator":"Sham/no-treatment eligible; reported estimates versus sham","findings":"Short-term IIEF-EF MD 3.89 (2.89–4.89; 937 men) compared with chosen 4 point MCID; long-term MD 5.25 (2.47–8.04; 276 men). Authors rate all outcomes low-certainty. No satisfaction/sexual-quality-of-life evidence. Short-term harms RD 0.00 (−0.01 to 0.02), but abstract lists 1,400 safety participants against 1,357 total.","patient_relevance":"A central reference for realistic ED explanations, including modest average benefits, uncertainty, lack of satisfaction evidence and careful definition of follow-up.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Long term means only more than three months and five studies supply the function estimate.","implication":"Do not translate the label into established multi-year durability.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The safety denominator exceeds the stated unique randomized total.","implication":"Reconcile crossover, arm reuse or reporting counts before treating 1,400 as unique people; cause is unverified.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"An explicitly abridged companion PMID 41906634 reproduces these 21 trials.","implication":"Count one review family, not two independent evidence sets.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"MCID is chosen as 4 points despite varying baseline severity and absent satisfaction data.","implication":"Patient importance depends on baseline severity and goals; a mean score gain is not guaranteed satisfactory sex.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40654049/","next":["Reconcile safety count from analysis tables and trial-family mapping.","Inspect MCID severity handling, device protocols and outcome-specific biases."]},{"id":"SW200-186","pmid":"37615315","doi":"10.2340/jphs.v58.12333","title":"Long-term effectiveness of conservative management for lateral epicondylitis: a meta-analysis.","year":2023,"condition":"Lateral epicondylitis with at least 12-month follow-up","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Meta-analysis of long-term comparative trials","pt-BR":"Metanálise de ensaios comparativos com seguimento prolongado"},"report_type":"Meta-analysis of long-term conservative-treatment trials","population":"Human randomized-trial participants","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human randomized-trial participants","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Trial-specific controls; other treatments separately compared","findings":"ESWT pain SMD −0.19 (−0.36 to −0.02) favored therapy. Function SMD 0.24 is paired with printed CI [−0.02,−0.49], which is reversed and does not contain the estimate. Authors say function not significant and favor ESWT overall.","patient_relevance":"Addresses a valuable durability question but should communicate a small average pain signal and unresolved function result, not broad proof that ESWT alone works long term.","critique":[{"category":"reporting","observation":"The function interval is internally malformed in the abstract.","implication":"Hold the numeric function estimate until source tables/plots resolve bounds; do not repair by guessing.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Pain effect is small and narrowly excludes zero.","implication":"Clinical relevance requires a scale translation and threshold, not just significance.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Eligibility requires English and downloadable data, and treatment-specific counts are absent.","implication":"Selection/availability and small comparison sets may affect generalizability.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37615315/","next":["Retrieve forest plot and full function estimates/CI direction.","Check ESWT sample size, control type, dropout and clinically important change."]},{"id":"SW200-191","pmid":"40093995","doi":"10.1177/17585732251324484","title":"Current evidence on hyaluronic acid injections for rotator cuff tendinopathy: A scoping review.","year":2026,"condition":"Rotator-cuff tendinopathy; calcific status unspecified","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Rotator-cuff / subacromial pain: mixed or unspecified subtype","pt-BR":"Dor do manguito rotador / subacromial: subtipo misto ou não especificado"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Evidence synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese de evidências"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Scoping / narrative review","pt-BR":"Revisão de escopo / narrativa"},"report_type":"Scoping/narrative review of hyaluronic-acid procedures","population":"Human studies; nine RCTs and two prospective nonrandomized reports","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human studies; nine RCTs and two prospective nonrandomized reports","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT in one combination study","comparator":"Hyaluronic-acid regimens and other injections; ESWT comparison unresolved","findings":"Authors report HA benefits, tolerability differences and a 'synergistic' HA/ESWT effect. No combination effect size or trial design is supplied in the abstract.","patient_relevance":"Useful for explaining combination-treatment claims but not evidence that paying for both procedures necessarily produces extra benefit.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"A synergistic claim rests on one cited combination study.","implication":"Benefit of adding a component does not by itself prove biological/statistical synergy; a suitable interaction comparison is needed.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"The review is about HA procedural choices and does not identify calcific status for the shockwave subgroup.","implication":"Do not assign its findings to either calcific or noncalcific ESWT care without the underlying trial.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The title calls it scoping while the abstract describes narrative methods.","implication":"Clarify selection and appraisal methods before treating it as a comprehensive comparative synthesis.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The review includes nonrandomized HA evidence, while the design and arms of the single HA-plus-ESWT source still require tracing.","implication":"Do not transfer nonrandomized HA findings to ESWT. Establish whether the combination source is randomized; if it is observational, examine selection, baseline severity and cointerventions before interpreting improvement as an added treatment effect.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40093995/","next":["Retrieve the single HA-plus-ESWT trial and exact randomized arms.","Check whether interaction, incremental benefit or only within-group change supports synergy wording.","Map the design of each ESWT-contributing source before attributing mixed-design review findings to shockwave treatment."]},{"id":"SW200-198","pmid":"38310528","doi":"10.24425/fmc.2023.147213","title":"Treatment Options for Tennis Elbow - An Umbrella Review.","year":2023,"condition":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy/tennis elbow","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia lateral do cotovelo"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Umbrella review","pt-BR":"Revisão de revisões"},"report_type":"Umbrella review with re-extraction of primary studies","population":"Human primary trial literature nested within 40 meta-analyses","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Review or contextual record: inspect the source for reported counts and units; no independent participant total is displayed.","pt-BR":"Revisão ou registro contextual: consultar as contagens e unidades no registro de origem; nenhum total independente de participantes é exibido."},"source_population":"Human primary trial literature nested within 40 meta-analyses","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"Unspecified shockwave","comparator":"Authors emphasize independent treatment results rather than comparisons","findings":"Abstract declares blood/PRP injections effective and shockwave/acupuncture ineffective, without reporting effect estimates, CIs, study counts per therapy or timepoints.","patient_relevance":"A high-priority example of conflicting review conclusions that should be explained through methods rather than voting by publication count.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Authors explicitly promote independent results not compared with other treatments.","implication":"Within-group improvement or null change cannot establish causal efficacy or inefficacy; exact analysis needs inspection.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Forty meta-analyses may contain repeated primary trials.","implication":"Verify deduplication and unique participant counts before using the apparent evidence volume.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Conclusion says 'proving' ineffectiveness without numerical results in the abstract.","implication":"A categorical claim demands comparator-specific precision and clinically important bounds, not significance alone.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38310528/","next":["Inspect exact statistical estimator and whether control arms were used.","Map primary trial duplicates, follow-ups, effect CIs and review quality."]},{"id":"SW200-199","pmid":"37485429","doi":"10.5312/wjo.v14.i7.572","title":"Instrumented assisted soft tissue mobilization vs extracorporeal shock wave therapy in treatment of myofascial pain syndrome.","year":2023,"condition":"Active upper-trapezius myofascial trigger-point pain","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Neck and trapezius myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial cervical e do trapézio"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Reported randomized, single-blind comparative clinical trial","population":"Human 40 adults aged 20–40; 28 women 12 men","sample":{"n":40,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"40 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"40 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human 40 adults aged 20–40; 28 women 12 men","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"Unspecified ESWT","comparator":"Instrument-assisted soft-tissue mobilization; both groups also muscle-energy technique","findings":"Both arms improved within-group; between-arm posttreatment differences were nonsignificant (pain p .90/.76; PPT p .09/.91 at two trigger points). No magnitude or CI reported in abstract.","patient_relevance":"Useful for comparing two common offered procedures, but the available abstract cannot identify a better option or promise lasting relief.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Both groups receive active care and shared muscle-energy technique without sham/no-care.","implication":"Within-group change cannot isolate either procedure's effect from shared care, natural history or expectations.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Nonsignificant posttreatment tests do not establish equivalence.","implication":"Small n 20 arms and absent intervals may permit clinically important differences.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Outcomes are immediate after two weeks and limited to pain/PPT.","implication":"Durable function, work participation and quality of life are not demonstrated.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37485429/","next":["Verify allocation, who was blinded, ESWT parameters and between-group change CIs.","Check harm collection, functional outcomes and any later follow-up."]},{"id":"SW200-202","pmid":"40852560","doi":"10.1007/s43465-025-01422-5","title":"Comparative Effectiveness of Ultrasound-Guided Corticosteroid Injection and Radial Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy for Plantar Fasciitis: A Double-Blind Randomized Controlled Trial.","year":2025,"condition":"Plantar fasciitis / plantar heel pain","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy","pt-BR":"Dor plantar no calcanhar / fasciopatia plantar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Randomized interventional trial described as double blind","population":"Human; 170 enrolled adults, with 70 per group completing follow-up.","sample":{"n":170,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"170 enrolled; 140 completed follow-up, 70 per group.","pt-BR":"170 participantes incluídos; 140 concluíram o seguimento, 70 por grupo."},"source_population":"Human; 170 enrolled adults, with 70 per group completing follow-up.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"CTRI/2024/01/061283","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Ultrasound-guided methylprednisolone plus lignocaine injection versus three weekly radial ESWT sessions.","findings":"The abstract reports greater short-term pain and functional improvement with injection. Pain in the ESWT group initially improved and then increased by eight weeks. Both groups showed reduced fascia thickness; the reported intergroup difference became significant at eight weeks. The abstract provides mainly p values rather than effect estimates.","patient_relevance":"Helps patients compare the pace of early symptom response between an injection and ESWT. It cannot settle long-term choice or comparative safety.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"170 participants were enrolled, while completed follow-up is reported for 140.","implication":"The randomized arm counts, reasons for 30 missing participants and intention-to-treat handling could materially affect the comparison.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"Injection and repeated ESWT sessions are visibly different interventions, although the study is labeled double blind.","implication":"Verify who was masked, whether a double-dummy procedure existed, and whether outcome assessors were independent; do not assume absent blinding merely from the abstract.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Follow-up stops at eight weeks.","implication":"Results address early response, not sustained benefit, recurrence, or longer-term comparative harms.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Multiple pain contexts, functional subscales and imaging timepoints are reported chiefly through significance tests.","implication":"Check the prespecified primary outcome, multiplicity strategy and confidence intervals before estimating a patient-relevant advantage.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40852560/","next":["Review the participant flow and intention-to-treat analysis.","Verify masking and extract absolute between-group pain/function differences.","Compare the report with CTRI/2024/01/061283 and inspect harms reporting."]},{"id":"SW200-204","pmid":"41070206","doi":"10.1136/bmjsem-2024-002442","title":"Exercise, radial pressure waves, and photobiomodulation for management of non-insertional Achilles tendinopathy in runners: a three-arm non-blinded randomised control trial.","year":2025,"condition":"Non-insertional Achilles tendinopathy in runners","category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Midportion Achilles tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia da porção média do tendão de Aquiles"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial with later elective crossover","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com troca posterior de tratamento por escolha"},"report_type":"Three-arm nonblinded randomized trial with subsequent elective crossover","population":"Human; 46 runners with symptoms exceeding three months.","sample":{"n":46,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"46 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"46 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 46 runners with symptoms exceeding three months.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"NCT04725513","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial pressure waves","comparator":"Exercise alone versus exercise plus radial pressure waves versus exercise plus radial pressure waves and photobiomodulation.","findings":"VISA-A improved by a reported 33 points with exercise plus radial pressure waves versus 18 with exercise alone (p=0.023). The additional-photobiomodulation group improved by 25 versus 18 points, without a detected difference (p=0.12). All groups showed clinically meaningful improvement by the authors’ criteria. Elective crossover participants subsequently improved.","patient_relevance":"Relevant to runners considering an adjunct to a loading program. It reinforces that loading was part of every treatment and does not generalize directly to insertional disease.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The study was nonblinded and compared added treatments with exercise alone.","implication":"Expectations, treatment contact and adherence may contribute to self-reported differences; the contrast estimates the combined clinical package.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Only 46 runners were distributed across three arms.","implication":"Precision is limited and lack of significance for the third arm is not evidence that photobiomodulation removes or negates ESWT benefit.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"Later crossover was elective rather than a new randomized allocation.","implication":"Post-crossover changes are selected observational follow-up and should not be pooled with the initial randomized comparison.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract prints the two VISA-A confidence intervals in descending order.","implication":"Confirm the table values and contrast direction before reusing an interval; the ordering issue alone does not demonstrate an analysis error.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41070206/","next":["Check NCT04725513, planned primary contrast and multiplicity.","Verify confidence-interval order, arm sizes, adherence and missing data.","Separate randomized and elective-crossover outcome tables."]},{"id":"SW200-205","pmid":"42291382","doi":"10.5606/tftrd.2025.15454","title":"Comparison of the short-term effectiveness of myofascial dextrose injection and radial extracorporeal shockwave therapy in myofascial pain syndrome: A prospective, randomized clinical study.","year":2026,"condition":"Upper and/or middle trapezius myofascial pain syndrome","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Neck and trapezius myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial cervical e do trapézio"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Prospective randomized clinical comparison","population":"Human; 70 adults, 62 women and eight men, randomized 35 per arm.","sample":{"n":70,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"70 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"70 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 70 adults, 62 women and eight men, randomized 35 per arm.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Three weekly sessions of 5% myofascial dextrose injection versus three weekly radial ESWT sessions; both groups received an exercise program.","findings":"Both groups improved on the reported outcomes. Dextrose injection showed greater pain and disability improvements at both follow-ups, and greater pressure-pain-threshold and health-profile improvement at week four. Between-group effect sizes and confidence intervals are not provided in the abstract.","patient_relevance":"Useful when comparing treatment options for trapezius pain. The short-term result favoring injection is not a general recommendation for all myofascial pain or proof of lasting advantage.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Both treatments were delivered alongside exercise and neither arm is an inert placebo.","implication":"Within-group gains cannot isolate ESWT efficacy; the randomized contrast addresses which combined program performed better over the short term.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Outcomes were followed only through week four in a predominantly female trapezius-pain sample.","implication":"Durability and extrapolation to other muscles, pelvic-floor pain or other headache conditions remain uncertain.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Several outcomes and timepoints are summarized using p values without the magnitude or uncertainty of differences.","implication":"Clinical importance cannot be established from statistical significance alone.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"The abstract does not describe concealment, masking, attrition or the missing-data strategy.","implication":"These features need full-text verification rather than an automatic high-risk judgment based on abstract silence.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42291382/","next":["Extract between-group pain and disability changes with confidence intervals.","Verify randomization, masking, missing participants and trial registration.","Check whether exercise adherence and adverse-event collection were comparable."]},{"id":"SW200-207","pmid":"39690426","doi":"10.1186/s43019-024-00252-3","title":"A comparative analysis of platelet-rich plasma alone versus combined with extracorporeal shockwave therapy in athletes with patellar tendinopathy and knee pain: a randomized controlled trial.","year":2024,"condition":"Chronic patellar tendinopathy in athletes","category":"knee","categoryLabel":{"en":"Knee","pt-BR":"Joelho"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Patellar tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia patelar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial with sham / placebo control","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com tratamento simulado / placebo"},"report_type":"Randomized PRP-plus-ESWT versus PRP-plus-sham clinical trial","population":"Human; 33 athletes randomized into two groups.","sample":{"n":33,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"33 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"33 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 33 athletes randomized into two groups.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"researchregistry9518","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified; ESWT at 0.2 mJ/mm² reported, but generator type not established in abstract","comparator":"PRP injection plus one subsequent active ESWT session versus PRP injection plus sham ESWT.","findings":"The authors report faster pain reduction with added ESWT at one month. The abstract describes improvement in both groups over one year but does not give a numerical persistent between-group clinical advantage. Several cytokines increased at twelve months, attributed speculatively to further training. No adverse effects were reported.","patient_relevance":"May inform a discussion of adding ESWT to PRP in athletic patellar tendinopathy. It does not show that either combination is necessary, that ESWT monotherapy works, or that no adverse effects can occur.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Both groups received PRP, and only the shockwave addition differs.","implication":"Any incremental result applies to ESWT added to this PRP regimen, not ESWT alone or PRP efficacy itself.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Thirty-three participants support limited precision, and several clinical, imaging and cytokine endpoints were examined.","implication":"The early pain finding needs its magnitude, uncertainty and prespecified status checked; mechanistic markers should remain exploratory.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract describes the PRP injection as intraarticular despite a patellar-tendon target.","implication":"Verify the actual injection site and technique before reproducing treatment details; do not silently substitute an intratendinous route.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"A registry entry dated 14 September 2023 is cited, but enrollment timing is absent from the abstract.","implication":"Prospective registration cannot be assumed and must be compared with actual recruitment dates.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39690426/","next":["Verify the PRP route, ESWT generator and rehabilitation exposure.","Compare recruitment and prespecified outcomes with researchregistry9518.","Extract time-specific between-group clinical effects and adverse-event methods."]},{"id":"SW200-208","pmid":"37671381","doi":"10.5606/tftrd.2023.12106","title":"Comparison of shock wave therapy and corticosteroid injection in the treatment of greater trochanteric pain syndrome: A single-blind, randomized study.","year":2023,"condition":"Greater trochanteric pain syndrome","category":"hip_pelvis","categoryLabel":{"en":"Hip and pelvis","pt-BR":"Quadril e pelve"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Greater trochanteric pain / gluteal tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Dor trocantérica / tendinopatia glútea"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized comparative clinical trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio clínico comparativo randomizado"},"report_type":"Single-blind randomized clinical trial","population":"Human; 60 adults randomized to shockwave (32) or corticosteroid/local-anesthetic injection (28).","sample":{"n":60,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"60 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"60 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 60 adults randomized to shockwave (32) or corticosteroid/local-anesthetic injection (28).","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified in abstract","comparator":"Three weekly shockwave sessions versus corticosteroid plus local-anesthetic injection.","findings":"Both groups improved in pain, tenderness and WOMAC at follow-up. No significant between-group efficacy difference was detected. Selected physical and pain quality-of-life domains improved similarly. The authors conclude neither option was superior.","patient_relevance":"Offers a short-term comparison between two commonly considered lateral-hip options. It helps explain uncertainty in choosing between them rather than selecting one universal winner.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"The report describes nonsignificant between-group tests rather than a prespecified equivalence margin.","implication":"Patients should hear that this study did not detect a difference, not that the treatments are proven equivalent.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"This is an active-comparator trial and both groups may experience contextual effects or natural improvement.","implication":"Within-group improvement alone does not establish either treatment’s benefit versus no treatment.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Follow-up is limited to three months, and GTPS is a clinical syndrome with potentially varied tendon and bursal pathology.","implication":"Long-term recurrence and applicability to a specific imaging-confirmed lesion require separate evidence.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract does not identify the shockwave modality or provide between-group estimates with confidence intervals.","implication":"Device-specific recommendations and a claim of clinically negligible differences require full-text details.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37671381/","next":["Identify focused versus radial modality, settings and concomitant care.","Extract confidence intervals, attrition, masking and adverse events.","Check diagnostic inclusion criteria, registration and the primary endpoint."]},{"id":"SW200-209","pmid":"42830738","doi":"10.1016/j.asmart.2026.09.001","title":"Focused extracorporeal shock wave therapy following intramedullary screw fixation for Jones fractures in high-level athletes may be associated with earlier bone union and return to sport.","year":2026,"condition":"Jones fracture following intramedullary screw fixation","category":"bone","categoryLabel":{"en":"Bone healing and bone disorders","pt-BR":"Consolidação e doenças ósseas"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Fracture healing, delayed union and nonunion","pt-BR":"Consolidação de fraturas, atraso de consolidação e pseudoartrose"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparisons","pt-BR":"Comparações não randomizadas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Retrospective nonrandomized treatment comparison","pt-BR":"Comparação retrospectiva não randomizada de tratamentos"},"report_type":"Retrospective nonrandomized comparative cohort","population":"Human; 34 high-level athletes, 13 receiving adjunct focused ESWT and 21 fixation without ESWT.","sample":{"n":34,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"34 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"34 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 34 high-level athletes, 13 receiving adjunct focused ESWT and 21 fixation without ESWT.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"focused","comparator":"Intramedullary screw fixation with postoperative focused ESWT versus fixation without shockwave augmentation.","findings":"All patients achieved union and returned to their original sports level. Median union times were eight versus ten weeks and return-to-sport times nine versus twelve weeks, favoring the ESWT group observationally. One refracture occurred without ESWT; complication rates did not show a statistically detectable difference.","patient_relevance":"A preliminary signal relevant to athletes recovering from a surgically fixed Jones fracture, with clear uncertainty about whether ESWT itself shortened recovery.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Adjunct ESWT was not randomized.","implication":"Patient selection, fracture characteristics, clinician preference and calendar-time changes may account for group differences; an association is not an established causal acceleration of healing.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"design","observation":"Both groups underwent surgery, and ESWT was one postoperative component.","implication":"Check rehabilitation, loading restrictions, imaging frequency and return-to-sport criteria for concurrent-treatment and ascertainment differences.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The treated group contains only 13 athletes and there was one reported refracture overall.","implication":"The study has little information about comparative harms; p=1.000 does not demonstrate equal safety.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Eligibility required high-level athletic participation.","implication":"Results may not apply to ordinary recreational patients, other fracture locations, nonsurgical treatment or established nonunion.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42830738/","next":["Inspect baseline fracture characteristics and reasons for receiving ESWT.","Check matching/adjustment, rehabilitation and missing-record handling.","Verify blinded union assessment and standardized return-to-sport criteria."]},{"id":"SW200-211","pmid":"38913436","doi":"10.1097/js9.0000000000001848","title":"Prognostic factors of extracorporeal shockwave therapy in the treatment of nonunion in long bones: a retrospective study.","year":2024,"condition":"Tibial or femoral long-bone nonunion","category":"bone","categoryLabel":{"en":"Bone healing and bone disorders","pt-BR":"Consolidação e doenças ósseas"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Fracture healing, delayed union and nonunion","pt-BR":"Consolidação de fraturas, atraso de consolidação e pseudoartrose"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Retrospective treated-cohort prognostic study","pt-BR":"Estudo prognóstico retrospectivo de coorte tratada"},"report_type":"Retrospective treated-cohort prognostic study","population":"Human; 91 patients treated with ESWT between January 2004 and January 2018.","sample":{"n":91,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"91 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"91 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 91 patients treated with ESWT between January 2004 and January 2018.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified in abstract; OssaTron device is named, but focused/radial classification requires verification.","comparator":"No untreated or surgical-control cohort; prognostic comparisons among ESWT-treated nonunions.","findings":"The authors report overall union of 62.6%, with 69.9% for trophic and 33.3% for atrophic nonunions. Prior surgeries, maximum fracture gap and atrophic morphology were associated with failure. More than one previous operation and a gap greater than 3.94 mm were proposed as unfavorable thresholds.","patient_relevance":"Can explain why fracture stability, gap, morphology and treatment history matter when discussing nonunion options. It cannot tell patients their chance of healing because of ESWT or prove ESWT replaces surgery.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Only ESWT recipients were included.","implication":"The observed union proportion cannot establish comparative efficacy versus surgery, observation or another bone-stimulation approach.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Prognostic thresholds were derived from this 91-patient dataset.","implication":"Data-driven cutoffs may be optimistic and should not become exclusion rules or patient calculators without validation.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"design","observation":"Recruitment spans fourteen years with prior surgery and nonunion morphology varying among patients.","implication":"Selection into ESWT, concurrent stabilization and changing clinical practice may confound prognostic associations; verify adjustment and missing records.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"The cohort concerns tibial and femoral established nonunion.","implication":"It should not support blanket claims for acute fractures, all bone sites or avoidance of indicated surgery.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/38913436/","next":["Verify generator type, dosing, concurrent stabilization and radiographic adjudication.","Inspect model events-per-variable, missing data and external validation.","Check source population, exclusions and reasons for selecting ESWT."]},{"id":"SW200-214","pmid":"41892829","doi":"10.3390/medsci14010114","title":"Clinical and Metabolic Predictors of Response to Focused Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy in Rotator Cuff Tendinopathy: A Retrospective Cohort Study.","year":2026,"condition":"Calcific and noncalcific supraspinatus/rotator-cuff tendinopathy","category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Rotator-cuff / subacromial pain: mixed or unspecified subtype","pt-BR":"Dor do manguito rotador / subacromial: subtipo misto ou não especificado"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Retrospective treated-cohort prognostic study","pt-BR":"Estudo prognóstico retrospectivo de coorte tratada"},"report_type":"Retrospective treated-cohort prognostic study","population":"Human; 239 ESWT-treated patients, including 101 with calcific disease, at one rehabilitation centre.","sample":{"n":239,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"239 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"239 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 239 ESWT-treated patients, including 101 with calcific disease, at one rehabilitation centre.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"focused","comparator":"No untreated comparator; predictors of changes among focused-ESWT recipients.","findings":"Mean VAS decreased from 6.50 to 3.96 and Constant-Murley score rose from 60.38 to 75.88. Good/excellent Roles and Maudsley outcomes were reported in 91.2%. Baseline severity predicted improvement; higher BMI was associated with less functional change, approximately one Constant-Murley point per kg/m².","patient_relevance":"Helpful for discussing uncertainty in recovery across different shoulder presentations. It cannot justify promising a 91% success chance or advising that changing BMI will improve ESWT effectiveness.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The study includes only patients selected to receive focused ESWT.","implication":"Observed improvements and the satisfaction proportion cannot be attributed to ESWT without accounting for natural history, expectations and concurrent treatment.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Baseline severity predicts a change score that itself contains the baseline measurement.","implication":"Mathematical coupling and regression to the mean can contribute to this association; inspect model specification before calling it a treatment-response mechanism.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Backward selection identifies predictors in the same cohort.","implication":"Assess model optimism, missing data, prespecification and validation rather than using coefficients as an individual treatment-selection rule.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Calcific and noncalcific disease are combined, and BMI is an observational predictor.","implication":"Verify subtype results and confounding; the BMI association does not show that weight reduction increases the benefit caused by ESWT.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41892829/","next":["Check calcific/noncalcific subgroup patterns and selection criteria.","Inspect baseline-adjusted model formulation, missingness and validation.","Document concomitant treatment, ESWT parameters and follow-up response rate."]},{"id":"SW200-215","pmid":"39790213","doi":"10.1002/hsr2.70311","title":"Extracorporeal Shock Waves Therapy for the Treatment of Acute and Chronic Wounds-A Prospective, Monocentric Clinical Trial to Examine the Effect of Shock Waves on Wound Healing.","year":2025,"condition":"Healing of skin-graft donor and recipient wounds in patients undergoing surgery for chronic wounds","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Chronic wounds and graft wounds","pt-BR":"Feridas crônicas e áreas de enxerto"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Controlled clinical study; random allocation unverified","pt-BR":"Estudo clínico controlado; randomização não confirmada"},"report_type":"Prospective blinded controlled clinical study; random allocation is not established in the abstract","population":"Human; 35 patients, 25 in the verum/placebo group and 10 in a separate sham group.","sample":{"n":35,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"35 patients; wound-area comparisons within people and a separate sham group require separate units of analysis.","pt-BR":"35 pacientes; comparações entre áreas de ferida na mesma pessoa e um grupo separado de tratamento simulado exigem unidades de análise distintas."},"source_population":"Human; 35 patients, 25 in the verum/placebo group and 10 in a separate sham group.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified; described as low-energy/low-frequency ESWT","comparator":"Active and placebo wound areas in 25 participants, plus a separate 10-patient sham group intended to examine a possible remote effect.","findings":"Authors report faster epithelialization at donor and recipient sites versus sham/placebo and reduced infection risk; no serious side effects were reported. The abstract gives 0.86 versus 0.92 without defining the metric or its timepoint, so it cannot support a days-to-healing estimate.","patient_relevance":"Useful for an emerging applications page on postoperative graft healing. These surgically treated wounds do not represent all acute wounds or all chronic ulcers.