ondasdechoque.org
PT-BR

Plantar heel pain / plantar fasciopathy · Randomized trial · 2024

Does adding shockwave to insoles help heel pain?

Heel pain during activity dropped from about 6 to under 4 out of 10 over six months with three sessions of radial shockwave, one a week, alongside custom insoles and advice. People who had insoles and advice alone improved by a similar amount.

Similar to insoles and advice alone
adults with long-lasting heel pain
200
sessions, one a week
3
followed up
6 mo

Good to know: Everyone got custom insoles and advice; the extra treatments were added on top.

Heide M, Røe C, Mørk M, et al. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2024 · Read the paper ↗

How this study worked

Shockwave +insoles an…50 peopleSham +insoles an…50 peopleExercise +insoles an…50 peopleInsoles andadvice…50 peopleShockwaveShamShamSham
People were assigned by lot. One group had a sham: the same-looking treatment without the active waves. Each dot stands for 2 people.

What happened

Heel pain during activity

0–10 pain scale · start and after six months

StartAfter 6 months

Pain dropped from about 6 to under 4 out of 10 in every group. Adding shockwave to insoles and advice gave a result similar to insoles and advice on their own.
Show the numbers
GroupPeopleStartAfter 6 months
Shockwave + insoles and advice476.363.79
Sham + insoles and advice416.243.13
Exercise + insoles and advice436.343.64
Insoles and advice alone456.33.71

The treatment

Shockwave + insoles and advice

Radial, once a week for 3 weeks

Radial wavesSpread out from the skin; strongest near the surface
Sessions
3, one a week
Numbing
Not mentioned
Device
Not named in the paper
Everyone also got
Custom insoles and advice

Compared with: Sham shockwave, a high-load exercise programme, or insoles and advice alone

Settings are what each study used, not a prescription.

Who took part

Adults aged 18–70 with >3-month plantar fascia insertion heel pain; 200 randomized, 50 per arm, at one Norwegian outpatient hospital.

hollow squares: no final score

Shockwave + insoles and advice47 of 50 measured
Sham + insoles and advice41 of 50 measured
Exercise + insoles and advice43 of 50 measured
Insoles and advice alone45 of 50 measured
176 of 200 people (88%) had a final score.

Side effects

No major harms were registered, apart from treatment-related pain and discomfort across all treatment groups. Detailed event counts and concomitant treatments are referenced in unavailable supplement 1.

All the numbers and the full appraisal
FROM THE FULL PAPER

The results, in numbers.

Adults aged 18–70 with >3-month plantar fascia insertion heel pain; 200 randomized, 50 per arm, at one Norwegian outpatient hospital.

Radial ESWT50randomized

ITT assignment group; six-month outcome-specific n is shown in Table 2.

Sham radial ESWT50randomized

ITT assignment group; six-month outcome-specific n is shown in Table 2.

High-load exercise50randomized

ITT assignment group; six-month outcome-specific n is shown in Table 2.

Advice plus customised orthoses50randomized

ITT assignment group; six-month outcome-specific n is shown in Table 2.

Heel pain during activity (primary)3 reported outcomes
01
6 months

Heel pain during activity (primary) — Sham radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

NRSa points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
3.71
Sham radial ESWT
3.13
010 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses456.3 [CI 5.68; 6.92]3.71 [CI 3.05; 4.36]
Sham radial ESWT416.24 [CI 5.62; 6.86]3.13 [CI 2.45; 3.81]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline0.52CI 95% -0.49 to 1.53p = 0.31

Sham radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-0.7Equal results 01.8

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, −2.59 (advice/orthoses) − (−3.11) (sham) = 0.52: activity pain fell 0.52 points more in the sham group. Value kept as printed.

