ondasdechoque.org
PT-BR

Radial shockwaves and stabilization for disc-related low-back pain · Randomized trial · 2019

Does adding shockwave to exercise help low-back pain from a worn disc?

In this trial, everyone also did daily stabilising exercises. Right after the ten sessions, pain was lower with sham than with radial shockwave (about 3 vs 4 out of 10). By three months, pain with shockwave had dropped to about 2, while the sham group was back at about 4, and disability was lower with shockwave.

Helped more than sham by 3 months
adults with long-lasting low-back pain from a worn disc
40
sessions over 5 weeks
10
months of follow-up after treatment
3

Good to know: Everyone also did 45-minute stabilising exercise sessions five days a week.

Walewicz K, Taradaj J, Rajfur K, et al. Clinical Interventions in Aging, 2019 · Read the paper ↗

How this study worked

Shockwave + exercise20 peopleSham + exercise20 peopleShockwaveSham
People were assigned by lot. One group had a sham: the same-looking treatment without the active waves. Each dot is one person.

What happened

Low-back pain

0–10 pain scale · start, end of treatment, then 1 and 3 months later

Shockwave + exerciseSham + exercise

Right after treatment, pain was lower with sham (about 3 vs 4). By three months it had dropped to about 2 with shockwave, while the sham group was back at about 4.
Show the numbers
GroupStartEnd of treatment1 month later3 months later
Shockwave + exercise4.74.42.72
Sham + exercise4.73.13.54.4

The treatment

Shockwave + exercise

Radial, twice a week for 5 weeks

Radial wavesSpread out from the skin; strongest near the surface
Sessions
10, two a week
Pulses
2,000 per session
Strength
2.5bar · 5 per second
Numbing
Not mentioned
Device
Pro-Shock Waves
Everyone also got
Stabilising exercises, 45 minutes a day, five days a week

Compared with: Sham shockwave (a cap absorbed the waves but kept the sound) with the same exercises

Settings are what each study used, not a prescription.

Who took part

40 adults (average age 51–56) with low-back pain for over three months from a worn disc at the base of the spine, without nerve damage or past back surgery.

hollow squares: no final score

Shockwave + exercise20 people
Sham + exercise17 of 20 measured
37 of 40 people (93%) had a final score.

Side effects

The study does not report side effects.

All the numbers and the full appraisal
FROM THE FULL PAPER

The results, in numbers.

Adults with MRI-confirmed L5–S1 discopathy, pain over three months and pseudoradicular symptoms, without prior spinal surgery. Mean ages 51.1 and 55.8 years; average symptom duration 9.8 and 9.0 years. Radicular syndrome and neurological deficits were excluded.

Radial plus stabilization20randomized

Participants; no attrition reported.

Sham plus stabilization20randomized

20 immediate, 19 one-month, 17 three-month observations; no imputation reported.

Pain intensity3 reported outcomes
01
Immediately after five-week course

Pain intensity

VAS Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization204.7 (SD 1.9)4.4 (SD 1.8)
Sham plus stabilization204.7 (SD 1.4)3.1 (SD 1.4)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp = 0.039

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

02
One month after treatment

Pain intensity

VAS Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization204.7 (SD 1.9)2.7 (SD 1.7)
Sham plus stabilization194.7 (SD 1.4)3.5 (SD 1.1)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp >0.05

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

03
Three months after treatment

Pain intensity

VAS Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization204.7 (SD 1.9)2 (SD 2)
Sham plus stabilization174.7 (SD 1.4)4.4 (SD 1.2)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp <0.0001

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

Laitinen pain3 reported outcomes
04
Immediately after five-week course

Laitinen pain

LPS Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization206.3 (SD 2)5.7 (SD 2.4)
Sham plus stabilization206.2 (SD 2.8)4.3 (SD 2.1)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp >0.05

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

05
One month after treatment

Laitinen pain

LPS Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization206.3 (SD 2)3.9 (SD 1.8)
Sham plus stabilization196.2 (SD 2.8)5.2 (SD 2.2)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp = 0.043

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

06
Three months after treatment

Laitinen pain

LPS Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization206.3 (SD 2)2.2 (SD 2)
Sham plus stabilization176.2 (SD 2.8)6.4 (SD 2.6)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp <0.0001

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

Disability3 reported outcomes
07
Immediately after five-week course

Disability

ODI Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization2016.1 (SD 5.2)13.6 (SD 5.6)
Sham plus stabilization2016.1 (SD 8)12.3 (SD 8.4)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp >0.05

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

08
One month after treatment

Disability

ODI Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization2016.1 (SD 5.2)9.3 (SD 7.1)
Sham plus stabilization1916.1 (SD 8)14.6 (SD 7.3)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp = 0.033

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

09
Three months after treatment

Disability

ODI Points

means
GroupnBaselineFollow-up
Radial plus stabilization2016.1 (SD 5.2)9.3 (SD 8.7)
Sham plus stabilization1716.1 (SD 8)17.8 (SD 7.2)

SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.

REPORTED COMPARISON TESTp = 0.004

Radial plus training versus sham plus training

Mann–Whitney U

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Analysis details and source

Reported means and SD; baseline 20 each, follow-up counts vary. No between-group confidence interval reported.