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The comparison includes wound areas within patients and a separate sham group; allocation is described as assignment rather than randomization.","implication":"Within-patient pairing and selection into the separate sham group affect causal interpretation.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Repeated assessments and multiple wound sites may produce correlated observations; the abstract does not describe the analysis unit.","implication":"Precision depends on accounting for wound-within-person and repeated-measure correlation.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The reported epithelialization values lack units/timepoint, and infection events and denominators are not supplied.","implication":"Clinical magnitude, absolute infection benefit and safety precision remain unresolved.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39790213/","next":["Confirm allocation, wound-pairing scheme and standardized co-interventions.","Extract the epithelialization definition, units, complete-healing time and day-90 results.","Check infection numerators, denominators and adverse-event surveillance."]},{"id":"SW200-217","pmid":"42071234","doi":"10.1186/s12984-026-01983-y","title":"Efficacy of radial shock wave therapy for ankle spasticity in patients with stroke within 3 months of onset: a prospective quasi-experimental study.","year":2026,"condition":"Ankle spasticity 1–3 months after stroke","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Post-stroke spasticity and motor function","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e função motora após AVC"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled repeated-measures clinical study","pt-BR":"Estudo clínico com medidas repetidas, sem grupo de controle"},"report_type":"Prospective quasi-experimental repeated-measures clinical study","population":"Human; 52 patients with early-subacute poststroke ankle spasticity.","sample":{"n":52,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"52 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"52 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 52 patients with early-subacute poststroke ankle spasticity.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"UMIN-CTR000050477","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Participants grouped by 1, 2 or 3 months from stroke onset; all received treatment, with pretreatment measurements as reference.","findings":"Relative to baseline, authors report the greatest cumulative changes after session three: mean MAS reduction 0.6 points and PROM increase 6.4 degrees, maintained for five weeks. No serious treatment-related adverse events were reported. The abstract also refers to immediate reductions in PROM measurements, which needs reconciliation with its later reported increase.","patient_relevance":"Can explain preliminary research on early ankle stiffness after stroke. It does not show better walking, independence, or benefit beyond usual rehabilitation.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Every group received ESWT, and groups were defined by time since stroke rather than random assignment to treatment.","implication":"Early recovery, rehabilitation and baseline severity can account for some change; there is no untreated estimate of the counterfactual course.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Later sessions coincide with longer elapsed recovery time, and MAS is an ordinal tone scale.","implication":"Greater cumulative change does not establish a session dose-response, and a 0.6-point average does not by itself establish meaningful functional recovery.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The immediate-results sentence says PROM decreased, whereas cumulative results specify a 6.4-degree increase.","implication":"Movement definition and sign convention must be checked before visualizing range-of-motion improvement.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42071234/","next":["Check baseline comparability, rehabilitation and medications across onset groups.","Confirm PROM direction, assessor blinding and repeated-measures handling.","Inspect registry UMIN-CTR000050477 and clinically meaningful functional outcomes."]},{"id":"SW200-218","pmid":"42062986","doi":"10.1186/s12905-026-04496-x","title":"Effects of extracorporeal shockwave therapy on pain and pelvic floor function in women with pelvic floor myofascial pain: a retrospective cohort analysis.","year":2026,"condition":"Female pelvic floor myofascial pain","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Female pelvic pain and dyspareunia","pt-BR":"Dor pélvica feminina e dispareunia"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Retrospective single-cohort before-after study","pt-BR":"Estudo retrospectivo de antes e depois em uma coorte"},"report_type":"Retrospective single-cohort before-after study","population":"Human; 20 women, median age 55 years, treated between July 2022 and February 2024.","sample":{"n":20,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"20 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"20 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 20 women, median age 55 years, treated between July 2022 and February 2024.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified; perineal application of 2,000 impulses per session","comparator":"The same patients before versus after four weekly treatments; no parallel comparator.","findings":"Median pain VAS fell from 7.0 to 2.0 and PFDI-20 from 33.0 to 26.5 after four weeks. Prolapse, colorectal and urinary subscales also fell; reported within-patient effect sizes ranged from −0.54 to −0.88. Authors explicitly describe associations and short-term change rather than established effectiveness.","patient_relevance":"Shows that female pelvic-floor pain is being studied and identifies relevant symptom measures. The authors’ restrained causal language should be preserved.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"There is no control group and records come from patients selected for ESWT.","implication":"Confounding by indication, regression to the mean and concurrent care can explain some observed improvement; the large pre/post change is not a comparative treatment effect.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract does not establish whether all treated patients had complete follow-up or whether co-interventions were unchanged.","implication":"Selection of available records and follow-up completeness need checking before judging the size of improvement.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"The reported endpoint is four weeks and includes several symptom subscales in 20 women.","implication":"Durability, adverse effects and broader sexual or daily-life benefit are unresolved; results should not be transferred to male pelvic pain.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42062986/","next":["Check consecutive enrolment, exclusions, missing records and concomitant pelvic-floor treatment.","Verify device type, pain-scale range and PFDI-20 scoring.","Extract harms and any later follow-up beyond four weeks."]},{"id":"SW200-219","pmid":"42088481","doi":"10.1093/sexmed/qfag025","title":"Development of a clinical scoring system to predict response to low-intensity shock wave therapy in clinically diagnosed vasculogenic erectile dysfunction: a prospective, non-randomized, single-arm, interventional study.","year":2026,"condition":"Clinically diagnosed mild-to-moderate vasculogenic erectile dysfunction","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Erectile dysfunction","pt-BR":"Disfunção erétil"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Single-arm intervention and prediction-model study","pt-BR":"Estudo de intervenção de braço único e de modelo de predição"},"report_type":"Prospective nonrandomized single-arm intervention and prediction-model development study","population":"Human; 219 men from two centres; vasculogenic classification was clinical rather than routinely Doppler-confirmed.","sample":{"n":219,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"219 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"219 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 219 men from two centres; vasculogenic classification was clinical rather than routinely Doppler-confirmed.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"focused; electrohydraulic generator with focusing probe, as described in selected full text","comparator":"Responders versus nonresponders among treated men; no sham or untreated group.","findings":"145/219 met the response definition. The score had reported AUC 0.819 (95% CI 0.762–0.877), with 73% sensitivity and 77% specificity at 4.5 points. Authors acknowledge no external validation.","patient_relevance":"Supports an explanation of response prediction versus treatment benefit. Do not publish the score as a clinical decision tool yet.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"All participants received Li-ESWT; the model predicts improvement in treated patients.","implication":"It cannot identify who benefits specifically because of shockwave therapy rather than who has a better prognosis or placebo response.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Predictors and continuous-variable cutoffs were selected from the same cohort; 1,000 bootstrap iterations are reported.","implication":"Internal validation is a strength, but optimism correction must include all selection steps; transportability remains untested.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Eligibility used clinical vascular diagnosis, mild-to-moderate severity and multiple exclusions; the composite accepts improvement on either of two scales.","implication":"The 66.2% response cannot be presented as a universal success probability or a validated patient self-test.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42088481/","next":["Inspect whether bootstrap validation repeats predictor and cutoff selection and reports optimism-corrected calibration.","Verify missing follow-up, outcome-scale naming and background therapy.","Seek external validation and assess a comparator-based treatment-interaction model."]},{"id":"SW200-220","pmid":"42540594","doi":"10.1093/sexmed/qfag069","title":"Is extracorporeal shock wave therapy more effective in younger patients in the treatment of mild-to-moderate erectile dysfunction? A prospective controlled study.","year":2026,"condition":"Mild-to-moderate erectile dysfunction, comparison by age","category":"sexual_urinary","categoryLabel":{"en":"Sexual and urinary health","pt-BR":"Saúde sexual e urinária"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Erectile dysfunction","pt-BR":"Disfunção erétil"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparative study","pt-BR":"Estudo comparativo não randomizado"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized age-group comparison within a treated cohort","pt-BR":"Comparação não randomizada por idade em uma coorte tratada"},"report_type":"Prospective nonrandomized treated-cohort comparison by age","population":"Human; 52 men, mean age 49.6 years, without concurrent medical or intracavernosal ED treatment.","sample":{"n":52,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"52 reported participants; see the source for recruitment, randomization and analysis denominators.","pt-BR":"52 participantes informados; consultar os denominadores de recrutamento, randomização e análise no registro de origem."},"source_population":"Human; 52 men, mean age 49.6 years, without concurrent medical or intracavernosal ED treatment.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"unspecified","comparator":"Men younger than 50 versus men 50 or older; both groups received the same ESWT regimen.","findings":"Younger-group IIEF means were 21.9, 22.1 and 21.9 at months 1, 3 and 6, versus 13.3, 17.6 and 19.0 in older men. Authors report between-group differences at each follow-up; erection-hardness improvement did not differ significantly. The conclusion proposes ESWT as sufficient standalone treatment in younger men.","patient_relevance":"Useful when patients ask whether age affects observed outcomes, with clear separation of prognosis and proven treatment benefit.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"The control in the title is an older treated group, not sham or no ESWT.","implication":"Age differences cannot establish treatment efficacy or that younger men derive a larger treatment-specific effect.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"Nonsignificant baseline score tests are reported, but adjustment for age-associated comorbidity, ED duration and baseline severity is not described in the abstract.","implication":"Prognostic imbalance remains possible; comparing follow-up means alone is insufficient to establish an age-by-treatment interaction.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The standalone-efficacy conclusion exceeds a comparison in which everyone received treatment; IIEF differences lack confidence intervals and EHS changes were not significantly different.","implication":"A patient guide should present an age-associated signal, not promise young men effective monotherapy.","verification":"interpretation"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42540594/","next":["Check baseline group sizes, IIEF version, change scores and adjusted analyses.","Review recruitment, comorbidities and missing follow-up by age.","Extract prespecified success thresholds and harms."]},{"id":"SW200-224","pmid":"42769704","doi":"10.1016/j.arrct.2026.100657","title":"Systematic Review and Meta-analysis Assessing the Effects of Focal and Radial Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy on Pain and Function in Patellar Tendinopathy.","year":2026,"condition":"Patellar tendinopathy","category":"knee","categoryLabel":{"en":"Knee","pt-BR":"Joelho"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Patellar tendinopathy","pt-BR":"Tendinopatia patelar"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise"},"report_type":"Systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized and nonrandomized studies","population":"Human clinical evidence; 13 mixed-design reports; 530 VAS observations and 369 VISA observations are outcome-specific totals, not established unique participants.","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"530 VAS and 369 VISA observations are outcome-specific totals, not verified unique people.","pt-BR":"530 observações de EVA e 369 de VISA são totais por desfecho, não números confirmados de pessoas únicas."},"source_population":"Human clinical evidence; 13 mixed-design reports; 530 VAS observations and 369 VISA observations are outcome-specific totals, not established unique participants.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed; focused and radial","comparator":"Separate pools of within-arm change in ESWT and heterogeneous control arms; four included studies reportedly lacked controls.","findings":"ESWT-arm mean VAS reduction was 2.53 versus 1.09 in the control pool; VISA increase was 20.22 versus 8.27. These are pooled within-arm changes, not extracted randomized between-arm effects. ESWT heterogeneity was I² 89% for VAS and 94% for VISA.","patient_relevance":"Important for explaining why large before-after improvements can coexist with uncertain comparative benefit. Do not reuse headline effect sizes as treatment-caused gains.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Controlled and uncontrolled treatment arms are pooled separately from control arms across studies.","implication":"Comparing those pools does not preserve within-trial randomization and is vulnerable to baseline, co-treatment and design confounding.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract adds 530 VAS and 369 VISA to claim 899 participants; Table 2 shows multiple reports contributed both outcomes.","implication":"899 is not a verified unique-person total; independent denominators require reconstruction.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Table 1 assigns GRADE labels to individual studies, while pooled changes are compared with MCID thresholds.","implication":"Those labels are not outcome-level certainty, and exceeding an MCID within an arm does not establish incremental treatment benefit.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The modality section claims only van der Worp directly compared focused and radial, whereas Table 2 also lists Şah as focused/radial/sham.","implication":"The stated basis for declining head-to-head synthesis needs reconciliation with primary reports.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42769704/","next":["Re-extract randomized within-trial contrasts, unique cohorts, outcomes and follow-up times.","Audit forest plots, paired-change variance assumptions and source table transcription.","Rebuild condition/outcome certainty and check the omitted head-to-head comparison rationale."]},{"id":"SW200-225","pmid":"40292269","doi":"10.1177/15563316251332189","title":"Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy for Tendinopathies Around the Hip and Pelvis: A Systematic Review.","year":2026,"condition":"Greater trochanteric pain syndrome/gluteal tendinopathy, proximal hamstring tendinopathy and calcific tendinopathy around the hip/pelvis","category":"hip_pelvis","categoryLabel":{"en":"Hip and pelvis","pt-BR":"Quadril e pelve"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Hip and pelvic tendinopathies","pt-BR":"Tendinopatias do quadril e da pelve"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical review","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática de estudos clínicos"},"report_type":"Systematic review of randomized and nonrandomized clinical evidence","population":"Human clinical evidence; 18 reports spanning evidence levels I–V, with overlapping condition counts.","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"18 reports; condition counts overlap. No unique-person total extracted.","pt-BR":"18 relatos; as contagens por condição se sobrepõem. Não foi extraído um total de pessoas únicas."},"source_population":"Human clinical evidence; 18 reports spanning evidence levels I–V, with overlapping condition counts.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed; 11 studies used radial and seven focused","comparator":"Varies: conservative treatment, sham, ultrasound, corticosteroid injection, eccentric exercise, minimal-dose ESWT and other ESWT regimens; some reports assess before-after change.","findings":"Authors report pain/function improvement in 17 studies, but only six reported superiority to a listed comparator. One GTPS study reported comparable outcomes to eccentric exercise; two comparisons found no significant differences for minimal-dose or combined ESWT. Follow-up ranged 0.5–27 months. Six studies reported adverse events, including pain and skin irritation; the abstract gives 65/557 (12%).","patient_relevance":"Useful as an overview directing patients to the correct hip or hamstring condition. The evidence and expected outcomes should remain diagnosis-specific.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The headline counts improvement across level-I to level-V studies rather than a single controlled effect.","implication":"Within-group improvement and comparative benefit must be separated; observational results may reflect selection, concurrent rehabilitation and natural course.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Three diagnoses, multiple active comparators and widely different follow-up times are combined descriptively.","implication":"Neither the session frequency nor the overall favorable conclusion establishes one optimal regimen for every hip/pelvis condition.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Only six of 18 studies reported adverse events, while a combined 12% rate is presented.","implication":"The denominator and surveillance method need verification; absent reporting in other studies cannot be interpreted as no harms.","verification":"requires_fulltext"}],"depth":"abstract_critical_screen","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/40292269/","next":["Map overlapping conditions and separate randomized contrasts from uncontrolled change.","Extract follow-up-specific estimates and co-interventions for the six superiority comparisons.","Reconstruct harms denominators and active ascertainment."]},{"id":"SW200-226","pmid":"41602486","doi":"10.3205/iprs000192","title":"State of shock - a systematic review of extracorporeal shockwave therapy in hand surgery.","year":2025,"condition":"Dupuytren disease, trigger finger, de Quervain tenosynovitis, lunate osteonecrosis and carpal tunnel syndrome","category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Multiple hand and wrist disorders","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições da mão e do punho"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review combining primary studies and reviews","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática que combina estudos primários e revisões"},"report_type":"Systematic qualitative review combining primary clinical reports and systematic reviews","population":"Human evidence; review includes randomized/observational primary studies and systematic reviews; claimed total over 16,623 is not verified as unique patients.","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Primary studies and reviews overlap; the claimed total is not verified as unique participants.","pt-BR":"Estudos primários e revisões se sobrepõem; o total declarado não foi confirmado como número de participantes únicos."},"source_population":"Human evidence; review includes randomized/observational primary studies and systematic reviews; claimed total over 16,623 is not verified as unique patients.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PROSPERO CRD42024598627","link_status":"requires_resolution","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"mixed; radial and focused considered","comparator":"Condition-dependent: sham, local corticosteroid injection, pretreatment baseline and other comparisons.","findings":"Authors report pain/function gains for several conditions and recommend ESWT for Dupuytren disease, trigger finger and CTS. Abstract claims three sessions are optimal for trigger finger and comparable efficacy to injections. Full text acknowledges that a definite protocol recommendation is impossible and that only one lunate study supports no clinical recommendation.","patient_relevance":"Useful for finding condition-specific hand studies. Do not turn the stated session counts into a treatment prescription or imply proven avoidance of surgery.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"Primary trials and systematic reviews enter the same qualitative evidence base.","implication":"Overlapping trial populations may inflate apparent replication and participant totals; a study-family map is needed.","verification":"requires_fulltext"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The trigger-finger session claim is based on patterns across different studies; the checked section does not describe a randomized three-versus-other-session comparison.","implication":"Cross-study significance and onset differences cannot establish an optimal number of sessions.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"Injection comparisons are described as equally effective, with fewer harms, but checked text often reports no significant difference.","implication":"Equivalence and comparative safety require suitable margins, precision and harm ascertainment, not nonsignificance alone.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Lunate evidence comprises one study, whereas CTS has a much broader literature.","implication":"A single recommendation across five conditions would hide major differences in support.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41602486/","next":["Build a unique-trial matrix across included reviews and primary reports.","Verify injection comparisons, harms and any direct dose comparisons.","Extract condition-specific long-term recurrence and subsequent surgery outcomes."]},{"id":"SW200-227","pmid":"39463916","doi":"10.7759/cureus.71869","title":"The Role of Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy in Keloids and Hypertrophic Scars: A Systematic Review.","year":2024,"condition":"Keloids and hypertrophic scars, with separate clinical and preclinical evidence","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Keloids and hypertrophic scars","pt-BR":"Queloides e cicatrizes hipertróficas"},"level":"mixed_translational","levelLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical / preclinical","pt-BR":"Evidência clínica / pré-clínica"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review of human and preclinical studies","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática de estudos em humanos e pré-clínicos"},"report_type":"Systematic review of clinical and preclinical primary studies","population":"Mixed; nine clinical reports (two keloid and seven hypertrophic-scar) plus two rabbit experiments and one fibroblast-culture study.","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"not_displayed","description":{"en":"Nine human clinical reports, two rabbit experiments and one cell-culture study; these units cannot be combined.","pt-BR":"Nove relatos clínicos em humanos, dois experimentos em coelhos e um estudo em cultura celular; essas unidades não podem ser somadas."},"source_population":"Mixed; nine clinical reports (two keloid and seven hypertrophic-scar) plus two rabbit experiments and one fibroblast-culture study.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports may reuse participants. Keep primary, companion and review records linked; do not add their sample sizes.","pt-BR":"As publicações podem reutilizar participantes. Vincular estudos primários, relatos complementares e revisões; não somar suas amostras."}},"modality":"unspecified for most clinical studies; the review also includes radial/focused preclinical applications","comparator":"Varies: ESWT versus intralesional steroid, ESWT added to steroid versus steroid alone, sham/control and before-after observations.","findings":"For keloids, a 39-patient trial found within-group improvements without significant ESWT-versus-steroid differences; a separate 40-patient trial reported greater scar-scale improvement with ESWT plus steroid than steroid alone. Hypertrophic-scar results varied by symptom and appearance measure; total VSS, erythema, skin-barrier and pigment findings were not uniformly positive. Histological findings partly came from preclinical work.","patient_relevance":"Can support an emerging scar-treatment page describing specific symptoms under study. Human evidence must be distinguished from mechanism illustrations.","critique":[{"category":"synthesis","observation":"The 12-report total includes three preclinical studies.","implication":"It must not be marketed as 12 human trials; cellular and rabbit effects do not establish patient cosmetic or functional benefit.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The monotherapy comparison had no significant difference, whereas the add-on trial used a different causal comparison.","implication":"Neither establishes equivalence to steroid; an add-on benefit cannot establish steroid replacement or fewer injections.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"Keloid evidence relies on two small trials, and hypertrophic-scar endpoints show mixed findings with limited long follow-up.","implication":"Scar subtype, recurrence, symptom relief and appearance should be reported separately rather than as universal scar regeneration.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39463916/","next":["Retrieve the two keloid trials for allocation, effect intervals, recurrence and harms.","Extract hypertrophic-scar between-group outcomes and concomitant scar therapy.","Audit review extraction against primary reports before using numerical infographics."]},{"id":"SW200-228","pmid":"42424664","doi":"10.1016/j.clinsp.2026.101034","title":"Radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy improves upper limb function in chronic stroke patients: a randomized sham-controlled trial.","year":2026,"condition":"Upper-limb dysfunction after chronic middle-cerebral-artery ischemic stroke","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Post-stroke spasticity and motor function","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e função motora após AVC"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized sham-controlled trial; per-protocol primary analysis","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado com tratamento simulado; análise primária por protocolo"},"report_type":"Randomized sham-controlled clinical trial with per-protocol primary analysis","population":"Human; 23 randomized patients, all with absent baseline motor-evoked potentials; 16 analyzed per protocol.","sample":{"n":23,"unit":"people","basis":"reported_population","description":{"en":"23 randomized; 16 analyzed per protocol.","pt-BR":"23 participantes randomizados; 16 analisados por protocolo."},"source_population":"Human; 23 randomized patients, all with absent baseline motor-evoked potentials; 16 analyzed per protocol.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":null},"modality":"radial","comparator":"Four weekly sessions versus a sham handpiece delivering no pressure waves.","findings":"Table 5 gives mean FMA-UE change of +5.111 for active versus −0.286 for sham; the unadjusted change comparison was nonsignificant. Baseline-adjusted ANCOVA gives a 7.319-point difference favoring active treatment (p=.038). These are different analyses, not contradictory estimates. Authors also report a proximal-function and strength signal.","patient_relevance":"Promising functional evidence beyond tone measurements, but the loss of randomized participants and exploratory analyses need prominent explanation.","critique":[{"category":"design","observation":"Seven of 23 randomized patients were excluded after allocation; analysis retained nine active and seven sham participants.","implication":"Postrandomization exclusion can compromise comparability and the assignment-effect estimate, despite sound stated allocation procedures.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"analysis","observation":"The proximal/distal split is explicitly described as belated, and several models were used on 16 participants.","implication":"Subcomponent findings are exploratory; multiplicity and model selection require scrutiny without dismissing appropriate baseline adjustment.","verification":"source_confirmed"},{"category":"applicability","observation":"All participants had absent motor-evoked potentials, and outcomes were short term.","implication":"This small selected group cannot establish durable benefit across stroke severities or prove the proposed peripheral mechanism.","verification":"interpretation"},{"category":"reporting","observation":"The abstract proximal p=.004 differs from the checked ANCOVA proximal p=.030 in Table 5; several tests are reported.","implication":"Identify the intended analysis before reproducing the abstract result; this is an unresolved reporting query, not a misconduct finding.","verification":"source_confirmed"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"deep_review_priority","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42424664/","next":["Check registry/prespecified analysis, reasons for all exclusions and missing-data sensitivity.","Verify effect intervals, the proximal p-value and multiplicity handling.","Inspect eligibility consistency, adverse events and device-consultant disclosure context."],"editorial":{"presentation":"ink"}},{"id":"SW200-229","pmid":"27149465","doi":"10.1097/md.0000000000003544","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27149465/","title":"Effect of Radial Shock Wave Therapy on Spasticity of the Upper Limb in Patients With Chronic Stroke: A Prospective, Randomized, Single Blind, Controlled Trial.","year":2016,"report_type":"Single-centre randomized, assessor-blinded, sham-controlled trial, registered NCT02221011. An independent researcher used computer-generated block allocation, 1:1:1; 60 participants completed follow-up.","population":"Adults with stable wrist/hand spasticity of at least MAS 1+, at least nine months after stroke; 20 per group. Fixed contracture, bilateral hemiplegia and recent/planned neurolytic or botulinum treatment were excluded. Mean time since stroke was roughly 62–67 months.","comparator":"Group C received three weekly sham sessions producing the same sound but no energy. Antispastic medication and rehabilitation were unchanged from two months before enrollment through follow-up; 6, 8 and 7 participants in A/B/C used antispastic drugs.","findings":"Three sessions improved MAS relative to sham through week 16; at week 16 hand changes were −1.20, −0.05 and +0.05 in A/B/C, and wrist changes −0.60, −0.05 and +0.05. One session differed from sham through week 12 for hand and week 8 for wrist. FMA hand change at week 16 was +1.70/+0.60/+0.10; wrist control was no longer different overall at week 16 (p=.472). For wrist function, the significant comparison with sham ended at week 8, despite broader abstract wording about 12 weeks.","patient_relevance":"Three radial sessions may temporarily reduce hand and wrist stiffness and improve some hand tasks after chronic stroke. The small trial does not show that one session improves function, and durable daily-life benefit remains uncertain.","condition":"Chronic post-stroke hand and wrist spasticity","modality":"Pagani radial device: 1,500 pulses at 3.5 bar and 5 Hz to flexor carpi radialis/ulnaris bellies, plus 4,000 at 3 bar and 5 Hz to intrinsic hand muscles/flexor tendons with ultrasound guidance. No anesthesia or analgesic was needed. Group A received three weekly sessions; group B one.","level":"randomized_trial","category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Chronic post-stroke hand and wrist spasticity","pt-BR":"Espasticidade crônica da mão e do punho após AVC"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Single-centre randomized, assessor-blinded, sham-controlled trial, registered NCT02221011. An independent researcher used computer-generated block allocation, 1:1:1; 60 participants completed follow-up.","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado de centro único, com avaliador cego e controle simulado, registrado NCT02221011. Um pesquisador independente utilizou alocação em blocos por computador, 1:1:1; 60 participantes completaram o seguimento."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":60,"unit":"people","basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Adults with stable wrist/hand spasticity of at least MAS 1+, at least nine months after stroke; 20 per group. Fixed contracture, bilateral hemiplegia and recent/planned neurolytic or botulinum treatment were excluded. Mean time since stroke was roughly 62–67 months.","pt-BR":"Adultos com espasticidade estável de punho/mão de pelo menos MAS 1+, nove meses ou mais após AVC; 20 por grupo. Contratura fixa, hemiplegia bilateral e tratamento neurolítico ou botulínico recente/planejado foram excluídos. O tempo médio após AVC foi aproximadamente 62–67 meses."},"source_population":"Adults with stable wrist/hand spasticity of at least MAS 1+, at least nine months after stroke; 20 per group. Fixed contracture, bilateral hemiplegia and recent/planned neurolytic or botulinum treatment were excluded. Mean time since stroke was roughly 62–67 months.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Twenty participants per arm, a single centre and an ordinal MAS treated numerically limit precision and interpretation. Repeated pointwise ANOVAs do not establish a longitudinal effect model. Group A had lower baseline FMA, leaving greater room for improvement; the authors acknowledge this and possible effects of concomitant care. Treatment operators were not blinded, and session schedules differed.","implication":"The findings concern chronic stable upper-limb spasticity without fixed contracture, under continuing rehabilitation. They do not establish equivalence to botulinum toxin, a benefit in acute stroke, or improvement in global independence.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["A larger trial should adjust for baseline function, use a prespecified repeated-measures analysis, compare clinically relevant regimens directly and measure patient priorities and longer-term function."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Chronic post-stroke hand and wrist spasticity","pt-BR":"Espasticidade crônica da mão e do punho após AVC"},"summary":{"en":"Three radial sessions may temporarily reduce hand and wrist stiffness and improve some hand tasks after chronic stroke. The small trial does not show that one session improves function, and durable daily-life benefit remains uncertain.","pt-BR":"Três sessões radiais podem reduzir temporariamente a rigidez da mão e do punho e melhorar algumas tarefas manuais após AVC crônico. O ensaio pequeno não demonstra que uma sessão melhore a função, e o benefício duradouro na vida diária permanece incerto."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Can three weekly radial shockwave sessions reduce chronic post-stroke hand and wrist spasticity more durably than one session or sham?","pt-BR":"Três sessões semanais de ondas radiais reduzem a espasticidade crônica da mão e do punho após AVC por mais tempo que uma sessão ou aplicação simulada?"},"population":{"en":"Adults with stable wrist/hand spasticity of at least MAS 1+, at least nine months after stroke; 20 per group. Fixed contracture, bilateral hemiplegia and recent/planned neurolytic or botulinum treatment were excluded. Mean time since stroke was roughly 62–67 months.","pt-BR":"Adultos com espasticidade estável de punho/mão de pelo menos MAS 1+, nove meses ou mais após AVC; 20 por grupo. Contratura fixa, hemiplegia bilateral e tratamento neurolítico ou botulínico recente/planejado foram excluídos. O tempo médio após AVC foi aproximadamente 62–67 meses."},"comparison":{"en":"Group C received three weekly sham sessions producing the same sound but no energy. Antispastic medication and rehabilitation were unchanged from two months before enrollment through follow-up; 6, 8 and 7 participants in A/B/C used antispastic drugs.","pt-BR":"O grupo C recebeu três sessões semanais simuladas com o mesmo som, mas sem energia. Medicamentos antiespásticos e reabilitação permaneceram estáveis desde dois meses antes da inclusão até o fim; 6, 8 e 7 participantes de A/B/C usavam esses medicamentos."},"note":{"en":"Twenty participants per arm, a single centre and an ordinal MAS treated numerically limit precision and interpretation. Repeated pointwise ANOVAs do not establish a longitudinal effect model. Group A had lower baseline FMA, leaving greater room for improvement; the authors acknowledge this and possible effects of concomitant care. Treatment operators were not blinded, and session schedules differed.","pt-BR":"Vinte participantes por grupo, centro único e tratamento numérico de uma MAS ordinal limitam precisão e interpretação. ANOVAs separadas em vários momentos não estabelecem um modelo longitudinal do efeito. O grupo A tinha FMA inicial menor, com maior margem de melhora; os autores reconhecem isso e possíveis efeitos do cuidado concomitante. Aplicadores não eram cegos e os esquemas de sessões diferiam."