02
6 months

Heel pain during activity (primary) — Radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

NRSa points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
3.71
Radial ESWT
3.79
010 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses456.3 [CI 5.68; 6.92]3.71 [CI 3.05; 4.36]
Radial ESWT476.36 [CI 5.74; 6.98]3.79 [CI 3.15; 4.43]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-0.02CI 95% -1.01 to 0.96p = 0.96

Radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-1.2Equal results 01.2

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, −2.59 (advice/orthoses) − (−2.57) (radial ESWT) = −0.02: activity pain fell 0.02 points less in the radial ESWT group. Value kept as printed.

03
6 months

Heel pain during activity (primary) — High-load exercise vs advice/orthoses

NRSa points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
3.71
High-load exercise
3.64
010 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses456.3 [CI 5.68; 6.92]3.71 [CI 3.05; 4.36]
High-load exercise436.34 [CI 5.72; 6.96]3.64 [CI 2.97; 4.3]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-0.11CI 95% -1.11 to 0.89p = 0.83

High-load exercise versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-1.4Equal results 01.1

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts.

Heel pain at rest3 reported outcomes
04
6 months

Heel pain at rest — Sham radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

NRSr points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
2.37
Sham radial ESWT
2.26
010 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses454.04 [CI 3.39; 4.69]2.37 [CI 1.69; 3.06]
Sham radial ESWT413.9 [CI 3.25; 4.55]2.26 [CI 1.55; 2.96]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-0.02CI 95% -1.04 to 0.99p = 0.97

Sham radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-1.3Equal results 01.2

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here the within-group changes are −1.67 (advice/orthoses) and −1.64 (sham); the printed −0.02 has the sign of advice/orthoses minus sham, so resting pain fell slightly less in the sham group. Value kept as printed.

05
6 months

Heel pain at rest — Radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

NRSr points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
2.37
Radial ESWT
2.14
010 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses454.04 [CI 3.39; 4.69]2.37 [CI 1.69; 3.06]
Radial ESWT473.58 [CI 2.93; 4.23]2.14 [CI 1.47; 2.81]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-0.23CI 95% -1.21 to 0.76p = 0.65

Radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-1.4Equal results 01

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, −1.67 (advice/orthoses) − (−1.44) (radial ESWT) = −0.23: resting pain fell 0.23 points less in the radial ESWT group. Value kept as printed.

06
6 months

Heel pain at rest — High-load exercise vs advice/orthoses

NRSr points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
2.37
High-load exercise
2.44
010 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses454.04 [CI 3.39; 4.69]2.37 [CI 1.69; 3.06]
High-load exercise433.42 [CI 2.77; 4.07]2.44 [CI 1.75; 3.14]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline0.69CI 95% -0.31 to 1.69p = 0.18

High-load exercise versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-0.6Equal results 01.9

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts.

Foot Function Index–Revised Short Form total score3 reported outcomes
07
6 months

Foot Function Index–Revised Short Form total score — Sham radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

FFI-RS points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
26.57
Sham radial ESWT
25.11
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4447.15 [CI 41.64; 52.65]26.57 [CI 20.83; 32.3]
Sham radial ESWT4040.89 [CI 35.42; 46.35]25.11 [CI 19.21; 31]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-4.8CI 95% -12.26 to 2.67p = 0.21

Sham radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-14.1Equal results 04.5

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, −20.58 (advice/orthoses) − (−15.78) (sham) = −4.80: the FFI-RS score (lower is better) fell 4.80 points less in the sham group. Value kept as printed.

08
6 months

Foot Function Index–Revised Short Form total score — Radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

FFI-RS points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
26.57
Radial ESWT
29.22
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4447.15 [CI 41.64; 52.65]26.57 [CI 20.83; 32.3]
Radial ESWT4350.09 [CI 44.62; 55.55]29.22 [CI 23.47; 34.7]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline0.29CI 95% -7.06 to 7.64p = 0.94

Radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-8.8Equal results 09.4

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, −20.58 (advice/orthoses) − (−20.87) (radial ESWT) = 0.29: the FFI-RS score (lower is better) fell 0.29 points more in the radial ESWT group. Value kept as printed.

