Plantar fasciitis · Randomized trial · 2009
Does radial shockwave ease heel pain more than physiotherapy?
In this small trial, 10 of 16 people who had three radial shockwave sessions, one a week, had little or no morning heel pain at three months. With physiotherapy, 9 of 16 did. Walking and standing pain were similar too, and both groups improved.
Both helped- adults with heel pain
- 32
- sessions, one a week
- 3
- months of follow-up
- 3
Good to know: Small trial (32 people), followed for three months. Everyone also did home stretching.
Greve JM, Grecco MV, Santos-Silva PR Clinics (Sao Paulo), 2009 · Read the paper ↗
How this study worked
Conceptual animation: a radial wave spreads from the applicator and weakens with distance. Not to scale. Tap the field to send a pulse.
What happened
Little or no morning pain at 3 months
People scoring 0 or 1 for morning pain
Show the numbers
| Group | Count | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Shockwave + home stretching | 10 / 16 | 62.5% |
| Physiotherapy + home stretching | 9 / 16 | 56.3% |
The treatment
Shockwave + home stretching
Radial, once a week for 3 weeks
- Sessions
- 3, one a week
- Pulses
- 2,000 per session
- Strength
- 3MPa pressure as printed in the paper · 6 per second
- Numbing
- Not mentioned
- Device
- Swiss DolorClast
- Everyone also got
- Home stretching
Compared with: Physiotherapy: 10 sessions of ultrasound and supervised exercise, twice a week, plus the same home stretching
Settings are what each study used, not a prescription.
Who took part
32 adults with heel pain for at least 3 months; most were women, and over half had pain in both feet.
Side effects
No complications were reported with shockwave.
All the numbers and the full appraisal
Every reported result
The results, in numbers.
32 adults, symptoms ≥3 months and fascia >4 mm; 81% women, 56% bilateral disease.
Participant counts; outcome-specific denominators remain in each panel.
Participant counts; outcome-specific denominators remain in each panel.
Morning pain VAS 0–11 reported outcome
Morning pain VAS 0–1
Morning pain VAS 0–1 participants
Between reported groups
ANOVA (intergroup evaluation)
No significant between-group difference in the source.
Analysis details and source
No significant between-group difference in the source. At baseline (Table 3, Evaluation 1) 1 of 16 shockwave patients and 0 of 16 physiotherapy patients already scored 0–1, although the Discussion states that all patients rated their morning pain at five or more before treatment; values are kept as printed in Table 3.
Walking pain VAS 0–11 reported outcome
Walking pain VAS 0–1
Walking pain VAS 0–1 participants
Between reported groups
ANOVA (intergroup evaluation)
Both groups improved; no superiority.
Analysis details and source
Both groups improved; no superiority.
Standing pain VAS 0–11 reported outcome
Standing pain VAS 0–1
Standing pain VAS 0–1 participants
Between reported groups
ANOVA (intergroup evaluation)
Equal observed counts do not prove equivalence.
Analysis details and source
Equal observed counts do not prove equivalence.
Stopped analgesics1 reported outcome
Stopped analgesics
Stopped analgesics participants
Between reported groups
Fisher's exact test
Denominator is baseline users in Table 8, not all randomized patients.
Analysis details and source
Denominator is baseline users in Table 8, not all randomized patients. Table 8 lists 13 analgesic users per group before treatment (26 in all), whereas the Methods report that 24 patients (75%) were using analgesics. The table prints p = 0.411 while its footnote reads "p > 0.5 (N.S.)". Values are kept as printed in Table 8.
Pain frequency, duration and pressure sensitivity1 reported outcome
Pain frequency, duration and pressure sensitivity
Pain frequency, duration and pressure sensitivity qualitative evidence
At three months, radial versus physiotherapy: no weekly pain 6/16 versus 7/16; zero daily pain hours 7/16 versus 8/16; no calcaneal algometry pain 21/26 versus 21/24 feet; no gastrocnemius algometry pain 13/26 versus 15/24 feet. Immediately after treatment: no weekly pain 6/16 versus 5/16, zero daily pain hours 6/16 in each group and morning VAS 0–1 in 7/16 each. All reported between-group comparisons were nonsignificant; these data do not establish faster relief with radial treatment.