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-230","pmid":null,"doi":"10.5152/ABCR.2024.23176","pubmed_url":null,"title":"Comparison of the Efficacy of Laser and Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy in Patients with Myofascial Pain Syndrome","year":2024,"report_type":"Prospective randomized comparative study. Forty-six patients were allocated; six with missing assessments were excluded and 40 were analyzed. The random sequence, allocation concealment and assessor masking are not described.","population":"Patients with at least three months of neck/dorsal myofascial symptoms, diagnosed by Travell and Simons criteria, with trapezius or paraspinal trigger points; 20 analyzed per treatment. Mean age was 35.3 years. Fibromyalgia and severe cervical disc disease were excluded.","comparator":"Ga-As laser, 904 nm, 1.2 J/cm², 6 kHz for 30 seconds at the same two trigger points, 15 sessions over three weeks plus the same home exercises. There was no sham or exercise-only arm.","findings":"At one month VAS fell from 6.8 to 3.1 with laser and 7.1 to 3.9 with ESWT. Reported improvement magnitudes were 3.7 versus 3.2 points (between-group p=.512). Pressure threshold rose to 3.7 versus 3.5 kg; BDI and physical SF-36 improved within groups, but none of the ten between-group outcome/time comparisons was significant. Mental SF-36 did not improve significantly within either group. Nonsignificance does not demonstrate equivalence.","patient_relevance":"Both treatment packages were followed by less pain, and this small study did not identify a superior one. Because everyone exercised and there was no inactive control, the improvement cannot be attributed entirely to the devices.","condition":"Laser versus shockwaves for myofascial pain","modality":"BTL-5000 SWT compressor POWER: 2,000 pulses, 2.0 bar, 10–15 Hz to the two most tender trapezius/paraspinal points; three sessions 5–8 days apart. Both groups received posture, range-of-motion and stretching exercises, three sets of ten daily at home for two months. The report does not explicitly classify the device as focused or radial.","level":"randomized_trial","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Laser versus shockwaves for myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Laser versus ondas de choque para dor miofascial"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Prospective randomized comparative study. Forty-six patients were allocated; six with missing assessments were excluded and 40 were analyzed. The random sequence, allocation concealment and assessor masking are not described.","pt-BR":"Estudo comparativo prospectivo descrito como randomizado. Quarenta e seis pacientes foram alocados; seis com avaliações ausentes foram excluídos e 40 analisados. Não se descrevem sequência aleatória, ocultação de alocação ou cegamento do avaliador."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":46,"unit":"people","basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Patients with at least three months of neck/dorsal myofascial symptoms, diagnosed by Travell and Simons criteria, with trapezius or paraspinal trigger points; 20 analyzed per treatment. Mean age was 35.3 years. Fibromyalgia and severe cervical disc disease were excluded.","pt-BR":"Pacientes com sintomas miofasciais cervicais/dorsais por pelo menos três meses, diagnosticados pelos critérios de Travell e Simons, com pontos-gatilho no trapézio ou paravertebrais; 20 analisados por tratamento. Idade média de 35,3 anos. Fibromialgia e doença discal cervical grave foram excluídas."},"source_population":"Patients with at least three months of neck/dorsal myofascial symptoms, diagnosed by Travell and Simons criteria, with trapezius or paraspinal trigger points; 20 analyzed per treatment. Mean age was 35.3 years. Fibromyalgia and severe cervical disc disease were excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Small completer analysis excludes six randomized patients without arm-specific attrition. No placebo/exercise-only arm separates treatment effects from exercise, expectation or natural change. The one-month horizon is short and masking/allocation details are missing. Demographic sex counts/percentages in Table 1 conflict internally and with the Results narrative; Table 2 prints an incomplete ESWT post-treatment BDI SD. These are not silently corrected.","implication":"This addresses trapezius/paraspinal MPS with shared home exercise, not generalized fibromyalgia. Fewer shockwave visits may be practical, but neither equivalent efficacy nor cost-effectiveness was tested.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Use concealed allocation, blinded assessment, intention-to-treat analysis, an exercise-only/sham arm, longer follow-up and explicit adverse-event recording; correct demographic and ethics reporting inconsistencies."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Laser versus shockwaves for myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Laser versus ondas de choque para dor miofascial"},"summary":{"en":"Both treatment packages were followed by less pain, and this small study did not identify a superior one. Because everyone exercised and there was no inactive control, the improvement cannot be attributed entirely to the devices.","pt-BR":"Ambos os conjuntos de tratamento foram seguidos por menos dor, e este estudo pequeno não identificou um superior. Como todos fizeram exercícios e não houve controle inativo, a melhora não pode ser atribuída integralmente aos aparelhos."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Does three-session shockwave therapy differ from 15-session laser therapy when both accompany exercise for chronic myofascial neck/back pain?","pt-BR":"Três sessões de ondas de choque diferem de 15 sessões de laser quando ambas acompanham exercícios para dor miofascial cervical/dorsal crônica?"},"population":{"en":"Patients with at least three months of neck/dorsal myofascial symptoms, diagnosed by Travell and Simons criteria, with trapezius or paraspinal trigger points; 20 analyzed per treatment. Mean age was 35.3 years. Fibromyalgia and severe cervical disc disease were excluded.","pt-BR":"Pacientes com sintomas miofasciais cervicais/dorsais por pelo menos três meses, diagnosticados pelos critérios de Travell e Simons, com pontos-gatilho no trapézio ou paravertebrais; 20 analisados por tratamento. Idade média de 35,3 anos. Fibromialgia e doença discal cervical grave foram excluídas."},"comparison":{"en":"Ga-As laser, 904 nm, 1.2 J/cm², 6 kHz for 30 seconds at the same two trigger points, 15 sessions over three weeks plus the same home exercises. There was no sham or exercise-only arm.","pt-BR":"Laser Ga-As, 904 nm, 1,2 J/cm², 6 kHz por 30 segundos nos mesmos dois pontos-gatilho, 15 sessões em três semanas mais os mesmos exercícios. Não houve grupo simulado nem apenas exercícios."},"note":{"en":"Small completer analysis excludes six randomized patients without arm-specific attrition. No placebo/exercise-only arm separates treatment effects from exercise, expectation or natural change. The one-month horizon is short and masking/allocation details are missing. Demographic sex counts/percentages in Table 1 conflict internally and with the Results narrative; Table 2 prints an incomplete ESWT post-treatment BDI SD. These are not silently corrected.","pt-BR":"A análise pequena de completadores exclui seis pacientes randomizados sem perdas por grupo. Sem placebo ou grupo apenas exercício, não se separam efeitos específicos de exercício, expectativa ou evolução natural. O horizonte de um mês é curto e faltam detalhes de cegamento/alocação. Contagens/percentuais por sexo da Tabela 1 conflitam internamente e com o texto; a Tabela 2 imprime DP incompleto para Beck após ondas. Esses problemas não foram corrigidos silenciosamente."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false},"source_url":"https://doi.org/10.5152/ABCR.2024.23176","source_identity":"citation_only","source_citation":"Özyiğit E, Erdal A. Comparison of the Efficacy of Laser and Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy in Patients with Myofascial Pain Syndrome. Archives of Basic and Clinical Research. 2024."},{"id":"SW200-231","pmid":"35280414","doi":"10.21037/atm-22-295","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35280414/","title":"Efficacy of extracorporeal shock waves in the treatment of myofascial pain syndrome: a systematic review and meta-analysis of controlled clinical studies.","year":2022,"report_type":"Systematic review with meta-analysis of controlled clinical studies, searching four databases to October 2021 in English. Nonrandomized and allocation-unclear studies were eligible. The abstract says eight studies, whereas the flowchart, Table 1 and Discussion identify ten.","population":"The authors report 571 participants, 541 with neck/upper-back pain and 30 with lumbar pain. However, Table 1 and the pain forest plot sum to 570 participants (283 experimental, 287 control). These conflicting source totals must remain visible; the pooled sample is not one new cohort.","comparator":"Controls included trigger-point injection with/without TENS, dry needling, ultrasound with/without other modalities, phonophoresis and kinesiology taping. Pooling these comparators does not estimate efficacy against any single treatment. The Discussion incorrectly conflates ultrasound with ultrasound-guided pulsed radiofrequency.","findings":"Reported pooled pain MD was −1.34 (95% CI −1.87 to −0.81; I²85%). Pressure threshold MD was +0.90 (0.73 to 1.07; I²98%) and NDI MD −1.79 (−2.48 to −1.10; I²92%). Figures 5 and 6 label the latter two models fixed-effect, contradicting the random-effects description. Individual comparisons with dry needling crossed the null; the review does not justify superiority to every comparator.","patient_relevance":"The review suggests possible short-term improvement, but important reporting and analysis inconsistencies make its precise pooled numbers uncertain. It does not prove shockwaves are better than every other treatment.","condition":"Shockwaves for myofascial pain: pooled evidence with reporting concerns","modality":"ESWT protocols varied across the included studies; Table 1 names treatments but does not provide a reproducible device, energy, pulse and session schedule for each. The review cannot define one recommended dose.","level":"clinical_synthesis","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shockwaves for myofascial pain: pooled evidence with reporting concerns","pt-BR":"Ondas para dor miofascial: evidência combinada com problemas de relato"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical evidence syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas de evidências clínicas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review with meta-analysis of controlled clinical studies, searching four databases to October 2021 in English. Nonrandomized and allocation-unclear studies were eligible. The abstract says eight studies, whereas the flowchart, Table 1 and Discussion identify ten.","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática com metanálise de estudos clínicos controlados, com busca em quatro bases até outubro de 2021, em inglês. Estudos não randomizados e com alocação incerta eram elegíveis. O resumo diz oito estudos, mas fluxograma, Tabela 1 e Discussão identificam dez."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"The authors report 571 participants, 541 with neck/upper-back pain and 30 with lumbar pain. However, Table 1 and the pain forest plot sum to 570 participants (283 experimental, 287 control). These conflicting source totals must remain visible; the pooled sample is not one new cohort.","pt-BR":"Os autores relatam 571 participantes, 541 com dor cervical/dorsal e 30 lombar. Porém, Tabela 1 e gráfico de dor somam 570 (283 experimentais, 287 controles). Os totais conflitantes da fonte precisam permanecer visíveis; a amostra combinada não constitui uma nova coorte."},"source_population":"The authors report 571 participants, 541 with neck/upper-back pain and 30 with lumbar pain. However, Table 1 and the pain forest plot sum to 570 participants (283 experimental, 287 control). These conflicting source totals must remain visible; the pooled sample is not one new cohort.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"High heterogeneity, nonrandomized studies, English-only inclusion and many inaccessible/excluded full texts weaken causal and coverage claims. Model labels disagree with Methods for pressure threshold and NDI; study and participant totals disagree internally. A visually symmetric funnel with few studies cannot exclude reporting bias. The stated PEDro scoring framework also needs caution.","implication":"Evidence mostly concerns neck/upper-back MPS and short follow-up. It cannot be generalized to lumbar disease on the basis of one 30-person comparison, nor used to select a device or replace exercise.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Reconcile the extraction with primary reports, correct study totals and comparator labels, rerun appropriate heterogeneous-effect models and provide comparator-specific, longer-term estimates and harms."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves for myofascial pain: pooled evidence with reporting concerns","pt-BR":"Ondas para dor miofascial: evidência combinada com problemas de relato"},"summary":{"en":"The review suggests possible short-term improvement, but important reporting and analysis inconsistencies make its precise pooled numbers uncertain. It does not prove shockwaves are better than every other treatment.","pt-BR":"A revisão sugere possível melhora em curto prazo, mas inconsistências importantes de relato e análise tornam incertos seus números combinados. Não prova que ondas sejam melhores que qualquer outro tratamento."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Does ESWT improve short-term pain, pressure sensitivity and neck disability more than other therapies for myofascial pain?","pt-BR":"Ondas de choque melhoram dor, sensibilidade à pressão e incapacidade cervical em curto prazo mais que outras terapias para dor miofascial?"},"population":{"en":"The authors report 571 participants, 541 with neck/upper-back pain and 30 with lumbar pain. However, Table 1 and the pain forest plot sum to 570 participants (283 experimental, 287 control). These conflicting source totals must remain visible; the pooled sample is not one new cohort.","pt-BR":"Os autores relatam 571 participantes, 541 com dor cervical/dorsal e 30 lombar. Porém, Tabela 1 e gráfico de dor somam 570 (283 experimentais, 287 controles). Os totais conflitantes da fonte precisam permanecer visíveis; a amostra combinada não constitui uma nova coorte."},"comparison":{"en":"Controls included trigger-point injection with/without TENS, dry needling, ultrasound with/without other modalities, phonophoresis and kinesiology taping. Pooling these comparators does not estimate efficacy against any single treatment. The Discussion incorrectly conflates ultrasound with ultrasound-guided pulsed radiofrequency.","pt-BR":"Controles incluíram infiltração de pontos-gatilho com/sem TENS, agulhamento seco, ultrassom com/sem outras modalidades, fonoforese e bandagem. Combinar esses controles não estima eficácia frente a um único tratamento. A Discussão confunde ultrassom com radiofrequência pulsada guiada por ultrassom."},"note":{"en":"High heterogeneity, nonrandomized studies, English-only inclusion and many inaccessible/excluded full texts weaken causal and coverage claims. Model labels disagree with Methods for pressure threshold and NDI; study and participant totals disagree internally. A visually symmetric funnel with few studies cannot exclude reporting bias. The stated PEDro scoring framework also needs caution.","pt-BR":"Heterogeneidade alta, estudos não randomizados, restrição ao inglês e muitos textos inacessíveis/excluídos enfraquecem causalidade e cobertura. Rótulos dos modelos divergem dos Métodos para limiar de pressão e NDI; totais de estudos e participantes divergem internamente. Funil visualmente simétrico com poucos estudos não exclui viés de publicação. A forma declarada de pontuar PEDro também exige cautela."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-232","pmid":"36013480","doi":"10.3390/medicina58081014","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36013480/","title":"Efficacy and Effectiveness of Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy in Patients with Myofascial Pain or Fibromyalgia: A Scoping Review.","year":2022,"report_type":"PRISMA-ScR scoping review of English-language human interventional and observational studies in PubMed through December 2021. Nineteen studies were included from 76 search records; no pooled effect or formal certainty assessment is supplied.","population":"All 19 eligible studies concerned myofascial pain: 12 radial and seven focused; 15 randomized trials and four observational reports. No eligible fibromyalgia trial was identified. Sites included trapezius, quadratus lumborum, quadriceps and gastrocsoleus, with a broad mixed myofascial/articular retrospective cohort.","comparator":"Comparators included dry needling, laser, ultrasound, exercise, sham/very-low-energy treatment, trigger-point injections, kinesiology taping and topical diclofenac. The review does not provide a direct pooled radial-versus-focused comparison.","findings":"Sham comparisons generally favored ESWT, while active-treatment comparisons were mixed. Dry-needling and some ultrasound comparisons found no clear superiority. Jeon found no pain/mobility advantage over injection plus TENS; Hong reported a pain advantage without disability differences. Eftekharsadat favored corticosteroid injection at two weeks and radial therapy at one month. There is no eligible trial evidence for fibromyalgia.","patient_relevance":"Shockwaves may help some people with regional myofascial pain, but the best regimen and superiority to other active care remain uncertain. This review found no eligible fibromyalgia trial, so its suggested protocol is an untested research proposal.","condition":"Myofascial pain and fibromyalgia: where the evidence differs","modality":"Radial protocols generally used 1,000–4,500 pulses and focused protocols 1,000–3,000 pulses at 0.056–0.25 mJ/mm². Three weekly sessions were common, but schedules varied. Tables contain inconsistent units and modality descriptions, so these ranges are a map of reporting rather than a validated prescription.","level":"clinical_synthesis","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain and fibromyalgia: where the evidence differs","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial e fibromialgia: onde a evidência difere"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical evidence syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas de evidências clínicas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"PRISMA-ScR scoping review of English-language human interventional and observational studies in PubMed through December 2021. Nineteen studies were included from 76 search records; no pooled effect or formal certainty assessment is supplied.","pt-BR":"Revisão de escopo PRISMA-ScR de estudos humanos intervencionais e observacionais em inglês no PubMed até dezembro de 2021. Foram incluídos 19 estudos de 76 registros; não há efeito combinado nem avaliação formal de certeza."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"All 19 eligible studies concerned myofascial pain: 12 radial and seven focused; 15 randomized trials and four observational reports. No eligible fibromyalgia trial was identified. Sites included trapezius, quadratus lumborum, quadriceps and gastrocsoleus, with a broad mixed myofascial/articular retrospective cohort.","pt-BR":"Todos os 19 estudos elegíveis abordaram dor miofascial: 12 radiais e sete focais; 15 ensaios randomizados e quatro relatos observacionais. Nenhum ensaio elegível de fibromialgia foi identificado. Locais incluíram trapézio, quadrado lombar, quadríceps e gastrocnêmio/sóleo, além de coorte retrospectiva ampla com dor miofascial/articular."},"source_population":"All 19 eligible studies concerned myofascial pain: 12 radial and seven focused; 15 randomized trials and four observational reports. No eligible fibromyalgia trial was identified. Sites included trapezius, quadratus lumborum, quadriceps and gastrocsoleus, with a broad mixed myofascial/articular retrospective cohort.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Single-database, English-only searching and qualitative synthesis can miss studies and cannot quantify comparative benefit. Study design, anatomy, controls and dosing differ markedly. Some table units and modality labels conflict with narrative; primary papers should govern protocol decisions. The proposed fibromyalgia protocol was not tested.","implication":"The review supports research and clinical discussion for regional myofascial pain, but a trigger-point response cannot be generalized to widespread fibromyalgia. Mechanism diagrams are hypotheses, not measured outcomes in these patients.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Test clearly specified regimens against credible sham and active care, distinguish radial from focused devices, report harms and meaningful functional change, and study fibromyalgia directly before recommending the proposed schedule."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Myofascial pain and fibromyalgia: where the evidence differs","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial e fibromialgia: onde a evidência difere"},"summary":{"en":"Shockwaves may help some people with regional myofascial pain, but the best regimen and superiority to other active care remain uncertain. This review found no eligible fibromyalgia trial, so its suggested protocol is an untested research proposal.","pt-BR":"Ondas podem ajudar algumas pessoas com dor miofascial regional, mas melhor esquema e superioridade a outros cuidados ativos continuam incertos. Esta revisão não encontrou ensaio elegível em fibromialgia; seu protocolo sugerido é proposta de pesquisa não testada."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"What clinical evidence supports radial or focused ESWT for myofascial pain syndrome and fibromyalgia?","pt-BR":"Que evidência clínica sustenta ondas radiais ou focais para síndrome dolorosa miofascial e fibromialgia?"},"population":{"en":"All 19 eligible studies concerned myofascial pain: 12 radial and seven focused; 15 randomized trials and four observational reports. No eligible fibromyalgia trial was identified. Sites included trapezius, quadratus lumborum, quadriceps and gastrocsoleus, with a broad mixed myofascial/articular retrospective cohort.","pt-BR":"Todos os 19 estudos elegíveis abordaram dor miofascial: 12 radiais e sete focais; 15 ensaios randomizados e quatro relatos observacionais. Nenhum ensaio elegível de fibromialgia foi identificado. Locais incluíram trapézio, quadrado lombar, quadríceps e gastrocnêmio/sóleo, além de coorte retrospectiva ampla com dor miofascial/articular."},"comparison":{"en":"Comparators included dry needling, laser, ultrasound, exercise, sham/very-low-energy treatment, trigger-point injections, kinesiology taping and topical diclofenac. The review does not provide a direct pooled radial-versus-focused comparison.","pt-BR":"Comparadores incluíram agulhamento seco, laser, ultrassom, exercício, simulação/energia muito baixa, infiltrações, bandagem e diclofenaco tópico. A revisão não fornece comparação direta combinada entre radial e focal."},"note":{"en":"Single-database, English-only searching and qualitative synthesis can miss studies and cannot quantify comparative benefit. Study design, anatomy, controls and dosing differ markedly. Some table units and modality labels conflict with narrative; primary papers should govern protocol decisions. The proposed fibromyalgia protocol was not tested.","pt-BR":"Busca em base única, restrição ao inglês e síntese qualitativa podem omitir estudos e não quantificam benefício comparativo. Desenho, anatomia, controles e doses variam muito. Algumas unidades e modalidades das tabelas conflitam com o texto; os estudos primários devem orientar decisões de protocolo. O esquema proposto para fibromialgia não foi testado."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-233","pmid":"41157174","doi":"10.3390/life15101501","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41157174/","title":"The State of Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy for Myofascial Pain Syndrome-A Scoping Review and a Call for Standardized Protocols.","year":2025,"report_type":"Scoping review of primary studies harvested from seven existing reviews/meta-analyses identified through PubMed, PEDro and Cochrane to August 2025. Of 83 extracted records, 48 duplicates were removed and 35 articles analyzed. This is a methodological audit, not a new efficacy meta-analysis.","population":"The 35 studies largely concerned upper-trapezius myofascial pain but included lumbar, jaw and lower-limb sites and observational cohorts. No new patients were recruited and no reliable deduplicated patient total was calculated.","comparator":"The audit compares reporting practices and discusses existing comparisons with sham, ultrasound, injection, dry needling and laser. It does not randomize device modality or test whether guideline-adherent treatment works better.","findings":"Results report Travell–Simons criteria in 20/35 studies, pain recognition in six, operator background in 14 and operator experience in four; 13 had follow-up of two weeks or less. The discussion changes several denominators/ranges, including 12/36 short follow-ups and 8/24 radial-unit errors despite 23 radial studies in Results. The efficacy discussion finds benefit mainly over sham or ultrasound, without established superiority over injection, dry needling or laser.","patient_relevance":"This review explains why results are hard to compare. It supports clearer protocols and longer follow-up, but does not supply a new numerical estimate of how much shockwaves improve pain or prove one modality best.","condition":"Why myofascial shockwave protocols are hard to compare","modality":"Results classify 23 studies as radial pressure waves and 12 as focused ESWT. Reported dosing varied greatly, with missing frequency, point-specific impulse counts and operator qualifications. Radial pressure in bar must not be converted into focused energy flux density.","level":"clinical_synthesis","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Why myofascial shockwave protocols are hard to compare","pt-BR":"Por que é difícil comparar protocolos de ondas para dor miofascial"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical evidence syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas de evidências clínicas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Scoping review of primary studies harvested from seven existing reviews/meta-analyses identified through PubMed, PEDro and Cochrane to August 2025. Of 83 extracted records, 48 duplicates were removed and 35 articles analyzed. This is a methodological audit, not a new efficacy meta-analysis.","pt-BR":"Revisão de escopo de estudos primários extraídos de sete revisões/metanálises encontradas no PubMed, PEDro e Cochrane até agosto de 2025. Dos 83 registros, 48 duplicados foram removidos e 35 artigos analisados. É auditoria metodológica, não nova metanálise de eficácia."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"The 35 studies largely concerned upper-trapezius myofascial pain but included lumbar, jaw and lower-limb sites and observational cohorts. No new patients were recruited and no reliable deduplicated patient total was calculated.","pt-BR":"Os 35 estudos abordaram principalmente trapézio superior, incluindo região lombar, mandíbula, membros inferiores e coortes observacionais. Não houve novos pacientes nem cálculo de total confiável de participantes sem duplicação."},"source_population":"The 35 studies largely concerned upper-trapezius myofascial pain but included lumbar, jaw and lower-limb sites and observational cohorts. No new patients were recruited and no reliable deduplicated patient total was calculated.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Sampling through existing reviews can inherit their selection omissions. No causal analysis links diagnostic precision or protocol adherence with treatment benefit. Several internal count/range inconsistencies prevent treating audit percentages as exact. Mechanistic findings from cells or other tissues do not establish comparative MPS efficacy.","implication":"The paper is useful for designing reproducible research and distinguishing radial from focused delivery. Its preferred guideline framework and longer follow-up recommendation are methodological proposals rather than proof that a specific technique is superior.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Future trials should publish reproducible diagnoses, actual device/settings, treatment targeting, practitioner qualifications, meaningful functional outcomes, adverse events and follow-up beyond the immediate response; audit counts should be reconciled against tables."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Why myofascial shockwave protocols are hard to compare","pt-BR":"Por que é difícil comparar protocolos de ondas para dor miofascial"},"summary":{"en":"This review explains why results are hard to compare. It supports clearer protocols and longer follow-up, but does not supply a new numerical estimate of how much shockwaves improve pain or prove one modality best.","pt-BR":"A revisão explica por que é difícil comparar resultados. Apoia protocolos claros e acompanhamento maior, mas não fornece nova estimativa numérica de melhora da dor nem prova qual modalidade é melhor."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"How consistently do myofascial ESWT studies diagnose trigger points, describe treatment and follow patients?","pt-BR":"Com que consistência estudos de ondas para dor miofascial diagnosticam pontos-gatilho, descrevem tratamento e acompanham pacientes?"},"population":{"en":"The 35 studies largely concerned upper-trapezius myofascial pain but included lumbar, jaw and lower-limb sites and observational cohorts. No new patients were recruited and no reliable deduplicated patient total was calculated.","pt-BR":"Os 35 estudos abordaram principalmente trapézio superior, incluindo região lombar, mandíbula, membros inferiores e coortes observacionais. Não houve novos pacientes nem cálculo de total confiável de participantes sem duplicação."},"comparison":{"en":"The audit compares reporting practices and discusses existing comparisons with sham, ultrasound, injection, dry needling and laser. It does not randomize device modality or test whether guideline-adherent treatment works better.","pt-BR":"A auditoria compara práticas de relato e discute comparações existentes com simulação, ultrassom, infiltração, agulhamento e laser. Não randomiza modalidades nem testa se seguir diretrizes produz resultados melhores."},"note":{"en":"Sampling through existing reviews can inherit their selection omissions. No causal analysis links diagnostic precision or protocol adherence with treatment benefit. Several internal count/range inconsistencies prevent treating audit percentages as exact. Mechanistic findings from cells or other tissues do not establish comparative MPS efficacy.","pt-BR":"Amostragem por revisões existentes pode herdar omissões. Não há análise causal ligando precisão diagnóstica ou adesão ao protocolo ao benefício. Inconsistências internas de contagem/intervalo impedem tratar percentuais da auditoria como exatos. Achados celulares ou de outros tecidos não estabelecem eficácia comparativa em síndrome miofascial."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-234","pmid":"39767813","doi":"10.3390/biomedicines12122909","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/39767813/","title":"The Use and Benefits of Focused Shockwaves for the Diagnosis of Myofascial Pain Syndrome by Examining Myofascial Trigger Points in Low Back Pain.","year":2024,"report_type":"Single-centre observational proof-of-concept diagnostic study, without blinded comparison, independent reference standard or treatment efficacy follow-up.","population":"Twenty-eight adults with chronic nonspecific low-back pain were recruited by newspaper advertisement: 15 women, 13 men, mean age 59.0 years and mean symptom duration 87.39 months. Investigators selected 115 trigger-point/muscle observations; these are not 115 independent patients.","comparator":"All tested sites were preselected using manual palpation by experienced clinicians. There was no randomized sham, asymptomatic control or blinded independent diagnostic reference.","findings":"Referral occurred in 25/26 quadratus-lumborum, 22/23 gluteus-medius and 13/14 gluteus-minimus selections; recognition in 22/26, 20/23 and 12/14. Iliopsoas referral was 13/14 but recognition only 7/14. One of 28 participants had neither response. These are elicitation proportions, not sensitivity, specificity or validated diagnostic accuracy.","patient_relevance":"Focused stimulation often reproduced familiar or spreading pain at preselected sites. This early study does not prove that it identifies the true cause of back pain or that a positive response predicts treatment benefit.","condition":"Focused shockwaves as a diagnostic stimulus in low-back pain","modality":"Wolf PiezoWave2 FB10 G10 focused source, approximately 10-mm focal zone, 5 Hz and 0.06–0.30 mJ/mm² adjusted to verbal tolerance. Gel spacers placed the focus 3–5 cm deep for lumbar/gluteal targets or 1–3 cm for superficial targets. Total pulses per diagnostic point were not reported.","level":"uncontrolled_clinical","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Focused shockwaves as a diagnostic stimulus in low-back pain","pt-BR":"Ondas focais como estímulo diagnóstico na lombalgia"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Clinical cohorts without a treatment control","pt-BR":"Coortes clínicas sem grupo de controle do tratamento"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Single-centre observational proof-of-concept diagnostic study, without blinded comparison, independent reference standard or treatment efficacy follow-up.","pt-BR":"Estudo diagnóstico observacional de prova de conceito, em centro único, sem comparação cega, padrão de referência independente ou seguimento de eficácia terapêutica."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":28,"unit":"people","basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Twenty-eight adults with chronic nonspecific low-back pain were recruited by newspaper advertisement: 15 women, 13 men, mean age 59.0 years and mean symptom duration 87.39 months. Investigators selected 115 trigger-point/muscle observations; these are not 115 independent patients.","pt-BR":"Vinte e oito adultos com lombalgia inespecífica crônica foram recrutados por anúncio: 15 mulheres, 13 homens, idade média de 59,0 anos e duração média dos sintomas de 87,39 meses. Foram selecionadas 115 observações de pontos/músculos; não são 115 pacientes independentes."},"source_population":"Twenty-eight adults with chronic nonspecific low-back pain were recruited by newspaper advertisement: 15 women, 13 men, mean age 59.0 years and mean symptom duration 87.39 months. Investigators selected 115 trigger-point/muscle observations; these are not 115 independent patients.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"The authors acknowledge one centre/investigator and palpation preselection. Small selected sample, subjective responses, no blinding or reference standard, repeated sites within participants and ambiguous units prevent claims of diagnostic accuracy or reproducibility. The reported recruitment end date is 31 September 2022, an invalid calendar date.","implication":"The technique may help describe familiar pain in selected chronic low-back-pain patients. It has not been shown to distinguish radiculopathy, determine surgical indications, prevent failed surgery or improve treatment outcomes.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Use independent blinded examiners, repeatability testing, prespecified reference diagnoses, asymptomatic and disease controls, patient-level clustered analyses and prospective diagnostic accuracy/management outcomes."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Focused shockwaves as a diagnostic stimulus in low-back pain","pt-BR":"Ondas focais como estímulo diagnóstico na lombalgia"},"summary":{"en":"Focused stimulation often reproduced familiar or spreading pain at preselected sites. This early study does not prove that it identifies the true cause of back pain or that a positive response predicts treatment benefit.","pt-BR":"A estimulação focal frequentemente reproduziu dor familiar ou irradiada nos locais selecionados. Este estudo inicial não prova que identifique a verdadeira causa da lombalgia nem que resposta positiva preveja benefício terapêutico."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Can focused shockwave stimulation of palpation-selected lumbar/gluteal/thigh trigger points reproduce familiar or referred pain?","pt-BR":"A estimulação focal de pontos-gatilho lombares/glúteos/da coxa selecionados por palpação reproduz dor familiar ou irradiada?"},"population":{"en":"Twenty-eight adults with chronic nonspecific low-back pain were recruited by newspaper advertisement: 15 women, 13 men, mean age 59.0 years and mean symptom duration 87.39 months. Investigators selected 115 trigger-point/muscle observations; these are not 115 independent patients.","pt-BR":"Vinte e oito adultos com lombalgia inespecífica crônica foram recrutados por anúncio: 15 mulheres, 13 homens, idade média de 59,0 anos e duração média dos sintomas de 87,39 meses. Foram selecionadas 115 observações de pontos/músculos; não são 115 pacientes independentes."},"comparison":{"en":"All tested sites were preselected using manual palpation by experienced clinicians. There was no randomized sham, asymptomatic control or blinded independent diagnostic reference.","pt-BR":"Todos os locais foram pré-selecionados por palpação de profissionais experientes. Não houve simulação randomizada, controle assintomático ou referência diagnóstica cega independente."},"note":{"en":"The authors acknowledge one centre/investigator and palpation preselection. Small selected sample, subjective responses, no blinding or reference standard, repeated sites within participants and ambiguous units prevent claims of diagnostic accuracy or reproducibility. The reported recruitment end date is 31 September 2022, an invalid calendar date.","pt-BR":"Autores reconhecem centro/investigador únicos e pré-seleção por palpação. Amostra pequena selecionada, respostas subjetivas, ausência de cegamento/padrão de referência, locais repetidos por participante e unidade ambígua impedem alegações de acurácia ou reprodutibilidade. O término do recrutamento foi informado como 31 de setembro de 2022, data inexistente."