09
6 months

Foot Function Index–Revised Short Form total score — High-load exercise vs advice/orthoses

FFI-RS points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
26.57
High-load exercise
26.33
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4447.15 [CI 41.64; 52.65]26.57 [CI 20.83; 32.3]
High-load exercise4343.78 [CI 38.32; 49.25]26.33 [CI 20.58; 32.08]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline3.12CI 95% -4.23 to 10.48p = 0.40

High-load exercise versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-6Equal results 012.2

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts.

RAND-12 physical component summary3 reported outcomes
10
6 months

RAND-12 physical component summary — Sham radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

RAND-12 PCS12 points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
45.86
Sham radial ESWT
46.94
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4438.79 [CI 35.96; 41.62]45.86 [CI 42.91; 48.82]
Sham radial ESWT3841.34 [CI 38.5; 44.18]46.94 [CI 43.82; 50.06]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline1.48CI 95% -2.51 to 5.46p = 0.47

Sham radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-3.5Equal results 06.4

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, 7.08 (advice/orthoses) − 5.60 (sham) = 1.48: PCS12 (higher is better) rose 1.48 points less in the sham group. Value kept as printed.

11
6 months

RAND-12 physical component summary — Radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

RAND-12 PCS12 points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
45.86
Radial ESWT
44.41
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4438.79 [CI 35.96; 41.62]45.86 [CI 42.91; 48.82]
Radial ESWT4437.4 [CI 34.57; 40.23]44.41 [CI 41.45; 47.36]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline0.07CI 95% -3.8 to 3.84p = 0.97

Radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-4.7Equal results 04.8

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, 7.08 (advice/orthoses) − 7.01 (radial ESWT) = 0.07: PCS12 (higher is better) rose 0.07 points less in the radial ESWT group. Value kept as printed.

12
6 months

RAND-12 physical component summary — High-load exercise vs advice/orthoses

RAND-12 PCS12 points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
45.86
High-load exercise
46.5
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4438.79 [CI 35.96; 41.62]45.86 [CI 42.91; 48.82]
High-load exercise4239.55 [CI 36.71; 42.38]46.5 [CI 43.49; 49.51]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-0.12CI 95% -4.02 to 3.78p = 0.95

High-load exercise versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-5Equal results 04.7

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts.

RAND-12 mental component summary3 reported outcomes
13
6 months

RAND-12 mental component summary — Sham radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

RAND-12 MCS12 points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
46.25
Sham radial ESWT
46.79
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4441.78 [CI 38.67; 44.9]46.25 [CI 43.01; 49.48]
Sham radial ESWT3844.24 [CI 41.11; 47.37]46.79 [CI 43.4; 50.19]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline1.91CI 95% -2.05 to 5.87p = 0.34

Sham radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-3Equal results 06.8

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, 4.46 (advice/orthoses) − 2.55 (sham) = 1.91: MCS12 (higher is better) rose 1.91 points less in the sham group. Value kept as printed.

14
6 months

RAND-12 mental component summary — Radial ESWT vs advice/orthoses

RAND-12 MCS12 points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
46.25
Radial ESWT
44.55
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4441.78 [CI 38.67; 44.9]46.25 [CI 43.01; 49.48]
Radial ESWT4439.6 [CI 36.49; 42.71]44.55 [CI 41.32; 47.78]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-0.49CI 95% -4.32 to 3.35p = 0.80

Radial ESWT versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-5.2Equal results 04.3

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts. Direction: Table 2 does not say which group is subtracted from which. In the sham and radial ESWT rows the printed difference equals the advice/orthoses change minus that group's change; in the exercise rows it is the other way round (exercise minus advice/orthoses). Here, 4.46 (advice/orthoses) − 4.95 (radial ESWT) = −0.49: MCS12 (higher is better) rose 0.49 points more in the radial ESWT group. Value kept as printed.

