Adding lidocaine injection to radial shockwaves · Randomized trial · 2022
Does shockwave, with or without a lidocaine injection, ease upper-shoulder muscle pain?
In this trial, both shockwave groups had less pain and neck disability than standard care (heat and exercise) after four weeks. Adding a lidocaine injection just before shockwave eased pain further, at one and four weeks, but did not clearly improve disability more.
Helped more than standard care at 4 weeks- adults with long-lasting upper-shoulder muscle pain
- 45
- shockwave sessions, one a week
- 3
- weeks of follow-up
- 4
Good to know: Both shockwave groups also had home exercise and posture advice.
Anwar N, Li S, Long L, et al. American Journal of Translational Research, 2022 · Read the paper ↗
How this study worked
The treatment
Shockwave
Radial, once a week for 3 weeks
- Sessions
- 3, one a week
- Pulses
- 1,000 per point
- Strength
- 1.2bar · 5 per second
- Numbing
- Not mentioned
- Device
- Power Shocker LGT-2500
- Everyone also got
- Home exercise and posture advice
Shockwave + lidocaine injection
Radial, once a week for 3 weeks
- Sessions
- 3, one a week
- Pulses
- 1,000 per point
- Strength
- 1.2bar · 5 per second
- Numbing
- Local anaesthetic · an ultrasound-guided lidocaine injection into the trigger point just before shockwave
- Device
- Power Shocker LGT-2500
- Everyone also got
- Home exercise and posture advice
Compared with: Standard care: heat and supervised exercise every other day for two weeks, plus stretching and posture advice
Settings are what each study used, not a prescription.
Who took part
45 adults aged 20–65 with neck pain for over three months and one or two trigger points in the upper trapezius, treated at a rehabilitation department in China; 41 were analysed.
hollow squares: no final score
Side effects
Some people had mild redness and soreness after the injection. Nothing serious was reported.
All the numbers and the full appraisal
What the full paper reports.
Adults aged 20–65 with neck pain over three months, VAS at least 3 and one or two upper-trapezius trigger points on either/both sides; radiculopathy and structural cervical disease were excluded. Recruitment occurred at a Chinese rehabilitation department during 2020–2021.
15 randomized; 13 completed/analyzed.
15 randomized; 13 completed/analyzed.
15 randomized; 15 completed/analyzed.
Pain intensity1 reported outcome
Pain intensity
Pain intensity Narrative finding
Combined versus shockwave alone
Reported ANOVA comparison
Combined group favored; exact effect and CI are not tabulated.
Analysis details and source
Source provides p-value thresholds and unlabeled bars; no exact mean, SD or effect CI invented.
Elastic stiffness1 reported outcome
Elastic stiffness
Elastic stiffness Narrative finding
Combined versus shockwave alone
Reported ANOVA comparison
Combined group favored in elastography; surrogate clinical significance uncertain.
Analysis details and source
Source provides p-value thresholds and unlabeled bars; no exact mean, SD or effect CI invented.
Neck disability1 reported outcome
Neck disability
Neck disability Narrative finding
Each active group versus control
Reported ANOVA comparison
Both active treatments reduced neck disability more than control (standard care) at one and four weeks (P<0.01). The Results and Figure 4 show no significant difference between the combined and shockwave-only groups, although the Discussion says the combination improved functional disability more than shockwave alone.
Analysis details and source
Source provides p-value thresholds and unlabeled bars; no exact mean, SD or effect CI invented.
Surface EMG1 reported outcome
Surface EMG
Surface EMG Narrative finding
Across groups
Reported ANOVA comparison
No significant between-group or within-group changes.
Analysis details and source
Source provides p-value thresholds and unlabeled bars; no exact mean, SD or effect CI invented.
Skin temperature1 reported outcome
Skin temperature
Skin temperature Narrative finding
Each active group versus control
Reported ANOVA comparison
Temperature decreased relative to control at four weeks; no between-group difference at one week.
Analysis details and source
Source provides p-value thresholds and unlabeled bars; no exact mean, SD or effect CI invented.
Pain at one week1 reported outcome
Pain at one week
VAS Reported comparison
Combined treatment reduced pain compared with control and shockwaves alone (both p<.01); shockwaves alone did not significantly differ from control.
Analysis details and source
Means were graphically presented without exact labels; no numeric means invented.
How treatment was delivered
Power Shocker LGT-2500 radial device: 1,000 pulses per point, 5 Hz, 1.2 bar, once weekly for three sessions. Combined care added ultrasound-guided injection immediately before ESWT on the same day; the source describes 3 mL of 0.5% lidocaine and 0.5% normal saline, an unusual formulation description that requires clarification. Both active groups received home exercise/posture guidance.