Analysis details and source
At three months, radial versus physiotherapy: no weekly pain 6/16 versus 7/16; zero daily pain hours 7/16 versus 8/16; no calcaneal algometry pain 21/26 versus 21/24 feet; no gastrocnemius algometry pain 13/26 versus 15/24 feet. Immediately after treatment: no weekly pain 6/16 versus 5/16, zero daily pain hours 6/16 in each group and morning VAS 0–1 in 7/16 each. All reported between-group comparisons were nonsignificant; these data do not establish faster relief with radial treatment.
How treatment was delivered
Radial shockwaves from a Swiss DolorClast with a low-intensity applicator, always given by the same physician: 2,000 impulses at 6 Hz and a printed pressure of 3 MPa, applicator perpendicular to the plantar fascia insertion on the calcaneus, with gel. Three sessions, once a week. Anesthesia not stated.
Conventional physiotherapy: ultrasound printed as 1.0 Hz and 1.2 W/cm² (units kept as printed), followed by exercises stretching all posterior leg muscles and strengthening the tibialis anterior, guided by the same physiotherapist; ten sessions, two per week.
All patients were advised to do active stretching of the gastrocnemius and plantar fascia at home.
No radial-treatment complications reported.
Small comparison with no blinding described and unequal therapist contact. Algometry uses 26 versus 24 feet, not participants, without a stated bilateral clustering adjustment. Abstract faster-relief wording does not establish superiority. Table 8 analgesic baseline totals differ from introductory summary.
Findings checked against the full source by a separate automated reviewer.
Limitations noted by the reviewers
- Small comparison with no blinding described and unequal therapist contact. Algometry uses 26 versus 24 feet, not participants, without a stated bilateral clustering adjustment. Abstract faster-relief wording does not establish superiority. Table 8 analgesic baseline totals differ from introductory summary.
Source-linked critical reading
Randomized trials
Technical source record
Full source read: body, methods, results, all eight tables, discussion and references. The article has no figures, supplementary material or disclosure statements.
Both approaches helped, and this small trial did not show that radial treatment was better after three months.
Does radial shockwave treatment plus stretching improve plantar fasciitis pain more than conventional physiotherapy plus stretching?
Randomized comparative trial of 32 adults, with 16 assigned to each treatment and assessments before treatment, immediately afterward and at three months.
32 adults, symptoms ≥3 months and fascia >4 mm; 81% women, 56% bilateral disease.
Three radial shockwave treatments, once a week, plus home stretching.
Ten ultrasound and supervised exercise sessions, twice weekly, plus the same home stretching.
The extracted panels retain the original outcome units and assessment times. Pain frequency, duration, morning, walking and standing pain improved within both groups; no between-group advantage was demonstrated at three months. Analgesic cessation was 7/13 versus 10/13 (p=.411).
Pain frequency, duration, morning, walking and standing pain improved within both groups; no between-group advantage was demonstrated at three months. Analgesic cessation was 7/13 versus 10/13 (p=.411).
No radial-treatment complications reported.
Small comparison with no blinding described and unequal therapist contact. Algometry uses 26 versus 24 feet, not participants, without a stated bilateral clustering adjustment. Abstract faster-relief wording does not establish superiority. Table 8 analgesic baseline totals differ from introductory summary.
Applies to chronic plantar heel pain treated alongside stretching; the negative comparison does not prove equivalence.
A larger trial should compare matched therapist contact, mask outcome assessors, prespecify clinically meaningful pain differences and account for bilateral feet in algometry.
Read the original article.
Comparison of radial shockwaves and conventional physiotherapy for treating plantar fasciitis
Greve JM, Grecco MV, Santos-Silva PR. · Clinics (Sao Paulo) · 2009
Open the publication record or available full-text files.
Checked against the full paper · Clinical review: Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai, · How we review →