15
6 months

RAND-12 mental component summary — High-load exercise vs advice/orthoses

RAND-12 MCS12 points

BaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses
46.25
High-load exercise
47.43
0100 points
means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Advice plus customised orthoses4441.78 [CI 38.67; 44.9]46.25 [CI 43.01; 49.48]
High-load exercise4243.43 [CI 40.32; 46.54]47.43 [CI 44.16; 50.71]

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

Mean difference in change from baseline-0.46CI 95% -4.34 to 3.41p = 0.67

High-load exercise versus advice plus customised orthoses

1 study

Linear mixed-effects model; ITT; group×time interaction over repeated measures

-5.3Equal results 04.3

The between-group 95% CI includes no difference; the source reports no statistically significant contrast. Within-group improvement is not evidence of superiority.

Analysis details and source

Groups are reported as mean (95% CI), not SD. n is outcome-specific at six months; all 200 randomized participants were included in the ITT mixed model. This source reports group-vs-control contrasts, not active-vs-sham contrasts.

Patient Global Impression of Change1 reported outcome
16
6 months

Patient Global Impression of Change

PGIC response categories

Pooled overall proportions: very much improved 12.5%, much improved 30.5%, minimally improved 31%, unchanged 19.5%, minimally worse 3%, much worse 3.5%; none very much worse. No significant between-group difference.

Analysis details and source

Overall response-category percentages only; arm-specific denominators not reported in the main text. Post-hoc Mann–Whitney U test.

How treatment was delivered
Radial ESWT

Prone position; once weekly for 3 treatments. Device, energy, pressure, pulse count and frequency are not specified in the article text; the cited protocol supplement is unavailable.

Sham radial ESWT

Delivered in the same manner as active radial ESWT, with participant prone, once weekly for 3 sessions. Sham tactile/sensory details are not available in the article text; protocol supplement unavailable.

High-load exercise

Unilateral heel raises and squats; 3 times/week for 12 weeks; 3 sets, progression from 12-RM (weeks 1–3) to 6-RM (weeks 9–12); 8 supervised physiotherapy sessions.

Shared advice and orthoses

Standardized advice on condition/prognosis, stay active within pain tolerance, cushioned footwear; written handout; customised semirigid foot orthoses, wear as much as possible, optional refitting visit. All groups asked to avoid other treatments.

HARMS & TOLERABILITY

No major harms were registered, apart from treatment-related pain and discomfort across all treatment groups. Detailed event counts and concomitant treatments are referenced in unavailable supplement 1.

LIMITS OF THE ANALYSIS

Results state 184/200 (92%) attended six months, whereas Table 2 observed n values sum to 176 across groups for the primary outcome; outcome-specific missingness is evident and should not be reconciled by assumption.

No between-group differences were statistically significant at 3, 6 or 12 months. The main table supplies six-month contrasts; full estimates for other follow-ups and detailed device/sham descriptions are in cited supplements unavailable in this source package.

The treating physiotherapist was unblinded, and participants knew whether they received exercise or control. Figure captions were available, but figure image pixels were not supplied for visual inspection.

The article states that all groups improved significantly within groups; this does not establish comparative benefit. No active-versus-sham contrast is presented in Table 2.

Findings checked against the full source by a separate automated reviewer.

Limitations noted by the reviewers

  • Results state 184/200 (92%) attended six months, whereas Table 2 observed n values sum to 176 across groups for the primary outcome; outcome-specific missingness is evident and should not be reconciled by assumption.
  • No between-group differences were statistically significant at 3, 6 or 12 months. The main table supplies six-month contrasts; full estimates for other follow-ups and detailed device/sham descriptions are in cited supplements unavailable in this source package.
  • The treating physiotherapist was unblinded, and participants knew whether they received exercise or control. Figure captions were available, but figure image pixels were not supplied for visual inspection.
  • The article states that all groups improved significantly within groups; this does not establish comparative benefit. No active-versus-sham contrast is presented in Table 2.
Research review

Source-linked critical reading

Randomized trial with sham / placebo control

Reading depthMaterial consulted
Technical source record

Full article XML, all sections, Tables 1–2 and Figures 1–3 captions read. Linked supplemental appendix 1 and protocol supplement 2 were requested through the public PMC article-bin/CDN routes but returned 404/non-PDF responses; no supplements recovered. Figure images were not present locally, so plots were not visually inspected.

