Chronic low back pain: shockwaves versus conventional physical therapy · Comparison study · 2015
Does shockwave ease chronic low back pain more than standard physical therapy?
In this study, pain fell from about 7 to 3.6 out of 10 after six weeks of twice-weekly shockwave, and from about 6.6 to 4.9 with hot packs, ultrasound and electrical stimulation. Disability also fell more with shockwave.
Possible early help for chronic low back pain- adults with chronic low back pain
- 30
- sessions a week for 6 weeks
- 2
- weeks of treatment
- 6
Good to know: The groups may not have been randomized.
Han H, Lee D, Lee S, et al. Journal of Physical Therapy Science, 2015 · Read the paper ↗
How this study worked
What happened
Disability from back pain
Oswestry disability index, 0–100 · start and after six weeks
StartAfter 6 weeks
Show the numbers
| Group | People | Start | After 6 weeks |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shockwave | — | 30.1 | 17.5 |
| Hot packs, ultrasound and TENS | — | 30.4 | 25 |
The treatment
Shockwave
Shockwave, twice a week for 6 weeks
- Pulses
- 1,000 per session
- Strength
- 0.01–0.16mJ/mm²
- Numbing
- Not mentioned
- Device
- VITERA (Comed)
Compared with: Hot packs, ultrasound and TENS electrical stimulation, twice a week for six weeks
Settings are what each study used, not a prescription.
This protocol among the library’s
Each dot is a group treated with shockwaves in a study in this library, at the midpoint when the paper gave a range. The dark dots are this study.
Of the other 69 groups: 3 lower, 2 the same, 64 higher.
Who took part
30 adults with low back pain for at least 3 months at one orthopaedic hospital in Daegu, Korea; average age 46 to 50.
Side effects
The study does not report side effects.
All the numbers and the full appraisal
The results, in numbers.
30 adults (9 men, 21 women) diagnosed with chronic low back pain by orthopedic specialists, with pain for at least 3 months, seen at one orthopedic hospital in Daegu, Korea. Mean ages 49.7 ± 8.3 years (shockwave) and 46.0 ± 8.9 years (conventional therapy). Previous lumbar surgery, vertebral compression fracture, spinal tumor, disc infection, inflammatory disease such as rheumatism, heart disease and structural abnormalities were exclusions. The sex split by group and the cause of pain are not reported.
People. Allocation method not described, so no randomized count is recorded. Number analysed and any losses are not reported; Table 1 gives no n.
People. Allocation method not described, so no randomized count is recorded. Number analysed and any losses are not reported; Table 1 gives no n.
Pain intensity1 reported outcome
Pain intensity
VAS Points (range not stated)
| Group | n | Baseline | Follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shockwave therapy group | — | 7 (SD 0.76) | 3.6 (SD 1.1) |
| Conventional physical therapy group | — | 6.6 (SD 1.5) | 4.9 (SD 1.3) |
SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.
Shockwave group versus conventional physical therapy group after treatment
VAS fell from 7.0 to 3.6 with shockwaves and from 6.6 to 4.9 with conventional therapy; the between-group test was P<0.05. Baseline pain was somewhat higher in the shockwave group.
Analysis details and source
Means ± SD from Table 1; n per group not given in the table (15 allocated per group). Within-group paired t tests P<0.01 in both groups. The between-group symbol is attached to the shockwave post-treatment value, while the Results text says the decreases were larger; whether post scores or changes were compared is unclear. No effect size or interval.
Oswestry Disability Index, modified 9-item version1 reported outcome
Disability
Oswestry Disability Index, modified 9-item version Percent of the 45-point maximum
| Group | n | Baseline | Follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shockwave therapy group | — | 30.1 (SD 12.4) | 17.5 (SD 8.1) |
| Conventional physical therapy group | — | 30.4 (SD 11.7) | 25 (SD 11.4) |
SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.
Shockwave group versus conventional physical therapy group after treatment
ODI fell from 30.1% to 17.5% with shockwaves and from 30.4% to 25.0% with conventional therapy; the between-group test was P<0.01.
Analysis details and source
Means ± SD from Table 1; n per group not given in the table (15 allocated per group). Within-group paired t tests P<0.01 in both groups. The between-group symbol is attached to the shockwave post-treatment value, while the Results text says the decreases were larger; whether post scores or changes were compared is unclear. No effect size or interval. The sex-life item was removed, so scores are not directly comparable with the standard 10-item ODI.
