How shock waves create forces in tissue: a physics model · Lab study · 2025
Why do shock waves act strongly on bone and stones but gently on soft tissue?
This physics paper explains why shockwave acts mostly at boundaries: a shock wave pushes hardest where two tissues that carry sound differently meet, such as muscle and bone. Between similar soft tissues the push is much weaker. The authors also offer untested ideas about nerves, pain memory and Alzheimer’s disease.
Explores how shockwave works- tissue boundaries with calculated forces, from fat and water to bone and stone
- 5
- example pulse used for the calculations
- 1
- year published
- 2025
Good to know: One author works for the device maker and the other consults for it, yet the paper declares no conflict of interest.
Wess O, Mayer J International Journal of Surgery (London, England), 2025 · Read the paper ↗
The treatment
- Example pulse used in the calculations
- Momentum Po = 350 µNs in a circular focal area of 5 mm diameter, described as what “a typical shock wave generator may have at a selected power level”; reflection time Δt about 1 µs. The device and its settings are not named.
- Pulse characteristics
- Solitary pressure pulse of about 1 µs (wavelength about 1.5 mm in soft tissue) with a rise of a few nanoseconds, followed by a tensile (negative-pressure) phase of several microseconds and decaying reverberations; cavitation bubbles appear after the first pressure minimum. Energy flux density is named, but the authors state that its link to clinical success has not been established.
- Treatment in patients
- None was tested. The paper describes, citing a book chapter, treating the most painful point until numbness occurs and then the next point, over repeated sessions; this is a narrative account, not a study protocol.
Who took part
The paper calculates forces from standard physical values for fat, muscle, bone, water and kidney stones.
Side effects
The study does not report side effects.
All the numbers and the full appraisal
What the full paper reports.
No patients, animals or cells. The calculations use generic acoustic impedance values for air, fat, water, muscle, brain, bone and stones listed in Table 1 without a cited source, and an example pulse momentum of 350 µNs over a 5 mm focal area; the physical measurements behind the model come from the authors’ earlier work on artificial kidney stones.
Force model at tissue interfaces1 reported outcome
Force model at tissue interfaces
Force model at tissue interfaces Narrative finding
The paper derives a momentum change ΔP = 2R·Po at an interface and a force F = 2R·Po/Δt, so force scales with the reflection coefficient R = (Z2 − Z1)/(Z2 + Z1). Between soft tissues with similar impedance R is small and little force arises; at bone, stones or gas R is large and forces are high. The authors simplify to straight-line motion and perpendicular reflection.
Analysis details and source
Theoretical derivation; no measurement in tissue is reported in this paper.
Calculated forces at five interfaces1 reported outcome
Calculated forces at five interfaces
Calculated forces at five interfaces Narrative finding
Table 2 lists R and force for the example pulse: water/water 0 and 0 N; fat/water 0.053 and 37.2 N; muscle/fat 0.10 and 70 N; muscle/bone 0.58 and 406 N; water/stone 0.78 and 546 N. These are model outputs, not forces measured in tissue.
Analysis details and source
Contradiction kept as printed: the abstract describes soft-tissue forces of “few (≤10) Newton”, the text says forces differ by tissue “(<10)” and gives soft/soft reflection below 1% and soft/hard R of about 50–70%, whereas Table 2 lists R of 0.053–0.10 with 37.2–70 N at soft interfaces and R of 0.78 for water/stone.
From microsecond pulse to millisecond tissue strain1 reported outcome
From microsecond pulse to millisecond tissue strain
From microsecond pulse to millisecond tissue strain Narrative finding
The authors propose that momentum given to tissue moves it at several cm/s and that the attached surrounding tissue then stretches and squeezes cell membranes for milliseconds, a time scale they consider suited to opening ion channels, releasing substances such as eNOS, BMP, VEGF and substance P, and firing nerves. They argue that ultrasound lacks comparable momentum. The velocity calculation is in unread supplemental material, and no tissue motion, membrane opening or mediator release was measured here.
Analysis details and source
Hypothesis built on the physical model; the cited biological mediators are not tested in this paper.
Pain-memory and brain-stimulation hypotheses1 reported outcome
Pain-memory and brain-stimulation hypotheses
Pain-memory and brain-stimulation hypotheses Narrative finding
The paper restates the first author’s earlier theory that chronic pain is a learned pathological reflex that intense nerve stimulation can erase, and hypothesizes that transcranial pulse stimulation reactivates neurons in Alzheimer’s disease. The authors call the medical aspects hypothetical and difficult to verify; no patient data are presented, and the transcranial studies cited are not appraised.
Analysis details and source
The Discussion and Conclusion describe this approach as promising for Alzheimer’s disease; that is the authors’ opinion, not a result of this paper.
How treatment was delivered
Momentum Po = 350 µNs in a circular focal area of 5 mm diameter, described as what “a typical shock wave generator may have at a selected power level”; reflection time Δt about 1 µs. The device and its settings are not named.
Solitary pressure pulse of about 1 µs (wavelength about 1.5 mm in soft tissue) with a rise of a few nanoseconds, followed by a tensile (negative-pressure) phase of several microseconds and decaying reverberations; cavitation bubbles appear after the first pressure minimum. Energy flux density is named, but the authors state that its link to clinical success has not been established.
None was tested. The paper describes, citing a book chapter, treating the most painful point until numbness occurs and then the next point, over repeated sessions; this is a narrative account, not a study protocol.
No harms data were collected. The authors warn that strong reflection at gas-filled organs such as lung and bowel may rupture tissue and that these organs should be kept out of the shock-wave path. Funding statement: one author is a consultant to and the other an employee of Storz Medical AG, a shockwave device maker, and Figure 8 shows a branded device; the separate conflict-of-interest section declares no conflicts. Provenance and peer review are marked “Not applicable” for this invited paper.