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-235","pmid":"35173837","doi":null,"pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35173837/","title":"Combined effectiveness of extracorporeal radial shockwave therapy and ultrasound-guided trigger point injection of lidocaine in upper trapezius myofascial pain syndrome.","year":2022,"report_type":"Single-blind prospective randomized trial, computer-generated allocation in sealed packets. Forty-five participants were randomized equally; 41 completed and were analyzed: 13 control, 13 shockwave, 15 combined. Masking of subjective treatment experiences was not feasible.","population":"Adults aged 20–65 with neck pain over three months, VAS at least 3 and one or two upper-trapezius trigger points on either/both sides; radiculopathy and structural cervical disease were excluded. Recruitment occurred at a Chinese rehabilitation department during 2020–2021.","comparator":"Standard care included heat and supervised exercise on alternate days for two weeks plus self-stretching/postural guidance. No injection-only or sham-injection arm was used.","findings":"At four weeks combined treatment had less pain than shockwaves alone (p<.05) and less stiffness (p<.01). Both active groups had lower pain and disability than control (p<.01), but no demonstrated combined-versus-shockwave disability advantage is reported. Surface EMG did not differ between or within groups (p>.05). Temperature differed from control at four weeks, not one week.","patient_relevance":"Adding injection may improve short-term pain and measured stiffness, but extra functional benefit and durability are unproven. Mild injection reactions were reported despite a conflicting no-harms statement.","condition":"Adding lidocaine injection to radial shockwaves","modality":"Power Shocker LGT-2500 radial device: 1,000 pulses per point, 5 Hz, 1.2 bar, once weekly for three sessions. Combined care added ultrasound-guided injection immediately before ESWT on the same day; the source describes 3 mL of 0.5% lidocaine and 0.5% normal saline, an unusual formulation description that requires clarification. Both active groups received home exercise/posture guidance.","level":"randomized_trial","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Adding lidocaine injection to radial shockwaves","pt-BR":"Associação de infiltração com lidocaína às ondas radiais"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Single-blind prospective randomized trial, computer-generated allocation in sealed packets. Forty-five participants were randomized equally; 41 completed and were analyzed: 13 control, 13 shockwave, 15 combined. Masking of subjective treatment experiences was not feasible.","pt-BR":"Ensaio prospectivo randomizado descrito como simples-cego, com alocação computadorizada em envelopes. Quarenta e cinco participantes foram randomizados igualmente; 41 completaram e foram analisados: 13 controles, 13 ondas, 15 combinados. Não era possível cegar experiências subjetivas dos tratamentos."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":45,"unit":"people","basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Adults aged 20–65 with neck pain over three months, VAS at least 3 and one or two upper-trapezius trigger points on either/both sides; radiculopathy and structural cervical disease were excluded. Recruitment occurred at a Chinese rehabilitation department during 2020–2021.","pt-BR":"Adultos de 20–65 anos, cervicalgia acima de três meses, EVA pelo menos 3 e um ou dois pontos-gatilho no trapézio em um/ambos os lados; radiculopatia e doença cervical estrutural foram excluídas. Recrutamento em serviço chinês de reabilitação em 2020–2021."},"source_population":"Adults aged 20–65 with neck pain over three months, VAS at least 3 and one or two upper-trapezius trigger points on either/both sides; radiculopathy and structural cervical disease were excluded. Recruitment occurred at a Chinese rehabilitation department during 2020–2021.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Small completer sample, four-week follow-up, no injection-only or sham arm and uncertain blinding limit causal attribution to the combination. Surrogate imaging changes do not establish long-term function. Some repeated panels appear inconsistent, especially EMG between-group versus within-group bar heights; exact values were not estimated from graphics. Safety statements conflict.","implication":"This concerns selected chronic upper-trapezius pain and a combined invasive/noninvasive package. It does not show whether lidocaine alone would perform similarly or whether additional pain relief persists beyond four weeks.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Provide numerical datasets, resolve duplicate-plot and injection-formulation inconsistencies, include injection-only and credible sham comparisons, analyze all randomized patients and follow clinical function and harms for several months."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Adding lidocaine injection to radial shockwaves","pt-BR":"Associação de infiltração com lidocaína às ondas radiais"},"summary":{"en":"Adding injection may improve short-term pain and measured stiffness, but extra functional benefit and durability are unproven. Mild injection reactions were reported despite a conflicting no-harms statement.","pt-BR":"Associar infiltração pode melhorar dor e rigidez medida em curto prazo, mas benefício funcional adicional e duração não foram comprovados. Houve reações leves após infiltração apesar da afirmação conflitante de ausência de danos."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Does adding ultrasound-guided lidocaine trigger-point injection to radial shockwaves improve upper-trapezius myofascial pain more than shockwaves or standard care?","pt-BR":"Associar infiltração com lidocaína guiada por ultrassom às ondas radiais melhora a dor miofascial do trapézio mais que ondas ou cuidado padrão?"},"population":{"en":"Adults aged 20–65 with neck pain over three months, VAS at least 3 and one or two upper-trapezius trigger points on either/both sides; radiculopathy and structural cervical disease were excluded. Recruitment occurred at a Chinese rehabilitation department during 2020–2021.","pt-BR":"Adultos de 20–65 anos, cervicalgia acima de três meses, EVA pelo menos 3 e um ou dois pontos-gatilho no trapézio em um/ambos os lados; radiculopatia e doença cervical estrutural foram excluídas. Recrutamento em serviço chinês de reabilitação em 2020–2021."},"comparison":{"en":"Standard care included heat and supervised exercise on alternate days for two weeks plus self-stretching/postural guidance. No injection-only or sham-injection arm was used.","pt-BR":"Cuidado padrão incluiu calor e exercícios supervisionados em dias alternados por duas semanas, além de alongamento/postura. Não houve grupo apenas infiltração nem infiltração simulada."},"note":{"en":"Small completer sample, four-week follow-up, no injection-only or sham arm and uncertain blinding limit causal attribution to the combination. Surrogate imaging changes do not establish long-term function. Some repeated panels appear inconsistent, especially EMG between-group versus within-group bar heights; exact values were not estimated from graphics. Safety statements conflict.","pt-BR":"Amostra pequena de completadores, quatro semanas, ausência de grupo apenas infiltração/simulado e cegamento incerto limitam atribuição causal à combinação. Mudanças de imagem não estabelecem função duradoura. Alguns painéis repetidos parecem inconsistentes, especialmente alturas de EMG entre e dentro dos grupos; valores exatos não foram estimados dos gráficos. Relatos de segurança conflitam."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-236","pmid":"35629410","doi":"10.3390/life12050743","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/35629410/","title":"Molecular Mechanisms Underlying the Pain-Relieving Effects of Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy: A Focus on Fascia Nociceptors.","year":2022,"report_type":"Narrative mechanistic review combining cell studies, animal experiments, human anatomical/experimental pain studies and selected clinical reports. It presents no systematic search, pooled efficacy estimate or new controlled experiment.","population":"Sources range from cultured fibroblasts/stem cells and rat, rabbit or horse nerve experiments to cadaver fascia and patients with plantar fasciitis, myofascial pain and other musculoskeletal disorders. These distinct evidence layers are not interchangeable populations.","comparator":"Experimental comparisons include treated versus untreated tissue and repeated versus single exposure. Clinical studies have differing controls; Table 2 often reports within-treatment changes without the comparator data needed for a causal estimate.","findings":"Animal work suggests selective loss of unmyelinated fibers, reduced SP/CGRP signals and altered peripheral sensitivity. Repeated exposure may delay reinnervation. However, rat studies found no spinal SP/CGRP or endogenous-opioid response after low-energy treatment. The authors explicitly conclude that clear evidence on the fascial nociceptive system is still lacking.","patient_relevance":"The article offers possible explanations for pain relief, mainly from laboratory and animal evidence. It does not prove that altering fascial nerves is the mechanism in patients or establish the size of clinical benefit.","condition":"Fascial nerves and possible shockwave analgesia mechanisms","modality":"Focused and radial devices differ in energy distribution and penetration. Experimental exposures varied by species, target and intensity. No single patient treatment schedule is established; the physical summaries in Table 1 should not substitute for a device-specific clinical protocol.","level":"mixed_translational","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Fascial nerves and possible shockwave analgesia mechanisms","pt-BR":"Nervos fasciais e possíveis mecanismos de analgesia por ondas"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical and preclinical reviews","pt-BR":"Revisões com estudos clínicos e pré-clínicos"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Narrative mechanistic review combining cell studies, animal experiments, human anatomical/experimental pain studies and selected clinical reports. It presents no systematic search, pooled efficacy estimate or new controlled experiment.","pt-BR":"Revisão mecanística narrativa que reúne células, animais, anatomia/dor experimental humana e relatos clínicos selecionados. Não apresenta busca sistemática, efeito combinado ou novo experimento controlado."},"disposition":"background_only","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Sources range from cultured fibroblasts/stem cells and rat, rabbit or horse nerve experiments to cadaver fascia and patients with plantar fasciitis, myofascial pain and other musculoskeletal disorders. These distinct evidence layers are not interchangeable populations.","pt-BR":"Fontes vão de fibroblastos/células-tronco e experimentos nervosos em ratos, coelhos/cavalos a fáscia cadavérica e pacientes com fascite plantar, dor miofascial e outras doenças. Essas camadas de evidência não são populações intercambiáveis."},"source_population":"Sources range from cultured fibroblasts/stem cells and rat, rabbit or horse nerve experiments to cadaver fascia and patients with plantar fasciitis, myofascial pain and other musculoskeletal disorders. These distinct evidence layers are not interchangeable populations.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Narrative selection, cross-species and cross-tissue extrapolation, variable doses and incomplete clinical comparator data limit inference. Demonstrating fascial innervation and demonstrating a shockwave nerve effect elsewhere are separate observations; combining them does not prove the proposed human MPS mechanism.","implication":"This is explanatory background for researchers and clinicians, not a treatment-effect estimate, dose recommendation or reason to replace surgery across diagnoses. A plausible mechanism cannot identify who will benefit.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Directly measure fascial nociceptor responses at clinically relevant exposures, distinguish reversible modulation from injury, link biological changes to blinded patient outcomes and assess durability and safety."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Fascial nerves and possible shockwave analgesia mechanisms","pt-BR":"Nervos fasciais e possíveis mecanismos de analgesia por ondas"},"summary":{"en":"The article offers possible explanations for pain relief, mainly from laboratory and animal evidence. It does not prove that altering fascial nerves is the mechanism in patients or establish the size of clinical benefit.","pt-BR":"O artigo oferece explicações possíveis para analgesia, sobretudo de laboratório e animais. Não prova que alterar nervos fasciais seja o mecanismo em pacientes nem estabelece o tamanho do benefício clínico."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Could changes in fascial sensory nerves and pain mediators explain ESWT analgesia?","pt-BR":"Mudanças nos nervos sensitivos da fáscia e mediadores da dor poderiam explicar a analgesia por ondas de choque?"},"population":{"en":"Sources range from cultured fibroblasts/stem cells and rat, rabbit or horse nerve experiments to cadaver fascia and patients with plantar fasciitis, myofascial pain and other musculoskeletal disorders. These distinct evidence layers are not interchangeable populations.","pt-BR":"Fontes vão de fibroblastos/células-tronco e experimentos nervosos em ratos, coelhos/cavalos a fáscia cadavérica e pacientes com fascite plantar, dor miofascial e outras doenças. Essas camadas de evidência não são populações intercambiáveis."},"comparison":{"en":"Experimental comparisons include treated versus untreated tissue and repeated versus single exposure. Clinical studies have differing controls; Table 2 often reports within-treatment changes without the comparator data needed for a causal estimate.","pt-BR":"Comparações experimentais incluem tecido tratado/não tratado e exposição repetida/única. Estudos clínicos têm controles diferentes; Tabela 2 frequentemente relata mudanças no grupo tratado sem dados comparativos necessários para efeito causal."},"note":{"en":"Narrative selection, cross-species and cross-tissue extrapolation, variable doses and incomplete clinical comparator data limit inference. Demonstrating fascial innervation and demonstrating a shockwave nerve effect elsewhere are separate observations; combining them does not prove the proposed human MPS mechanism.","pt-BR":"Seleção narrativa, extrapolação entre espécies/tecidos, doses variadas e dados clínicos comparativos incompletos limitam inferência. Demonstrar inervação fascial e efeito nervoso das ondas em outro local são observações separadas; reuni-las não prova o mecanismo proposto em síndrome miofascial humana."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-237","pmid":"29995794","doi":"10.1097/md.0000000000011432","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29995794/","title":"High- versus low-energy extracorporeal shock-wave therapy for myofascial pain syndrome of upper trapezius: A prospective randomized single blinded pilot study.","year":2018,"report_type":"Randomized pilot trial with random-number block allocation and opaque envelopes; patients and follow-up assessors were blinded. Thirty participants were analyzed. The flow describes 37 assessed, six declining after symptom relief and one follow-up loss.","population":"Upper-trapezius MPS diagnosed with tender taut-band nodule, referred pain and local twitch; pain onset within three months and numeric pain at least 4. Mean age was approximately 32; 27/30 participants were women and mean symptom duration about 8 weeks. This is not a chronic longstanding-pain cohort.","comparator":"Lower-energy arm used 0.068 mJ/mm² with the same pulses, sessions and local anesthesia. Rescue acetaminophen up to 2 g/day was allowed; other conservative treatments were prohibited until follow-up. No sham group was included.","findings":"At follow-up pain was 3.00 versus 3.07 (p=.838), showing no higher-energy advantage. NDI was 4.20 versus 6.47 (p=.008), and flexion 65.47° versus 55.93° (p=.029), favoring higher energy. Pressure threshold and other movement directions did not differ significantly. The conclusion wording claiming superior pain relief overstates the actual between-group pain test.","patient_relevance":"Higher energy improved two functional measures in this small study, but did not outperform lower energy for pain. The findings support further research rather than choosing the highest intensity automatically.","condition":"Higher versus lower shockwave energy for trapezius pain","modality":"Dornier AR2 focused treatment to the more painful trigger point: 1,500 pulses once weekly for two weeks, 0.210 mJ/mm² in the high-energy arm. All patients received 5 mL of 1% subcutaneous lidocaine before every session. Pulse frequency was not reported.","level":"randomized_trial","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Higher versus lower shockwave energy for trapezius pain","pt-BR":"Maior versus menor energia de ondas para dor no trapézio"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized pilot trial with random-number block allocation and opaque envelopes; patients and follow-up assessors were blinded. Thirty participants were analyzed. The flow describes 37 assessed, six declining after symptom relief and one follow-up loss.","pt-BR":"Ensaio piloto randomizado com blocos por números aleatórios e envelopes opacos; pacientes e avaliadores de seguimento cegos. Trinta participantes foram analisados. O fluxo descreve 37 avaliados, seis desistências após alívio e uma perda de seguimento."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":30,"unit":"people","basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Upper-trapezius MPS diagnosed with tender taut-band nodule, referred pain and local twitch; pain onset within three months and numeric pain at least 4. Mean age was approximately 32; 27/30 participants were women and mean symptom duration about 8 weeks. This is not a chronic longstanding-pain cohort.","pt-BR":"Síndrome miofascial do trapézio diagnosticada por nódulo em banda tensa, dor referida e resposta contrátil; início em até três meses e dor numérica pelo menos 4. Idade média aproximada 32 anos; 27/30 eram mulheres e duração média cerca de 8 semanas. Não é coorte de dor crônica de longa duração."},"source_population":"Upper-trapezius MPS diagnosed with tender taut-band nodule, referred pain and local twitch; pain onset within three months and numeric pain at least 4. Mean age was approximately 32; 27/30 participants were women and mean symptom duration about 8 weeks. This is not a chronic longstanding-pain cohort.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Only 15 analyzed per arm, predominantly young women, short follow-up and no sham limit generalization. NDI baseline differed numerically and comparisons used unadjusted endpoints. Multiple outcomes raise false-positive concerns. Equal lidocaine exposure may modify the shockwave response and cannot establish results without anesthesia.","implication":"Findings concern two short-course focused regimens under local anesthesia in relatively recent MPS. They do not establish that more energy is universally better or that observed disability differences are durable.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["A larger prespecified dose trial should adjust baseline outcomes, include a credible sham, report analgesic use and minor harms, and follow function for months with and without local anesthesia."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Higher versus lower shockwave energy for trapezius pain","pt-BR":"Maior versus menor energia de ondas para dor no trapézio"},"summary":{"en":"Higher energy improved two functional measures in this small study, but did not outperform lower energy for pain. The findings support further research rather than choosing the highest intensity automatically.","pt-BR":"Maior energia melhorou duas medidas funcionais neste estudo pequeno, mas não superou menor energia para dor. Os achados apoiam pesquisa adicional, não escolha automática da maior intensidade."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Does higher-energy focused ESWT improve upper-trapezius myofascial pain and function more than lower energy?","pt-BR":"Ondas focais de maior energia melhoram dor e função miofascial do trapézio mais que menor energia?"},"population":{"en":"Upper-trapezius MPS diagnosed with tender taut-band nodule, referred pain and local twitch; pain onset within three months and numeric pain at least 4. Mean age was approximately 32; 27/30 participants were women and mean symptom duration about 8 weeks. This is not a chronic longstanding-pain cohort.","pt-BR":"Síndrome miofascial do trapézio diagnosticada por nódulo em banda tensa, dor referida e resposta contrátil; início em até três meses e dor numérica pelo menos 4. Idade média aproximada 32 anos; 27/30 eram mulheres e duração média cerca de 8 semanas. Não é coorte de dor crônica de longa duração."},"comparison":{"en":"Lower-energy arm used 0.068 mJ/mm² with the same pulses, sessions and local anesthesia. Rescue acetaminophen up to 2 g/day was allowed; other conservative treatments were prohibited until follow-up. No sham group was included.","pt-BR":"Grupo de menor energia utilizou 0,068 mJ/mm² com os mesmos impulsos, sessões e anestesia. Paracetamol de resgate até 2 g/dia foi permitido; outras terapias foram proibidas até o seguimento. Não houve grupo simulado."},"note":{"en":"Only 15 analyzed per arm, predominantly young women, short follow-up and no sham limit generalization. NDI baseline differed numerically and comparisons used unadjusted endpoints. Multiple outcomes raise false-positive concerns. Equal lidocaine exposure may modify the shockwave response and cannot establish results without anesthesia.","pt-BR":"Apenas 15 analisados por grupo, predominância de mulheres jovens, seguimento curto e ausência de simulação limitam generalização. NDI inicial diferiu numericamente e comparação utilizou escores finais sem ajuste. Múltiplos desfechos elevam risco de falso positivo. Lidocaína comum pode modificar resposta e não estabelece resultados sem anestesia."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-238","pmid":"34840977","doi":"10.1155/2021/5937250","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/34840977/","title":"Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy for Treating Chronic Low Back Pain: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials.","year":2021,"report_type":"Systematic review and random-effects meta-analysis of 10 randomized trials, searched through 30 April 2021 across databases, registries and grey literature; protocol CRD 42021250013. Risk of bias, Jadad and GRADE assessments were used.","population":"The pain analysis included 455 participants, mostly young and middle-aged adults with pain longer than three months. Trials mixed nonspecific, myofascial, postpartum and disc-related presentations; mean ages ranged 29.2–55.8 years.","comparator":"Comparators included sham, medication, exercise, trigger-point injection, thermomagnetic therapy and manual trigger therapy. Add-on and standalone comparisons were pooled; they answer different questions.","findings":"Pain favored ESWT at one month: SMD−0.81 (95%CI−1.21 to−0.42; I²74%), low certainty. At three months pain was inconclusive:−0.39 (−0.97 to 0.19), very low certainty. Disability estimates favored ESWT at one month−1.45 (−2.68 to−0.22; very low certainty) and three months−0.69 (−1.08 to−0.31; moderate certainty). These standardized effects are not points on a 0–10 pain scale.","patient_relevance":"Average short-term pain and disability may improve, but the three-month pain comparison did not clearly favor shockwaves. The uncertainty and reporting errors prevent a promise of lasting relief.","condition":"Shockwaves for chronic low-back pain: short-term pooled results","modality":"Focused and radial devices, sometimes combined with exercise, medications or manual treatment, used heterogeneous schedules. Reported energy densities were generally 0.10–0.18 mJ/mm² and courses 3–12 sessions; not every study reported all parameters. These are descriptions, not an established optimal prescription.","level":"clinical_synthesis","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shockwaves for chronic low-back pain: short-term pooled results","pt-BR":"Ondas para lombalgia crônica: resultados combinados de curto prazo"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical evidence syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas de evidências clínicas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Systematic review and random-effects meta-analysis of 10 randomized trials, searched through 30 April 2021 across databases, registries and grey literature; protocol CRD 42021250013. Risk of bias, Jadad and GRADE assessments were used.","pt-BR":"Revisão sistemática e metanálise de efeitos aleatórios de 10 ensaios randomizados, busca até 30 abril 2021 em bases, registros e literatura cinzenta; protocolo CRD 42021250013. Avaliações de risco de viés, Jadad e GRADE foram usadas."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"The pain analysis included 455 participants, mostly young and middle-aged adults with pain longer than three months. Trials mixed nonspecific, myofascial, postpartum and disc-related presentations; mean ages ranged 29.2–55.8 years.","pt-BR":"A análise de dor incluiu 455 participantes, sobretudo adultos jovens e de meia-idade com dor superior a três meses. Ensaios misturaram quadros inespecíficos, miofasciais, pós-parto e discais; idades médias 29,2–55,8 anos."},"source_population":"The pain analysis included 455 participants, mostly young and middle-aged adults with pain longer than three months. Trials mixed nonspecific, myofascial, postpartum and disc-related presentations; mean ages ranged 29.2–55.8 years.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Small heterogeneous trials, limited blinding and short observation reduce confidence. Forest plots visibly contain sign inconsistencies: Walewicz pain one-month and ODI one-month estimates, and Taheri pain three-month estimate, conflict with their plotted direction; Figure 4 omits the minus before the lower pooled ODI confidence limit. Pooled values here follow Results text and plots, without silently correcting individual trials.","implication":"The evidence suggests possible short-term benefit as part of care but cannot select a device, dose or subgroup. Within-group clinically important changes do not establish a clinically important incremental advantage over a comparator.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Future blinded trials should prespecify a primary outcome, verify raw extraction and effect direction, standardize comparators, measure harms and work participation, and extend follow-up beyond three months."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves for chronic low-back pain: short-term pooled results","pt-BR":"Ondas para lombalgia crônica: resultados combinados de curto prazo"},"summary":{"en":"Average short-term pain and disability may improve, but the three-month pain comparison did not clearly favor shockwaves. The uncertainty and reporting errors prevent a promise of lasting relief.","pt-BR":"Dor e incapacidade médias podem melhorar em curto prazo, mas dor em três meses não favoreceu claramente ondas. Incerteza e erros de relato impedem prometer alívio duradouro."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Does ESWT reduce chronic low-back pain and disability compared with other care?","pt-BR":"Ondas extracorpóreas reduzem dor lombar crônica e incapacidade comparadas a outros cuidados?"},"population":{"en":"The pain analysis included 455 participants, mostly young and middle-aged adults with pain longer than three months. Trials mixed nonspecific, myofascial, postpartum and disc-related presentations; mean ages ranged 29.2–55.8 years.","pt-BR":"A análise de dor incluiu 455 participantes, sobretudo adultos jovens e de meia-idade com dor superior a três meses. Ensaios misturaram quadros inespecíficos, miofasciais, pós-parto e discais; idades médias 29,2–55,8 anos."},"comparison":{"en":"Comparators included sham, medication, exercise, trigger-point injection, thermomagnetic therapy and manual trigger therapy. Add-on and standalone comparisons were pooled; they answer different questions.","pt-BR":"Controles incluíram simulação, medicamentos, exercício, infiltração de pontos, terapia termomagnética e terapia manual. Comparações isoladas e de tratamento adicional foram combinadas; respondem perguntas diferentes."},"note":{"en":"Small heterogeneous trials, limited blinding and short observation reduce confidence. Forest plots visibly contain sign inconsistencies: Walewicz pain one-month and ODI one-month estimates, and Taheri pain three-month estimate, conflict with their plotted direction; Figure 4 omits the minus before the lower pooled ODI confidence limit. Pooled values here follow Results text and plots, without silently correcting individual trials.","pt-BR":"Ensaios pequenos heterogêneos, cegamento limitado e observação curta reduzem confiança. Gráficos apresentam inconsistências visíveis de sinal: estimativas de dor e ODI de Walewicz em um mês e dor de Taheri em três meses divergem da direção desenhada; Figura 4 omite menos no limite inferior do IC combinado de ODI. Valores combinados aqui seguem texto de Resultados e gráficos, sem corrigir silenciosamente estudos individuais."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-239","pmid":"31806944","doi":"10.2147/cia.s224001","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31806944/","title":"The Effectiveness Of Radial Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy In Patients With Chronic Low Back Pain: A Prospective, Randomized, Single-Blinded Pilot Study.","year":2019,"report_type":"Prospective randomized patient-blinded pilot trial in Poland; computer-generated allocation and coded statistical analysis. Forty of 52 screened patients entered, 20 per group; control follow-up declined to 19 at one month and 17 at three months.","population":"Adults with MRI-confirmed L5–S1 discopathy, pain over three months and pseudoradicular symptoms, without prior spinal surgery. Mean ages 51.1 and 55.8 years; average symptom duration 9.8 and 9.0 years. Radicular syndrome and neurological deficits were excluded.","comparator":"Sham used an energy-absorbing polyethylene cap with matching sound. Both groups received 45-minute stabilization sessions daily five days weekly. No pain-reducing treatment was allowed during follow-up; this tests an addition to an intensive exercise program.","findings":"Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.","patient_relevance":"In this small study shockwaves did not give faster relief; early pain favored sham. Later pain and disability favored shockwaves plus exercise, but larger studies are needed before promising lasting benefit.","condition":"Radial shockwaves and stabilization for disc-related low-back pain","modality":"Pro-Shock Waves pneumatic device: 2,000 pulses, 2.5 bar, 5 Hz, seven minutes, twice weekly for five weeks, ten sessions, moved over the painful lumbosacral area. The paper equates this with 0.1 mJ/mm²; this device-specific statement is not a universal pressure-energy conversion.","level":"randomized_trial","category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Radial shockwaves and stabilization for disc-related low-back pain","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais e estabilização para lombalgia discal"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Prospective randomized patient-blinded pilot trial in Poland; computer-generated allocation and coded statistical analysis. Forty of 52 screened patients entered, 20 per group; control follow-up declined to 19 at one month and 17 at three months.","pt-BR":"Ensaio piloto prospectivo randomizado com pacientes cegos na Polônia; alocação computadorizada e análise codificada. Quarenta de 52 avaliados entraram, 20 por grupo; controle caiu para 19 em um mês e 17 em três meses."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":40,"unit":"people","basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Adults with MRI-confirmed L5–S1 discopathy, pain over three months and pseudoradicular symptoms, without prior spinal surgery. Mean ages 51.1 and 55.8 years; average symptom duration 9.8 and 9.0 years. Radicular syndrome and neurological deficits were excluded.","pt-BR":"Adultos com discopatia L5–S1 confirmada por ressonância, dor superior a três meses e sintomas pseudorradiculares, sem cirurgia prévia. Idades médias 51,1 e 55,8 anos; duração média 9,8 e 9,0 anos. Síndrome radicular e déficit neurológico excluídos."},"source_population":"Adults with MRI-confirmed L5–S1 discopathy, pain over three months and pseudoradicular symptoms, without prior spinal surgery. Mean ages 51.1 and 55.8 years; average symptom duration 9.8 and 9.0 years. Radicular syndrome and neurological deficits were excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Small single-center sample, participant-only blinding, unequal follow-up losses, multiple tests and no clearly reported imputation limit confidence. The source uses unusual/inconsistent Modic grading, including grade 4, and should not define diagnostic criteria. Three-month follow-up is insufficient to establish durable long-term remission.","implication":"Results apply to selected chronic L5–S1 discopathy with concurrent stabilization training; they do not establish efficacy for sciatica, all nonspecific back pain, or radial treatment alone.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["A larger multicenter blinded trial should account for all randomized patients, check sham credibility, prespecify clinically meaningful effects and follow disability, work and harms beyond six to twelve months."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Radial shockwaves and stabilization for disc-related low-back pain","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais e estabilização para lombalgia discal"},"summary":{"en":"In this small study shockwaves did not give faster relief; early pain favored sham. Later pain and disability favored shockwaves plus exercise, but larger studies are needed before promising lasting benefit.","pt-BR":"Neste estudo pequeno ondas não aliviaram mais rápido; dor inicial favoreceu simulação. Depois dor e incapacidade favoreceram ondas com exercício, mas estudos maiores são necessários antes de prometer benefício duradouro."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Does adding radial shockwaves to stabilization training improve chronic disc-related low-back pain beyond sham treatment?","pt-BR":"Adicionar ondas radiais ao treino de estabilização melhora lombalgia discal crônica além de aplicação simulada?"},"population":{"en":"Adults with MRI-confirmed L5–S1 discopathy, pain over three months and pseudoradicular symptoms, without prior spinal surgery. Mean ages 51.1 and 55.8 years; average symptom duration 9.8 and 9.0 years. Radicular syndrome and neurological deficits were excluded.","pt-BR":"Adultos com discopatia L5–S1 confirmada por ressonância, dor superior a três meses e sintomas pseudorradiculares, sem cirurgia prévia. Idades médias 51,1 e 55,8 anos; duração média 9,8 e 9,0 anos. Síndrome radicular e déficit neurológico excluídos."},"comparison":{"en":"Sham used an energy-absorbing polyethylene cap with matching sound. Both groups received 45-minute stabilization sessions daily five days weekly. No pain-reducing treatment was allowed during follow-up; this tests an addition to an intensive exercise program.","pt-BR":"Simulação usou tampa de polietileno absorvedora de energia com som semelhante. Ambos receberam estabilização 45 minutos por dia, cinco dias semanais. Tratamento analgésico não permitido no seguimento; testa acréscimo a programa intensivo de exercícios."},"note":{"en":"Small single-center sample, participant-only blinding, unequal follow-up losses, multiple tests and no clearly reported imputation limit confidence. The source uses unusual/inconsistent Modic grading, including grade 4, and should not define diagnostic criteria. Three-month follow-up is insufficient to establish durable long-term remission.","pt-BR":"Amostra pequena unicêntrica, cegamento apenas de pacientes, perdas desiguais, testes múltiplos e ausência de imputação claramente relatada limitam confiança. A fonte usa classificação Modic incomum/inconsistente, inclusive grau 4, e não deve definir critérios diagnósticos. Três meses não estabelecem remissão duradoura."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-240","pmid":"22642362","doi":"10.1111/j.1524-475x.2012.00796.x","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22642362/","title":"Extracorporeal shock wave therapy (ESWT) for wound healing: technology, mechanisms, and clinical efficacy.","year":2012,"report_type":"Narrative review of shockwave technology, experimental mechanisms and selected clinical studies. No reproducible systematic search, pooled analysis or formal risk-of-bias assessment is presented.","population":"Evidence spans cell cultures, rodent ischemic flaps and diabetic wounds, plus human burns, donor sites, pressure ulcers, venous/arterial ulcers and diabetic foot ulcers. These populations cannot be treated as one clinical cohort.","comparator":"Some studies had no control; others used standard wound care, sham crossover or hyperbaric oxygen. Debridement, vascular care, dressings and offloading remain core treatment; the review does not establish replacement of these measures.","findings":"An uncontrolled 208-patient series reported 156 complete healings(75%), but venous-ulcer healing was 36%. Selected comparisons favored treatment: a 32-wound series reported 50% healing versus 1/10 control ulcers; diabetic-ulcer comparison reported 31% versus 22% with hyperbaric oxygen. These are secondary summaries, not pooled causal estimates. The small pressure-ulcer crossover study had nine ulcers and possible carryover.","patient_relevance":"Early studies suggested that shockwaves might support healing, but this review itself calls the clinical evidence weak. It provides research rationale rather than a reliable probability of benefit for an individual wound.","condition":"Shockwaves for wound healing: mechanisms and early clinical evidence","modality":"Low-energy defocused/soft-focused applications cover superficial wound areas. Table 1 reports heterogeneous regimens, approximately 0.03–0.15 mJ/mm², often 100 pulses/cm², using electrohydraulic or electromagnetic systems. Device geometry, total energy, frequency and session intervals are incompletely reported.","level":"mixed_translational","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shockwaves for wound healing: mechanisms and early clinical evidence","pt-BR":"Ondas para cicatrização: mecanismos e evidência clínica inicial"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical and preclinical reviews","pt-BR":"Revisões com estudos clínicos e pré-clínicos"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Narrative review of shockwave technology, experimental mechanisms and selected clinical studies. No reproducible systematic search, pooled analysis or formal risk-of-bias assessment is presented.","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa de tecnologia, mecanismos experimentais e estudos clínicos selecionados. Não apresenta busca sistemática reproduzível, análise combinada ou avaliação formal de viés."},"disposition":"background_only","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Evidence spans cell cultures, rodent ischemic flaps and diabetic wounds, plus human burns, donor sites, pressure ulcers, venous/arterial ulcers and diabetic foot ulcers. These populations cannot be treated as one clinical cohort.","pt-BR":"Evidência abrange culturas, retalhos isquêmicos e feridas diabéticas em roedores, além de queimaduras, áreas doadoras, úlceras de pressão, venosas/arteriais e pé diabético humanos. Não formam uma única coorte clínica."},"source_population":"Evidence spans cell cultures, rodent ischemic flaps and diabetic wounds, plus human burns, donor sites, pressure ulcers, venous/arterial ulcers and diabetic foot ulcers. These populations cannot be treated as one clinical cohort.