Beck Depression Inventory (BDI)1 reported outcome
Depressive symptoms
Beck Depression Inventory (BDI) Points (0–63)
| Group | n | Baseline | Follow-up |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shockwave therapy group | — | 19.6 (SD 6.7) | 12.5 (SD 5.7) |
| Conventional physical therapy group | — | 18.7 (SD 6.4) | 16.3 (SD 4.5) |
SD: standard deviation. CI: confidence interval. IQR: interquartile range. —: not extracted.
Shockwave group versus conventional physical therapy group after treatment
BDI fell from 19.6 to 12.5 with shockwaves and from 18.7 to 16.3 with conventional therapy; the between-group test was P<0.01.
Analysis details and source
Means ± SD from Table 1; n per group not given in the table (15 allocated per group). Within-group paired t tests P<0.01 in both groups. The between-group symbol is attached to the shockwave post-treatment value, while the Results text says the decreases were larger; whether post scores or changes were compared is unclear. No effect size or interval. Range 0–63 as given by the paper's score bands (0–9 up to 24–63).
How treatment was delivered
VITERA (Comed, Korea), 17 mm head. Radial or focused modality not stated.
1,000 shock waves at low energy flux density 0.01–0.16 mJ/mm². Frequency printed as both '7 times per sec' and 2.5 Hz in the same sentence; the discrepancy is unresolved.
Twice a week for 6 weeks (both groups).
Prone; quadratus lumborum muscle and sacroiliac joint, where patients complained of pain.
Anesthesia not reported. Whether the shockwave group received any conventional therapy or exercise is not reported.
Hot packs 20 minutes, ultrasound 5 minutes and TENS electrotherapy 15 minutes, twice weekly for 6 weeks. No sham shockwave; blinding not reported.
Adverse events are not reported for either group; this means unknown, not zero. The paper prints no funding or conflict-of-interest statement.
Author-reported: small number of patients so results cannot be generalized; lumbar lesion sites were limited and daily life could not be controlled; no earlier studies of shockwaves and depression for comparison.
Extractor assessment: allocation method, concealment and blinding are not described; dropouts and analysed numbers are not reported; no follow-up after treatment; comparator is a different passive package rather than sham; between-group results are P values without effect sizes or intervals, and the table marks post-treatment values while the text speaks of larger decreases.
Reporting inconsistencies: shockwave frequency printed as both 7 per second and 2.5 Hz; ODI modified to nine items; VAS range not stated; the Discussion lists 'VAS, ODI, and VAS' where BDI appears intended; the abstract concludes that shockwaves are 'an effective intervention' although the design cannot isolate a treatment effect.
Findings checked against the full source by a separate automated reviewer.
Limitations noted by the reviewers
- Author-reported: small number of patients so results cannot be generalized; lumbar lesion sites were limited and daily life could not be controlled; no earlier studies of shockwaves and depression for comparison.
- Extractor assessment: allocation method, concealment and blinding are not described; dropouts and analysed numbers are not reported; no follow-up after treatment; comparator is a different passive package rather than sham; between-group results are P values without effect sizes or intervals, and the table marks post-treatment values while the text speaks of larger decreases.
- Reporting inconsistencies: shockwave frequency printed as both 7 per second and 2.5 Hz; ODI modified to nine items; VAS range not stated; the Discussion lists 'VAS, ODI, and VAS' where BDI appears intended; the abstract concludes that shockwaves are 'an effective intervention' although the design cannot isolate a treatment effect.
Source-linked critical reading
Two-group comparative study at one Korean hospital; allocation method not described (treated as allocation-unclear). 30 patients, 15 per group; analysed numbers and dropouts not reported; outcomes at end of 6-week treatment only.
In this small Korean study of 30 people with chronic low back pain, pain, disability and depression scores fell more after 6 weeks of shockwave therapy than after hot packs, ultrasound and TENS. How patients were assigned to groups is not described and results after treatment ended were not measured, so this study alone cannot show how large or lasting the difference is.
In people with chronic low back pain, is a 6-week course of shockwave therapy followed by larger reductions in pain, disability and depression scores than a course of conventional physical therapy with hot packs, ultrasound and TENS?