How treatment was delivered
Active course

Pro-Shock Waves pneumatic device: 2,000 pulses, 2.5 bar, 5 Hz, seven minutes, twice weekly for five weeks, ten sessions, moved over the painful lumbosacral area. The paper equates this with 0.1 mJ/mm²; this device-specific statement is not a universal pressure-energy conversion.

Common care and sham

Sham used an energy-absorbing polyethylene cap with matching sound. Both groups received 45-minute stabilization sessions daily five days weekly. No pain-reducing treatment was allowed during follow-up; this tests an addition to an intensive exercise program.

HARMS & TOLERABILITY

The article does not report adverse events or side effects. Higher immediate pain in the active group is an unfavorable clinical result, not a quantified adverse-event rate. Polish ministry/university grants funded the study; no conflicts declared.

LIMITS OF THE ANALYSIS

Single-center sample, participant-only blinding, unequal follow-up losses, multiple tests and no clearly reported imputation limit confidence. The source uses unusual/inconsistent Modic grading, including grade 4, and should not define diagnostic criteria. Three-month follow-up is insufficient to establish durable long-term remission. Control losses were due to recurrent pain requiring analgesics, making attrition potentially informative.

Findings checked against the full source by a separate automated reviewer.

Limitations noted by the reviewers

  • Single-center sample, participant-only blinding, unequal follow-up losses, multiple tests and no clearly reported imputation limit confidence. The source uses unusual/inconsistent Modic grading, including grade 4, and should not define diagnostic criteria. Three-month follow-up is insufficient to establish durable long-term remission. Control losses were due to recurrent pain requiring analgesics, making attrition potentially informative.
Research review

Source-linked critical reading

Prospective randomized patient-blinded pilot trial in Poland; computer-generated allocation and coded statistical analysis. Forty of 52 screened patients entered, 20 per group; control follow-up declined to 19 at one month and 17 at three months.

Reading depthMaterial consulted
Technical source record

Full local PDF read; All 12 PDF pages including cover; Tables 1–5; Figures 1–3 captions; Methods; complete Results; Discussion; limitations; Funding; disclosures; references

Review statusAI-assisted draft · independent automated checkThis automated check comes before the editor’s clinical review.
Study design

Prospective randomized patient-blinded pilot trial in Poland; computer-generated allocation and coded statistical analysis. Forty of 52 screened patients entered, 20 per group; control follow-up declined to 19 at one month and 17 at three months.

Participants and setting

Adults with MRI-confirmed L5–S1 discopathy, pain over three months and pseudoradicular symptoms, without prior spinal surgery. Mean ages 51.1 and 55.8 years; average symptom duration 9.8 and 9.0 years. Radicular syndrome and neurological deficits were excluded.

Treatment protocol

Pro-Shock Waves pneumatic device: 2,000 pulses, 2.5 bar, 5 Hz, seven minutes, twice weekly for five weeks, ten sessions, moved over the painful lumbosacral area. The paper equates this with 0.1 mJ/mm²; this device-specific statement is not a universal pressure-energy conversion.

Comparison

Sham used an energy-absorbing polyethylene cap with matching sound. Both groups received 45-minute stabilization sessions daily five days weekly. No pain-reducing treatment was allowed during follow-up; this tests an addition to an intensive exercise program.

What was measured

Primary VAS pain plus Laitinen pain and ODI disability were assessed before and immediately after the five-week course, then one and three months after treatment. Published ODI values are retained as points rather than converted to percentages.

Results and interpretation

Immediately after treatment VAS favored sham, 4.4 versus 3.1 (p=.039). At one month pain 2.7 versus 3.5 did not differ significantly. At three months pain favored radial treatment, 2.0 versus 4.4 (p<.0001); ODI 9.3 versus 17.8 (p=.004), and Laitinen 2.2 versus 6.4 (p<.0001). The delayed advantage must be interpreted with control-group attrition.

Harms and disclosures

The article does not report adverse events or side effects. Higher immediate pain in the active group is an unfavorable clinical result, not a quantified adverse-event rate. Polish ministry/university grants funded the study; no conflicts declared.

Limitations

Single-center sample, participant-only blinding, unequal follow-up losses, multiple tests and no clearly reported imputation limit confidence. The source uses unusual/inconsistent Modic grading, including grade 4, and should not define diagnostic criteria. Three-month follow-up is insufficient to establish durable long-term remission. Control losses were due to recurrent pain requiring analgesics, making attrition potentially informative.

Applicability

Results apply to selected chronic L5–S1 discopathy with concurrent stabilization training; they do not establish efficacy for sciatica, all nonspecific back pain, or radial treatment alone.

What stronger evidence needs

A larger multicenter blinded trial should account for all randomized patients, check sham credibility, prespecify clinically meaningful effects and follow disability, work and harms beyond six to twelve months.

THE ORIGINAL SOURCE

Read the original article.

The Effectiveness Of Radial Extracorporeal Shock Wave Therapy In Patients With Chronic Low Back Pain: A Prospective, Randomized, Single-Blinded Pilot Study.

Walewicz K, Taradaj J, Rajfur K, Ptaszkowski K, Kuszewski MT, Sopel M, Dymarek R. · Clinical interventions in aging · 2019

Open the publication record or available full-text files.

Checked against the full paper · Clinical review: Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai, · How we review →