Review statusAI-assisted draft · independent automated checkThis automated check comes before the editor’s clinical review.
Design and evidence base

Four-arm, parallel-group randomized, sham-controlled trial at Oslo University Hospital. Two hundred patients were randomized, 50 per group; primary analysis was ITT using repeated-measures linear mixed models.

Population

Adults aged 18–70 with >3 months of focal heel pain at the proximal plantar fascia insertion, tenderness, and activity pain NRS ≥3; referred to an outpatient clinic in Norway.

Intervention protocols

All groups received standardized information/advice and customised semirigid foot orthoses. Real and sham radial ESWT were given prone once weekly for three sessions; device/dose specifics are in unavailable protocol supplement. The exercise arm performed unilateral heel raises and squats three times weekly for 12 weeks, progressing from 12-RM to 6-RM, 3 sets, with 8 supervised physiotherapy visits.

Comparators

Advice plus customised orthoses alone was the control. The sham procedure was delivered in the same manner as real rESWT; participants were blinded to real vs sham but not to the exercise/control assignment.

Outcomes and timing

Primary outcome: activity-related heel pain NRSa at 6 months. Secondary outcomes: resting pain NRSr, FFI-RS, RAND-12 physical and mental summaries, and PGIC. Table 2 reports six-month group means/95% CIs and group-vs-control change estimates; the article states no significant between-group differences at 3, 6, or 12 months.

Comparative findings

All three additions (real rESWT, sham-rESWT, exercise) had nonsignificant six-month change contrasts versus advice/orthoses for the primary and secondary outcomes. This includes NRSa, NRSr, FFI-RS and both RAND-12 summaries. No active-vs-sham superiority is established. All groups improved from baseline, but that within-group change does not establish a treatment effect.

Harms and tolerability

The article reports no major harms, aside from treatment-related pain and discomfort across groups. The cited supplemental appendix with detailed co-interventions/harms was unavailable, so detailed event counts cannot be verified.

Limitations and uncertainty

Main-text six-month observed n totals 176 in Table 2, while Results state that 184 (92%) attended the six-month visit; outcome-specific missingness/analysis denominators are unclear. The source says 200 were included in ITT mixed models. Appendix/protocol supplements containing other timepoints, detailed interventions and harms public retrieval attempts returned 404/non-PDF responses; neither supplement was recovered. Participants were not blinded to exercise/control, and the treating physiotherapist was unblinded.

Applicability

The trial addresses chronic plantar fasciopathy in a Norwegian outpatient setting with advice and customised orthoses provided to all. Its null group-vs-control contrasts do not rule out effects in other populations or protocols.

What stronger research should do

Report complete arm-specific follow-up at all planned timepoints, detailed device and sham parameters, prespecified contrasts including active-vs-sham, co-interventions and harms, and reconcile visit attendance with outcome denominators.

THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Read the original article.

Is radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy (rESWT), sham-rESWT or a standardised exercise programme in combination with advice plus customised foot orthoses more effective than advice plus customised foot orthoses alone in the treatment of plantar fasciopathy? A double-blind, randomised, sham-controlled trial.

Heide M, Røe C, Mørk M, Myhre K, Brunborg C, Brox JI, Hoksrud AF. · British journal of sports medicine · 2024

Open the publication record or available full-text files.

Checked against the full paper · Clinical review: Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai, · How we review →