Two-group comparative study at one orthopedic hospital in Daegu, Korea. Thirty patients were 'divided into' a shockwave group (15) and a conventional physical therapy group (15); the paper does not describe randomization, allocation concealment or blinding, so it is treated here as a comparison with unclear allocation. Analysed numbers and dropouts are not reported, and outcomes were measured only at the end of treatment. Ethics approval came from the Youngdong University review board; no trial registration is reported.
30 adults (9 men, 21 women) diagnosed with chronic low back pain by orthopedic specialists, with pain for at least 3 months, seen at one orthopedic hospital in Daegu, Korea. Mean ages 49.7 ± 8.3 years (shockwave) and 46.0 ± 8.9 years (conventional therapy). Previous lumbar surgery, vertebral compression fracture, spinal tumor, disc infection, inflammatory disease such as rheumatism, heart disease and structural abnormalities were exclusions. The sex split by group and the cause of pain are not reported.
VITERA device (Comed, Korea), patient lying prone: 1,000 shock waves per session at a low energy flux density of 0.01–0.16 mJ/mm² with a 17 mm head, over the quadratus lumborum muscle and the sacroiliac joint where patients reported pain; twice a week for 6 weeks. The frequency is reported inconsistently, as both '7 times per sec' and 2.5 Hz. The paper does not state whether the waves were radial or focused, and does not say whether this group also received any of the conventional modalities.
Conventional physical therapy twice a week for 6 weeks: hot packs for 20 minutes, ultrasound for 5 minutes and TENS for 15 minutes. There was no sham shockwave, so the study compares two different active treatments, and no blinding of patients or assessors is reported.
Pain on a visual analogue scale (range not stated); disability on a modified Oswestry Disability Index with nine items (the sex-life item was dropped), expressed as a percentage of the 45-point maximum, higher worse; and depression on the 21-item Beck Depression Inventory (0–63, higher worse). Measured before and at the end of the 6-week course only. Paired t tests within groups and independent t tests between groups; results are means ± SD in Table 1.
After 6 weeks VAS fell from 7.0 ± 0.76 to 3.6 ± 1.1 with shockwaves and from 6.6 ± 1.5 to 4.9 ± 1.3 with conventional therapy (between-group P<0.05). ODI fell from 30.1% to 17.5% and from 30.4% to 25.0% (P<0.01). BDI fell from 19.6 to 12.5 and from 18.7 to 16.3 (P<0.01). Both groups improved within-group (P<0.01). The table marks the between-group test on the post-treatment values while the text describes larger decreases, so it is unclear whether end scores or changes were compared; no effect size or confidence interval is reported.
Adverse events are not reported for either group; this means unknown, not zero. The paper prints no funding or conflict-of-interest statement.
Allocation method, concealment and blinding are not described; with 15 per group, baseline differences (VAS 7.0 versus 6.6) and unmeasured factors could affect the comparison. Dropouts and analysed numbers are not reported. Results cover only the end of treatment. The comparator is a different passive treatment, not a sham, and it is unclear whether the shockwave group also had conventional therapy. The shockwave frequency is reported inconsistently, the ODI was modified, the VAS range is not stated, and the Discussion repeats VAS where BDI appears to be meant. The authors note the small sample, limited lesion sites and uncontrolled daily activities. In the extractor's view, the abstract's conclusion that shockwaves are 'an effective intervention' goes beyond what this design can show.
Applies, at most, to adults with chronic low back pain at one Korean orthopedic hospital, comparing this low-energy protocol with a hot-pack, ultrasound and TENS package over 6 weeks. It does not show what happens after treatment ends, how shockwaves compare with sham or exercise, or effects in sciatica or after spinal surgery.
A registered randomized trial with concealed allocation, a sham-controlled arm, blinded assessment, complete participant accounting, between-group differences with confidence intervals, follow-up for months after treatment, and adverse-event recording.
Read the original article.
The effects of extracorporeal shock wave therapy on pain, disability, and depression of chronic low back pain patients.
Han H, Lee D, Lee S, Jeon C, Kim T. · Journal of physical therapy science · 2015
Open the publication record or available full-text files.
Checked against the full paper · Clinical review: Dr. Marcus Yu Bin Pai, · How we review →