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Selection bias, small uncontrolled samples, varied wound etiologies and protocols limit confidence. The review labels the 31% versus 22% healing comparison significant without enough detail to audit that claim. Its own mouse systemic-effect experiment was not statistically significant. Ongoing 430-patient interim experience and illustrative supplementary cases are not completed comparative evidence.","implication":"This is a historical rationale and early-evidence review. Its regulatory and practice descriptions reflect 2012, not current status. Neither animal angiogenesis nor selected healing percentages establish effectiveness for a particular patient today.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Needed trials should stratify ulcer etiology, preserve standard wound care, blind healing assessment, report time to sustained closure, recurrence, infection, amputation and costs, and specify reproducible acoustic dosing."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves for wound healing: mechanisms and early clinical evidence","pt-BR":"Ondas para cicatrização: mecanismos e evidência clínica inicial"},"summary":{"en":"Early studies suggested that shockwaves might support healing, but this review itself calls the clinical evidence weak. It provides research rationale rather than a reliable probability of benefit for an individual wound.","pt-BR":"Estudos iniciais sugeriram apoio à cicatrização, mas a própria revisão chama evidência clínica fraca. Fornece fundamento de pesquisa, não probabilidade confiável de benefício para ferida individual."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"What biological rationale and early clinical evidence supported shockwaves for wound healing in 2012?","pt-BR":"Qual fundamento biológico e evidência clínica inicial apoiavam ondas para cicatrização em 2012?"},"population":{"en":"Evidence spans cell cultures, rodent ischemic flaps and diabetic wounds, plus human burns, donor sites, pressure ulcers, venous/arterial ulcers and diabetic foot ulcers. These populations cannot be treated as one clinical cohort.","pt-BR":"Evidência abrange culturas, retalhos isquêmicos e feridas diabéticas em roedores, além de queimaduras, áreas doadoras, úlceras de pressão, venosas/arteriais e pé diabético humanos. Não formam uma única coorte clínica."},"comparison":{"en":"Some studies had no control; others used standard wound care, sham crossover or hyperbaric oxygen. Debridement, vascular care, dressings and offloading remain core treatment; the review does not establish replacement of these measures.","pt-BR":"Alguns estudos não tiveram controle; outros usaram cuidado padrão, simulação cruzada ou oxigênio hiperbárico. Desbridamento, cuidado vascular, curativos e descarga permanecem essenciais; a revisão não estabelece substituição."},"note":{"en":"Selection bias, small uncontrolled samples, varied wound etiologies and protocols limit confidence. The review labels the 31% versus 22% healing comparison significant without enough detail to audit that claim. Its own mouse systemic-effect experiment was not statistically significant. Ongoing 430-patient interim experience and illustrative supplementary cases are not completed comparative evidence.","pt-BR":"Viés de seleção, amostras pequenas sem controle, etiologias e protocolos variados limitam confiança. Revisão chama 31% versus 22% significativo sem detalhes suficientes para conferir. Seu experimento de efeito sistêmico em camundongos não foi significativo. Experiência interina de 430 pacientes e casos ilustrativos suplementares não são evidência comparativa concluída."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-241","pmid":"17720194","doi":"10.1016/j.jss.2006.12.552","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17720194/","title":"Extracorporeal shock wave enhanced extended skin flap tissue survival via increase of topical blood perfusion and associated with suppression of tissue pro-inflammation.","year":2007,"report_type":"Controlled laboratory animal experiment with 36 male Sprague Dawley rats divided equally among three groups. Random allocation and blinded outcome assessment are not clearly described. No human patients were enrolled.","population":"Rats weighing 250–300 g underwent a modified McFarlane 10×3 cm caudally based dorsal random-pattern flap, elevated and sutured back. This acute surgical ischemia model differs from chronic human ulcers and postoperative rescue situations.","comparator":"Control received surgery without shockwaves; the third group received the same 500-pulse treatment immediately and again the next day. Each group contained 12 animals. Repeated treatment doubled exposure, rather than simply reproducing a human clinical schedule.","findings":"One treatment reduced necrotic area to 13±2.6% versus 42.2±5.7% control (p=.003). Two treatments yielded 28.8±6.2%, not significantly different from control. Day 3 perfusion increased with one treatment, 0.40±0.04 versus 0.21±0.03 (p=.005), while two treatments 0.21±0.02 did not (p=.45). Day 1 perfusion did not differ.","patient_relevance":"One treatment helped a rat skin flap survive, while repeating it did not improve the untreated comparison. This is a research finding and cannot predict whether shockwaves will save a human flap.","condition":"Shockwaves and skin-flap survival in rats","modality":"Ossatron treatment under anesthesia delivered 500 impulses at 14 kV, reported equivalent to 0.15 mJ/mm², over five ischemic distal areas immediately after surgery; approximately ten minutes with ultrasound gel.","level":"background_mechanism","category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shockwaves and skin-flap survival in rats","pt-BR":"Ondas e sobrevivência de retalhos cutâneos em ratos"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Narrative, contextual and guideline reviews","pt-BR":"Revisões narrativas, contextuais e diretrizes"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Controlled laboratory animal experiment with 36 male Sprague Dawley rats divided equally among three groups. Random allocation and blinded outcome assessment are not clearly described. No human patients were enrolled.","pt-BR":"Experimento animal controlado com 36 ratos machos Sprague Dawley divididos igualmente em três grupos. Alocação aleatória e avaliação cega não são claramente descritas. Nenhum paciente humano participou."},"disposition":"background_only","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Rats weighing 250–300 g underwent a modified McFarlane 10×3 cm caudally based dorsal random-pattern flap, elevated and sutured back. This acute surgical ischemia model differs from chronic human ulcers and postoperative rescue situations.","pt-BR":"Ratos de 250–300 g receberam retalho dorsal caudal aleatório McFarlane modificado 10×3 cm, elevado e ressuturado. Modelo de isquemia cirúrgica aguda difere de úlceras humanas crônicas e resgate pós-operatório."},"source_population":"Rats weighing 250–300 g underwent a modified McFarlane 10×3 cm caudally based dorsal random-pattern flap, elevated and sutured back. This acute surgical ischemia model differs from chronic human ulcers and postoperative rescue situations.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Only 12 animals per arm, male-only sampling, short seven-day endpoint and unclear blinding limit inference. Biomarker associations cannot determine whether reduced inflammation causes or follows reduced necrosis; authors acknowledge this. An optimal human dose cannot be derived from two animal schedules.","implication":"This provides preclinical biological plausibility for flap preservation, not evidence of clinical healing or a treatment recommendation. Dose, anatomical scale, anesthesia and acute ischemia differ materially from patient care.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Replicate with randomization, blinded assessment, both sexes and dose-response controls; test causal pathways and longer tissue function before independently monitored human trials."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves and skin-flap survival in rats","pt-BR":"Ondas e sobrevivência de retalhos cutâneos em ratos"},"summary":{"en":"One treatment helped a rat skin flap survive, while repeating it did not improve the untreated comparison. This is a research finding and cannot predict whether shockwaves will save a human flap.","pt-BR":"Uma aplicação ajudou sobrevivência de retalho em ratos, enquanto repetição não melhorou comparação com ausência de tratamento. É achado de pesquisa e não prevê preservação de retalho humano."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Can shockwaves rescue an experimentally ischemic skin flap, and does repeating treatment improve the response?","pt-BR":"Ondas podem preservar retalho cutâneo experimentalmente isquêmico e repetir aplicação melhora a resposta?"},"population":{"en":"Rats weighing 250–300 g underwent a modified McFarlane 10×3 cm caudally based dorsal random-pattern flap, elevated and sutured back. This acute surgical ischemia model differs from chronic human ulcers and postoperative rescue situations.","pt-BR":"Ratos de 250–300 g receberam retalho dorsal caudal aleatório McFarlane modificado 10×3 cm, elevado e ressuturado. Modelo de isquemia cirúrgica aguda difere de úlceras humanas crônicas e resgate pós-operatório."},"comparison":{"en":"Control received surgery without shockwaves; the third group received the same 500-pulse treatment immediately and again the next day. Each group contained 12 animals. Repeated treatment doubled exposure, rather than simply reproducing a human clinical schedule.","pt-BR":"Controle recebeu cirurgia sem ondas; terceiro grupo recebeu mesmos 500 impulsos imediatamente e no dia seguinte. Cada grupo tinha 12 animais. Repetição dobrou exposição, não reproduziu simplesmente esquema clínico humano."},"note":{"en":"Only 12 animals per arm, male-only sampling, short seven-day endpoint and unclear blinding limit inference. Biomarker associations cannot determine whether reduced inflammation causes or follows reduced necrosis; authors acknowledge this. An optimal human dose cannot be derived from two animal schedules.","pt-BR":"Apenas 12 animais por grupo, machos, avaliação de sete dias e cegamento incerto limitam inferência. Associações não determinam se menor inflamação causa ou sucede menor necrose; autores reconhecem. Dose humana ótima não deriva de dois esquemas animais."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-242","pmid":"15046427","doi":"10.1302/0301-620x.86b2.14253","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15046427/","title":"Extracorporeal shock-wave therapy in the management of chronic soft-tissue conditions.","year":2004,"report_type":"Narrative management review with selected randomized trials organized by indication. It is not a new trial or a systematic meta-analysis, and no reproducible search or formal certainty grading is supplied.","population":"Clinical studies addressed calcific and noncalcific rotator-cuff disease, lateral epicondylitis and plantar fasciitis, with differing chronicity and prior treatment. Tissue-mechanism evidence largely came from animals and lithotripsy research.","comparator":"Comparators included no treatment and several sham techniques: blocking foil, uncoupling heads, low-energy exposure or absorbing materials. Differences in sensation and anesthesia could compromise blinding and comparability.","findings":"Calcific shoulder trial (n = 80) reported higher three-month Constant scores with high energy: 63.7 or 68.5 versus 47.8 control, while low energy 51.6 did not show clear benefit. Noncalcific shoulder trials (n = 40, n = 74) found no significant advantage. A 270-person elbow trial reported success 25.8% versus 25.4%, difference 0.4 percentage points (95% CI −10.5 to 11.3). Heel trials were mixed; one 160-person trial had 12-week pain improvement 26.3 versus 25.7 (p=.99), despite positive results in other regimens.","patient_relevance":"The historical evidence was condition-specific and conflicting: some calcific-shoulder and heel regimens helped, while several well-controlled shoulder, elbow and heel trials did not show an added benefit.","condition":"Shockwaves for chronic soft-tissue disorders: a 2004 evidence review","modality":"Focused electrohydraulic, electromagnetic and piezoelectric generators differed in waveform, targeting and energy. Protocols varied from single high-energy exposure to repeated lower-energy sessions, with inconsistent local anesthesia. High/low energy labels lacked a shared definition.","level":"clinical_synthesis","category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shockwaves for chronic soft-tissue disorders: a 2004 evidence review","pt-BR":"Ondas para condições crônicas de partes moles: revisão de 2004"},"levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic clinical evidence syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas de evidências clínicas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Narrative management review with selected randomized trials organized by indication. It is not a new trial or a systematic meta-analysis, and no reproducible search or formal certainty grading is supplied.","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa de manejo com ensaios selecionados por indicação. Não é novo ensaio nem metanálise sistemática e não fornece busca reproduzível ou graduação formal de certeza."},"disposition":"relevant_support","depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Full source; study participants only, never animal or review study counts","description":{"en":"Clinical studies addressed calcific and noncalcific rotator-cuff disease, lateral epicondylitis and plantar fasciitis, with differing chronicity and prior treatment. Tissue-mechanism evidence largely came from animals and lithotripsy research.","pt-BR":"Estudos clínicos abordaram doença calcária/não calcária do manguito, epicondilite lateral e fascite plantar, com diferentes cronicidades e tratamentos prévios. Mecanismos vieram sobretudo de animais e litotripsia."},"source_population":"Clinical studies addressed calcific and noncalcific rotator-cuff disease, lateral epicondylitis and plantar fasciitis, with differing chronicity and prior treatment. Tissue-mechanism evidence largely came from animals and lithotripsy research.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_linked","source_note":"Standalone source; overlap with other trials or reviews has not been resolved."},"critique":[{"category":"Study limitations","observation":"Trial selection and heterogeneous protocols limit synthesis; the author also discusses their own trials. Tables contain reference-number inconsistencies, and the plantar trial is described as 160 participants but allocations 81+85 total 166. Table VI has a malformed subjective-improvement confidence interval. Such discrepancies require primary-source checking before quantitative reuse.","implication":"This is a 2004 evidence snapshot. Historical regulatory statements and the then-current preference for certain regimens do not establish current approvals or recommendations. Different diagnoses and devices should not be merged into a universal efficacy claim.","verification":"Complete local PDF read; independent source review pending.","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"next":["Compare reproducible device-specific protocols with credible sham, consistent anesthesia, prespecified patient-centered outcomes, intention-to-treat analysis and follow-up long enough to separate natural history from treatment effect."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves for chronic soft-tissue disorders: a 2004 evidence review","pt-BR":"Ondas para condições crônicas de partes moles: revisão de 2004"},"summary":{"en":"The historical evidence was condition-specific and conflicting: some calcific-shoulder and heel regimens helped, while several well-controlled shoulder, elbow and heel trials did not show an added benefit.","pt-BR":"Evidência histórica foi específica e conflitante: alguns esquemas para ombro calcário/calcanhar ajudaram, enquanto vários ensaios controlados de ombro, cotovelo e calcanhar não mostraram benefício adicional."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"What did randomized studies and technical research show about shockwaves for chronic soft-tissue disorders in 2004?","pt-BR":"O que estudos randomizados e pesquisa técnica mostravam sobre ondas para condições crônicas de partes moles em 2004?"},"population":{"en":"Clinical studies addressed calcific and noncalcific rotator-cuff disease, lateral epicondylitis and plantar fasciitis, with differing chronicity and prior treatment. Tissue-mechanism evidence largely came from animals and lithotripsy research.","pt-BR":"Estudos clínicos abordaram doença calcária/não calcária do manguito, epicondilite lateral e fascite plantar, com diferentes cronicidades e tratamentos prévios. Mecanismos vieram sobretudo de animais e litotripsia."},"comparison":{"en":"Comparators included no treatment and several sham techniques: blocking foil, uncoupling heads, low-energy exposure or absorbing materials. Differences in sensation and anesthesia could compromise blinding and comparability.","pt-BR":"Controles incluíram ausência de tratamento e várias simulações: barreira, desacoplamento, baixa energia ou materiais absorvedores. Diferenças sensoriais e de anestesia poderiam comprometer cegamento e comparabilidade."},"note":{"en":"Trial selection and heterogeneous protocols limit synthesis; the author also discusses their own trials. Tables contain reference-number inconsistencies, and the plantar trial is described as 160 participants but allocations 81+85 total 166. Table VI has a malformed subjective-improvement confidence interval. Such discrepancies require primary-source checking before quantitative reuse.","pt-BR":"Seleção e heterogeneidade limitam síntese; autora também discute ensaios próprios. Tabelas têm inconsistências de referências; ensaio plantar descrito com 160 participantes apresenta 81+85, total 166. Tabela VI tem IC de melhora subjetiva malformado. Discrepâncias exigem consulta primária antes de reutilização quantitativa."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-243","pmid":"19219314","doi":"10.1590/s1807-59322009000200006","title":"Comparison of radial shockwaves and conventional physiotherapy for treating plantar fasciitis","year":2009,"condition":["Plantar fasciitis"],"category":"achilles_heel","categoryLabel":{"en":"Achilles tendon and heel","pt-BR":"Tendão de Aquiles e calcanhar"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Plantar fasciitis","pt-BR":"Fasciíte plantar"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"32 adults, symptoms ≥3 months and fascia >4 mm; 81% women, 56% bilateral disease.","sample":{"n":32,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"32 adults, symptoms ≥3 months and fascia >4 mm; 81% women, 56% bilateral disease.","pt-BR":"32 adultos, sintomas ≥3 meses e fáscia >4 mm; 81% mulheres, 56% com acometimento bilateral."},"source_population":"32 adults, symptoms ≥3 months and fascia >4 mm; 81% women, 56% bilateral disease.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Three weekly radial treatments plus home stretching."],"comparator":"Ten ultrasound and supervised exercise sessions, twice weekly, plus the same home stretching.","findings":"Pain frequency, duration, morning, walking and standing pain improved within both groups; no between-group advantage was demonstrated at three months. Analgesic cessation was 7/13 versus 10/13 (p=.411).","patient_relevance":"Both approaches helped, and this small trial did not show that radial treatment was better after three months.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Small unblinded comparison with unequal therapist contact. Algometry uses 26 versus 24 feet, not participants, without a stated bilateral clustering adjustment. Abstract faster-relief wording does not establish superiority. Table 8 analgesic baseline totals differ from introductory summary.","implication":"Applies to chronic plantar heel pain treated alongside stretching; the negative comparison does not prove equivalence.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19219314/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Plantar fasciitis","pt-BR":"Fasciíte plantar"},"summary":{"en":"Both approaches helped, and this small trial did not show that radial treatment was better after three months.","pt-BR":"Ambas as abordagens ajudaram; este pequeno ensaio não demonstrou superioridade das ondas radiais após três meses."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"32 adults, symptoms ≥3 months and fascia >4 mm; 81% women, 56% bilateral disease.","pt-BR":"32 adultos, sintomas ≥3 meses e fáscia >4 mm; 81% mulheres, 56% com acometimento bilateral."},"comparison":{"en":"Ten ultrasound and supervised exercise sessions, twice weekly, plus the same home stretching.","pt-BR":"Dez sessões de ultrassom e exercícios supervisionados, duas por semana, com o mesmo alongamento domiciliar."},"note":{"en":"Small unblinded comparison with unequal therapist contact. Algometry uses 26 versus 24 feet, not participants, without a stated bilateral clustering adjustment. Abstract faster-relief wording does not establish superiority. Table 8 analgesic baseline totals differ from introductory summary.","pt-BR":"Comparação pequena, sem cegamento descrito e com contato terapêutico desigual. Algometria usa 26 versus 24 pés, não pessoas, sem ajuste bilateral descrito. A expressão de alívio mais rápido no resumo não comprova superioridade. Totais basais de analgésicos da Tabela 8 diferem do resumo inicial."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-244","pmid":"20071091","doi":"10.1016/j.burns.2009.11.012","title":"Extracorporeal shock waves, a new non-surgical method to treat severe burns","year":2010,"condition":["Deep burns"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Deep burns","pt-BR":"Queimaduras profundas"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Clinical cohorts without a treatment control","pt-BR":"Coortes clínicas sem grupo de controle do tratamento"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"report_type":"uncontrolled clinical","population":"15 adults with deep partial/full-thickness burns under 5% body surface area; one lost to follow-up.","sample":{"n":15,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"15 adults with deep partial/full-thickness burns under 5% body surface area; one lost to follow-up.","pt-BR":"15 adultos com queimaduras profundas em menos de 5% da superfície corporal; uma perda de seguimento."},"source_population":"15 adults with deep partial/full-thickness burns under 5% body surface area; one lost to follow-up.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Unfocused low-energy ESWT on days 3 and 5 after injury with Mepilex Ag dressings."],"comparator":"No concurrent comparison; perfusion before the first and second applications was assessed by laser Doppler.","findings":"Table 2 records 12 spontaneous healings among 14 followed patients, including one at day 29; two underwent grafting on day 21. Perfusion color changes were descriptive, not a controlled treatment effect.","patient_relevance":"Some burns healed without surgery, but without a control group we cannot know how much shockwaves contributed.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"No controls and only 15 participants. Abstract 80%, 15%, 5% figures do not map cleanly onto Table 2 and one loss. Table 2 includes a day 29 healing, so the statement of healing before 3 weeks is not universal. Authors disclose no financial interests.","implication":"Exploratory experience in small-area burns cannot establish avoidance of surgery or cost effectiveness.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20071091/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Deep burns","pt-BR":"Queimaduras profundas"},"summary":{"en":"Some burns healed without surgery, but without a control group we cannot know how much shockwaves contributed.","pt-BR":"Algumas queimaduras cicatrizaram sem cirurgia, mas sem controle não sabemos quanto as ondas contribuíram."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"15 adults with deep partial/full-thickness burns under 5% body surface area; one lost to follow-up.","pt-BR":"15 adultos com queimaduras profundas em menos de 5% da superfície corporal; uma perda de seguimento."},"comparison":{"en":"No concurrent comparison; perfusion before the first and second applications was assessed by laser Doppler.","pt-BR":"Sem controle simultâneo; perfusão antes da primeira e segunda aplicações avaliada por Doppler laser."},"note":{"en":"No controls and only 15 participants. Abstract 80%, 15%, 5% figures do not map cleanly onto Table 2 and one loss. Table 2 includes a day 29 healing, so the statement of healing before 3 weeks is not universal. Authors disclose no financial interests.","pt-BR":"Sem controles e apenas 15 participantes. Percentuais de 80%, 15%, 5% do resumo não correspondem claramente à Tabela 2 e à perda. Há cicatrização no dia 29, portanto o prazo inferior a três semanas não é universal. Autores declaram ausência de interesses financeiros."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-245","pmid":"19022007","doi":"10.1016/j.athoracsur.2008.07.117","title":"Prophylactic Low-Energy Shock Wave Therapy Improves Wound Healing After Vein Harvesting for Coronary Artery Bypass Graft Surgery: A Prospective, Randomized Trial","year":2008,"condition":["Vein-harvest wound healing"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Vein-harvest wound healing","pt-BR":"Cicatrização da retirada de veia"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"100 elective CABG patients, randomized 50:50; open vein harvesting, with or without valve surgery.","sample":{"n":100,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"100 elective CABG patients, randomized 50:50; open vein harvesting, with or without valve surgery.","pt-BR":"100 pacientes de revascularização eletiva, randomizados 50:50; retirada aberta de veia, com ou sem cirurgia valvar."},"source_population":"100 elective CABG patients, randomized 50:50; open vein harvesting, with or without valve surgery.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["One intraoperative prophylactic shockwave application after wound closure."],"comparator":"Routine open harvesting and wound care; both groups received cefazolin.","findings":"ASEPSIS scores were 4.4±5.3 versus 11.6±8.3 (p=.0001). Wound antibiotics were needed in 4% versus 22% (p=.015). Revision rates 2% versus 10% did not reach significance (p=.092); hospital stay 15±11 versus 16±19 days did not differ.","patient_relevance":"Early wound scores and antibiotic use improved, but fewer reoperations or shorter hospitalization were not demonstrated.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Single-center short-term assessment; patients/operators not sham blinded but wound assessor blinded. Cost effectiveness and satisfaction unmeasured. Grimm and Schaden report financial relationships with TRT; MTS supplied equipment/disposables.","implication":"Evidence concerns prevention after open harvesting, not treatment of chronic ischemic diabetic ulcers or endoscopic harvest sites.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19022007/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Vein-harvest wound healing","pt-BR":"Cicatrização da retirada de veia"},"summary":{"en":"Early wound scores and antibiotic use improved, but fewer reoperations or shorter hospitalization were not demonstrated.","pt-BR":"Melhoraram escores precoces e uso de antibióticos, mas não se demonstraram menos reoperações ou internação mais curta."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"100 elective CABG patients, randomized 50:50; open vein harvesting, with or without valve surgery.","pt-BR":"100 pacientes de revascularização eletiva, randomizados 50:50; retirada aberta de veia, com ou sem cirurgia valvar."},"comparison":{"en":"Routine open harvesting and wound care; both groups received cefazolin.","pt-BR":"Retirada aberta e cuidados habituais; ambos receberam cefazolina."},"note":{"en":"Single-center short-term assessment; patients/operators not sham blinded but wound assessor blinded. Cost effectiveness and satisfaction unmeasured. Grimm and Schaden report financial relationships with TRT; MTS supplied equipment/disposables.","pt-BR":"Avaliação de curto prazo em um centro; sem simulação para pacientes/operadores, avaliador da ferida cego. Custo-efetividade e satisfação não medidos. Grimm e Schaden declaram relações financeiras com TRT; MTS forneceu equipamento/descartáveis."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-246","pmid":"20156981","doi":"10.1177/0269215509346083","title":"Randomized control of extracorporeal shock wave therapy versus placebo for chronic decubitus ulceration","year":2010,"condition":["Chronic pressure ulcers"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Chronic pressure ulcers","pt-BR":"Lesões por pressão crônicas"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"Eight people with severe neurological disability and nine ulcers; randomization unit was the ulcer, including both ankles of one participant.","sample":{"n":8,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"Eight people with severe neurological disability and nine ulcers; randomization unit was the ulcer, including both ankles of one participant.","pt-BR":"Oito pessoas com incapacidade neurológica grave e nove úlceras; randomização por úlcera, incluindo dois tornozelos de uma pessoa."},"source_population":"Eight people with severe neurological disability and nine ulcers; randomization unit was the ulcer, including both ankles of one participant.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Four weekly unfocused ESWT sessions, crossover after a two-week washout."],"comparator":"Identical-sounding inactive applicator; five ulcers placebo-first and four ESWT-first, with routine dressings unchanged.","findings":"Mean baseline areas were 1.79 and 1.23 cm² for placebo-first and ESWT-first ulcers. At 8 weeks after finishing ESWT, changes were−1.15 and−0.83 cm². Improvement emerged 6–8 weeks after starting ESWT, longer than the washout.","patient_relevance":"Healing followed treatment in a few long-standing ulcers, but the crossover design and delayed effects make the size of benefit uncertain.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Very small ulcer-level crossover with correlated lesions and delayed persistent effects incompatible with a clean two-week washout. Table 1 shows within-sequence change rather than a treatment-effect estimate. Text says nine patients while abstract/flow support eight; flow group labels are inconsistent. Department of Health funded staff; manufacturer lent modified equipment.","implication":"Hypothesis-generating for static ulcers in highly dependent neurological patients; cannot establish a reliable comparative healing benefit.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20156981/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Chronic pressure ulcers","pt-BR":"Lesões por pressão crônicas"},"summary":{"en":"Healing followed treatment in a few long-standing ulcers, but the crossover design and delayed effects make the size of benefit uncertain.","pt-BR":"Houve cicatrização após tratamento em poucas úlceras antigas, mas o cruzamento e o efeito tardio tornam incerta a magnitude do benefício."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"Eight people with severe neurological disability and nine ulcers; randomization unit was the ulcer, including both ankles of one participant.","pt-BR":"Oito pessoas com incapacidade neurológica grave e nove úlceras; randomização por úlcera, incluindo dois tornozelos de uma pessoa."},"comparison":{"en":"Identical-sounding inactive applicator; five ulcers placebo-first and four ESWT-first, with routine dressings unchanged.","pt-BR":"Aplicador inativo com mesmo ruído; cinco úlceras começaram com placebo e quatro com ondas, sem alterar curativos."},"note":{"en":"Very small ulcer-level crossover with correlated lesions and delayed persistent effects incompatible with a clean two-week washout. Table 1 shows within-sequence change rather than a treatment-effect estimate. Text says nine patients while abstract/flow support eight; flow group labels are inconsistent. Department of Health funded staff; manufacturer lent modified equipment.","pt-BR":"Cruzamento muito pequeno por úlcera, com lesões correlacionadas e efeito tardio persistente incompatível com washout limpo de duas semanas. Tabela 1 mostra mudança por sequência, não efeito comparativo. Texto menciona nove pacientes, resumo/fluxo oito; rótulos do fluxo são inconsistentes. Departamento de Saúde financiou pessoal; fabricante emprestou equipamento."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-247","pmid":"19473538","doi":"10.1186/1471-2474-10-54","title":"The management of neuropathic ulcers of the foot in diabetes by shock wave therapy","year":2009,"condition":["Neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers","pt-BR":"Úlceras neuropáticas do pé diabético"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"30 adults with insulin-treated type 1 diabetes and chronic neuropathic foot ulcers, adequate arterial perfusion; 15 per group, all completed 20 weeks.","sample":{"n":30,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"30 adults with insulin-treated type 1 diabetes and chronic neuropathic foot ulcers, adequate arterial perfusion; 15 per group, all completed 20 weeks.","pt-BR":"30 adultos com diabetes tipo 1 em insulina e úlceras neuropáticas crônicas, perfusão arterial adequada; 15 por grupo, todos completaram 20 semanas."},"source_population":"30 adults with insulin-treated type 1 diabetes and chronic neuropathic foot ulcers, adequate arterial perfusion; 15 per group, all completed 20 weeks.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Three focused electromagnetic treatments in addition to debridement, Silvercell and offloading."],"comparator":"The same wound care and therapeutic footwear without ESWT.","findings":"Complete closure: 8/15 versus 5/15 by 20 weeks. Among healers only, healing time 60.8±4.7 versus 82.2±4.7 days (p<.001). Re-epithelialization 2.97±.34 versus 1.30±.26 mm²/day (p<.001).","patient_relevance":"Healing was faster in selected patients, but the small study does not settle how much treatment increases complete healing for everyone.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Small trial without described allocation concealment or blinding. Healing time excludes nonhealers, so is not a time-to-event analysis of all randomized patients. Some prose calls means medians; Methods specify mean±SD. No competing interests declared; Storz acknowledged for scientific support.","implication":"Selection excludes major vascular disease; results cannot be extrapolated to ischemic infected ulcers or replace pressure relief.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19473538/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Neuropathic diabetic foot ulcers","pt-BR":"Úlceras neuropáticas do pé diabético"},"summary":{"en":"Healing was faster in selected patients, but the small study does not settle how much treatment increases complete healing for everyone.","pt-BR":"A cicatrização foi mais rápida em pacientes selecionados, mas o estudo pequeno não define quanto aumenta o fechamento completo para todos."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"30 adults with insulin-treated type 1 diabetes and chronic neuropathic foot ulcers, adequate arterial perfusion; 15 per group, all completed 20 weeks.","pt-BR":"30 adultos com diabetes tipo 1 em insulina e úlceras neuropáticas crônicas, perfusão arterial adequada; 15 por grupo, todos completaram 20 semanas."},"comparison":{"en":"The same wound care and therapeutic footwear without ESWT.","pt-BR":"Mesmos cuidados e calçado terapêutico sem ondas."},"note":{"en":"Small trial without described allocation concealment or blinding. Healing time excludes nonhealers, so is not a time-to-event analysis of all randomized patients. Some prose calls means medians; Methods specify mean±SD. No competing interests declared; Storz acknowledged for scientific support.","pt-BR":"Ensaio pequeno sem ocultação ou cegamento descritos. Tempo de cicatrização exclui não cicatrizados, não sendo análise temporal de todos os randomizados. Texto chama algumas médias de medianas; Métodos especificam média±DP. Sem interesses declarados; Storz recebeu agradecimento por apoio científico."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-248","pmid":"20800193","doi":"10.1016/j.jamcollsurg.2010.05.012","title":"Prospective Randomized Trial of Accelerated Re-epithelization of Skin Graft Donor Sites Using Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy","year":2010,"condition":["Skin graft donor sites"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Skin graft donor sites","pt-BR":"Áreas doadoras de enxerto"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"28 adults requiring split-thickness grafting for burns or trauma; 13 ESWT and 15 standard care, all analyzed.","sample":{"n":28,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"28 adults requiring split-thickness grafting for burns or trauma; 13 ESWT and 15 standard care, all analyzed.","pt-BR":"28 adultos com enxerto de pele por queimadura ou trauma; 13 ondas e 15 cuidados habituais, todos analisados."},"source_population":"28 adults requiring split-thickness grafting for burns or trauma; 13 ESWT and 15 standard care, all analyzed.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Single defocused treatment immediately after skin harvesting, while anesthetized."],"comparator":"Mepitel silicone mesh and polyhexanide/octenidine gel, changed daily in both groups.","findings":"Time to ≥95% epithelialization was 13.9±2.0 versus 16.7±2.0 days (p=.0001); all donor sites healed within 11–20 days. Study stopped at planned interim analysis after 28 rather than 54 participants.","patient_relevance":"The donor skin site closed sooner in this small trial, but effects on pain and later scarring remain unknown.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Early stopping and small sample can exaggerate benefit; no pain, distress, quality-of-life or cosmetic outcomes measured. Patients and outcome expert blinded, treating physician not blinded. Schaden/Thiele disclosed TRT stock; Schaden board membership.","implication":"Result is specific to donor sites receiving this dressing regimen; it does not establish superior cosmetic healing or less pain.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20800193/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Skin graft donor sites","pt-BR":"Áreas doadoras de enxerto"},"summary":{"en":"The donor skin site closed sooner in this small trial, but effects on pain and later scarring remain unknown.","pt-BR":"A área doadora fechou antes neste ensaio pequeno, mas efeitos na dor e cicatriz tardia permanecem desconhecidos."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"28 adults requiring split-thickness grafting for burns or trauma; 13 ESWT and 15 standard care, all analyzed.","pt-BR":"28 adultos com enxerto de pele por queimadura ou trauma; 13 ondas e 15 cuidados habituais, todos analisados."},"comparison":{"en":"Mepitel silicone mesh and polyhexanide/octenidine gel, changed daily in both groups.","pt-BR":"Tela de silicone Mepitel e gel de polihexanida/octenidina, trocados diariamente em ambos."