Author-reported: only the physical part of momentum transfer is experimentally proven; the medical aspects are hypothetical and difficult to verify, and further investigations are required.
Extractor interpretation: there is no new measurement in tissue. The impedance values are generic, the momentum value is an unnamed example, and the model assumes perpendicular reflection at single interfaces; cavitation, shown in Figure 1, is not part of the force estimates. Mediator release, nerve effects, pain memory and benefit in Alzheimer’s disease are cited or hypothesized, not tested.
Extractor interpretation: disclosure and consistency problems. Device-maker employment and consultancy appear beside a “no conflicts” declaration; soft-tissue force figures differ between the abstract, text and Table 2; and the momentum measurement is dated 2018 in the text but referenced to a 2020 paper.
Findings checked against the full source by a separate automated reviewer.
Limitations noted by the reviewers
- Author-reported: only the physical part of momentum transfer is experimentally proven; the medical aspects are hypothetical and difficult to verify, and further investigations are required.
- Extractor interpretation: there is no new measurement in tissue. The impedance values are generic, the momentum value is an unnamed example, and the model assumes perpendicular reflection at single interfaces; cavitation, shown in Figure 1, is not part of the force estimates. Mediator release, nerve effects, pain memory and benefit in Alzheimer’s disease are cited or hypothesized, not tested.
- Extractor interpretation: disclosure and consistency problems. Device-maker employment and consultancy appear beside a “no conflicts” declaration; soft-tissue force figures differ between the abstract, text and Table 2; and the momentum measurement is dated 2018 in the text but referenced to a 2020 paper.
Source-linked critical reading
Theoretical physics paper with clinical hypotheses
Technical source record
Full local PDF read: all 9 pages including Tables 1–2, Figures 1–8 and captions, funding, conflict-of-interest and provenance statements and references. The online Supplemental Digital Content and the authors’ earlier measurement paper were not read.
This physics paper offers one explanation of why shock waves act strongly on stones and bone but gently on soft tissue: the force arises where tissues that carry sound differently (they differ in density and sound speed), such as soft tissue and bone, meet. It contains no patient, animal or cell experiments. Its ideas about nerve stimulation, pain memory and Alzheimer’s disease are hypotheses from authors linked to a device maker, and they do not show that treatment helps.
Can momentum transfer at tissue interfaces explain both how shock waves fragment stones and how they stimulate soft tissue and nerves?
Invited theoretical physics paper: a momentum-transfer model of shock-wave forces at tissue interfaces, illustrated with generic impedance values listed without a cited source and one example pulse, followed by hypotheses on nerve stimulation, pain memory and transcranial stimulation. No new experiment, patients, animals or cells.
No patients, animals or cells. The calculations use generic acoustic impedance values for air, fat, water, muscle, brain, bone and stones listed in Table 1 without a cited source, and an example pulse momentum of 350 µNs over a 5 mm focal area; the physical measurements behind the model come from the authors’ earlier work on artificial kidney stones.
No treatment was given. The calculations assume an unnamed device delivering 350 µNs over a 5 mm focal area with a pulse of about 1 µs; a typical clinical session is described narratively (treating the most painful point until numbness), citing a book chapter.
No experimental comparison. The model compares interfaces on paper (water/water, fat/water, muscle/fat, muscle/bone, water/stone) and argues, without new measurements, that shock waves carry more momentum than ultrasound.
Calculated reflection coefficients and forces at five interfaces (Table 2), using the impedance values in Table 1, and qualitative arguments about millisecond tissue movement, mechanotransduction, nerve stimulation and pain memory. No biological or clinical outcome was measured.
The model states that the force at an interface equals twice the reflection coefficient R times the incoming momentum, divided by the reflection time, so force is small where neighbouring tissues have similar impedance and large at bone, stone or gas. For the example pulse, Table 2 lists 0 N (water/water), 37.2 N (fat/water), 70 N (muscle/fat), 406 N (muscle/bone) and 546 N (water/stone). The abstract and text, however, describe soft-tissue forces of 10 N or less. The steps from these forces to mechanotransduction, nerve firing, erased pain memory and benefit in Alzheimer’s disease are hypotheses; the authors write that only the physical part is experimentally proven.
No harms data were collected. The authors warn that strong reflection at gas-filled organs such as lung and bowel may rupture tissue and that these organs should be kept out of the shock-wave path. Funding statement: one author is a consultant to and the other an employee of Storz Medical AG, a shockwave device maker, and Figure 8 shows a branded device; the separate conflict-of-interest section declares no conflicts. Provenance and peer review are marked “Not applicable” for this invited paper.
The authors state that only the physics is experimentally proven and the medical aspects are hypothetical. There is no new measurement in tissue: impedance values are generic, the pulse is an unnamed example, reflection is simplified to perpendicular single interfaces and cavitation is left out of the force estimates. The device-maker ties stand beside a “no conflicts” declaration, soft-tissue force figures differ between the abstract and Table 2, and the measurement is dated 2018 in the text but referenced to 2020.
Read it as one physical hypothesis about where shock-wave forces arise in the body. It cannot show which biological effect follows in people, set a dose or predict benefit, and its statements about clinical promise, including for Alzheimer’s disease, are the authors’ opinion.
Measure forces, tissue motion and cell responses at real tissue interfaces under defined treatment settings, test the model’s predictions against ultrasound and sham exposure, and link any biological change to blinded patient outcomes, with independent investigators.
Read the original article.
The interaction of shock waves with biological tissue – momentum transfer, the key for tissue stimulation and fragmentation
Wess O, Mayer J. · International journal of surgery (London, England) · 2025
Open the publication record or available full-text files.
Checked against the full paper · Clinical review: Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai, · How we review →