Standard care included heat and supervised exercise on alternate days for two weeks plus self-stretching/postural guidance. No injection-only or sham-injection arm was used.
Results claim no adverse effects, but Discussion explicitly reports mild redness and soreness after injection in some patients, without counts; no serious events were reported. Funding came from NSFC and Chongqing/hospital programs; no conflicts were declared.
Small completer sample, four-week follow-up, no injection-only or sham arm and uncertain blinding limit causal attribution to the combination. Surrogate imaging changes do not establish long-term function. Some repeated panels appear inconsistent, especially EMG between-group versus within-group bar heights; exact values were not estimated from graphics. Safety statements conflict.
Findings checked against the full source by a separate automated reviewer.
Limitations noted by the reviewers
- Small completer sample, four-week follow-up, no injection-only or sham arm and uncertain blinding limit causal attribution to the combination. Surrogate imaging changes do not establish long-term function. Some repeated panels appear inconsistent, especially EMG between-group versus within-group bar heights; exact values were not estimated from graphics. Safety statements conflict.
Source-linked critical reading
Single-blind prospective randomized trial, computer-generated allocation in sealed packets. Forty-five participants were randomized equally; 41 completed and were analyzed: 13 control, 13 shockwave, 15 combined. Masking of subjective treatment experiences was not feasible.
Technical source record
Full local PDF read; All 15 PDF pages; Methods; Results; Table1; Figures1–7 and captions; Figures3–6 visually inspected, pages188–190; Discussion; safety contradiction; limitations; funding; conflicts; references
Adding injection may improve short-term pain and measured stiffness, but extra functional benefit and durability are unproven. Mild injection reactions were reported despite a conflicting no-harms statement.
Does adding ultrasound-guided lidocaine trigger-point injection to radial shockwaves improve upper-trapezius myofascial pain more than shockwaves or standard care?
Single-blind prospective randomized trial, computer-generated allocation in sealed packets. Forty-five participants were randomized equally; 41 completed and were analyzed: 13 control, 13 shockwave, 15 combined. Masking of subjective treatment experiences was not feasible.
Adults aged 20–65 with neck pain over three months, VAS at least 3 and one or two upper-trapezius trigger points on either/both sides; radiculopathy and structural cervical disease were excluded. Recruitment occurred at a Chinese rehabilitation department during 2020–2021.
Power Shocker LGT-2500 radial device: 1,000 pulses per point, 5 Hz, 1.2 bar, once weekly for three sessions. Combined care added ultrasound-guided injection immediately before ESWT on the same day; the source describes 3 mL of 0.5% lidocaine and 0.5% normal saline, an unusual formulation description that requires clarification. Both active groups received home exercise/posture guidance.
Standard care included heat and supervised exercise on alternate days for two weeks plus self-stretching/postural guidance. No injection-only or sham-injection arm was used.
Primary pain VAS 0–10, Neck Disability Index, surface EMG root-mean-square activity, shear-wave elastography in kPa and skin temperature were measured at baseline, one and four weeks. Numerical group means are shown as unlabeled bars rather than a full outcome table; exact means and uncertainty cannot be transcribed reliably.
At four weeks combined treatment had less pain than shockwaves alone (p<.05) and less stiffness (p<.01). Both active groups had lower pain and disability than control (p<.01), but no demonstrated combined-versus-shockwave disability advantage is reported. Surface EMG did not differ between or within groups (p>.05). Temperature differed from control at four weeks, not one week.
Results claim no adverse effects, but Discussion explicitly reports mild redness and soreness after injection in some patients, without counts; no serious events were reported. Funding came from NSFC and Chongqing/hospital programs; no conflicts were declared.
Small completer sample, four-week follow-up, no injection-only or sham arm and uncertain blinding limit causal attribution to the combination. Surrogate imaging changes do not establish long-term function. Some repeated panels appear inconsistent, especially EMG between-group versus within-group bar heights; exact values were not estimated from graphics. Safety statements conflict.
This concerns selected chronic upper-trapezius pain and a combined invasive/noninvasive package. It does not show whether lidocaine alone would perform similarly or whether additional pain relief persists beyond four weeks.
Provide numerical datasets, resolve duplicate-plot and injection-formulation inconsistencies, include injection-only and credible sham comparisons, analyze all randomized patients and follow clinical function and harms for several months.
Read the original article.
Combined effectiveness of extracorporeal radial shockwave therapy and ultrasound-guided trigger point injection of lidocaine in upper trapezius myofascial pain syndrome.
Anwar N, Li S, Long L, Zhou L, Fan M, Zhou Y, Wang S, Yu L. · American journal of translational research · 2022
Open the publication record or available full-text files.
Checked against the full paper · Clinical review: Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai, · How we review →