},"note":{"en":"Early stopping and small sample can exaggerate benefit; no pain, distress, quality-of-life or cosmetic outcomes measured. Patients and outcome expert blinded, treating physician not blinded. Schaden/Thiele disclosed TRT stock; Schaden board membership.","pt-BR":"Interrupção precoce e amostra pequena podem exagerar benefício; dor, sofrimento, qualidade de vida e estética não medidos. Pacientes e avaliador cegos, médico tratante não. Schaden/Thiele declararam ações TRT; Schaden membro do conselho."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-249","pmid":"18394777","doi":"10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2008.01.010","title":"Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy for Management of Chronic Ulcers in the Lower Extremities","year":2008,"condition":["Chronic lower-limb wounds"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Chronic lower-limb wounds","pt-BR":"Feridas crônicas dos membros inferiores"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized or allocation-unclear comparisons","pt-BR":"Comparações não randomizadas ou com alocação incerta"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparisons","pt-BR":"Comparações não randomizadas"},"report_type":"nonrandom comparative","population":"30 ESWT patients with 32 wounds and 10 dressing-control patients with 10 wounds; traumatic, venous and diabetic etiologies.","sample":{"n":40,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"30 ESWT patients with 32 wounds and 10 dressing-control patients with 10 wounds; traumatic, venous and diabetic etiologies.","pt-BR":"30 pacientes tratados com 32 feridas e 10 controles com 10 feridas; etiologias traumática, venosa e diabética."},"source_population":"30 ESWT patients with 32 wounds and 10 dressing-control patients with 10 wounds; traumatic, venous and diabetic etiologies.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Focused ESWT every two weeks, 4–10 sessions, with prior wound care continued."],"comparator":"Ten separately recruited controls received regular dressings for 8 weeks; random treatment allocation is not established.","findings":"16/32 treated wounds closed, versus 1/10 controls at 8 weeks. Treated wounds closed within 4–6 sessions; additional sessions up to 10 gave little further benefit. Pain fell from 6.65 to 5.03, versus 6.2 to 5.5 in controls.","patient_relevance":"Some stubborn wounds closed, especially traumatic wounds, but this comparison cannot tell how much benefit came from shockwaves.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Unclear allocation, unequal follow-up and different etiologies prevent a causal estimate. Wounds outnumber patients; no clustering correction described. Text alternates 11/12 venous ulcers and tables contain dimension/area discrepancies. No formal economic evaluation supports cost-effectiveness wording; no explicit conflict statement located.","implication":"Suggests feasibility after failed dressings, but posttraumatic, venous and diabetic wounds should not be combined into a universal success probability.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18394777/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Chronic lower-limb wounds","pt-BR":"Feridas crônicas dos membros inferiores"},"summary":{"en":"Some stubborn wounds closed, especially traumatic wounds, but this comparison cannot tell how much benefit came from shockwaves.","pt-BR":"Algumas feridas persistentes fecharam, sobretudo traumáticas, mas a comparação não determina quanto benefício veio das ondas."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"30 ESWT patients with 32 wounds and 10 dressing-control patients with 10 wounds; traumatic, venous and diabetic etiologies.","pt-BR":"30 pacientes tratados com 32 feridas e 10 controles com 10 feridas; etiologias traumática, venosa e diabética."},"comparison":{"en":"Ten separately recruited controls received regular dressings for 8 weeks; random treatment allocation is not established.","pt-BR":"Dez controles recrutados separadamente receberam curativos por 8 semanas; alocação aleatória do tratamento não estabelecida."},"note":{"en":"Unclear allocation, unequal follow-up and different etiologies prevent a causal estimate. Wounds outnumber patients; no clustering correction described. Text alternates 11/12 venous ulcers and tables contain dimension/area discrepancies. No formal economic evaluation supports cost-effectiveness wording; no explicit conflict statement located.","pt-BR":"Alocação incerta, seguimento desigual e etiologias distintas impedem estimativa causal. Mais feridas que pessoas, sem ajuste descrito. Texto alterna 11/12 úlceras venosas e tabelas divergem entre dimensões/área. Sem avaliação econômica formal nem declaração explícita de conflitos localizada."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-250","pmid":"17904157","doi":"10.1016/j.jss.2007.01.009","title":"Shock Wave Therapy for Acute and Chronic Soft Tissue Wounds: A Feasibility Study","year":2007,"condition":["Acute and chronic soft-tissue wounds"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Acute and chronic soft-tissue wounds","pt-BR":"Feridas agudas e crônicas de partes moles"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Clinical cohorts without a treatment control","pt-BR":"Coortes clínicas sem grupo de controle do tratamento"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"report_type":"uncontrolled clinical","population":"208 patients in a prospective two-center feasibility cohort; 32 dropped out and were counted as incomplete healers. Mixed etiologies; mean age 61 years.","sample":{"n":208,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"208 patients in a prospective two-center feasibility cohort; 32 dropped out and were counted as incomplete healers. Mixed etiologies; mean age 61 years.","pt-BR":"208 pacientes em coorte prospectiva de viabilidade em dois centros; 32 perdas contadas como não cicatrizados. Etiologias variadas; idade média 61 anos."},"source_population":"208 patients in a prospective two-center feasibility cohort; 32 dropped out and were counted as incomplete healers. Mixed etiologies; mean age 61 years.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Defocused outpatient ESWT combined with debridement and unchanged moist dressings."],"comparator":"No treatment control; analyses compare prognostic subgroups among treated patients.","findings":"Complete epithelialization occurred in 156/208 (75%) including all enrolled, or 156/176 (88.6%) completers. Mean observation 44 days. Venous ulcers had 9/25 closures; burns 7/7. Smaller, younger and shorter-duration wounds did better; diabetes, location, depth and cavity comparisons were not significant.","patient_relevance":"Many wounds healed during combined care, but this study cannot separate shockwaves from the benefit of wound care and natural recovery.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"No concurrent control, short follow-up, heterogeneous wounds and 15.4% attrition. Better debridement and care may explain improvement. Table 4 odds ratios have direction/coding ambiguity despite favorable prose; no causal treatment effect should be inferred. Dedicated commercial conflict statement not identified.","implication":"Feasibility and descriptive healing evidence, not proof of superiority to dressings or prevention of recurrence.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/17904157/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Acute and chronic soft-tissue wounds","pt-BR":"Feridas agudas e crônicas de partes moles"},"summary":{"en":"Many wounds healed during combined care, but this study cannot separate shockwaves from the benefit of wound care and natural recovery.","pt-BR":"Muitas feridas cicatrizaram durante cuidados combinados, mas o estudo não separa ondas, cuidados e recuperação natural."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"208 patients in a prospective two-center feasibility cohort; 32 dropped out and were counted as incomplete healers. Mixed etiologies; mean age 61 years.","pt-BR":"208 pacientes em coorte prospectiva de viabilidade em dois centros; 32 perdas contadas como não cicatrizados. Etiologias variadas; idade média 61 anos."},"comparison":{"en":"No treatment control; analyses compare prognostic subgroups among treated patients.","pt-BR":"Sem controle de tratamento; análises comparam subgrupos prognósticos entre tratados."},"note":{"en":"No concurrent control, short follow-up, heterogeneous wounds and 15.4% attrition. Better debridement and care may explain improvement. Table 4 odds ratios have direction/coding ambiguity despite favorable prose; no causal treatment effect should be inferred. Dedicated commercial conflict statement not identified.","pt-BR":"Sem controle simultâneo, seguimento curto, feridas heterogêneas e 15,4% de perdas. Melhor desbridamento/cuidados podem explicar melhora. Razões de chances da Tabela 4 têm ambiguidade de direção/codificação; não inferir efeito causal. Sem declaração comercial específica identificada."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-251","pmid":"21310502","doi":"10.1016/j.diabres.2011.01.019","title":"Treatment of diabetic foot ulcers: A comparative study of extracorporeal shockwave therapy and hyperbaric oxygen therapy","year":2011,"condition":["Diabetic ulcers: shockwaves versus hyperbaric oxygen"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Diabetic ulcers: shockwaves versus hyperbaric oxygen","pt-BR":"Úlceras diabéticas: ondas versus oxigênio hiperbárico"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"88 allocated patients, 43 ESWT/45 HBOT; 77 patients with 84 feet analyzed after 4/7 losses, respectively.","sample":{"n":88,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"88 allocated patients, 43 ESWT/45 HBOT; 77 patients with 84 feet analyzed after 4/7 losses, respectively.","pt-BR":"88 alocados, 43 ondas/45 oxigênio; 77 pessoas com 84 pés analisados após 4/7 perdas, respectivamente."},"source_population":"88 allocated patients, 43 ESWT/45 HBOT; 77 patients with 84 feet analyzed after 4/7 losses, respectively.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Six ESWT sessions over 3 weeks, with offloading and local wound care."],"comparator":"Forty HBOT sessions, 2.5 ATA, 90 min, five per week; same wound care.","findings":"Table 3 reports 57% (24/44) completely healed after ESWT and 25% (10/40) after HBOT, p=.003; numerator and percentage conflict. ≥50% improvement 14/44 versus 6/40, p=.071; unchanged 5/44 versus 24/40. Perfusion post-treatment 0.61 versus 0.50, p=.002.","patient_relevance":"The report favored shockwaves, but inconsistent healing counts and study design mean the size of the advantage remains uncertain.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Open-label, predictable odd/even assignment; 11 exclusions and foot-level analysis without clustering adjustment. Table 3 ESWT categories sum 43, not 44, and 24/44 is not 57%. Second courses were clinician-selected, not rerandomized. Sanuwave supplied device/applicators; Wang advisory relationship disclosed.","implication":"Suggestive comparison with HBOT, but source discrepancies and attrition prevent a clean precision estimate or general claim of superiority.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21310502/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Diabetic ulcers:shockwaves versus hyperbaric oxygen","pt-BR":"Úlceras diabéticas:ondas versus oxigênio hiperbárico"},"summary":{"en":"The report favored shockwaves, but inconsistent healing counts and study design mean the size of the advantage remains uncertain.","pt-BR":"O relato favoreceu ondas, mas contagens inconsistentes e desenho tornam incerta a magnitude da vantagem."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"88 allocated patients, 43 ESWT/45 HBOT; 77 patients with 84 feet analyzed after 4/7 losses, respectively.","pt-BR":"88 alocados, 43 ondas/45 oxigênio; 77 pessoas com 84 pés analisados após 4/7 perdas, respectivamente."},"comparison":{"en":"Forty HBOT sessions, 2.5 ATA, 90 min, five per week; same wound care.","pt-BR":"Quarenta sessões hiperbáricas, 2,5 ATA, 90 min, cinco semanais; mesmos cuidados."},"note":{"en":"Open-label, predictable odd/even assignment; 11 exclusions and foot-level analysis without clustering adjustment. Table 3 ESWT categories sum 43, not 44, and 24/44 is not 57%. Second courses were clinician-selected, not rerandomized. Sanuwave supplied device/applicators; Wang advisory relationship disclosed.","pt-BR":"Aberto, alocação previsível par/ímpar; 11 exclusões e análise por pé sem ajuste de correlação. Categorias da Tabela 3 somam 43, não 44, e 24/44 não é 57%. Segundo ciclo selecionado pelo médico, não randomizado novamente. Sanuwave forneceu equipamento; Wang declarou relação consultiva."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-252","pmid":"24721603","doi":"10.1016/j.jss.2014.03.002","title":"Long-term outcomes of extracorporeal shockwave therapy for chronic foot ulcers","year":2014,"condition":["Five-year course of foot ulcers"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Five-year course of foot ulcers","pt-BR":"Evolução de úlceras do pé em cinco anos"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Clinical cohorts without a treatment control","pt-BR":"Coortes clínicas sem grupo de controle do tratamento"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"report_type":"uncontrolled clinical","population":"67 treated patients with 72 ulcers: 38 people/40 ulcers with diabetes and 29/32 without diabetes. At 5 years 57 survivors/61 ulcers remained.","sample":{"n":67,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"67 treated patients with 72 ulcers: 38 people/40 ulcers with diabetes and 29/32 without diabetes. At 5 years 57 survivors/61 ulcers remained.","pt-BR":"67 tratados com 72 úlceras: 38 pessoas/40 úlceras com diabetes e 29/32 sem diabetes. Em 5 anos, 57 sobreviventes/61 úlceras."},"source_population":"67 treated patients with 72 ulcers: 38 people/40 ulcers with diabetes and 29/32 without diabetes. At 5 years 57 survivors/61 ulcers remained.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"Possible relationship to earlier Wang cohorts requires participant-level confirmation; do not sum sample sizes.","link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["All received six ESWT treatments and necessary ongoing wound/diabetes care."],"comparator":"Diabetic versus nondiabetic prognosis; historical diabetic controls and a separate HBOT QOL sample were not randomized concurrent controls.","findings":"Complete healing 40/72 at 1 year and 35/61 at 5 years; the later denominator excludes 10 deaths. Diabetes 13/30 versus nondiabetes 22/31 ulcers healed at 5 years. Perfusion gains at 1 year declined by 5 years. Six of 57 survivors underwent amputation.","patient_relevance":"Healing did not eliminate future risks: deaths, operations and amputations occurred over five years, especially with diabetes.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"No standard-care concurrent control; survivorship changes denominators. Historical cohorts differ in case mix and follow-up. Multiple ulcer observations may be correlated. QOL timing/comparator selection unclear. Wang disclosed Sanuwave advisory role; Chang Gung grants funded work.","implication":"Describes prognosis after treatment, not sustained causal benefit. Booster therapy is a hypothesis, not tested here.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/24721603/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Five-year course of foot ulcers","pt-BR":"Evolução de úlceras do pé em cinco anos"},"summary":{"en":"Healing did not eliminate future risks: deaths, operations and amputations occurred over five years, especially with diabetes.","pt-BR":"Cicatrização não eliminou riscos futuros: mortes, cirurgias e amputações ocorreram em cinco anos, sobretudo com diabetes."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"67 treated patients with 72 ulcers: 38 people/40 ulcers with diabetes and 29/32 without diabetes. At 5 years 57 survivors/61 ulcers remained.","pt-BR":"67 tratados com 72 úlceras: 38 pessoas/40 úlceras com diabetes e 29/32 sem diabetes. Em 5 anos, 57 sobreviventes/61 úlceras."},"comparison":{"en":"Diabetic versus nondiabetic prognosis; historical diabetic controls and a separate HBOT QOL sample were not randomized concurrent controls.","pt-BR":"Prognóstico com/sem diabetes; controles diabéticos históricos e amostra hiperbárica separada de qualidade de vida não foram controles simultâneos randomizados."},"note":{"en":"No standard-care concurrent control; survivorship changes denominators. Historical cohorts differ in case mix and follow-up. Multiple ulcer observations may be correlated. QOL timing/comparator selection unclear. Wang disclosed Sanuwave advisory role; Chang Gung grants funded work.","pt-BR":"Sem controle simultâneo habitual; sobrevivência altera denominadores. Coortes históricas diferem em perfil e seguimento. Úlceras múltiplas podem correlacionar. Prazo/seleção do comparador de qualidade de vida incertos. Wang declarou consultoria Sanuwave; bolsas Chang Gung financiaram estudo."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-253","pmid":null,"doi":null,"title":"Advanced Protocol of Shock Wave Therapy for Diabetic Foot Ulcer","year":2013,"condition":["Diabetic ulcers with an experimental dose schedule"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Diabetic ulcers with an experimental dose schedule","pt-BR":"Úlceras diabéticas com esquema experimental"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized primary trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios clínicos randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"40 adults aged 40–70 with diabetic lower-limb ulcers >3 months, 1–20 cm², grade 2/3; 20 per group, all completed. Vascular insufficiency excluded.","sample":{"n":40,"unit":"people","basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"40 adults aged 40–70 with diabetic lower-limb ulcers >3 months, 1–20 cm², grade 2/3; 20 per group, all completed. Vascular insufficiency excluded.","pt-BR":"40 adultos de 40–70 anos com úlceras diabéticas >3 meses, 1–20 cm², grau 2/3; 20 por grupo, todos completaram. Insuficiência vascular excluída."},"source_population":"40 adults aged 40–70 with diabetic lower-limb ulcers >3 months, 1–20 cm², grade 2/3; 20 per group, all completed. Vascular insufficiency excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"PDF title/authors/journal verified: Adel A. Nossair, Marwa M. Eid, Amr B. Salama. Journal of American Science 2013; 9(4): 633–638. No DOI printed, no exact-title Europe PMC match; PMID remains null.","link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Three weekly shockwave sessions in addition to usual medical/wound care."],"comparator":"Medical treatment, debridement, pressure relief and infection treatment alone.","findings":"Table 1 wound area decreased 8.86±3.41 to 1.92±3.28 cm² with ESWT and 8.32±3.88 to 4.65±3.43 with control. Reported epithelialization percentages 83.26±27.43 versus 48.66±31.68 at 12 weeks.","patient_relevance":"The paper reports smaller wounds, but inconsistent graphs and statistics make the result uncertain.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Randomization method, concealment and assessor blinding unreported. Table 1 t=2.57 with p=.0001 is internally questionable; prose says p<.01. Figure 1 prints 5.92 instead of table 1.92 and chart labels conflict; Figure 2 labels reverse values. Use Table 1 descriptively without accepting exact significance. No funding/conflict statement located.","implication":"Small selected sample and source inconsistencies limit confidence. The BTL device is called unfocused in the paper; physical modality and energy reporting need verification.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":null,"next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Diabetic ulcers with an experimental dose schedule","pt-BR":"Úlceras diabéticas com esquema experimental"},"summary":{"en":"The paper reports smaller wounds, but inconsistent graphs and statistics make the result uncertain.","pt-BR":"O artigo relata feridas menores, mas gráficos e estatísticas inconsistentes tornam o resultado incerto."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"40 adults aged 40–70 with diabetic lower-limb ulcers >3 months, 1–20 cm², grade 2/3; 20 per group, all completed. Vascular insufficiency excluded.","pt-BR":"40 adultos de 40–70 anos com úlceras diabéticas >3 meses, 1–20 cm², grau 2/3; 20 por grupo, todos completaram. Insuficiência vascular excluída."},"comparison":{"en":"Medical treatment, debridement, pressure relief and infection treatment alone.","pt-BR":"Tratamento médico, desbridamento, alívio de pressão e tratamento de infecção isolados."},"note":{"en":"Randomization method, concealment and assessor blinding unreported. Table 1 t=2.57 with p=.0001 is internally questionable; prose says p<.01. Figure 1 prints 5.92 instead of table 1.92 and chart labels conflict; Figure 2 labels reverse values. Use Table 1 descriptively without accepting exact significance. No funding/conflict statement located.","pt-BR":"Método de randomização, ocultação e cegamento não informados. Tabela 1: t=2,57 com p=0,0001 é questionável; texto diz p<0,01. Figura 1 imprime 5,92 em vez de 1,92 e rótulos divergem; Figura 2 inverte rótulos. Usar Tabela 1 descritivamente sem aceitar significância exata. Sem declaração financeira localizada."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false},"source_url":"https://www.jofamericanscience.org/","source_identity":"citation_only","source_citation":"Adel A. Nossair; Marwa M. Eid; Amr B. Salama. Advanced Protocol of Shock Wave Therapy for Diabetic Foot Ulcer. Journal of American Science. 2013."},{"id":"SW200-254","pmid":"26079500","doi":"10.1016/j.ijsu.2015.06.024","title":"Extracorporeal shockwave therapy in diabetic foot ulcers","year":2015,"condition":["What early diabetic-foot reports suggested"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"What early diabetic-foot reports suggested","pt-BR":"O que sugeriam os primeiros relatos de pé diabético"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Narrative clinical synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese clínica narrativa"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Narrative review","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa"},"report_type":"narrative clinical review","population":"Narrative review of diabetic and mixed foot-ulcer clinical studies; no new patient cohort or pooled analysis.","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"Narrative review of diabetic and mixed foot-ulcer clinical studies; no new patient cohort or pooled analysis.","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa de estudos de úlceras diabéticas e mistas; sem nova coorte nem análise combinada."},"source_population":"Narrative review of diabetic and mixed foot-ulcer clinical studies; no new patient cohort or pooled analysis.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":"Narrative review reuses Moretti, Saggini, Wang and Schaden cohorts represented elsewhere; never sum its populations with primary records.","link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Focused and defocused ESWT regimens summarized from individual studies."],"comparator":"Standard wound care, HBOT, and uncontrolled cohorts; comparisons belong to their original studies.","findings":"Moretti is summarized as 53.33% versus 33.33% closure; Omar as 54% versus 28.5% at 20 weeks and 64.5±8.06 versus 81.17±4.35 days among healed ulcers. The 2011 HBOT comparison reports 57% versus 25%. Five-year outcomes decline in clinical status/perfusion despite survivor-only closure percentages.","patient_relevance":"Early studies looked promising, but this review cannot establish the best dose or whether repeated booster treatment helps.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"No reproducible search, selection criteria or formal bias assessment. Strong superiority and cost-effectiveness language exceeds the narrative evidence. It repeats source percentage/count issues and merges nonrandom cohorts with trials. Funding and conflicts declared none in this review.","implication":"Useful historical overview, not an independent estimate of benefit or evidence for booster sessions.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26079500/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"What early diabetic-foot reports suggested","pt-BR":"O que sugeriam os primeiros relatos de pé diabético"},"summary":{"en":"Early studies looked promising, but this review cannot establish the best dose or whether repeated booster treatment helps.","pt-BR":"Estudos iniciais pareciam promissores, mas esta revisão não define melhor dose nem se reforços ajudam."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"Narrative review of diabetic and mixed foot-ulcer clinical studies; no new patient cohort or pooled analysis.","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa de estudos de úlceras diabéticas e mistas; sem nova coorte nem análise combinada."},"comparison":{"en":"Standard wound care, HBOT, and uncontrolled cohorts; comparisons belong to their original studies.","pt-BR":"Cuidados habituais, oxigênio hiperbárico e coortes sem controle; comparações pertencem aos estudos originais."},"note":{"en":"No reproducible search, selection criteria or formal bias assessment. Strong superiority and cost-effectiveness language exceeds the narrative evidence. It repeats source percentage/count issues and merges nonrandom cohorts with trials. Funding and conflicts declared none in this review.","pt-BR":"Sem busca reproduzível, critérios de seleção ou avaliação formal de viés. Linguagem forte de superioridade/custo-efetividade excede evidência narrativa. Repete problemas numéricos e mistura coortes com ensaios. Declara ausência de financiamento/conflitos nesta revisão."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-255","pmid":"21841528","doi":"10.1097/prs.0b013e318230c7d1","title":"Shock Wave Therapy in Wound Healing","year":2011,"condition":["Wound healing: clinical and laboratory evidence"],"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"conditionLabel":{"en":"Wound healing: clinical and laboratory evidence","pt-BR":"Cicatrização: evidência clínica e laboratorial"},"level":"mixed_translational","levelLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical and preclinical reviews","pt-BR":"Revisões com estudos clínicos e pré-clínicos"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical / preclinical","pt-BR":"Evidência clínica / pré-clínica"},"report_type":"mixed translational","population":"Review of animal, in-vitro and human wound, burn and flap-necrosis studies; no new patient cohort.","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"source_full_text","description":{"en":"Review of animal, in-vitro and human wound, burn and flap-necrosis studies; no new patient cohort.","pt-BR":"Revisão de animais, in vitro e estudos humanos de feridas, queimaduras e necrose de retalhos; sem nova coorte."},"source_population":"Review of animal, in-vitro and human wound, burn and flap-necrosis studies; no new patient cohort.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"source_note":null,"link_status":"not_established","caution":{"en":"Reports and reviews may reuse participants; do not add sample sizes.","pt-BR":"Relatos e revisões podem reutilizar participantes; não somar amostras."}},"modality":["Focused/unfocused devices with varied energy, pulses, timing and session counts."],"comparator":"Animal controls, gene therapy, standard human wound care and HBOT; incomparable populations are discussed separately.","findings":"Human donor-site trial:13.9±2.0 versus 16.7±2.0 days to epithelialization. Animal null findings matter: Zins found no faster closure and repeated treatments delayed healing; Davis found no macroscopic closure advantage despite reduced inflammatory infiltration. High-dose 5000 impulses increased flap necrosis in Kamelger.","patient_relevance":"There are encouraging human results, but laboratory improvements do not always mean a wound closes faster.","critique":[{"category":"analysis","observation":"Search databases and terms described, but no complete search flow or meta-analysis. Clinical trials small and inconsistently reported; animal mechanistic responses cannot establish clinical healing efficacy. Table 1 modality/counts contain source-report discrepancies. Orgill disclosed Sanuwave advisory and KCI research/expert-witness relationships.","implication":"Mechanotransduction and immunomodulation are hypotheses supported by preclinical work; optimal human wound selection and dose remain unresolved.","verification":"full_text_interpretation","source_locator":"Methods; Results; Discussion"}],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21841528/","next":["Independent full-source and bilingual review before delivery."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Wound healing:clinical and laboratory evidence","pt-BR":"Cicatrização:evidência clínica e laboratorial"},"summary":{"en":"There are encouraging human results, but laboratory improvements do not always mean a wound closes faster.","pt-BR":"Há resultados humanos encorajadores, mas melhora laboratorial nem sempre significa fechamento mais rápido."}},"opening":{"population":{"en":"Review of animal, in-vitro and human wound, burn and flap-necrosis studies; no new patient cohort.","pt-BR":"Revisão de animais, in vitro e estudos humanos de feridas, queimaduras e necrose de retalhos; sem nova coorte."},"comparison":{"en":"Animal controls, gene therapy, standard human wound care and HBOT; incomparable populations are discussed separately.","pt-BR":"Controles animais, terapia gênica, cuidados humanos e oxigênio; populações incomparáveis discutidas separadamente."},"note":{"en":"Search databases and terms described, but no complete search flow or meta-analysis. Clinical trials small and inconsistently reported; animal mechanistic responses cannot establish clinical healing efficacy. Table 1 modality/counts contain source-report discrepancies. Orgill disclosed Sanuwave advisory and KCI research/expert-witness relationships.","pt-BR":"Bases/termos descritos, mas sem fluxo completo nem metanálise. Ensaios pequenos e relato inconsistente; respostas animais não estabelecem eficácia clínica. Tabela 1 tem discrepâncias de modalidade/contagem. Orgill declarou consultoria Sanuwave e relações de pesquisa/perícia KCI."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-257","pmid":"25722746","doi":"10.1186/s13047-014-0059-0","title":"The effectiveness of extracorporeal shock wave therapy for the treatment of lower limb ulceration: a systematic review","year":2015,"condition":["Shockwaves for lower-limb ulcers:early evidence"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shockwaves for lower-limb ulcers: early evidence","pt-BR":"Ondas para úlceras dos membros inferiores: evidência inicial"},"category":"wounds_scars","categoryLabel":{"en":"Wounds, burns and scars","pt-BR":"Feridas, queimaduras e cicatrizes"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"clinical synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese clínica"},"report_type":"clinical synthesis","population":"Mainly diabetic foot ulcers with some venous/arterial and post-traumatic ulcers. Burns, pressure sores and surgical complications excluded. Numbers mix people and ulcers; no reliable single independent pooled cohort should be displayed.","comparator":"Only one randomized study assessed ESWT added to standard care against standard care alone. Two Wang reports compared with hyperbaric oxygen; shared wound care included offloading, cleansing and dressings. Saggini usual-care details were unclear.","findings":"Moretti at 20 weeks: closure 53.33% versus 33.33%, healing time 60.8±4.7 versus 82.2±4.7 days. Wang 2009: 31% versus 22% healed; Wang 2011: 57% versus 25%(p=.003), while≥50% improvement 32% versus 15% was not significant(p=.071). Saggini 16/32 ulcers healed but no between-group benefit established.","patient_relevance":"The early studies suggested faster healing, but this review found too little reliable evidence to know how much shockwaves add to good wound care.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25722746/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"Mainly diabetic foot ulcers with some venous/arterial and post-traumatic ulcers. Burns, pressure sores and surgical complications excluded. Numbers mix people and ulcers; no reliable single independent pooled cohort should be displayed.","pt-BR":"Principalmente úlceras diabéticas, com algumas venosas/arteriais e pós-traumáticas. Excluídas queimaduras, lesões por pressão e complicações cirúrgicas. Contagens misturam pessoas e úlceras; não exibir coorte combinada independente."},"source_population":"Mainly diabetic foot ulcers with some venous/arterial and post-traumatic ulcers. Burns, pressure sores and surgical complications excluded. Numbers mix people and ulcers; no reliable single independent pooled cohort should be displayed.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Small heterogeneous studies, unblinded outcome measurement, unclear standard care, attrition without adequate intention-to-treat analysis and weak external validity. Table 3 Wang sample counts differ from narrative; closure p<.001 in Moretti cannot be accepted as a verified between-group test without primary-source reconciliation. Four external supplements not in local PDF. Authors declared no competing interests.","implication":"Promising wound-healing signals cannot establish routine adjunctive benefit, especially for venous or arterial ulcers. ESWT should not be interpreted as replacing offloading, vascular assessment, infection treatment or standard wound care.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Well-defined ulcer types,standardized shared care,concealed randomization,blinded healing adjudication and patient-important endpoints including amputation/recurrence are needed."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves for lower-limb ulcers: early evidence","pt-BR":"Ondas para úlceras dos membros inferiores: evidência inicial"},"summary":{"en":"The early studies suggested faster healing, but this review found too little reliable evidence to know how much shockwaves add to good wound care.","pt-BR":"Estudos iniciais sugeriram cicatrização mais rápida, mas a revisão encontrou pouca evidência confiável para saber quanto ondas acrescentam ao bom cuidado."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves for lower-limb ulcers: early evidence","pt-BR":"Ondas para úlceras dos membros inferiores: evidência inicial"},"population":{"en":"Mainly diabetic foot ulcers with some venous/arterial and post-traumatic ulcers. Burns, pressure sores and surgical complications excluded. Numbers mix people and ulcers; no reliable single independent pooled cohort should be displayed.","pt-BR":"Principalmente úlceras diabéticas, com algumas venosas/arteriais e pós-traumáticas. Excluídas queimaduras, lesões por pressão e complicações cirúrgicas. Contagens misturam pessoas e úlceras; não exibir coorte combinada independente."},"comparison":{"en":"Only one randomized study assessed ESWT added to standard care against standard care alone. Two Wang reports compared with hyperbaric oxygen; shared wound care included offloading, cleansing and dressings. Saggini usual-care details were unclear.","pt-BR":"Apenas um randomizado testou ondas adicionais versus cuidado padrão isolado. Dois Wang compararam oxigênio hiperbárico; cuidados incluíam descarga, limpeza e curativos. Cuidados de Saggini pouco claros."},"note":{"en":"Small heterogeneous studies, unblinded outcome measurement, unclear standard care, attrition without adequate intention-to-treat analysis and weak external validity. Table 3 Wang sample counts differ from narrative; closure p<.001 in Moretti cannot be accepted as a verified between-group test without primary-source reconciliation. Four external supplements not in local PDF. Authors declared no competing interests.","pt-BR":"Estudos pequenos/heterogêneos, medição aberta, cuidado padrão incerto, perdas sem intenção de tratar adequada e baixa validade externa. N de Wang na Tabela 3 difere da narrativa; p<0,001 do fechamento Moretti não deve ser aceito como teste comparativo verificado sem fonte primária. Quatro suplementos externos ausentes. Sem conflitos declarados."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-258","pmid":"29264270","doi":"10.1016/j.asmart.2016.10.001","title":"Comparison of treatment effects on lateral epicondylitis between acupuncture and extracorporeal shockwave therapy","year":2017,"condition":["Lateral elbow pain: waves or acupuncture?"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Lateral elbow pain: waves or acupuncture?","pt-BR":"Dor lateral no cotovelo: ondas ou acupuntura?"},"category":"elbow_hand","categoryLabel":{"en":"Elbow and hand","pt-BR":"Cotovelo e mão"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"randomized trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"Thirty-four patients with 34 affected elbows in Hong Kong, 17 per group. Prior surgery, cervical referred pain, systemic connective-tissue disease and recent ESWT, acupuncture or steroid treatment were excluded.","comparator":"Six acupuncture sessions over three weeks, six named points, needle depth 1.25–2.5 cm and about 20 minutes per session; De qi every five minutes. No analgesia prescribed, but self-medication was not recorded.","findings":"At two weeks VAS was 3.18±2.13 with ESWT and 4.06±2.41 with acupuncture; grip was 98.39±22.64 versus 93.41±22.06 N and DASH 60.12±15.50 versus 63.94±15.34. No between-group difference was significant at any assessment. Pain improved within both arms; grip and disability changes were not significant. This is not an equivalence trial.","patient_relevance":"Both groups reported less elbow pain, with no clear winner and no confirmed functional improvement. The brief follow-up leaves lasting benefit uncertain.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29264270/","sample":{"n":34,"unit":"people","basis":"Source participant allocation","description":{"en":"Thirty-four patients with 34 affected elbows in Hong Kong, 17 per group. Prior surgery, cervical referred pain, systemic connective-tissue disease and recent ESWT, acupuncture or steroid treatment were excluded.","pt-BR":"Trinta e quatro pacientes, com 34 cotovelos afetados, em Hong Kong; 17 por grupo. Foram excluídos cirurgia prévia, dor referida cervical, doença sistêmica do tecido conjuntivo e tratamentos recentes com ondas, acupuntura ou corticoide."},"source_population":"Thirty-four patients with 34 affected elbows in Hong Kong, 17 per group. Prior surgery, cervical referred pain, systemic connective-tissue disease and recent ESWT, acupuncture or steroid treatment were excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Only two weeks of follow-up; no sham; incomplete randomization reporting and no recorded self-administered analgesia. Self-massage occurred in 11/17 acupuncture and 8/17 ESWT patients. Figure 2 mentions paired t tests although methods specify Wilcoxon for VAS. Authors declared no conflicts; university sports-medicine programme supported the study.","implication":"Useful as a small comparison of two active clinic regimens. It cannot establish that either exceeds natural recovery or provide long-term effectiveness or cost-effectiveness.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["A larger concealed, assessor-masked trial with sham/contextual control, recorded co-interventions, longer follow-up and confidence intervals would better separate effects."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Lateral elbow pain: waves or acupuncture?","pt-BR":"Dor lateral no cotovelo: ondas ou acupuntura?"},"summary":{"en":"Both groups reported less elbow pain, with no clear winner and no confirmed functional improvement. The brief follow-up leaves lasting benefit uncertain.","pt-BR":"Os dois grupos relataram menos dor no cotovelo, sem vencedor claro e sem melhora funcional confirmada. O seguimento curto deixa incerto o benefício duradouro."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Lateral elbow pain: waves or acupuncture?","pt-BR":"Dor lateral no cotovelo: ondas ou acupuntura?"},"population":{"en":"Thirty-four patients with 34 affected elbows in Hong Kong, 17 per group. Prior surgery, cervical referred pain, systemic connective-tissue disease and recent ESWT, acupuncture or steroid treatment were excluded.","pt-BR":"Trinta e quatro pacientes, com 34 cotovelos afetados, em Hong Kong; 17 por grupo. Foram excluídos cirurgia prévia, dor referida cervical, doença sistêmica do tecido conjuntivo e tratamentos recentes com ondas, acupuntura ou corticoide."},"comparison":{"en":"Six acupuncture sessions over three weeks, six named points, needle depth 1.25–2.5 cm and about 20 minutes per session; De qi every five minutes. No analgesia prescribed, but self-medication was not recorded.","pt-BR":"Seis sessões de acupuntura em três semanas, seis pontos definidos, profundidade de 1,25–2,5 cm e cerca de 20 minutos; De qi a cada cinco minutos. Não se prescreveu analgesia, mas automedicação não foi registrada."},"note":{"en":"Only two weeks of follow-up; no sham; incomplete randomization reporting and no recorded self-administered analgesia. Self-massage occurred in 11/17 acupuncture and 8/17 ESWT patients. Figure 2 mentions paired t tests although methods specify Wilcoxon for VAS. Authors declared no conflicts; university sports-medicine programme supported the study.","pt-BR":"Seguimento de apenas duas semanas; ausência de simulação; descrição incompleta da randomização e da automedicação. Houve automassagem em 11/17 pacientes da acupuntura e 8/17 das ondas. A Figura 2 menciona teste t pareado, enquanto os métodos indicam Wilcoxon para EVA. Autores declararam ausência de conflitos; apoio do programa universitário de medicina esportiva."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-259","pmid":"12846521","doi":null,"title":"An Overview of Shock Wave Therapy in Musculoskeletal Disorders","year":2003,"condition":["Orthopedic shockwaves: a historical mechanistic overview"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Orthopedic shockwaves: a historical mechanistic overview","pt-BR":"Ondas em ortopedia: panorama histórico dos mecanismos"},"category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"level":"mixed_translational","levelLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical / preclinical","pt-BR":"Evidência clínica / pré-clínica"},"typeLabel":{"en":"mixed translational","pt-BR":"Revisão clínica e pré-clínica"},"report_type":"mixed translational","population":"Diverse populations with fracture nonunion, plantar fasciitis, calcific shoulder tendinopathy and lateral epicondylitis. Experimental animal findings and preliminary hip, knee and cartilage applications are separate from clinical cohorts; no unique total can be calculated.","comparator":"Most selected clinical reports are uncontrolled; small control groups, low-dose comparisons and a surgery comparison appear. Differences across these designs prevent a single comparative estimate.","findings":"Reported ranges were 50–90% union, 34–88% plantar success, 47–70% shoulder success and 48–73% elbow success, without common definitions or pooling. One shoulder report found 60.6% complaint-free and 57.6% complete calcium elimination. Its six controls had one slight improvement. These selected proportions do not establish a general treatment probability.","patient_relevance":"This historical review explains why treatment was investigated, but its high success percentages cannot predict your chance of recovery. The underlying studies and diagnosis matter.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12846521/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"Diverse populations with fracture nonunion, plantar fasciitis, calcific shoulder tendinopathy and lateral epicondylitis. Experimental animal findings and preliminary hip, knee and cartilage applications are separate from clinical cohorts; no unique total can be calculated.","pt-BR":"Populações distintas com não consolidação de fraturas, fasciopatia plantar, tendinopatia calcária do ombro e epicondilalgia lateral. Animais e aplicações preliminares em quadril, joelho e cartilagem são separados das coortes clínicas; não há total único calculável."},"source_population":"Diverse populations with fracture nonunion, plantar fasciitis, calcific shoulder tendinopathy and lateral epicondylitis. Experimental animal findings and preliminary hip, knee and cartilage applications are separate from clinical cohorts; no unique total can be calculated.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Selective narrative synthesis, emphasis on the author’s studies, small controls, varying follow-up and incomplete denominators. The nonunion paragraph reports 72 enrolled but 55, 34 and 25 observed at successive times, then inconsistently says 22 patients at the last time. Elbow response categories total 44 despite 57 patients initially described. Preliminary unpublished results and historical regulatory statements are not current guidance. No structured conflict or funding declaration was located.","implication":"Useful for understanding the historical transition from lithotripsy to biological hypotheses. It cannot determine contemporary comparative effectiveness, an optimal dose or replacement of surgery.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Test each indication in prospectively registered randomized trials with consistent success definitions, complete follow-up denominators and systematic harms; separately test whether vascular changes mediate clinical improvement."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Orthopedic shockwaves: a historical mechanistic overview","pt-BR":"Ondas em ortopedia: panorama histórico dos mecanismos"},"summary":{"en":"This historical review explains why treatment was investigated, but its high success percentages cannot predict your chance of recovery. The underlying studies and diagnosis matter.","pt-BR":"Esta revisão histórica explica por que o tratamento foi pesquisado, mas porcentagens elevadas não predizem sua chance de recuperação. O diagnóstico e os estudos originais importam."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Orthopedic shockwaves: a historical mechanistic overview","pt-BR":"Ondas em ortopedia: panorama histórico dos mecanismos"},"population":{"en":"Diverse populations with fracture nonunion, plantar fasciitis, calcific shoulder tendinopathy and lateral epicondylitis. Experimental animal findings and preliminary hip, knee and cartilage applications are separate from clinical cohorts; no unique total can be calculated.","pt-BR":"Populações distintas com não consolidação de fraturas, fasciopatia plantar, tendinopatia calcária do ombro e epicondilalgia lateral. Animais e aplicações preliminares em quadril, joelho e cartilagem são separados das coortes clínicas; não há total único calculável."},"comparison":{"en":"Most selected clinical reports are uncontrolled; small control groups, low-dose comparisons and a surgery comparison appear. Differences across these designs prevent a single comparative estimate.","pt-BR":"Predominam relatos sem controle; aparecem pequenos controles, comparação de baixa dose e cirurgia. Diferenças entre desenhos impedem uma estimativa comparativa única."},"note":{"en":"Selective narrative synthesis, emphasis on the author’s studies, small controls, varying follow-up and incomplete denominators. The nonunion paragraph reports 72 enrolled but 55, 34 and 25 observed at successive times, then inconsistently says 22 patients at the last time. Elbow response categories total 44 despite 57 patients initially described. Preliminary unpublished results and historical regulatory statements are not current guidance. No structured conflict or funding declaration was located.","pt-BR":"Síntese seletiva, destaque aos estudos do autor, controles pequenos, seguimento variável e denominadores incompletos. Não consolidação: 72 incluídos, mas 55, 34 e 25 observados depois; o texto também menciona inconsistentes 22 pacientes ao final. Categorias do cotovelo somam 44 apesar de 57 descritos inicialmente. Resultados preliminares não publicados e regulação histórica não são orientação atual. Não localizada declaração estruturada de conflitos ou financiamento."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-260","pmid":"30061805","doi":"10.5455/msm.2018.30.141-146","title":"Effectiveness and Safety of Shockwave Therapy in Tendinopathies","year":2018,"condition":["Radial waves across four tendon conditions"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Radial waves across four tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais em quatro condições tendíneas"},"category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparisons","pt-BR":"Comparações não randomizadas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"nonrandom comparative","pt-BR":"Comparação não randomizada"},"report_type":"nonrandom comparative","population":"Elbow 117/18, plantar fascia 88/15, Achilles 65/13, and rotator cuff 56/12 ESWT/control participants. Adults only; diagnostic detail, symptom chronicity and recruitment/attrition reporting are limited.","comparator":"Conservative care included topical NSAIDs, straps, condition-specific exercise, activity change, friction massage and hot/cold packs. Equivalence of other care in the ESWT groups is unclear.","findings":"Tables 1–3 report nearly zero mean scores in all ESWT domains at 4 weeks, versus persisting control scores around 1.84–2.46; all between-group post-treatment/follow-up p<.001. These unusually large unadjusted differences need cautious interpretation given design and reporting weaknesses.","patient_relevance":"Large improvements were reported, but study limitations make the size of the true treatment benefit uncertain. The paper does not provide a reliable harms estimate.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30061805/","sample":{"n":384,"unit":"people","basis":"Source participant allocation","description":{"en":"Elbow 117/18, plantar fascia 88/15, Achilles 65/13, and rotator cuff 56/12 ESWT/control participants. Adults only; diagnostic detail, symptom chronicity and recruitment/attrition reporting are limited.","pt-BR":"Participantes ondas/controle: cotovelo 117/18, fáscia plantar 88/15, Aquiles 65/13, manguito 56/12. Apenas adultos; detalhes diagnósticos, cronicidade e recrutamento/perdas limitados."},"source_population":"Elbow 117/18, plantar fascia 88/15, Achilles 65/13, and rotator cuff 56/12 ESWT/control participants. Adults only; diagnostic detail, symptom chronicity and recruitment/attrition reporting are limited.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Nonrandom selection, unbalanced groups, unvalidated new outcome tool, short follow-up and unclear missing data. Tables repeat 117/18 column headings for all diagnoses despite differing sample sizes. Statistical method reporting is sparse, and some printed differences/p-values do not align transparently with group summaries. No conflicts declared.","implication":"The study describes one clinic’s radial practice; it does not justify a first-choice recommendation across all tendinopathies or establish comparison with modern progressive loading.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Use randomized diagnosis-specific comparisons,validated scales,transparent denominators and adverse-event collection,with longer follow-up and prespecified analyses."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Radial waves across four tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais em quatro condições tendíneas"},"summary":{"en":"Large improvements were reported, but study limitations make the size of the true treatment benefit uncertain. The paper does not provide a reliable harms estimate.","pt-BR":"Foram relatadas grandes melhoras, mas limitações tornam incerta a magnitude real do benefício. O artigo não fornece estimativa confiável de danos."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Radial waves across four tendon conditions","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais em quatro condições tendíneas"},"population":{"en":"Elbow 117/18, plantar fascia 88/15, Achilles 65/13, and rotator cuff 56/12 ESWT/control participants. Adults only; diagnostic detail, symptom chronicity and recruitment/attrition reporting are limited.","pt-BR":"Participantes ondas/controle: cotovelo 117/18, fáscia plantar 88/15, Aquiles 65/13, manguito 56/12. Apenas adultos; detalhes diagnósticos, cronicidade e recrutamento/perdas limitados."},"comparison":{"en":"Conservative care included topical NSAIDs, straps, condition-specific exercise, activity change, friction massage and hot/cold packs. Equivalence of other care in the ESWT groups is unclear.","pt-BR":"Cuidado conservador incluiu anti-inflamatório tópico, faixas, exercícios específicos, ajuste de atividade, massagem e calor/frio. Igualdade dos demais cuidados nos grupos de ondas é incerta."},"note":{"en":"Nonrandom selection, unbalanced groups, unvalidated new outcome tool, short follow-up and unclear missing data. Tables repeat 117/18 column headings for all diagnoses despite differing sample sizes. Statistical method reporting is sparse, and some printed differences/p-values do not align transparently with group summaries. No conflicts declared.","pt-BR":"Seleção não aleatória, grupos desequilibrados, instrumento novo sem validação suficiente, seguimento curto e perdas incertas. Tabelas repetem cabeçalhos 117/18 para todas condições apesar de amostras distintas. Métodos estatísticos escassos; algumas diferenças/p não se alinham claramente aos resumos. Sem conflitos declarados."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-261","pmid":"23185731","doi":"10.5535/arm.2012.36.5.665","title":"The Effect of Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy on Myofascial Pain Syndrome","year":2012,"condition":["Trapezius pain: shockwaves versus injection and TENS"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Trapezius pain: shockwaves versus injection and TENS","pt-BR":"Dor no trapézio: ondas versus infiltração e TENS"},"category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"level":"randomized_trial","levelLabel":{"en":"Randomized trials","pt-BR":"Ensaios randomizados"},"typeLabel":{"en":"randomized trial","pt-BR":"Ensaio randomizado"},"report_type":"randomized trial","population":"Hospital patients with posterior neck/shoulder pain and trapezius myofascial pain diagnosed on examination in 2011; 22 men and 8 women. Mean age was 40.86 in ESWT and 45.00 in control.","comparator":"Trigger-point injections once weekly for three weeks plus TENS 20 minutes/day, five times weekly for three weeks. Injection drug and dose are not reported sufficiently for replication.","findings":"Final VAS was 1.86±0.69 vs 2.80±0.84; threshold 12.57±0.72 vs 9.60±2.19 lb/cm² (ESWT/control). Group effects were p=.010 and .045, but VAS group×time was not significant (.162), whereas threshold interaction was .001. McGill and pain-rating group effects were null (.816/.644); McGill interaction was .031. Total neck motion and global-response comparisons were not significant.","patient_relevance":"Pain scores improved in both groups. Some pressure-pain findings favored shockwaves, but this small short-term trial does not establish a lasting advantage.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23185731/","sample":{"n":30,"unit":"people","basis":"Source participant allocation","description":{"en":"Hospital patients with posterior neck/shoulder pain and trapezius myofascial pain diagnosed on examination in 2011; 22 men and 8 women. Mean age was 40.86 in ESWT and 45.00 in control.","pt-BR":"Pacientes internados em 2011 com dor cervical posterior/ombro e diagnóstico clínico de dor miofascial do trapézio; 22 homens e oito mulheres. Idade média de 40,86 anos nas ondas e 45,00 no controle."},"source_population":"Hospital patients with posterior neck/shoulder pain and trapezius myofascial pain diagnosed on examination in 2011; 22 men and 8 women. Mean age was 40.86 in ESWT and 45.00 in control.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Small hospital sample and brief observation, unclear allocation safeguards, multiple outcomes and incomplete comparator details. The distinction between group main effect and interaction is essential: authors overinterpret VAS superiority despite a null interaction. No dedicated funding/conflict statement was found in the supplied article.","implication":"Findings concern hospitalized trapezius-pain patients and this low-energy protocol; they do not establish durable recovery, an optimal dose, or equivalence to injections/TENS.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Concealed randomized trials should prespecify a primary contrast, quantify harms, standardize injection/TENS and follow patients beyond the immediate course."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Trapezius pain: shockwaves versus injection and TENS","pt-BR":"Dor no trapézio: ondas versus infiltração e TENS"},"summary":{"en":"Pain scores improved in both groups. Some pressure-pain findings favored shockwaves, but this small short-term trial does not establish a lasting advantage.","pt-BR":"A dor melhorou nos dois grupos. Alguns resultados de sensibilidade à pressão favoreceram as ondas, mas este ensaio pequeno e curto não comprova vantagem duradoura."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Trapezius pain: shockwaves versus injection and TENS","pt-BR":"Dor no trapézio: ondas versus infiltração e TENS"},"population":{"en":"Hospital patients with posterior neck/shoulder pain and trapezius myofascial pain diagnosed on examination in 2011; 22 men and 8 women. Mean age was 40.86 in ESWT and 45.00 in control.","pt-BR":"Pacientes internados em 2011 com dor cervical posterior/ombro e diagnóstico clínico de dor miofascial do trapézio; 22 homens e oito mulheres. Idade média de 40,86 anos nas ondas e 45,00 no controle."},"comparison":{"en":"Trigger-point injections once weekly for three weeks plus TENS 20 minutes/day, five times weekly for three weeks. Injection drug and dose are not reported sufficiently for replication.","pt-BR":"Infiltração de ponto-gatilho semanal por três semanas e TENS por 20 minutos/dia, cinco vezes/semana por três semanas. Fármaco e dose da infiltração não são suficientemente informados para reprodução."},"note":{"en":"Small hospital sample and brief observation, unclear allocation safeguards, multiple outcomes and incomplete comparator details. The distinction between group main effect and interaction is essential: authors overinterpret VAS superiority despite a null interaction. No dedicated funding/conflict statement was found in the supplied article.","pt-BR":"Amostra hospitalar pequena, observação breve, proteção da alocação incerta, múltiplos desfechos e comparador pouco descrito. É essencial separar efeito principal de grupo e interação: autores ampliam a conclusão sobre EVA apesar da interação nula. Não foi localizada declaração específica de financiamento/conflitos no artigo fornecido."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-262","pmid":"37957975","doi":"10.3390/healthcare11212830","title":"Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy for the Treatment of Musculoskeletal Pain: A Narrative Review","year":2023,"condition":["Musculoskeletal pain: evidence varies by indication"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Musculoskeletal pain: evidence varies by indication","pt-BR":"Dor musculoesquelética: evidência varia por indicação"},"category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"clinical synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese clínica"},"report_type":"clinical synthesis","population":"Multiple tendon disorders, plantar fasciitis, axial pain, knee osteoarthritis, bone healing and vascular disorders, and carpal tunnel syndrome. Participants recur across cited reviews; there is no independent aggregate patient count.","comparator":"Placebo, exercises, physical modalities, injections and surgery vary by indication. Shared rehabilitation and differences between radial and focused treatment complicate cross-study comparisons.","findings":"Selected examples: a 104-person trochanteric trial reported 12-month VAS 37.1 versus 55.0 after injection comparison; a 44-athlete pubic-pain study reported return to football at 73.2 versus 102.6 days. Important null findings include low-back function, short-term patellar placebo comparisons, knee function versus PRP and carpal-tunnel comparisons with steroid injection. No common effect or certainty estimate can be derived.","patient_relevance":"The usefulness of shockwaves depends on the diagnosis and comparison treatment. Some studies show benefit, others show little difference; this review does not give one success rate for everyone.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37957975/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"Multiple tendon disorders, plantar fasciitis, axial pain, knee osteoarthritis, bone healing and vascular disorders, and carpal tunnel syndrome. Participants recur across cited reviews; there is no independent aggregate patient count.","pt-BR":"Diversas tendinopatias, fasciopatia plantar, dor axial, artrose de joelho, consolidação e doenças vasculares ósseas e túnel do carpo. Participantes podem se repetir entre revisões citadas; não há total independente agregado."},"source_population":"Multiple tendon disorders, plantar fasciitis, axial pain, knee osteoarthritis, bone healing and vascular disorders, and carpal tunnel syndrome. Participants recur across cited reviews; there is no independent aggregate patient count.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Subjective selection and heterogeneous controls limit conclusions. Table 3 lists nine 1− entries although the abstract says eight; avascular hip necrosis and femoral-head osteonecrosis overlap conceptually. Grades are not an outcome-specific GRADE assessment. Reference 79 is the historical Ogden overview, not a modern pooled trial analysis. No external funding or conflicts declared.","implication":"An orientation map for clinicians, requiring indication-specific appraisal. Broad claims of safety and efficacy should not replace the null and uncertain findings described in the body.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Conduct transparent condition-specific systematic reviews, reconcile selection counts, separate modalities and co-interventions, and use blinded trials with prespecified function, pain, harms and durable follow-up."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Musculoskeletal pain: evidence varies by indication","pt-BR":"Dor musculoesquelética: evidência varia por indicação"},"summary":{"en":"The usefulness of shockwaves depends on the diagnosis and comparison treatment. Some studies show benefit, others show little difference; this review does not give one success rate for everyone.","pt-BR":"A utilidade das ondas depende do diagnóstico e da comparação. Alguns estudos mostram benefício; outros, pouca diferença. Esta revisão não fornece uma taxa de sucesso para todos."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Musculoskeletal pain: evidence varies by indication","pt-BR":"Dor musculoesquelética: evidência varia por indicação"},"population":{"en":"Multiple tendon disorders, plantar fasciitis, axial pain, knee osteoarthritis, bone healing and vascular disorders, and carpal tunnel syndrome. Participants recur across cited reviews; there is no independent aggregate patient count.","pt-BR":"Diversas tendinopatias, fasciopatia plantar, dor axial, artrose de joelho, consolidação e doenças vasculares ósseas e túnel do carpo. Participantes podem se repetir entre revisões citadas; não há total independente agregado."},"comparison":{"en":"Placebo, exercises, physical modalities, injections and surgery vary by indication. Shared rehabilitation and differences between radial and focused treatment complicate cross-study comparisons.","pt-BR":"Placebo, exercícios, modalidades físicas, infiltrações e cirurgia variam por indicação. Reabilitação concomitante e diferenças entre radial e focal dificultam comparação entre estudos."},"note":{"en":"Subjective selection and heterogeneous controls limit conclusions. Table 3 lists nine 1− entries although the abstract says eight; avascular hip necrosis and femoral-head osteonecrosis overlap conceptually. Grades are not an outcome-specific GRADE assessment. Reference 79 is the historical Ogden overview, not a modern pooled trial analysis. No external funding or conflicts declared.","pt-BR":"Seleção subjetiva e controles heterogêneos limitam conclusões. Tabela 3 lista nove entradas 1−, embora o resumo diga oito; necrose avascular do quadril e osteonecrose da cabeça femoral se sobrepõem conceitualmente. Notas não são GRADE por desfecho. Referência 79 é o panorama histórico de Ogden, não análise moderna combinada de ensaios. Sem financiamento externo ou conflitos declarados."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-263","pmid":"19444437","doi":"10.1007/s00240-009-0190-8","title":"Pain relief by extracorporeal shockwave therapy: an update on the current understanding","year":2009,"condition":["How might shockwaves relieve pain? A 2009 debate"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"How might shockwaves relieve pain? A 2009 debate","pt-BR":"Como ondas poderiam aliviar dor? Debate de 2009"},"category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"level":"background_mechanism","levelLabel":{"en":"Context & narrative reviews","pt-BR":"Contexto e revisões narrativas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Letter to the editor","pt-BR":"Carta ao editor"},"report_type":"letter to the editor","population":"No new patient cohort. Discussion concerns plantar fascia, Achilles and lateral elbow entheses, with mechanistic evidence from rabbit femur and rat skin/neurons.","comparator":"The conceptual comparator is Wess’s associative pain-memory model; this is a scientific argument, not randomized comparison between devices or theories.","findings":"Authors argue peripheral tissue and sensory-neuron mechanisms provide plausible explanations for analgesia. These observations do not prove the dominant mechanism in humans or invalidate all central contributions to pain.","patient_relevance":"There are plausible biological explanations for pain relief, but this letter itself does not show how well a treatment works.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19444437/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"No new patient cohort. Discussion concerns plantar fascia, Achilles and lateral elbow entheses, with mechanistic evidence from rabbit femur and rat skin/neurons.","pt-BR":"Sem nova coorte. Discussão sobre enteses da fáscia plantar, Aquiles e cotovelo lateral, com mecanismos em fêmur de coelhos e pele/neurônios de ratos."},"source_population":"No new patient cohort. Discussion concerns plantar fascia, Achilles and lateral elbow entheses, with mechanistic evidence from rabbit femur and rat skin/neurons.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Polemic, selective citation and preclinical-to-clinical extrapolation; both authors are affiliated with EMS, a device manufacturer discussed favorably. Regulatory statements explicitly refer to February 2009 and cannot be treated as current approvals. No systematic search or risk-of-bias appraisal.","implication":"Useful for understanding historical mechanistic debate and the need for indication/device-specific evidence. It cannot choose a current device or estimate an individual patient’s likely benefit.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Direct human mechanistic studies and independently assessed device-specific clinical trials should connect biological changes with sustained patient outcomes."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"How might shockwaves relieve pain? A 2009 debate","pt-BR":"Como ondas poderiam aliviar dor? Debate de 2009"},"summary":{"en":"There are plausible biological explanations for pain relief, but this letter itself does not show how well a treatment works.","pt-BR":"Há explicações biológicas plausíveis para alívio, mas esta carta não demonstra por si quanto um tratamento funciona."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"How might shockwaves relieve pain? A 2009 debate","pt-BR":"Como ondas poderiam aliviar dor? Debate de 2009"},"population":{"en":"No new patient cohort. Discussion concerns plantar fascia, Achilles and lateral elbow entheses, with mechanistic evidence from rabbit femur and rat skin/neurons.","pt-BR":"Sem nova coorte. Discussão sobre enteses da fáscia plantar, Aquiles e cotovelo lateral, com mecanismos em fêmur de coelhos e pele/neurônios de ratos."},"comparison":{"en":"The conceptual comparator is Wess’s associative pain-memory model; this is a scientific argument, not randomized comparison between devices or theories.","pt-BR":"Comparador conceitual: modelo de memória associativa da dor de Wess; argumento científico, não comparação randomizada de aparelhos ou teorias."},"note":{"en":"Polemic, selective citation and preclinical-to-clinical extrapolation; both authors are affiliated with EMS, a device manufacturer discussed favorably. Regulatory statements explicitly refer to February 2009 and cannot be treated as current approvals. No systematic search or risk-of-bias appraisal.","pt-BR":"Texto argumentativo, citações seletivas e extrapolação animal-humano; ambos autores ligados à EMS, fabricante discutido favoravelmente. Regulação refere-se explicitamente a fevereiro de 2009, não a aprovações atuais. Sem busca sistemática ou avaliação de viés."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-264","pmid":"37355623","doi":"10.1186/s13018-023-03943-x","title":"Efficacy and safety of extracorporeal shockwave therapy in chronic low back pain: a systematic review and meta-analysis of 632 patients","year":2023,"condition":["Chronic low-back pain: pooled results need reconciliation"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Chronic low-back pain: pooled results need reconciliation","pt-BR":"Lombalgia crônica: resultados combinados exigem reconciliação"},"category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"clinical synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese clínica"},"report_type":"clinical synthesis","population":"Adults with mechanical chronic low-back pain; varied causes included quadratus-lumborum trigger points and sacroiliac pain. Total 318 ESWT/314 controls, but outcome-specific totals differ. Postoperative, pregnancy and specific serious spinal disorders excluded.","comparator":"Exercise, physical modalities, trigger-point injection, oral medicines and myofascial treatment; some trials used sham plus shared exercise. These control strategies are not interchangeable.","findings":"Pain MD −1.04 (95% CI −1.44 to −.65) at 4 weeks and −.85 (−1.30 to −.41) at 12 weeks. ODI −4.22 (−7.55 to −.89) and −4.51 (−8.58 to −.44). Mental health SMD 1.17 (−.10 to 2.45), p=.07. Injection subgroup pain and physiotherapy subgroup ODI were null.","patient_relevance":"The review reports modest average pain and disability differences, but important analysis problems reduce confidence. Mental-health benefit was not demonstrated.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37355623/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"Adults with mechanical chronic low-back pain; varied causes included quadratus-lumborum trigger points and sacroiliac pain. Total 318 ESWT/314 controls, but outcome-specific totals differ. Postoperative, pregnancy and specific serious spinal disorders excluded.","pt-BR":"Adultos com lombalgia mecânica crônica; causas variadas, incluindo pontos no quadrado lombar e dor sacroilíaca. Total 318 ondas/314 controles, com totais específicos por desfecho. Excluídos pós-operatório, gestação e doenças espinais graves."},"source_population":"Adults with mechanical chronic low-back pain; varied causes included quadratus-lumborum trigger points and sacroiliac pain. Total 318 ESWT/314 controls, but outcome-specific totals differ. Postoperative, pregnancy and specific serious spinal disorders excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"High heterogeneity, English-only selection and source-data concerns. Figure 4 uses fixed effects despite 87% heterogeneity and text claiming random effects. Figure 3 swaps Guo/Taheri sample sizes versus Table 1. The “Jin 2017” row matches Hong’s retrospective preference-based QL study, not a randomized trial. ODI 4 weeks p=.01 in figure/text differs from abstract p<.001. RoB2 is described with older seven-domain criteria. GRADE supplement absent. Academic/provincial funding; no conflicts declared.","implication":"Possible short-term benefits require reanalysis with verified trial identity and consistent models. The review cannot establish durable benefit, optimal modality or a mental-health effect.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Reconcile trial labels and denominators, remove nonrandomized reports from RCT-only synthesis, harmonize mental-health scales and prespecify outcome timepoints and models."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Chronic low-back pain: pooled results need reconciliation","pt-BR":"Lombalgia crônica: resultados combinados exigem reconciliação"},"summary":{"en":"The review reports modest average pain and disability differences, but important analysis problems reduce confidence. Mental-health benefit was not demonstrated.","pt-BR":"A revisão informa diferenças médias modestas em dor e incapacidade, mas problemas analíticos reduzem confiança. Benefício em saúde mental não foi demonstrado."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Chronic low-back pain: pooled results need reconciliation","pt-BR":"Lombalgia crônica: resultados combinados exigem reconciliação"},"population":{"en":"Adults with mechanical chronic low-back pain; varied causes included quadratus-lumborum trigger points and sacroiliac pain. Total 318 ESWT/314 controls, but outcome-specific totals differ. Postoperative, pregnancy and specific serious spinal disorders excluded.","pt-BR":"Adultos com lombalgia mecânica crônica; causas variadas, incluindo pontos no quadrado lombar e dor sacroilíaca. Total 318 ondas/314 controles, com totais específicos por desfecho. Excluídos pós-operatório, gestação e doenças espinais graves."},"comparison":{"en":"Exercise, physical modalities, trigger-point injection, oral medicines and myofascial treatment; some trials used sham plus shared exercise. These control strategies are not interchangeable.","pt-BR":"Exercícios, modalidades físicas, infiltração, medicação oral e tratamento miofascial; alguns usaram simulação mais exercício comum. Controles não são intercambiáveis."},"note":{"en":"High heterogeneity, English-only selection and source-data concerns. Figure 4 uses fixed effects despite 87% heterogeneity and text claiming random effects. Figure 3 swaps Guo/Taheri sample sizes versus Table 1. The “Jin 2017” row matches Hong’s retrospective preference-based QL study, not a randomized trial. ODI 4 weeks p=.01 in figure/text differs from abstract p<.001. RoB2 is described with older seven-domain criteria. GRADE supplement absent. Academic/provincial funding; no conflicts declared.","pt-BR":"Alta heterogeneidade, seleção em inglês e problemas de dados. Figura 4 usa efeito fixo apesar de 87% e texto afirmar aleatório. Figura 3 troca N Guo/Taheri contra Tabela 1. Linha “Jin 2017” corresponde ao estudo retrospectivo por preferência de Hong, não randomizado. P ODI 4 semanas=0,01 difere de resumo<0,001. RoB2 descrito com sete domínios antigos. Suplemento GRADE ausente. Financiamento acadêmico/provincial; sem conflitos."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-265","pmid":"11400888","doi":"10.1097/00003086-200106000-00005","title":"Shock Wave Therapy (Orthotripsy) in Musculoskeletal Disorders","year":2001,"condition":["Orthotripsy in 2001: early evidence and biological risks"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Orthotripsy in 2001: early evidence and biological risks","pt-BR":"Ortotripsia em 2001: evidência inicial e riscos biológicos"},"category":"multiple_conditions","categoryLabel":{"en":"Multiple conditions and methods","pt-BR":"Múltiplas condições e métodos"},"level":"mixed_translational","levelLabel":{"en":"Mixed clinical / preclinical","pt-BR":"Evidência clínica / pré-clínica"},"typeLabel":{"en":"mixed translational","pt-BR":"Revisão clínica e pré-clínica"},"report_type":"mixed translational","population":"More than 8,000 reported musculoskeletal cases; 2,723, approximately 34%, met the authors’ A–C categories. These are literature cases, not a new cohort or verified unique individuals. Indications include heel pain, elbow tendinopathy, nonunion and calcific shoulder disease.","comparator":"Only approximately 300 plantar patients were in the published Type A blinded randomized study; many other reports had no controls or were abstracts. Clinical success ranges therefore cannot establish superiority over placebo, surgery or usual care.","findings":"Among higher-ranked reports, plantar success ranged 34–88% in 736 cases, elbow 48–73% in 763, nonunion 62–83% in 714, and calcific shoulder 47–70% in more than 510. These are observed ranges, not pooled probabilities or comparative effects. Emerging indications lacked statistically valid results.","patient_relevance":"Early reports were promising but often lacked strong controls. A reported success percentage from this review is not a reliable prediction of your own result.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11400888/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"More than 8,000 reported musculoskeletal cases; 2,723, approximately 34%, met the authors’ A–C categories. These are literature cases, not a new cohort or verified unique individuals. Indications include heel pain, elbow tendinopathy, nonunion and calcific shoulder disease.","pt-BR":"Mais de 8.000 casos musculoesqueléticos publicados; 2.723, cerca de 34%, enquadrados em A–C. São casos da literatura, não nova coorte ou pessoas únicas verificadas. Inclui calcanhar, cotovelo, não consolidação e ombro calcário."},"source_population":"More than 8,000 reported musculoskeletal cases; 2,723, approximately 34%, met the authors’ A–C categories. These are literature cases, not a new cohort or verified unique individuals. Indications include heel pain, elbow tendinopathy, nonunion and calcific shoulder disease.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Historical evidence, inconsistent protocols, selective inclusion and no pooled uncertainty. A–C includes uncontrolled studies and is not equivalent to high-certainty evidence. Manufacturer/device claims and FDA status are dated to 2001. One author was affiliated with HealthTronics; no structured funding/conflict statement was located. Preclinical injury and repair hypotheses cannot establish human benefit.","implication":"Useful historical appraisal showing why trial quality and device calibration matter. It cannot support present-day universal success claims, comparative device superiority or treatment of every musculoskeletal condition.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Compare calibrated devices in randomized blinded trials with matched rehabilitation, complete denominators and adverse-event follow-up; study tissue exposure experimentally before extending to vulnerable structures."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Orthotripsy in 2001: early evidence and biological risks","pt-BR":"Ortotripsia em 2001: evidência inicial e riscos biológicos"},"summary":{"en":"Early reports were promising but often lacked strong controls. A reported success percentage from this review is not a reliable prediction of your own result.","pt-BR":"Relatos iniciais eram promissores, mas frequentemente sem controles fortes. Uma porcentagem de sucesso desta revisão não prediz de modo confiável seu resultado."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Orthotripsy in 2001: early evidence and biological risks","pt-BR":"Ortotripsia em 2001: evidência inicial e riscos biológicos"},"population":{"en":"More than 8,000 reported musculoskeletal cases; 2,723, approximately 34%, met the authors’ A–C categories. These are literature cases, not a new cohort or verified unique individuals. Indications include heel pain, elbow tendinopathy, nonunion and calcific shoulder disease.","pt-BR":"Mais de 8.000 casos musculoesqueléticos publicados; 2.723, cerca de 34%, enquadrados em A–C. São casos da literatura, não nova coorte ou pessoas únicas verificadas. Inclui calcanhar, cotovelo, não consolidação e ombro calcário."},"comparison":{"en":"Only approximately 300 plantar patients were in the published Type A blinded randomized study; many other reports had no controls or were abstracts. Clinical success ranges therefore cannot establish superiority over placebo, surgery or usual care.","pt-BR":"Apenas cerca de 300 pacientes plantares integravam o estudo publicado tipo A, randomizado e cego; muitos outros relatos eram sem controle ou resumos. Faixas de sucesso não estabelecem superioridade contra placebo, cirurgia ou cuidado habitual."},"note":{"en":"Historical evidence, inconsistent protocols, selective inclusion and no pooled uncertainty. A–C includes uncontrolled studies and is not equivalent to high-certainty evidence. Manufacturer/device claims and FDA status are dated to 2001. One author was affiliated with HealthTronics; no structured funding/conflict statement was located. Preclinical injury and repair hypotheses cannot establish human benefit.","pt-BR":"Evidência histórica, protocolos inconsistentes, seleção e ausência de incerteza combinada. A–C inclui estudos sem controle e não equivale a alta certeza. Afirmações sobre aparelhos e FDA datam de 2001. Uma autora vinculada à HealthTronics; não localizada declaração estruturada de financiamento/conflitos. Hipóteses experimentais de lesão e reparo não estabelecem benefício humano."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-266","pmid":"28971042","doi":"10.5535/arm.2017.41.4.582","title":"Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy Versus Trigger Point Injection in the Treatment of Myofascial Pain Syndrome in the Quadratus Lumborum","year":2017,"condition":["Quadratus lumborum pain: waves or injection?"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Quadratus lumborum pain: waves or injection?","pt-BR":"Dor no quadrado lombar: ondas ou infiltração?"},"category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparisons","pt-BR":"Comparações não randomizadas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"nonrandom comparative","pt-BR":"Comparação não randomizada"},"report_type":"nonrandom comparative","population":"Patients hospitalized April 2015–June 2016 with isolated QL myofascial pain lasting over three months. Imaging/electrodiagnosis excluded other spinal causes. Mean ages 55.46 and 53.13 years; 17 men/13 women overall.","comparator":"Ultrasound-guided trigger-point injection three times at three-day intervals. Injectate and volume are not adequately specified. Both groups received analgesics, rest and therapeutic exercise.","findings":"At one month VAS was 2.13±0.92 with ESWT versus 3.86±0.95 with injection; pressure threshold 4.95±0.64 versus 3.89±0.90 kg/cm². Figure 1 reports comparative change p=.001 for both pain outcomes. ODI, RM and Quebec differences were not significant (p=.160,.155,.089). Pain associations favored ESWT; causal superiority is not established by patient-selected allocation.","patient_relevance":"People choosing shockwaves reported greater short-term pain improvement, but function did not clearly improve more than with injection. The study cannot show which treatment caused the difference.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/28971042/","sample":{"n":30,"unit":"people","basis":"Source participant allocation","description":{"en":"Patients hospitalized April 2015–June 2016 with isolated QL myofascial pain lasting over three months. Imaging/electrodiagnosis excluded other spinal causes. Mean ages 55.46 and 53.13 years; 17 men/13 women overall.","pt-BR":"Internados entre abril de 2015 e junho de 2016 com dor miofascial isolada do quadrado lombar há mais de três meses. Imagem/eletrodiagnóstico excluíram outras causas espinais. Idades médias 55,46 e 53,13 anos; 17 homens/13 mulheres."},"source_population":"Patients hospitalized April 2015–June 2016 with isolated QL myofascial pain lasting over three months. Imaging/electrodiagnosis excluded other spinal causes. Mean ages 55.46 and 53.13 years; 17 men/13 women overall.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Preference-based allocation, small inpatient sample, no sham and short follow-up. The RM outcome is named Roles/Maudsley, but Table 1 scores around 16–17 conflict with the categorical method description; it must not be relabelled Roland-Morris without correction. Supported by Je Won Research Foundation; no relevant conflicts declared.","implication":"Results apply to selected inpatients with isolated QL pain receiving shared conservative care. Disability benefit over injection was not demonstrated, and longer-term outpatient outcomes remain unknown.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Randomize treatment, specify injectate and shared care, resolve RM instrument identity, blind assessors and report prespecified pain/disability contrasts with intervals and longer follow-up."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Quadratus lumborum pain: waves or injection?","pt-BR":"Dor no quadrado lombar: ondas ou infiltração?"},"summary":{"en":"People choosing shockwaves reported greater short-term pain improvement, but function did not clearly improve more than with injection. The study cannot show which treatment caused the difference.","pt-BR":"Quem escolheu ondas relatou maior melhora da dor no curto prazo, mas a função não melhorou claramente mais do que com infiltração. O estudo não identifica qual tratamento causou a diferença."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Quadratus lumborum pain: waves or injection?","pt-BR":"Dor no quadrado lombar: ondas ou infiltração?"},"population":{"en":"Patients hospitalized April 2015–June 2016 with isolated QL myofascial pain lasting over three months. Imaging/electrodiagnosis excluded other spinal causes. Mean ages 55.46 and 53.13 years; 17 men/13 women overall.","pt-BR":"Internados entre abril de 2015 e junho de 2016 com dor miofascial isolada do quadrado lombar há mais de três meses. Imagem/eletrodiagnóstico excluíram outras causas espinais. Idades médias 55,46 e 53,13 anos; 17 homens/13 mulheres."},"comparison":{"en":"Ultrasound-guided trigger-point injection three times at three-day intervals. Injectate and volume are not adequately specified. Both groups received analgesics, rest and therapeutic exercise.","pt-BR":"Infiltração guiada por ultrassom, três vezes a intervalos de três dias. Substância e volume não são suficientemente especificados. Ambos os grupos receberam analgésicos, repouso e exercícios terapêuticos."},"note":{"en":"Preference-based allocation, small inpatient sample, no sham and short follow-up. The RM outcome is named Roles/Maudsley, but Table 1 scores around 16–17 conflict with the categorical method description; it must not be relabelled Roland-Morris without correction. Supported by Je Won Research Foundation; no relevant conflicts declared.","pt-BR":"Alocação por preferência, amostra hospitalar pequena, sem simulação e seguimento curto. RM é denominado Roles/Maudsley, mas escores de 16–17 na Tabela 1 conflitam com a descrição categórica; não deve ser renomeado Roland-Morris sem correção. Apoio da Je Won Research Foundation; sem conflitos relevantes declarados."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-267","pmid":"42494855","doi":"10.3389/fresc.2026.1883205","title":"Extracorporeal shock wave therapy for temporomandibular disorders: efficacy on pain, maximal mouth opening, and dysfunction—a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials","year":2026,"condition":["Temporomandibular pain: pooled benefits with reporting conflicts"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Temporomandibular pain: pooled benefits with reporting conflicts","pt-BR":"Dor temporomandibular: benefícios combinados com conflitos de relato"},"category":"muscle_pain","categoryLabel":{"en":"Myofascial pain","pt-BR":"Dor miofascial"},"level":"clinical_synthesis","levelLabel":{"en":"Systematic syntheses","pt-BR":"Sínteses sistemáticas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"clinical synthesis","pt-BR":"Síntese clínica"},"report_type":"clinical synthesis","population":"Reported total 1,150 participants; pain 17 studies/1,036, opening 12/823, dysfunction 13/850. Mostly Chinese single-centre trials. Sex totals 509+601=1,110, not 1,150, and Table 1 reverses labels. Reference 40 is 2016 despite stated 2018–2025 inclusion range.","comparator":"Active rehabilitation, drugs, sham or no intervention were allowed. Combining add-on and replacement contrasts obscures how much benefit is specifically attributable to waves.","findings":"Figure 4: pain SMD−1.28 (95% CI−1.96 to−0.61), p=.0002, I²95%; text incorrectly prints p<.00001. Opening MD 3.76 mm(1.52–5.99), p=.001, I²97%; Figure 5 favors labels oppose higher-is-better direction. Dysfunction MD−.05(−.13,.03), p=.22, I²99%: no clear difference.","patient_relevance":"Some pooled results favor waves for pain and mouth opening, but jaw dysfunction did not clearly improve. Reporting problems mean the size and reliability of benefit remain uncertain.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/42494855/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"Reported total 1,150 participants; pain 17 studies/1,036, opening 12/823, dysfunction 13/850. Mostly Chinese single-centre trials. Sex totals 509+601=1,110, not 1,150, and Table 1 reverses labels. Reference 40 is 2016 despite stated 2018–2025 inclusion range.","pt-BR":"Total informado 1.150; dor 17 estudos/1.036, abertura 12/823, disfunção 13/850. Predominam centros únicos chineses. Sexos 509+601=1.110, não 1.150; Tabela 1 inverte rótulos. Referência 40 é 2016 apesar da faixa 2018–2025 declarada."},"source_population":"Reported total 1,150 participants; pain 17 studies/1,036, opening 12/823, dysfunction 13/850. Mostly Chinese single-centre trials. Sex totals 509+601=1,110, not 1,150, and Table 1 reverses labels. Reference 40 is 2016 despite stated 2018–2025 inclusion range.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Extreme heterogeneity, inadequate allocation/masking reporting, inconsistent metric and significance labels, incomplete trial characteristics and unverified MCID assertions. RoB framework and demographic inconsistencies reduce confidence; external supplements unavailable locally. No funding/conflicts declared. References 29/30 do not match the claimed Cochrane/PRISMA guidance.","implication":"The review suggests possible short-term pain/opening benefits, but source inconsistencies prevent confident point-scale interpretation or a preferred-treatment recommendation. Null dysfunction matters for daily function.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Reconcile every trial, metric and figure direction against original data, report reproducible doses, separate sham and active-control contrasts, and use prespecified long-term outcomes and GRADE."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Temporomandibular pain: pooled benefits with reporting conflicts","pt-BR":"Dor temporomandibular: benefícios combinados com conflitos de relato"},"summary":{"en":"Some pooled results favor waves for pain and mouth opening, but jaw dysfunction did not clearly improve. Reporting problems mean the size and reliability of benefit remain uncertain.","pt-BR":"Alguns resultados favorecem ondas para dor e abertura, mas a disfunção mandibular não melhorou claramente. Problemas de relato tornam incertas magnitude e confiabilidade do benefício."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Temporomandibular pain: pooled benefits with reporting conflicts","pt-BR":"Dor temporomandibular: benefícios combinados com conflitos de relato"},"population":{"en":"Reported total 1,150 participants; pain 17 studies/1,036, opening 12/823, dysfunction 13/850. Mostly Chinese single-centre trials. Sex totals 509+601=1,110, not 1,150, and Table 1 reverses labels. Reference 40 is 2016 despite stated 2018–2025 inclusion range.","pt-BR":"Total informado 1.150; dor 17 estudos/1.036, abertura 12/823, disfunção 13/850. Predominam centros únicos chineses. Sexos 509+601=1.110, não 1.150; Tabela 1 inverte rótulos. Referência 40 é 2016 apesar da faixa 2018–2025 declarada."},"comparison":{"en":"Active rehabilitation, drugs, sham or no intervention were allowed. Combining add-on and replacement contrasts obscures how much benefit is specifically attributable to waves.","pt-BR":"Admitidos reabilitação ativa, fármacos, simulação ou nenhuma intervenção. Reunir tratamentos adicionais e substitutivos obscurece benefício específico das ondas."},"note":{"en":"Extreme heterogeneity, inadequate allocation/masking reporting, inconsistent metric and significance labels, incomplete trial characteristics and unverified MCID assertions. RoB framework and demographic inconsistencies reduce confidence; external supplements unavailable locally. No funding/conflicts declared. References 29/30 do not match the claimed Cochrane/PRISMA guidance.","pt-BR":"Heterogeneidade extrema, alocação/cegamento insuficientes, rótulos métricos/p inconsistentes, características incompletas e afirmações de diferença clínica não verificadas. Inconsistências de viés/demografia reduzem confiança; suplementos externos ausentes. Sem financiamento/conflitos. Referências 29/30 não correspondem às diretrizes Cochrane/PRISMA alegadas."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-268","pmid":"29207984","doi":"10.1186/s12891-017-1873-x","title":"Individualised radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy (rESWT) for symptomatic calcific shoulder tendinopathy: a retrospective clinical study","year":2017,"condition":["Individualized radial waves for calcific shoulder pain"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Individualized radial waves for calcific shoulder pain","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais individualizadas para dor calcária do ombro"},"category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"level":"uncontrolled_clinical","levelLabel":{"en":"Uncontrolled studies","pt-BR":"Estudos sem controle"},"typeLabel":{"en":"uncontrolled clinical","pt-BR":"Estudo sem controle"},"report_type":"uncontrolled clinical","population":"67 people with 79 shoulders entered; three withdrew for financial/time reasons, leaving 64 people and 76 shoulders. Mean age 44.7±8.1 years; 25 men,39 women. Acute severe calcific pain, cuff rupture, previous surgery, recent steroid injection and previous ESWT were excluded.","comparator":"No control arm; comparisons with published fixed protocols are indirect and cannot show individualized treatment superiority.","findings":"VAS fell from 6.7±1.1 to 3.2±0.8,2.6±0.9,1.7±1.0 and 0.8±1.0. Figure 2 gives success 12%,51%,82%,92% at corresponding visits. Recurrence 7%, with 71/76 shoulders not requiring further treatment. Longer pretreatment duration correlated weakly with worse later pain; it did not correlate with session count (r=.080, p=.494).","patient_relevance":"Most treated shoulders improved during follow-up, but this study cannot tell how much improvement the waves caused or whether extra sessions were worthwhile.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/29207984/","sample":{"n":67,"unit":"people","basis":"Source participant allocation","description":{"en":"67 people with 79 shoulders entered; three withdrew for financial/time reasons, leaving 64 people and 76 shoulders. Mean age 44.7±8.1 years; 25 men,39 women. Acute severe calcific pain, cuff rupture, previous surgery, recent steroid injection and previous ESWT were excluded.","pt-BR":"Entraram 67 pessoas com 79 ombros; três desistiram por custo/tempo, restando 64 pessoas e 76 ombros. Idade 44,7±8,1 anos; 25 homens,39 mulheres. Excluídos dor calcária aguda intensa, ruptura do manguito, cirurgia prévia, corticoide recente e ondas prévias."},"source_population":"67 people with 79 shoulders entered; three withdrew for financial/time reasons, leaving 64 people and 76 shoulders. Mean age 44.7±8.1 years; 25 men,39 women. Acute severe calcific pain, cuff rupture, previous surgery, recent steroid injection and previous ESWT were excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"No control, retrospective selection, response-driven treatment duration, bilateral shoulders without clearly described clustering adjustment, no standardized function score or post-treatment calcification resolution assessment. Table 3 lists 74 shoulders at session 4 although reported minimum is 4, a source inconsistency. Storz paid publication costs; Lohrer declared research support and paid speaking.","implication":"This describes feasibility and symptom trajectories in selected nonacute patients. Natural resorption, regression to the mean and care effects remain plausible explanations for improvement.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Compare individualized and fixed radial protocols with sham or usual care, account for paired shoulders, and measure function, imaging, tolerance and cost prospectively."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Individualized radial waves for calcific shoulder pain","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais individualizadas para dor calcária do ombro"},"summary":{"en":"Most treated shoulders improved during follow-up, but this study cannot tell how much improvement the waves caused or whether extra sessions were worthwhile.","pt-BR":"A maioria dos ombros melhorou no seguimento, mas o estudo não mostra quanto dessa melhora foi causado pelas ondas nem se sessões adicionais valeram a pena."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Individualized radial waves for calcific shoulder pain","pt-BR":"Ondas radiais individualizadas para dor calcária do ombro"},"population":{"en":"67 people with 79 shoulders entered; three withdrew for financial/time reasons, leaving 64 people and 76 shoulders. Mean age 44.7±8.1 years; 25 men,39 women. Acute severe calcific pain, cuff rupture, previous surgery, recent steroid injection and previous ESWT were excluded.","pt-BR":"Entraram 67 pessoas com 79 ombros; três desistiram por custo/tempo, restando 64 pessoas e 76 ombros. Idade 44,7±8,1 anos; 25 homens,39 mulheres. Excluídos dor calcária aguda intensa, ruptura do manguito, cirurgia prévia, corticoide recente e ondas prévias."},"comparison":{"en":"No control arm; comparisons with published fixed protocols are indirect and cannot show individualized treatment superiority.","pt-BR":"Sem grupo controle; comparações com protocolos fixos de outros artigos são indiretas e não demonstram superioridade da individualização."},"note":{"en":"No control, retrospective selection, response-driven treatment duration, bilateral shoulders without clearly described clustering adjustment, no standardized function score or post-treatment calcification resolution assessment. Table 3 lists 74 shoulders at session 4 although reported minimum is 4, a source inconsistency. Storz paid publication costs; Lohrer declared research support and paid speaking.","pt-BR":"Sem controle, seleção retrospectiva, duração guiada pela resposta, ombros bilaterais sem ajuste de agrupamento claramente descrito, sem escore funcional padronizado nem avaliação da resolução calcária. Tabela 3 registra 74 ombros na sessão 4 apesar do mínimo relatado de 4, inconsistência da fonte. Storz pagou publicação; Lohrer declarou apoio e palestras remuneradas."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-269","pmid":"31001553","doi":"10.1155/2019/2958251","title":"Efficacy of Extracorporeal Shockwave Therapy on Calcified and Noncalcified Shoulder Tendinosis: A Propensity Score Matched Analysis","year":2019,"condition":["Shoulder calcification type and shockwave outcomes"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shoulder calcification type and shockwave outcomes","pt-BR":"Tipo de calcificação do ombro e resultados das ondas"},"category":"shoulder","categoryLabel":{"en":"Shoulder","pt-BR":"Ombro"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparisons","pt-BR":"Comparações não randomizadas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"nonrandom comparative","pt-BR":"Comparação não randomizada"},"report_type":"nonrandom comparative","population":"Shoulder tendinosis symptomatic>6 months despite≥3 months conservative care. Full-thickness tears and typeII/III acromia were excluded. Groups: noncalcific NCTS, dense typeI DCTS and translucent typeII/III TCTS. DCTS symptom duration remained longer after matching (20.3 vs 9.8 months for TCTS).","comparator":"Morphology groups received the same intervention. NSAIDs, aspirin and physiotherapy were stopped 2 weeks before and 4 weeks after. No untreated or sham comparison.","findings":"At 12 months VAS NCTS/TCTS/DCTS=2.9/1.5/3.8; CMS=78.7/86.9/71.1. Complaint-free counts 3/20,14/20,5/20. Night-pain and activity scores were similar between NCTS and TCTS, both better than DCTS. Results suggest morphology-associated prognosis, not proof of treatment efficacy.","patient_relevance":"Translucent deposits were associated with better outcomes after treatment. The study does not show that shockwaves outperform no treatment or that dense/noncalcific cases should automatically receive another procedure.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31001553/","sample":{"n":60,"unit":"people","basis":"Source participant allocation","description":{"en":"Shoulder tendinosis symptomatic>6 months despite≥3 months conservative care. Full-thickness tears and typeII/III acromia were excluded. Groups: noncalcific NCTS, dense typeI DCTS and translucent typeII/III TCTS. DCTS symptom duration remained longer after matching (20.3 vs 9.8 months for TCTS).","pt-BR":"Tendinose sintomática>6 meses apesar de≥3 meses de cuidado conservador. Excluídas rupturas completas e acrômiosII/III. Grupos: não calcária NCTS, densa tipoI DCTS e translúcidaII/III TCTS. Duração de sintomas DCTS permaneceu maior após pareamento (20,3 versus 9,8 meses TCTS)."},"source_population":"Shoulder tendinosis symptomatic>6 months despite≥3 months conservative care. Full-thickness tears and typeII/III acromia were excluded. Groups: noncalcific NCTS, dense typeI DCTS and translucent typeII/III TCTS. DCTS symptom duration remained longer after matching (20.3 vs 9.8 months for TCTS).","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Small retrospective matched subset, no sham, residual duration imbalance and incomplete imaging follow-up. Table 2 versus text p-values conflict: CMS .007/.014, pain subscore .004/.008, strength .002/.004. Table 1 TCTS age SD 93.58 and Table 2 activity range exceeding specified maximum are source errors requiring clarification. No conflicts declared; biostatistics support acknowledged.","implication":"For refractory shoulder symptoms, calcification morphology may inform prognosis. Natural resorption of typeII/III deposits and unmeasured factors prevent assigning the observed advantage to ESWT alone.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["A morphology-stratified sham-controlled trial with prospective imaging and validated outcome reporting is needed; reconcile the table/text inconsistencies first."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shoulder calcification type and shockwave outcomes","pt-BR":"Tipo de calcificação do ombro e resultados das ondas"},"summary":{"en":"Translucent deposits were associated with better outcomes after treatment. The study does not show that shockwaves outperform no treatment or that dense/noncalcific cases should automatically receive another procedure.","pt-BR":"Depósitos translúcidos associaram-se a melhores resultados após tratamento. O estudo não mostra superioridade a não tratar nem que casos densos/não calcários devam automaticamente receber outro procedimento."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Shoulder calcification type and shockwave outcomes","pt-BR":"Tipo de calcificação do ombro e resultados das ondas"},"population":{"en":"Shoulder tendinosis symptomatic>6 months despite≥3 months conservative care. Full-thickness tears and typeII/III acromia were excluded. Groups: noncalcific NCTS, dense typeI DCTS and translucent typeII/III TCTS. DCTS symptom duration remained longer after matching (20.3 vs 9.8 months for TCTS).","pt-BR":"Tendinose sintomática>6 meses apesar de≥3 meses de cuidado conservador. Excluídas rupturas completas e acrômiosII/III. Grupos: não calcária NCTS, densa tipoI DCTS e translúcidaII/III TCTS. Duração de sintomas DCTS permaneceu maior após pareamento (20,3 versus 9,8 meses TCTS)."},"comparison":{"en":"Morphology groups received the same intervention. NSAIDs, aspirin and physiotherapy were stopped 2 weeks before and 4 weeks after. No untreated or sham comparison.","pt-BR":"Grupos morfológicos receberam a mesma intervenção. Anti-inflamatórios, aspirina e fisioterapia suspensos 2 semanas antes e 4 depois. Sem comparação não tratada ou simulada."},"note":{"en":"Small retrospective matched subset, no sham, residual duration imbalance and incomplete imaging follow-up. Table 2 versus text p-values conflict: CMS .007/.014, pain subscore .004/.008, strength .002/.004. Table 1 TCTS age SD 93.58 and Table 2 activity range exceeding specified maximum are source errors requiring clarification. No conflicts declared; biostatistics support acknowledged.","pt-BR":"Subamostra retrospectiva pequena, sem simulação, duração residual desequilibrada e imagem incompleta. P da Tabela 2/texto divergem: CMS 0,007/0,014; dor 0,004/0,008; força 0,002/0,004. DP etário TCTS 93,58 e atividade acima do máximo descrito são erros que exigem esclarecimento. Sem conflitos; apoio estatístico reconhecido."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-270","pmid":"41939955","doi":"10.26603/001c.158527","title":"Radial Pressure Wave and Focused Shockwave Therapy for Proximal Hamstring Tendinopathy: The Role of Patient Positioning, a Narrative Review and Clinical Commentary","year":2026,"condition":["Hamstring treatment position: a proposal awaiting testing"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Hamstring treatment position: a proposal awaiting testing","pt-BR":"Posição no tratamento dos isquiotibiais: proposta ainda não testada"},"category":"hip_pelvis","categoryLabel":{"en":"Hip and pelvis","pt-BR":"Quadril e pelve"},"level":"background_mechanism","levelLabel":{"en":"Context & narrative reviews","pt-BR":"Contexto e revisões narrativas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"Narrative review and clinical commentary","pt-BR":"Revisão narrativa e comentário clínico"},"report_type":"background mechanism","population":"Reports involved athletes, runners and a para-swimmer with proximal hamstring tendinopathy. Stated 217 patients may overlap in two retrospective institutional cohorts; it must not be counted as independent treated participants.","comparator":"Literature describes supine hip/knee flexed 90 degrees in one RCT and prone in one case. No trial randomized patients between positions. Rich compared waves with individualized physiotherapy, not positions.","findings":"Cacchio: 85% versus 10% achieved ≥50% pain reduction at 3 months; 80% wave group returned to sport. Rich 100-person trial showed no primary VISA-H/global-change difference through 52 weeks, though some satisfaction/adherence measures favored waves. Retrospective MCID rates 69%, and 63% radial versus 57% combined are uncontrolled/descriptive.","patient_relevance":"Side-lying may make treatment easier to deliver, but it has not been shown to improve recovery. One larger trial found no significant difference between physiotherapy and waves on the main outcomes; this does not establish equivalence.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"background_only","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41939955/","sample":{"n":null,"unit":null,"basis":"Narrative or synthesis; no independent cohort total","description":{"en":"Reports involved athletes, runners and a para-swimmer with proximal hamstring tendinopathy. Stated 217 patients may overlap in two retrospective institutional cohorts; it must not be counted as independent treated participants.","pt-BR":"Relatos envolveram atletas, corredores e nadadora paralímpica com tendinopatia proximal. Total informado 217 pode sobrepor duas coortes institucionais; não contar como tratados independentes."},"source_population":"Reports involved athletes, runners and a para-swimmer with proximal hamstring tendinopathy. Stated 217 patients may overlap in two retrospective institutional cohorts; it must not be counted as independent treated participants.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Very few controlled studies, possible cohort overlap, heterogeneous rehabilitation and absent positioning comparisons. Source repeatedly prints frequencies in MHz; these require primary-source verification rather than prescription. Figure 2 caption mislabels side-lying image as supine. Appendix A is an external DOCX not included locally. Authors disclose no conflicts.","implication":"Positioning can be discussed for comfort/target access, but no evidence shows side-lying improves pain or function. Exercise and progressive loading remain integral within the reviewed management approaches.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Document device,standoff,ultrasound depth,hip/knee angles and common rehabilitation, then prospectively compare positioning with pain,function and harms."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Hamstring treatment position: a proposal awaiting testing","pt-BR":"Posição no tratamento dos isquiotibiais: proposta ainda não testada"},"summary":{"en":"Side-lying may make treatment easier to deliver, but it has not been shown to improve recovery. One larger trial found no significant difference between physiotherapy and waves on the main outcomes; this does not establish equivalence.","pt-BR":"Decúbito lateral pode facilitar aplicação, mas não demonstrou melhorar recuperação. Um ensaio maior não encontrou diferença nos principais desfechos entre fisioterapia e ondas."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Hamstring treatment position: a proposal awaiting testing","pt-BR":"Posição no tratamento dos isquiotibiais: proposta ainda não testada"},"population":{"en":"Reports involved athletes, runners and a para-swimmer with proximal hamstring tendinopathy. Stated 217 patients may overlap in two retrospective institutional cohorts; it must not be counted as independent treated participants.","pt-BR":"Relatos envolveram atletas, corredores e nadadora paralímpica com tendinopatia proximal. Total informado 217 pode sobrepor duas coortes institucionais; não contar como tratados independentes."},"comparison":{"en":"Literature describes supine hip/knee flexed 90 degrees in one RCT and prone in one case. No trial randomized patients between positions. Rich compared waves with individualized physiotherapy, not positions.","pt-BR":"Literatura descreve supino com quadril/joelho 90 graus em um ensaio e prono em um caso. Nenhum randomizou posições. Rich comparou ondas com fisioterapia individualizada, não posições."},"note":{"en":"Very few controlled studies, possible cohort overlap, heterogeneous rehabilitation and absent positioning comparisons. Source repeatedly prints frequencies in MHz; these require primary-source verification rather than prescription. Figure 2 caption mislabels side-lying image as supine. Appendix A is an external DOCX not included locally. Authors disclose no conflicts.","pt-BR":"Poucos controles, possível sobreposição, reabilitação heterogênea e ausência de comparação de posições. Fonte imprime repetidamente MHz; precisa conferir fonte primária, não prescrever. Legenda Figura 2 chama supina imagem lateral. Apêndice A externo DOCX ausente localmente. Sem conflitos declarados."}}},"editorialArt":"synthesis","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}},{"id":"SW200-271","pmid":"41995487","doi":"10.1097/MD.0000000000048410","title":"Extracorporeal shockwave therapy for zoster-associated pain: A retrospective analysis based on spinal musculoskeletal imbalance","year":2026,"condition":["Shockwaves added to early zoster care"],"conditionLabel":{"en":"Shockwaves added to early zoster care","pt-BR":"Ondas adicionadas ao cuidado inicial do zoster"},"category":"neurologic","categoryLabel":{"en":"Spasticity and neurological rehabilitation","pt-BR":"Espasticidade e reabilitação neurológica"},"level":"nonrandom_comparative","levelLabel":{"en":"Nonrandomized comparisons","pt-BR":"Comparações não randomizadas"},"typeLabel":{"en":"nonrandom comparative","pt-BR":"Comparação não randomizada"},"report_type":"nonrandom comparative","population":"Adults 50–80 years with thoracic/lumbar segmental zoster pain lasting≤1 month, admitted May 2023–June 2024. MRI abnormalities were found in 74/82. Uncontrolled disease, anticoagulation, spinal infection/tumor, fracture and incomplete records were excluded.","comparator":"Both groups received antivirals, neuropathic analgesics such as pregabalin/amitriptyline, NSAIDs, supportive care and individualized postural/activity advice. Actual medication doses and adherence were not controlled in the comparison.","findings":"At 3 months ESWT/control NRS 1.2±0.6/2.6±1.0, PSQI 3.6±1.3/6.1±2.0, SMIS 40.2±5.0/47.1±5.9; reported p<.001. PHN occurred in 2/41 versus 13/41. Week 1 NRS and SMIS comparisons were nonsignificant (p=.067/.327), despite later differences. These are unadjusted associations, not prevention proof.","patient_relevance":"Patients who received extra shockwave sessions had better later scores, but treatment choice and other care may explain part of the difference. Reliable prevention of persistent zoster pain remains unproven.","modality":["Extracorporeal shockwave therapy"],"depth":"abstract_plus_selected_fulltext","disposition":"relevant_support","pubmed_url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/41995487/","sample":{"n":82,"unit":"people","basis":"Source participant allocation","description":{"en":"Adults 50–80 years with thoracic/lumbar segmental zoster pain lasting≤1 month, admitted May 2023–June 2024. MRI abnormalities were found in 74/82. Uncontrolled disease, anticoagulation, spinal infection/tumor, fracture and incomplete records were excluded.","pt-BR":"Adultos 50–80 anos com dor zoster torácica/lombar há≤1 mês, internados entre maio 2023–junho 2024. Alterações de ressonância em 74/82. Excluídos doença descontrolada, anticoagulação, infecção/tumor espinal, fratura e prontuários incompletos."},"source_population":"Adults 50–80 years with thoracic/lumbar segmental zoster pain lasting≤1 month, admitted May 2023–June 2024. MRI abnormalities were found in 74/82. Uncontrolled disease, anticoagulation, spinal infection/tumor, fracture and incomplete records were excluded.","may_sum_across_records":false},"family":{"related_catalog_ids":[],"link_status":"not_established","source_note":"Independent report identity; overlap with other catalogue reports requires separate reconciliation."},"critique":[{"category":"methods","observation":"Selection/confounding acknowledged; three-month follow-up, small sample and no adjusted analysis. SMIS called validated but scoring items and reliability coefficients are not supplied. Several reported p values warrant checking against means/SD/n. Government/Hebei funding and no conflicts declared. A correction changes institutional affiliation from Technology to Engineering; ethics text still uses Technology.","implication":"Limited to early segmental zoster in selected inpatients. It cannot justify replacing antiviral/neuropathic care or treating imaging change as a demonstrated mechanism of neural recovery.","verification":"full_source_read","source_locator":"Discussion and methods"}],"next":["Prospective randomization, standardized medicines, transparent SMIS validation, prespecified PHN timing and6–12month follow-up would test the hypothesis."],"editorial":{"intro":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves added to early zoster care","pt-BR":"Ondas adicionadas ao cuidado inicial do zoster"},"summary":{"en":"Patients who received extra shockwave sessions had better later scores, but treatment choice and other care may explain part of the difference. Reliable prevention of persistent zoster pain remains unproven.","pt-BR":"Quem recebeu ondas adicionais teve escores posteriores melhores, mas escolha do tratamento e outros cuidados podem explicar parte da diferença. Prevenção confiável da dor persistente do zoster segue sem comprovação."}},"opening":{"title":{"en":"Shockwaves added to early zoster care","pt-BR":"Ondas adicionadas ao cuidado inicial do zoster"},"population":{"en":"Adults 50–80 years with thoracic/lumbar segmental zoster pain lasting≤1 month, admitted May 2023–June 2024. MRI abnormalities were found in 74/82. Uncontrolled disease, anticoagulation, spinal infection/tumor, fracture and incomplete records were excluded.","pt-BR":"Adultos 50–80 anos com dor zoster torácica/lombar há≤1 mês, internados entre maio 2023–junho 2024. Alterações de ressonância em 74/82. Excluídos doença descontrolada, anticoagulação, infecção/tumor espinal, fratura e prontuários incompletos."},"comparison":{"en":"Both groups received antivirals, neuropathic analgesics such as pregabalin/amitriptyline, NSAIDs, supportive care and individualized postural/activity advice. Actual medication doses and adherence were not controlled in the comparison.","pt-BR":"Ambos receberam antivirais, analgésicos neuropáticos como pregabalina/amitriptilina, anti-inflamatórios, suporte e orientações posturais/atividade. Doses reais e adesão não foram controladas na comparação."},"note":{"en":"Selection/confounding acknowledged; three-month follow-up, small sample and no adjusted analysis. SMIS called validated but scoring items and reliability coefficients are not supplied. Several reported p values warrant checking against means/SD/n. Government/Hebei funding and no conflicts declared. A correction changes institutional affiliation from Technology to Engineering; ethics text still uses Technology.","pt-BR":"Seleção/confundimento reconhecidos; três meses, amostra pequena e ausência de ajuste. SMIS chamado validado, mas itens e coeficientes de confiabilidade não são fornecidos. Diversos p merecem conferir contra médias/DP/n. Financiamento governamental/Hebei, sem conflitos. Correção muda instituição de Technology para Engineering; texto ético mantém Technology."}}},"editorialArt":"comparison","clinicalReview":{"status":"pending","approved":false}}]
